On January 26, 2014, rapper–producer duo Macklemore and Ryan Lewis performed their pro-marriage equality hit “Same Love” with guest artists Mary Lambert, Madonna, and Trombone Shorty at the fifty-sixth annual Grammy Awards show. As part of the performance, Queen Latifah officiated the legal marriage of thirty-three couples, many of whom were gay and lesbian. Latifah introduced the segment by stating, “This song is a love song not for some of us, but for all of us,” setting the stage for a performance and ceremony that featured couples that promoters touted as “gay, straight, old, young, of many races and many colors.”Footnote 2
While many lauded the performance as a powerful pro-marriage equality statement, others found it highly problematic. It provoked criticism not only from religious conservatives who opposed the song's message, but also from members of the LGBTQ (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, and Queer) community.Footnote 3 Writing for thegloss.com, Julia Sonenshein faulted the performance for positioning the heterosexual Macklemore as a savior figure for LGBTQ causes (almost literally so, as he stood on stage with neon church windows behind him). She rightly noted that Macklemore, due to his sexual orientation, benefited from rapping about homophobia without ever having to experience it himself.Footnote 4 These criticisms echo those voiced by openly queer black rapper Le1f, who, in a series of tweets blasting Macklemore after his appearance at the 2013 MTV Video Music Awards, asked, “do any proceeds go to any gay people? The HRC [Human Rights Campaign]? Aids [sic] foundation? Or does this straight white man keep the money?”Footnote 5 Macklemore and Lewis did contribute some of the proceeds from “Same Love” to Washington United for Marriage, but since that state legalized same-sex marriage in 2012, it is unclear if the proceeds from subsequent performances have gone to other groups organizing for LGBTQ rights. While the white, heterosexual Macklemore receives recognition and high-profile performance opportunities, queer, black rappers such as Le1f are largely left out of the spotlight.Footnote 6 Audiences largely reward Macklemore for his LGBTQ allyship but have yet to embrace actual LGBTQ artists on a large-scale level. It is therefore understandable that some critics would hold Macklemore's performances and activism to a high standard of accountability.
For many listeners, “Same Love,” and especially the performance of this track on the Grammy stage, highlighted tensions between mainstream white LGBTQ activism and communities of color. Although the broadcast amplified Macklemore's pro-LGBTQ message, allowing him to reach a large audience, it also helped disseminate his critiques of hip hop, which draw on rhetoric often used by proponents for marriage equality that creates a false dichotomy between black and LGBTQ communities and erases queer and trans people of color from the discourse.
Macklemore is a white male rapper who achieved mainstream success with his and Lewis's 2012 debut studio album, The Heist.Footnote 7 Unlike his white predecessors, who have navigated their racial identity either through their class status or through a notion of racial and musical transcendence, Macklemore presents himself as self-consciously aware of his own position within black hip hop culture and as committed to socially progressive causes.Footnote 8 However, his biggest commercial hits, which have reached a wide mainstream audience, demonstrate ways in which his own racial identity compromises his critiques of certain aspects of hip hop, such as its perceived homophobia and glorification of materialism. While Macklemore engages with tropes of hip hop authenticity in order to present himself as an insider to the culture, he also positions himself as an outsider by offering a critique of the genre that echoes white mainstream concerns that hip hop and, by extension, black communities are inherently more homophobic than white-dominated music genres and the white communities that produce them. In this essay, I offer a reading of “Same Love” that highlights some of the fissures within the mainstream LGBTQ movement, and I examine the track's relationship to the racially divisive rhetoric frequently used by white LGBTQ activists in the context of marriage equality. Ultimately, “Same Love” illustrates ways in which Macklemore's navigation of white privilege through LGBTQ activism further perpetuates harmful myths about race, sexuality, and hip hop music.
The role of white hip hop practitioners and fans is a hotly contested issue both within and outside the hip hop community. Multi-ethnic youth of color living in the Afro-Caribbean, African American, and Latinx neighborhoods of the Bronx, New York City first developed hip hop culture, whose original elements include rapping (also referred to as MCing or emceeing), DJing, dancing and graffiti art, in the 1970s.Footnote 9 When rap entered the American mainstream in the 1980s and 1990s, its multi-ethnic roots were somewhat obscured as it came to represent an expression of blackness, especially a particular kind of black masculinity.Footnote 10
In fact, rap is one of the few, if not only genres of American popular music that crossed into the white mainstream without becoming visibly white, and yet it has not been immune to co-optation.Footnote 11 Some of rap's most commercially successful artists have been white stars, including the Beastie Boys, Vanilla Ice, and Eminem, and their successes have often been recognized by predominantly white institutions, such as the Grammys, in ways that black artists’ have not. For example, Bakari Kitwana points out that much of the backlash against Eminem from hip hop insiders had to do with the commercial impact of his success on black artists:
The problem here is not simply that Eminem is white and can rap—but that he's white, can rap so well, has received honor after honor as a rap great by the entertainment establishment (two Grammys for Slim Shady and three for Marshall Mathers) and that for thirty years hip-hop has been almost exclusively associated with Black Americans. … It is not unprecedented in America's white supremacist culture for mediocre whites who perform as well as Blacks, in an area dominated by Blacks, to find themselves elevated through the stratosphere.Footnote 12
In addition to the increased mainstream attention their race often affords them, in their attempt to lay claim to hip hop's black masculine authenticity, white male rappers often invoke the worst stereotypes of black men, which are thus perpetuated through their aforementioned commercial success. Miles White argues that, for example, the Beastie Boys used “black music to act out for white audiences the brutish stereotypes of lewdness and violence historically associated with black males,” despite the white rappers’ middle-class upbringings.Footnote 13 As I demonstrate elsewhere, white women rappers Iggy Azalea and former members of the White Girl Mob similarly enact notions of “rachetness” to resist respectability and position themselves in proximity to blackness in order to offer more “authentic” rap performances.Footnote 14 While not all white rappers engage in performances that suggest their understandings of blackness hinge on exaggerated and negative stereotypes, they all must negotiate their racial identities within a music genre that “maintains its symbolic connection with the black underclass, specifically urban youth.”Footnote 15 Given the dissonance between commercial rap's common narratives of struggle over intersectional racism and poverty and the lived experiences of white rappers who, regardless of class background, do not experience racial oppression, these performers must navigate their whiteness in ways that allow them to appear genuine, or “real” to hip hop audiences while also relating to the accepted aesthetics of the genre and avoiding the pitfalls of cultural appropriation.Footnote 16 Macklemore's strategy for navigating his whiteness includes a politically-conscious approach that incorporates pro-LGBTQ activism, but one that ignores the historical and contemporary overlap between hip hop, queer identity, and black experiences in the United States.
Articulating White Privilege
To better understand the way in which Macklemore negotiates his whiteness within hip hop, let's consider “A Wake,” one of the tracks from The Heist, an album collaboration with producer and fellow Seattle-based artist Ryan Lewis. This mid-tempo track, which features singer–songwriter Evan Roman, would sound as if it belonged on a pop record were it not for Macklemore's rapped verses. Over a drum, bass, and synthesizer instrumental reminiscent of 1980s synthpop, he raps about shifting generational issues such as safe sex practices and drug use and abuse. In the second verse, however, he begins by acknowledging how fans and music critics praise his music in contrast to mainstream hip hop:
He then turns his attention to ongoing racial inequalities in the United States and situates himself as a self-aware white rapper who is concerned about racial inequality, mentioning Reaganomics, Ice T's “Cop Killer,” and the beating of Rodney King and the ensuing L.A. uprising. He continues:
Macklemore suggests that the topics he addresses in his songs contrast to those found in mainstream hip hop (outside of the subgenre of conscious rap) and that his lyrical approach invites a large crossover audience, not necessarily the music's pop sound. However, he also contextualizes his own position as a white rapper in a historical and contemporary moment of police brutality and racism. His strategy is to present himself as self-consciously aware of his whiteness and the privilege that it entails while also demonstrating that he advocates for racial justice through the mode of hip hop.
Macklemore's negotiation of his white identity and, to a lesser extent, class status in a black music genre contrasts with strategies employed by another famous white rapper, Eminem, who rose to fame a decade earlier. Unlike Macklemore, Eminem initially shied away from discussions of white privilege and racial justice, instead focusing on rearticulating his own racial and class identity in order to position himself as someone at a disadvantage within hip hop. Drawing on Mickey Hess's models of navigating whiteness in hip hop, Loren Kajikawa argues that in his breakout album The Slim Shady LP (1999) Eminem employed a strategy of “inversion” to negotiate his racial identity in the rap world.Footnote 17 Rather than attempting to transcend race or ignore it, as he did with his first unsuccessful album, Eminem began to address his own whiteness directly in a way that rendered himself legible to a rap audience. Kajikawa writes:
Parodying common understandings of whiteness, Eminem advanced a white identity both at ease with black culture and humble before it. He also emphasized the contradictions in whiteness, particularly with respect to class, allowing him to recast himself as the ultimate underdog.Footnote 18
Eminem's approach allowed him to acknowledge his whiteness and avoid being seen as an imitator of black rappers or an oppressive appropriator of hip hop culture. As Kajikawa argues, this particular strategy engaged with and reflected evolving notions of whiteness during the 1990s.Footnote 19
Like Eminem, Macklemore openly acknowledges his white identity in his music, but his position reflects the changing racial climate of the 2010s. In referencing gentrification of black neighborhoods and the 2012 killing of Florida teen Trayvon Martin, whose death sparked renewed national protests against rampant violence towards unarmed black men and youth, Macklemore demonstrates his own cognizance of persistent racial inequality. It is worth noting that during his time as an undergraduate at The Evergreen State College, Macklemore volunteered with incarcerated youth at the Green Hill School, a maximum-security juvenile detention facility where he ran workshops on writing and performing raps.Footnote 20 He attributes this experience with exposing him to many of the racial injustices of the prison system, and to sparking his awareness of racial difference more generally. Rather than situate himself as an activist for social justice and offer a call-to-arms, in “A Wake” Macklemore offers a glimpse into the self-conscious awareness he has as a white citizen who bears witness to institutional racism such as that he observed during his work with incarcerated youth. His verses articulate both a desire to create racial equality, but also an acknowledgement that he is the beneficiary of institutionalized racism and the discomfort such knowledge brings. It is a nuanced approach in which Macklemore positions himself as a self-aware white rapper who is attentive to the political repercussions of his own choices, both musical and otherwise.Footnote 21
Although Macklemore articulates a racial self-awareness in “A Wake,” that level of nuance is largely absent from his most commercially successful songs. For example, “Thrift Shop,” The Heist’s fifth single, illustrates a more problematic interplay of race and class in Macklemore's self-fashioning. “Thrift Shop” topped both the Billboard Hot 100 and Rap Songs charts in early 2013, making Macklemore and Lewis only the second independent artists to ever reach the number-one spot on the Hot 100, a feat that extended their fan base from a limited local audience to a widespread, national one.Footnote 22 The upbeat track, which uses a buoyant saxophone riff and features Wanz (the stage name of the Seattle-based singer Michael Wansley) performing the catchy hook, finds Macklemore embracing the hipster moment as he raps about finding sartorial treasures in second-hand stores. He raps: “I'll take those flannel zebra jammies, second hand, I rock that motherfucker / The built-in onesies with the socks on that motherfucker.” Wanz's hook, “I'm gonna pop some tags / Only got twenty dollars in my pocket / I'm hunting, looking for a come-up / This is fucking awesome,” succinctly captures the joy and cost-effectiveness of thrift shopping that permeates the song.
As Macklemore lists and celebrates his Goodwill finds, however, he also critiques the name-brand consumerism that is frequently associated with hip hop culture:
Macklemore never mentions hip hop by name, but as he himself has acknowledged in interviews, the track pushes back against the glorification of wealth and materialism found in much mainstream rap. In an interview for National Public Radio, which is not particularly known for having an audience that overlaps with hip hop fans but which does reach a wide listener base, he states: “Hip-hop is usually an art form that is about bling, consumption … it's usually about spending money.”Footnote 23
Of course, Macklemore is not the first rapper to confront hip hop's materialism, whether real or perceived. Anti-materialism is a common trope found in tracks by black conscious rappers such as the Roots, Common, Yasiin Bey (Mos Def), and Poor Righteous Teachers, to name just a few.Footnote 24 However, while this upbeat track might be understood as a socially conscious challenge to consumerist hip hop culture, it is also a problematic critique not only because it features a white rapper criticizing behaviors largely associated with a black music genre (that have already been critiqued by black artists), but it fails also to acknowledge the difference between choosing to buy clothing second hand because it fits a certain aesthetic or being required to because there are no other economically viable options. As music critic Brandon Soderberg writes, Macklemore's performance “stinks of privilege.”Footnote 25 He explains:
There is … a corny R. Kelly joke, and a point where he pitches his vocal down to sound like a black dude and calls himself a “honky.” Not to mention, the implicit message of this rap song is that “Thrift Shop” is not like all that other gauche hip-hop about ballin’ and champagne-poppin’, blah blah blah.
[I] Probably shouldn't have to explain this in 2013, but when you didn't have to wear hand-me-down threads or thrift-shop clothes your whole life, there's a novelty to wearing them in your 20s so you have some extra beer money. And hey, maybe you even feel like you're getting one over on a world of American Apparel–wearers by spending $2.99 on an already-worn-in colored T-shirt, but well, fall back. And that's not even the point. The dynamic that this is a song rejecting conspicuous consumption is, for the most part, projected by its listeners. Macklemore's embrace of the thrift shop is exclusively for wacky outfits to get him attention at parties, as well as something to lord over his peers in Gucci. He is, in the hierarchy of people poring over cheap-ass clothes in the Goodwill, only slightly above jerks who go there for Halloween outfits. At the top of this hierarchy, of course, are people who don't have enough money to buy new clothes.Footnote 26
While the interview cited above demonstrates Macklemore's perpetuation of the idea that this song is a rejection of consumerist culture, Soderberg is right to point out that Macklemore's main benefit from thrift shopping, as per the song lyrics, is not saving money, but rather attention from others, especially women. Had Macklemore grown up in an economic situation that required, rather than allowed, him to stock his wardrobe primarily with second-hand items, Soderberg posits, it would not hold the same allure. Instead, Macklemore makes an aesthetic choice that allows him to position himself as a moral authority on consumerist hip hop culture.
In addition to the thinly veiled critiques of hip hop culture, “Thrift Shop” also includes a self-referential nod to Macklemore's whiteness. In the first verse, he raps: “Ice on the fringe, it's so damn frosty / That people like, ‘Damn! That's a cold-ass honkey.’” As Soderberg points out, in the recording Macklemore lowers the pitch on his own vocal so that what we hear, and imagine is a black man, is really Macklemore himself. In the video for “Thrift Shop,” it is indeed a black man who points towards Macklemore off-screen and appears to be saying the line, a sort of blackface performance by proxy. This use of a derogatory slur for white people is indicative of Macklemore's approach of acknowledging his whiteness in a hip hop context while at the same time criticizing aspects of the genre, including its emphasis on consumerism and its homophobia.
“Same Love” and the Myth of Black Homophobia
As “Thrift Shop” and “A Wake” both demonstrate, Macklemore's strategic self-conscious awareness of his own racial identity has helped him navigate a genre that values above all else the notion of “keepin’ it real.” However, his self-acknowledged white privilege (and unacknowledged class privilege) has helped him achieve a certain status in the music industry from which he can reach a very large audience. Coming from this place of privilege, some of his critiques are framed in such a way that they perpetuate negative myths about black communities and erase the work of hip hop artists of color who are further marginalized because they are queer. Regardless of his actual intentions, whether to simply self-promote his work, to sincerely help marginalized groups, or some combination thereof, Mackelmore's music does not have a uniformly positive impact. The negative repercussions of his approach stem from a lack of intersectional understanding in his critiques of hip hop, especially regarding both its real or perceived materialism and homophobia, and they are most clearly illustrated in his and Lewis's most recognizable track, the hit single “Same Love.”
The fourth single from The Heist, “Same Love,” was recorded as part of the Music for Marriage Equality Project that worked to approve Washington State's Referendum 74, which legalized same-sex marriage in that state.Footnote 27 As mentioned above, the duo donated much of the proceeds from the song to the advocacy group Washington United for Marriage.Footnote 28 Following that successful campaign, “Same Love” rose up the charts in 2013 as the Supreme Court prepared to rule on challenges to the federal Defense of Marriage Act, and quickly became a nationally recognized anthem for marriage equality and LGBTQ rights.Footnote 29 American rock critic Robert Christgau wrote that the track was “the best gay marriage song to date in any genre and as corny as it damn well oughta be,” implying that it was sentimental in a way that might move listeners.Footnote 30 Writing for A.V. Club, Chris Mincher described the song as a “refreshing” reminder that “hip-hop can be an effective tool in advocating social transformation,” problematically suggesting that other contemporary hip hop singles were apolitical.Footnote 31 The New York Times noted that “Same Love” was “the first song to explicitly embrace and promote gay marriage that has made it into the Top 40,” indicating that unlike so-called gay anthems such as Lady Gaga's 2011 hit single, “Born This Way,” Macklemore and Lewis's track actually named marriage equality and LGBTQ rights as its focal point.Footnote 32
The track's breakthrough on the Billboard Top 40 charts followed the success of the duo's “Thrift Shop” and “Can't Hold Us,” all of which fit comfortably in the sonic realm of pop as well as hip hop and R&B genres, even if they were not marketed as such by promoters.Footnote 33 Macklemore and Lewis's crossover appeal can be at least partly attributed to their music's sonic characteristics, which share a pop aesthetic with other chart-topping hip hop and R&B tracks of that summer.Footnote 34 “Same Love” opens with a held chord, reminiscent of the opening of a church hymn. A hesitant-sounding piano introduction enters over this chord, closely followed by delicate string tremolos. These sounds then drop out to make space for the opening piano melody, based on the beginning of the 1965 single “People Get Ready,” a gospel-tinged R&B track written by Curtis Mayfield and initially performed by the Impressions. It is not until about halfway through Mackelmore's first verse that the beat (which consists of soft drum-set sonorities) is added, and it remains tertiary to the song's melodic and lyrical content. Indeed, the instruments used, especially the sustained organ chord and melodic piano, suggest churches and suburban spaces rather than the landscapes often invoked in commercial rap, such as the hip hop club or city streets. The inclusion of the melody from “People Get Ready,” a song very much rooted in African American freedom song traditions and which features Underground Railroad imagery, invokes comparisons between the mid-century civil rights movement for racial equality and the contemporary mainstream LGBTQ rights movement.Footnote 35
Macklemore begins his first verse with a personal story about growing up with stereotypical ideas about what it means to be gay, revealing that while he himself is straight, he has a gay uncle. He finishes the verse with a critique of religious and political conservatives for their anti-gay positions:
Additional references to anti-gay sentiment in churches recur throughout the track. In the second verse, for example, he raps, “It's the same hate that's caused wars from religion,” and “When I was at church they taught me something else / If you preach hate at the service those words aren't anointed / That holy water that you soak in has been poisoned.” The critique of religion, or more accurately, the homophobic use of religion and religious rhetoric, is particularly apt here as the campaign against Referendum 74 was heavily championed by religious organizations such as the state's three Catholic dioceses.Footnote 36
The emotional power of the track hinges in large part on the hook provided by Seattle-based queer singer–songwriter Mary Lambert, who sings, “And I can't change / Even if I tried/ Even if I wanted to / My love my love my love/ She keeps me warm.”Footnote 37 While this chorus is a touching cry for acceptance (both from self and from others), it also reinforces the idea that homosexuality or queerness is not a learned behavior or constructed identity but rather an inherent, possibly genetic trait such as hair or eye color. This claim has been used since the earliest gay rights movements in the United States as a plea for equal treatment.Footnote 38 This line of reasoning assumes that if queer people cannot help how they were born, if homosexuality is not a choice, then they constitute a protected class that the US government and other institutions must treat equally under the law. This argument stems from similar methods used by some civil rights activists, who suggest that because people of color have no control over the race into which they were born, it is both morally and legally unfair to treat them differently than white people. As we shall see, this connection, which Macklemore himself makes in lines such as, “Gender to skin color, the complexion of your pigment / The same fight that led people to walk-outs and sit-ins,” is a problematic comparison that many LGBTQ activists make, but has particular repercussions for a widely acclaimed hip hop song.
The music video for “Same Love” clearly illustrates the track's mainstream message for LGBTQ equality. It opens with a birth scene, which recalls the liberal LGBTQ tenet that queer people are born that way. The video continues to follow the apparently mixed-race child as he moves through childhood where he is shown playing carefree with friends in the woods and near a stream, to adolescence where he participates in a round of spin the bottle, making pained faces that only the camera picks up, letting the viewer in on his discomfort at this heterosexual rite of passage while his peers around him remain oblivious. In a scene that takes place at a high school dance, the teenager is shown first dancing with his classmates to dance tunes, but when a slow dance begins he is the odd man out, standing alone as everyone around him forms into heterosexual pairs. Eventually, this unnamed protagonist meets another man who becomes the love of his life, and, after a period of dating and some push back from his family (which is presented in the form of an awkward dinner scene in which the parents get up from the dinner table and walk away, leaving the protagonist and his partner alone), they get engaged and are married. Macklemore appears as a guest at their wedding, which is presented as the climactic pinnacle of this story, with even the aforementioned homophobic parents in attendance, smiling with tear-filled eyes as their son is wed.
The video ends with the interracial couple as old men, holding each other's hands as the protagonist lies dying in a hospital bed, presumably the same hospital in which he was born. While these images show that the couple has remained together for many years, seemingly demonstrating again that same-sex couples are just like heterosexual couples and that marriage equality leads to long, healthy relationships (rather than healthy relationships leading to successful marriages), they also illustrate another argument in favor of marriage equality that centers on legal protections for couples when one is hospitalized or dies.Footnote 39 Historically, without the ability to be legally married, LGBTQ couples have experienced many hardships that would be alleviated by the benefits afforded to their heterosexual counterparts. Same-sex partners who are not legally married are often not considered family or next-of-kin and can thus be barred from visiting ill partners in hospitals or prevented from making arrangements after a partner's death. Marriage equality extends those legal protections afforded to spouses to same-sex couples, including the right of spouses to serve as power of attorney in situations in which one partner is unable to make informed decisions.
The story offered in the “Same Love” video is familiar from narratives told as part of a mainstream and primarily gay, white, male-dominated movement for LGBTQ equality. These narratives are exemplified by the messages that make up the “It Gets Better Project” in that they illustrate the struggles of LGBTQ youth but suggest that if one can make it to adulthood most of their problems will dissipate because they will be assimilated into and accepted by the larger adult culture.Footnote 40 The “It Gets Better Project” was founded in 2010 by columnist and gay activist Dan Savage in an attempt to “communicate to lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender youth around the world that it gets better, and to create and inspire the changes needed to make it better for them.”Footnote 41 The project consists primarily of videos made by people, including celebrities and influential individuals such as President Barack Obama, expressing their support for LGBTQ youth and assuring them that whatever their current struggles, their lives will improve as they grow older. The idea is that these videos will inspire LGBTQ youth who may be coping with bullying, intolerant families, depression, and other LGBTQ-related issues to be resilient and positive. A section of the “It Gets Better Project” website, entitled “Timeline: How It's Gotten Better,” lists primarily legal accomplishments for LGBTQ populations in the United States and in other countries, such as progress for legal recognition for same-sex marriages and the passing of trans-inclusive legislation at local and national levels.
From its beginning, however, the project has been criticized for what many view as its lack of racial and gender analysis that has allowed it to capitalize on the deaths of white, male LGBTQ youth and focus on ways life gets better for that relatively privileged group. In a critique of the campaign, Kirk Grisham, a researcher at Columbia University writes:
Indeed, when we think of victims of homophobia-induced violence, many US citizens can easily recall the names of white gay males Tyler Clementi and Matthew Shepard but not Sakia Gunn, a black working class lesbian or Brandon White, a black gay youth. Why is that? Because many of the news stories prioritized within gay media outlets are framed by folk who seem to have a limited platform that favors particular persons, namely, middle-class white gay males, over some others. Savage and other middle-upper class gay white men benefit from this form of commodification.Footnote 42
Grisham goes on to cite several of Savage's implicitly racist comments throughout his career, including his supportive response to the US military involvement in Iraq in the early part of the twenty-first century, in which he engages in Islamophobia under the guise of eliminating anti-gay violence.Footnote 43 As Grisham concludes, Savage often uses the rhetoric of LGBTQ equality to justify the continued marginalization and oppression of people of color.
Although Macklemore's “Same Love” does not at first blush appear to engage in these same racial politics, especially given the racial identity of one of the video's protagonists, the circumstances surrounding the song's success, particularly when considering Macklemore's own position as a white, straight, cisgender male working within the genre of hip hop, raise similar concerns as the “It Gets Better Project” and of mainstream American LGBTQ movements in general, especially the current focus on marriage equality as a priority. Perhaps nowhere have these issues been more present than at Macklemore's and Ryan Lewis's appearance at the 2014 Grammy awards, where the duo not only took home four Grammy awards, including a contentious one in the Best Rap Album category, but also performed “Same Love” with Mary Lambert and guest artists Madonna, Trombone Shorty, and Queen Latifah, who officiated the legal marriage of thirty-three couples as part of the performance.
The segment begins with the aforementioned introduction by Queen Latifah, who appears in a simple, black evening gown. As she finishes her introduction, the lights on the stage darken and Latifah disappears, while neon lights in the shape of cathedral windows begin to take shape and Macklemore emerges in silhouette from an arched, neon gate. The scene created by the lights becomes more and more intricate as the song progresses, drawing designs and patterns reminiscent of the stained glass windows found in Christian places of worship. Thus, the Grammy stage becomes another institution in which the battle for marriage equality frequently plays out: the church. Mary Lambert comes into view not through the gate from which Macklemore emerged, but to the side of it, backed by the rich brass sounds of New Orleans’ Trombone Shorty and his band. The camera offers a few quick glimpses of Ryan Lewis, situated behind a drum set and computer setup.
After the third verse, the music pauses except for a held chord from a synthesized organ, the sound that brings audiences to the church they have just witnessed taking shape. Queen Latifah reemerges through the neon gates, taking on role of preacher as she begins to officiate the legal wedding ceremony from the Grammy stage. As she takes her place on the Grammy stage-cum-pulpit, she conducts the actual ceremony:
We are gathered here to celebrate love and harmony in every key and every color. As I look out on this audience I'm delighted to see the faces of thirty-three couples who've chosen this moment to celebrate their vows with us here in Los Angeles, and everyone watching around the world as witnesses. It is my distinct honor to now ask our participants to exchange rings to signal their commitment to one another and to a life shared together with the music of love. Will you please exchange rings? Do you each declare that you take each other as spouses? By the power vested in me by the state of California, I now declare you a married couple!
For audiences watching from their television sets, the camera toggles between shots of Latifah, the rows of brides and grooms, and birds-eye views of the entire audience. In quick succession, we see both queer and straight couples: one man in traditional Indian dress marrying another man in a Western suit; one white heterosexual couple next to them; and a Latina bride and her white soon-to-be husband next to them. After another quick shot of Latifah we see a lesbian couple, one femme-presenting with an arm full of tattoos clothed in a white dress and the other with a short haircut and a black suit. The scene points to the diversity of the participants, while also erasing their individual experiences under the auspices of their shared celebration of a difference-erasing love. In honoring the newlyweds as “married couples” Latifah folds the experiences of non-heterosexual couples into the heteronormative model.
As Latifah completes the ceremony, Madonna enters from the neon gate performing the chorus from her own “Open Your Heart” in a white tuxedo. The camera alternates between shots of her and views of the just-married couples. Many of these couples are shown crying, embracing, and sometimes dancing, but never kissing. Even as we see a few same-sex couples begin to lean towards each other, the camera quickly moves to a different scene, as if producers intentionally censor these displays of affection between people of the same gender. The music returns to that of “Same Love” as the newly wedded couples process through the audience along with Trombone Shorty, and Madonna joins Lambert for the end of the song. By the end of the performance, the stained glass windows of the neon cathedral that has been growing and increasing in detail are filled in with bright colors, the transformation of Grammy stage to church wedding now complete. As Lambert and Madonna finish the song, the camera shows celebrities such as Keith Urban and Beyoncé in the audience smiling and wiping tears from their eyes at the touching display.
In addition to subsuming queer couples under the rubric of heterosexual marriage, this live performance of “Same Love” also highlighted some of the tensions between mainstream white LGBTQ activism and communities of color. Perhaps in an effort to mitigate the Recording Academy's difficult relationship with hip hop over years, producers of the show advertised that the mass wedding would feature couples that were “gay, straight, old, young, of many races and many colors” prior to the broadcast.Footnote 44 However, the Grammy performance amplified Macklemore's critiques of hip hop, erasing the black music genre's history of grassroots activism and drawing on rhetoric often used by proponents for marriage equality that creates a false dichotomy between black communities and LGBTQ individuals.
This false dichotomy, which demonizes “black homophobia” as a particularly large hurdle for (white) LGBTQ Americans on the road to legalized same-sex marriage, was perhaps most evident in the backlash against black voters following the passing of California's Proposition 8 (hereafter Prop 8), an amendment to the state constitution that banned same-sex marriage in that state. Early exit polls, later proven inaccurate, estimated that seventy-percent of black voters, most of whom voted for President Barack Obama, also voted in favor of Prop 8.Footnote 45 In the days following the November 4, 2008 election, several of the biggest media outlets cited this statistic as fact, and struggled to account for a population of Californians who would elect a Democratic president while also approving such a conservative ballot measure. Political analyses that appeared in the following days in major publications included Karl Vick and Ashley Surdin's “Most of California's Black Voters Backed Gay Marriage Ban” in the Washington Post and Farhad Manjoo's “Props to Obama: Did He Help Push California's Gay-Marriage Ban Over the Top?” which appeared in Slate, each placing blame squarely on the large number of black voters who turned out to elect the nation's first black president.Footnote 46 Vick and Surdin wrote:
No ethnic group anywhere rejected the sanctioning of same-sex unions as emphatically as the state's black voters, according to exit polls. Fifty-three percent of Latinos also backed Proposition 8, overcoming the bare majority of white Californians who voted to let the court ruling [in favor of same-sex marriage] stand.
The outcome that placed two pillars of the Democratic coalition—minorities and gays—at opposite ends of an emotional issue sparked street protests in Los Angeles and a candlelight vigil in San Francisco.
Neither the Washington Post piece nor the Slate article mentions the staggering amount of financial and political backing offered by the Mormon Church, whose members are overwhelmingly white and who contributed in one estimate at least 50 percent of the financial backing used to pass the ballot measure.Footnote 47
As Vick and Surdin's language suggests, many white marriage equality supporters used the false exit poll results to justify scapegoating black communities for Prop 8's passing. Dan Savage wrote a blog post following the election in which he decried “black homophobia” as the root cause of the setback to marriage equality:
African American voters in California voted overwhelmingly for Prop 8, writing anti-gay discrimination into California's constitution and banning same-sex marriage in that state. … I'm thrilled that we've just elected our first African-American president. … But I can't help but feeling hurt that the love and support aren't mutual.
I do know this, though: I'm done pretending that the handful of racist gay white men out there—and they're out there, and I think they're scum—are a bigger problem for African Americans, gay and straight, than the huge numbers of homophobic African Americans are for gay Americans, whatever their color.Footnote 48
While Savage claims to be inclusive of LGBTQ people (or rather, simply gay people) who are nonwhite, his language suggests he is engaging in what is colloquially referred to as “oppression Olympics,” in which Savage, a member of an oppressed group (gay men), insists that the oppression that he experiences is worse than and, in many instances, caused by, another oppressed group, namely African Americans. He further insists on speaking for gay men of color (he only mentions gay men in his tirade, never women or people of other genders or sexualities) when he states that homophobia, not racism, is the greatest threat to their safety and happiness, rather than exploring ways in which homophobia and racism may interact in these men's lives.
Savage was far from the only commenter who jumped on the idea of black homophobia as way of explaining California's setback in marriage equality. Andrew Sullivan, another well-known white gay blogger, also voiced his opinion that the black church was rampant with homophobia and posed a threat to LGBTQ equality. Following the 2008 election, he echoed and built on Savage's comments:
For gay and lesbian black men and women, the blow [of black voters approving Prop 8] is even harder. But this community needs to be engaged not demonized, and we haven't engaged enough. The black church is one of the most powerful forces fomenting homophobia in America, and [it] has fostered attitudes that have literally killed countless gay black men. It's time to Act Up against those elements that p.c. liberals have been too timid to confront. For the sake of African American gay and lesbian people as much as anyone else.Footnote 49
Sullivan's approach, which appears at first to recognize the impact of the passing of Prop 8 on black LGBTQ people, takes a decidedly paternalistic turn, when he suggests that “we” (presumably white gay folks like himself) act on behalf of black LGBTQ people against the powerful homophobia of the black church.
As Slate contributor Jamelle Bouie points out, this scapegoating of black voters, like Macklemore's scapegoating of hip hop, is part of a larger phenomenon of “invented black pathology,” in which “behaviors present among other groups of Americans become pathologies when they're exhibited by blacks.”Footnote 50 Citing the report released by the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force in January 2009 that found that only 58 percent of African American voters supported Prop 8, he writes:
Prop 8 didn't win because of blacks or Latinos, it won because millions of Californians—white as much as black or brown—opposed same-sex marriage. Older Californians were most opposed (67 percent), but a near-majority of 30-to-44-year-olds and 45-to-64-year-olds also supported the amendment.
And yet, the narrative was set: If not for homophobic blacks, Prop 8 would have lost. As such, when North Carolina banned same-sex marriage in 2012, the blame fell again on black Americans, treating black support as a function of “blackness” and not religiosity or age.Footnote 51
This narrative, as Bouie illustrates, positions homophobia as a uniquely black problem, rather than an American problem that cuts across all ethnic and racial communities. By painting homophobia as such, white LGBTQ leaders position themselves as wiser, more progressive, and thus better situated as leaders of a mainstream movement that can “fix” the problems within communities of color. It also further marginalizes queer people of color who are left primarily outside of this discussion, unless they are invoked as infantile subjects in need of saving from their own communities.
Additionally, as Daniel Martinez HoSang chronicles, California has a history of proposing and passing ballot initiatives that contradicts the seemingly progressive and liberal attitude of its electorate, especially in the realm of race and racism.Footnote 52 He writes:
In the postwar era, rights and opportunity have been the lingua franca of California politics—the state has imagined itself at the forefront of not only national but global progress and development, fettered only by the limits to its own imagination. During this period, we can also locate many of the forces and dynamics posited to be the engines of “racial progress”: a generally liberal culture, a relatively robust economy, an increasingly diverse populace, and well-organized civil rights leadership. Yet … nearly every major civil rights and racial justice issue put before a vote of the people in California during this period has failed.Footnote 53
HoSang examines ballot measures that he argues represented and helped shape ideas about race in postwar California, but a similar argument could be made about propositions related to other aspects of social justice, such as LGBTQ rights and equality. The [white] liberal imagination that HoSang discusses also remains a largely heterosexual one, and it is partly through ballot initiatives such as Prop 8 and the discourses that surround them that homonormative notions of LGBTQ individuals and communities are produced and reproduced. In the discourses surrounding Prop 8, the LGBTQ community was represented as a largely white community and homophobia among black voters, rather than among California voters of all races that have a history of voting against civil rights initiatives, were positioned as oppositional to LGBTQ equality.
Macklemore's assertion in “Same Love” that, “If I were gay, I would think hip hop hates me” functions in much the same way as the backlash against black voters following the passing of Prop 8 in that it also relies on the exaggerated concept of black homophobia as a threat to LGBTQ people. Rather than emphasize the black church as the source of the communities’ bigotry, he targets the cultural institution of hip hop, but the accusation still relies on an invented black pathology that locates homophobia in hip hop but not in other, predominantly white genres. While it is true that some mainstream hip hop features anti-gay slurs and attitudes, Macklemore's position as a white rapper and the lack of any openly queer, black performers on his track complicates his criticism of the genre. Rather than combating homophobia in hip hop, his claims actually serve to bolster his strategic performance as a self-conscious, socially aware white rapper, while engaging in rhetoric that perpetuates a false dichotomy of black vs. gay.
Public Self-Fashioning
Macklemore and Ryan Lewis won four of the seven Grammys for which they were nominated in 2014, including those for Best New Artist, Best Rap Album, Best Rap Song, and Best Rap Performance, with the last three being major awards in the Rap category. Aware of his sweeping success in one of the few categories in which black artists often win, Macklemore sent a text message to fellow rapper Kendrick Lamar, whose 2012 release good kid, m.A.A.d. city was also nominated in the Best Rap Album category but lost to The Heist. In this text, Macklemore awkwardly attempts to demonstrate his cognizance of the privilege that won him this accolade. It reads:
You got robbed. I wanted you to win [Best Rap Album]. You should have. It's weird and sucks that I robbed you. I was gonna say that during the [acceptance] speech. Then the music started playing during my speech and I froze. Anyway, you know what it is. Congrats on this year and your music. [I] Appreciate you as an artist and as a friend. Much love.Footnote 54
Macklemore then posted a screen shot of the text to his Instagram account, making what most felt should have been a private admission to a colleague a very public performance of his self-awareness.Footnote 55 By posting this text online, Macklemore shared not just what might very well have been genuine admiration for a black artist in his genre, but also his own understanding of his white privilege. The Instagram photo was thus more a display of his own consciousness of his race than an apology to the individual he claimed to have “robbed,” and this public display further highlighted his strategic positioning of his own racial difference.
Macklemore later expressed regret for posting the text in an interview on HOT 97's Ebro in the Morning, a hip hop radio talk show with a wide following.Footnote 56 He stated:
We've [Lamar and Macklemore] texted [since the incident]. I made a mistake and a lot of fear was going into that moment. I wanted to win some Grammys. … I think we [Macklemore and Ryan Lewis] made a great album. I think it had great impact. … I wanted to win song of the year. I wanted to win best new artist. I wanted to win some rap categories. But I thought Kendrick had a better album. … The mistake came from Instagramming the text message and betraying my homie's trust. That's wack. … The language that I used was a bad call. “Robbed” was a bad choice of word. White people have been robbing black people for a long time. Of culture. Of music. Of freedom. Of their lives. That was a mistake.
Looking back at it, I learned about the voting process of the Grammys. Random people that aren't necessarily part of the culture whatsoever joining in on the ballot that comes back down to this whole issue of privilege because they're familiar with whoever is the biggest artist. That's who they check the box [for]. And in 2013, we had the biggest record.Footnote 57
Although Macklemore does state that he should not have shared the text as a public post (which was never removed from his Instagram account and remains available to anyone with internet access), he cites his use of language and his revelation of a private conversation as his mistake, not the highly visible display of race consciousness that it performed. The apology thus further serves Macklemore's self-fashioning project in that it both highlights his racial self-consciousness, including his self-awareness of his own privilege, and positions him as an authentic subject thoughtfully engaged in the racial discourses of contemporary hip hop.
In her book The Hip Hop Wars: What We Talk About When We Talk About Hip Hop—And Why It Matters, Tricia Rose examines these discourses surrounding the genre and explores the myths that shape them.Footnote 58 She suggests that the widely touted argument that “hip hop hurts black people” is, while pervasive, ultimately based on unfair generalizations. She writes:
The bulk of the kind of hip hop that promotes the worst of what we find in the music and imagery [including homophobia] is commercially promoted, encouraged, produced, and distributed by major corporations. Images and ideas that reflect good will, love of community, and a diverse range of black experiences are relegated—no matter the quality of the rhymes or beats—to the underground or to the commercial margins of youth culture … the one-dimensional but highly visible claim that hip hop hurts black people refuses to shine a light on these less exploitative artists [such as The Roots, Common, Immortal Technique, and others] and aspects of the music—where critiques of society as well as humanizing and contextualized internal critiques of black community-destroying behaviors are the norm rather than the exception.Footnote 59
Macklemore does not claim that hip hop, least of all his own brand of hip hop, hurts black people. He does, however, suggest that hip hop hurts gay people, an argument that is equally generalizing in its scope and detrimental to those hip hop practitioners who actively work against homophobia in their communities. It dismisses the work of openly queer black artists, such as Cakes da Killa, Mykki Blanco, Zebra Katz, Medusa, and the aforementioned Le1f, whose very existence, as well as their work, undermines such claims. Furthermore, the suggestion that hip hop hates gay people, like the idea that hip hop hurts black people, places the blame for homophobia squarely on the shoulders of the hip hop community, rather than situating it in a larger social and historical context of which hip hop is but a part.
In both his music and his public life, Macklemore carefully navigates the hip hop world by acknowledging his racial difference and privilege in a self-conscious way. Like Eminem, who rearticulated his whiteness to reflect the changing discourses around race and class in the late 1990s, Macklemore's approach also mirrors his own historical and social context. In presenting himself as an activist–artist concerned with social justice issues, he connects his work to pressing issues such as police brutality against black citizens and marriage equality. At the same time, however, he draws on rhetoric that both pathologizes black communities as disproportionately homophobic and continues to cast black people, and hip hop culture specifically, as oppositional to LGBTQ communities. He also continues to gain success in the larger music industry thanks in part to his whiteness, which draws the attention and appreciation of white fans that would not necessarily listen to black hip hop artists. As he himself stated, “Why am I safe? Why can I cuss on a record, have a parental advisory sticker on the cover of my album, yet parents are still like, ‘You're the only rap I let my kids listen to.’ … it's because of white privilege.”Footnote 60 He even addresses these issues in more recent songs, such as “White Privilege II,” released in 2016 and featuring black woman singer and poet Jamila Woods. His recognition of that fact and his willingness to engage in discussions of racial difference does not mitigate that reality, but it does open a space for him to perform a new kind of white authenticity in hip hop, one in which racial difference in the context of rap's predominant black masculinity is addressed directly rather than obfuscated through the lens of class.
Macklemore's racial self-awareness manifests itself in the ways in which he explicitly connects his work to pressing social justice issues such as police brutality against black people and marriage equality. At the same time, however, his track “Same Love,” which was widely heard through the Grammy award show broadcast and thus reached audiences beyond hip hop listeners, draws on rhetoric that relies on a false dichotomy between black communities and LGBTQ communities, suggesting that neither overlaps with the other. The idea that hip hop in particular is especially homophobic renders queer and trans hip hop practitioners, many of whom are black, invisible. The question, then, remains: is “Same Love” really a love song for all of us?
