Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T13:11:44.703Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Disrupt the upper or the lower conduit? The dual role of gas exsolution in the conduits of persistently active volcanoes

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 May 2022

Shirui Peng*
Affiliation:
Division of Geological and Planetary Sciences, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91106, USA
Davide Picchi
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, Università degli Studi di Brescia, Brescia 25123, Italy
Jenny Suckale
Affiliation:
Department of Geophysics, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USADepartment of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USAInstitute for Computational and Mathematical Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: speng2@caltech.edu

Abstract

Many volcanoes emit a significant portion of the gas they transport to the atmosphere during continual passive degassing rather than during eruptions. To maintain a high gas and thermal flux without erupting magma, the flow field in the volcanic conduit must be approximately balanced with gas-rich, buoyant magma ascending and degassed, heavy magma descending. In vertical conduits, this exchange flow takes the form of core–annular flow, where the gas-rich magma forms a core enclosed by an annulus of degassed magma. The flow dynamics of core–annular flow have been studied extensively in fluid dynamics, but mostly for constant material properties. Our study aims to advance our understanding of how core–annular flow responds to volatile exsolution – a simple, yet ubiquitous disruption in volcanic conduits, which alters both the density and the viscosity of the core fluid. By deriving an evolution equation for the core–annular interface based on a generalized exchange-flow condition using a lubrication approximation, we find that the response of the system to volatile exsolution depends on the conduit flow regime. The same nucleation event can lead to a flow adjustment only in the upper, only in the lower or in both portions of the volcanic conduit. Our results emphasize that the thermodynamic evolution of magma properties and volcanic conduit flow are intricately linked, which may help understand the observed variability of eruptive behaviour at persistently degassing volcanoes.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Sketch of the core–annular flow geometry in a vertical conduit. Motivated by the volcanic context, we consider a sudden exsolution event in the upper conduit that leads to a step-wise decrease in the effective density (a) and a step-wise increase in the effective viscosity (b) of the core magma. Note that bubbles are not plotted to scale.

Figure 1

Table 1.List of the dimensionless parameters and variables of the problem.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Nonconvexity of the flux function and associated variability in its derivative imply four ranges of $\delta$ with different associated wave behaviours. (a) Flux function $Te$ with $\mathcal {R}=0.95$ and $M=100$. The blue diamond and red triangle indicate the flux for the two steady-state solutions shown in panel (c). (b) Derivative of the flux function with respect to the volume fraction $\alpha$. The dashed and dash-dotted lines indicate the flooding point $\delta _{FP}$ and two inflection points $\delta _{I1}$, $\delta _{I2}$, respectively. (c) Vertical ascent speed in the radial direction for thin-core flow (blue) as compared to thick-core flow (red). The two solutions refer to the same total flux of $Te\approx 0.06$, highlighted in panel (a) as a dotted line.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Isolating and comparing the effect of a jump in effective core density to that in effective core viscosity. (a) Upper domain flux function $Te$ for different density jumps $\Delta _\rho =0.03,0,-0.05$ at constant core viscosity $\Delta _\mu =0$. The dashed and dash-dotted lines indicate the flooding point and two inflection points, which are identical for all three scenarios. (b) Upper domain flux function $Te$ for different viscosity jump $\Delta _\mu =9,0,-0.9$ at constant core density. The reference magma density and viscosity contrast are $\mathcal {R}=0.95$ and $M=100$. The flooding point position for each case corresponds to the dashed line with the same colour code. The arrows reflect the position shift of the flooding point due to a viscosity jump. Here we only consider the first flux term in (2.20).

Figure 4

Figure 4.Change in the sign of the kinematic wave speed implies two regimes in which information about volatile exsolution propagates either mostly downwards, $C_\alpha <0$, or mostly upwards, $C_\alpha >0$. (a) Kinematic wave speed, $C_\alpha$, as a function of the volume fraction, $\alpha$, and the viscosity ratio, $M$. The black dashed line represents the limit of infinite viscosity ratio. (b) The two dynamic regimes of upward and downward dynamics are separated by the flooding point (black line) and depend on core thickness, $\delta$, and viscosity ratio, $M$.

Figure 5

Figure 5.The density and viscosity waves are always upward oriented. (a) Viscosity wave speed $C_\varphi$ as a function of the core-thickness $\delta$ and the viscosity ratio $M$. We calculate $C_\varphi$ for $\psi =1$. (b) Density wave speed $C_\psi$ as a function of the core-thickness $\delta$ and the viscosity ratio $M$. In both cases, the black dashed line represents the limit of infinite viscosity ratio.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Numerical simulations showing the change in core thickness as well as the type and direction of the generated wave in response at the nucleation depth. Panels (a,c) show the flow adjustment in response to a 5 % drop in core density jump at $z=0$ in thin-core and thick-core flow, respectively. In the lower conduit, we assume a density ratio of $\mathcal {R}=0.95$ and viscosity ratio of $M=100$. Panels (b,d) show the flow adjustment in response to a nine-fold increase in core viscosity at $z=0$ in thin-core and thick-core flow, respectively. The magma properties in the lower conduit are identical to those in panels (a,c), but we now impose a viscosity jump of $\Delta _\mu =9$ at the nucleation depth, while keeping the core density constant, $\Delta _\rho = 0$. In panels (a–d), the type and direction of the generated wave are indicated through coloured arrows pointing in the direction of wave propagation. Cyan represents rarefactions (R) and brown represents shocks (S). Light and dark shading of these colours indicates ascending and descending motion, respectively.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Overview of the relative importance of the density and viscosity effect on the core volume fraction at the nucleation depth. The ratio between the wave speeds of the viscosity and the density waves is a proxy for the change in core volume fraction (see (3.7) and (3.9)) and shown here as a function of the core-thickness $\delta$ and the viscosity ratio $M$ over a wide range of parameters. The two effects are comparable only at relatively low viscosity ratio.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Simulation results for a 5 % drop in core density at $z=0$ and various uniform initial core thicknesses $\delta _0$. Panels (a,d,g) show $Te$-$\alpha$ diagrams with initial and final states highlighted. The light and dark grey curves represent the flux functions in the upper and lower domains, respectively. Dashed and dash-dotted lines indicate corresponding $\alpha$ values of the flooding point and inflection points. Each diagram in the (d,g), (e,h) and ( f,i) panels on the same row show the corresponding core radius $\delta (z,t)$ and total pressure gradient $\mathrm {d}p/\mathrm {d}z$. Arrows in (b,e,h) indicate wave types with ‘R’ for rarefaction, ‘S’ for shock. In all simulations, $\mathcal {R}=0.95$, $M=100$, $\Delta _\mu =0$ and $\Delta _\rho = -1/19$.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Simulation results for an increase in core viscosity at $z=0$ and various uniform initial core thicknesses $\delta _0$. Panels (a,d,g), (b,e,h) and (c, f,i) represent $Te$-$\alpha$ diagrams, core thickness evolution and total pressure gradient change. Since the viscosity jump shifts the positions of the flooding and inflection points (see § 3.1), the dashed lines now refer to different flux curves: In panels (a,d,g), the left dash-dotted line and the dashed line refer to the lower flux curve, and the right dash-dotted line refers to the higher flux curve. In all simulations, $\mathcal {R}=0.95$, $M=100$, $\Delta _\mu =9$ and $\Delta _\rho = 0$.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Summary of the dynamic regimes that can arise in response to volatile exsolution. Panels (a,b) are both based on a 5 % decrease in core density, but represent different viscosity contrasts of $M=100$ and $M=1000$, respectively. The dashed line and the dash-dotted line indicate the flooding and inflection points. Panels (c,d) are both based on a nine-fold increase in core viscosity. In both cases, $\mathcal {R}=0.95$, $\Delta _\rho = 0$ and $\Delta _\mu =9$, but the initial viscosity contrast is $M=100$ in panel (c) and $M=10^4$ in panel (d). The dashed line and the dash-dotted line on the left indicate the flooding and left inflection points of the lower flux function, while the dash-dotted line on the right represents the right inflection point of the higher flux function. Regions in panels (b,c) with dark cyan sitting above light cyan indicate the existence of both ascending and descending rarefactions.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Summary of our main finding that the impact of bubble nucleation depends sensitively on the conduit flow regime. (a,b) In thin-core flow, bubble nucleation leads to adjustments in the upper conduit. (c,d) In thick-core flow, bubble nucleation leads to adjustments in the lower conduit.

Supplementary material: File

Peng et al. supplementary material

Peng et al. supplementary material

Download Peng et al. supplementary material(File)
File 2 MB