Jeffrey Bortz argues that the overthrow of the Porfirian state allowed cotton textile workers to unleash a social revolution in the mills by seizing control over the factory floor, forming unions, allying with revolutionary leaders and generating a pro-labour regime. Workers' consciousness and actions constituted labour radicalism, formed through their experiences on the job, without orientation from socialism, anarchism or the dynamics of a moral economy. Bortz's conclusions, clearly argued and documented, demonstrate the importance of textile workers in the revolutionary process.
By 1900, cotton textile factories of varying size and production capacity proliferated along an industrial corridor that linked Mexico City, Puebla and Orizaba. Spanish and French entrepreneurs owned the largest and most modern factories, which produced comparatively inexpensive goods for Mexico's expanding population. Producers enjoyed the protection of the Porfirian state, which offered investment incentives and suppressed unions and strikes. By 1895 cotton textile factories employed over 500,000 workers, who mostly hailed from contiguous neighbourhoods. Adult males constituted 80 per cent of the workforce, but women predominated in knitwear plants and children laboured in significant numbers in the larger mills. Within the factories workers endured 14-hour days, stagnant wages, arbitrary fines, uncompensated work and brutal foremen.
Textile workers participated in the overthrow of Porfirio Díaz, against whom they had many grievances, and seized the opportunity to organise a revolution in the factories. During the general strike in 1911, textile workers won higher wages and improved conditions from owners no longer able to call in the troops. The following year, the administration of Francisco Madero approved a Reglamento de Trabajo that limited the working day to ten hours, established holidays and prohibited the hiring of children under the age of 14.
After Madero's overthrow, worker militancy increased and many state governments responded by enacting labour codes sanctioning unions, a minimum wage, the eight-hour day, equal pay for men and women, and arbitration boards to settle disputes between workers and owners. These provisions were subsequently incorporated into Article 123 of the Constitution of 1917, which created, at least on paper, the strongest labour regime in Latin America to that point. Progressive labour legislation represented a formal victory for workers, but its enforcement hinged on the support of the revolutionary state and the clout of the unions. In 1916, after Venustiano Carranza had crushed the anarchist Casa del Obrero Mundial, Luis Morones formed the Confederación Regional de Obreros Mexicanos (Regional Confederation of Mexican Workers, CROM), and allied with presidents Alvaro Obregón (1920–4) and Plutarco Elías Calles (1924–8). In the textile factories, CROM overcame competition from anarchist and company unions by using violence, intimidation and political manoeuvring. CROM officers came from the workforce, defended workers against management and maintained close ties with the rank and file. By the 1920s, however, many union bosses had emerged as caudillos more interested in power and money than the factory floor.
Bortz's carefully crafted study of textile workers will likely remain the standard book on the topic for years to come. To what extent, however, has Bortz changed our understanding of the Mexican Revolution? Previous scholars have concentrated on other aspects of the revolutionary process, especially land disputes, charismatic leadership, imperialism and political conflict, and have disagreed over the relative influence of each. Bortz's book puts textile workers into the mix by demonstrating that they ‘turned their world upside down’ by winning gains in real wages, legal rights and control over hiring, firing and disciplining in the factories. Workers achieved these victories through direct action and political organisation, as opposed to the generosity of a benevolent state. By way of comparison, Mexican copper miners engaged in similar struggles against mining companies during the revolution and succeeded in establishing unions, forging alliances with revolutionaries and winning benefits. Future studies of workers in other important sectors of the economy, such as the petroleum and railway industries, would facilitate a comprehensive view of the workers' revolution within the context of the larger revolution.
