Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T22:00:21.193Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Energy dissipation during laminar planar jump of a generalised time-independent non-Newtonian liquid – An analytical approach

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 March 2026

Banashree Samanta
Affiliation:
Department of Chemical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur, West Bengal 721302, India
Subhabrata Ray
Affiliation:
Department of Chemical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur, West Bengal 721302, India
Gargi Das*
Affiliation:
Department of Chemical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur, West Bengal 721302, India
*
Corresponding author: Gargi Das, gargi@che.iitkgp.ac.in

Abstract

This study presents an in-depth analysis of the energy dissipation and momentum balance during a laminar planar hydraulic jump in a viscous free surface flow, with shallow flow theory used to estimate the relevant jump parameters. The inclusion of momentum and kinetic energy correction factors incorporates the influence of the fluid nature. The fluid is described by the generalised Herschel–Bulkley model with Papanastasiou regularisation, which reduces to the Bingham plastic, power-law and Newtonian models under relevant limiting conditions. The analysis, extensively validated against experimental and simulated data, is explored to understand the physics of free surface flow during jump formation. Energy dissipation increases with an increase in the flow behaviour index n, flow consistency index k and yield stress τo since each of them increases the apparent viscosity. Interestingly, it is higher in the supercritical (upstream) compared with the subcritical (downstream) zone. For constant discharge rate and film thickness, the specific energy depends on the velocity profile and is thus a function of n and τo but not k, and the mechanism of influence of n and τo are also different. For a generalised approach, energy dissipation and jump parameters are discussed as a function of relevant non-dimensional numbers obtained from SFT. Energy dissipation during a hydraulic jump in non-Newtonian liquids is a hitherto unexplored aspect. In fact, energy dissipation during a planar jump in a viscous Newtonian liquid is also rare, although hydraulic jumps are primarily used as energy dissipators in free surface flows.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Specific energy diagram (Es vs h) and (b) schematic representation of free surface profile (A-1–2-C) during a planar hydraulic jump, where A, 1, 2 and C correspond to the channel inlet, position immediate upstream and downstream of the jump and the channel exit, respectively.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Schematic representation of a natural hydraulic jump in a HB fluid. The yield surface $(| \tau | =\tau _{o})$ is denoted by the green dashed line. Here u and v are the streamwise (x-directional) and the vertical (y-directional) component of velocity. Subscripts ‘1’ and ‘2’ denote the locations immediate upstream and downstream of the jump. The flow is supercritical (Fr1 > 1) upstream of the jump and subcritical (Fr2 < 1) after the jump. The respective heights of the shear zone and the liquid film are ho and h. Throughout the flow, the velocity increases from zero at the channel floor to um at the yield surface, and the velocity in the plug region remains constant at um, the maximum velocity of the shear zone.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Velocity distribution in terms of similarity parameters for a HB fluid with different n at a constant $\eta _{o}$ ( = 0.6). The position of the yield surface is denoted by a grey line that is extrapolated up to the y/h axis to show the value of the fractional thickness of the shear zone, $\eta _{o}=h_{o}/h$.

Figure 3

Table 1.Governing equations and relevant parameters to obtain a steady-state free surface profile and relative energy dissipation for different inelastic time-independent liquids ($\mu _{d}$ and $\mu _{p}$ are the dynamic viscosity of the Newtonian liquid and the plastic viscosity of the BP liquid, respectively).

Figure 4

Figure 4.Depiction of the solution methodology to evaluate the steady-state free surface profile (curve ABEF), jump location (x/hin-position corresponding to BE) and scaled conjugate depths (h1/hin and h2/hin) from SFT. The free surface profiles for three different mvalues (m = 0.1, 100 and 1000 s) are superimposed and so cannot be distinguished.

Figure 5

Table 2.Fluid properties, inlet slit height ($h_{\textit{in}}$) and inlet velocity ($u_{\textit{in}}$) during the experiments.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Theoretical vis-à-vis experimental steady-state free surface profiles at different q and L/hin for (a) 3 % BT, (b) 3 % BT + 0.05 % XG, (c) 3 % BT + 0.1 % XG, (d) 3 % BT + 0.15 %, (e) 6 % BT and (f) 0.1 % XG. Hollow circles represent experimental data. The upper and lower solid curves correspond to the upstream and downstream profiles obtained from (4.16). The dashed green curve is the profile obtained from the Bélanger equation (2.3) and the red dotted line denotes the jump location.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Schematic representation of the computational domain (rectangular channel ABCDA) with initial and boundary conditions. The yellow portion represents the liquid film and the remaining portion is filled with air. Here H is the height of the channel of length L and hin (AE) is the height of the inlet opening. The jump location (xj) and upstream (h1) and downstream (h2) heights are marked in the figure. In the wetted wall condition, $\hat{n}$ is the unit normal outward vector from the surface and $\theta _{w}$ is the contact angle of liquid with solid in the presence of air. Here phyd is the hydrostatic pressure of the liquid.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Steady-state velocity profiles from numerical simulations at different axial locations for (a) n = 0.4, HBin = 0.3, Frin = 12, Rein = 250 and L/ hin = 180, where the scaled jump location xj/hin = 18; (b) n = 0.7, HBin = 0.15, Frin = 10, Rein = 200 and L/ hin = 180, where xj/hin = 29. The red and blue curves indicate the velocity profile upstream and downstream of the jump. The position of the yield surface for the fully developed downstream velocity profile (blue curves) is denoted by the grey line, its ordinate (y/h) signifying the value of the fractional thickness of the shear zone, $\eta _{o}=h_{o}/h$.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Comparison of the velocity profile from SFT and numerical simulation (for the fully developed downstream section) for (a) 0.1 % XG, (b) 0.1 % XG + 3 % BT, (c) 0.05 % XG + 3 % BT, (d) 3 % BT corresponding to conditions as given in table 2. The location of the yield surface is shown in each plot along with the fractional thickness of the shear zone, $\eta _{o}$. The plug and shear zone are labelled in the figures.

Figure 10

Figure 9.Parity plots for (a) $\eta _{o}$, (b) $x_{j}$ and (c) $h_{2}$/$h_{1}$, obtained from SFT and simulation at different ${\textit{Re}}_{\textit{in}} , {\textit{Fr}}_{\textit{in}} , \textit{HB}_{\textit{in}}$ and $L/h_{\textit{in}}$. In each plot, the solid green line is the parity line [$\eta _{o,SFT} = \eta _{o,sim}$ in (a), $x_{j,\textit{SFT}} = x_{j,\textit{sim}}$ in (b) and $(h_{2}/h_{1})_{\textit{SFT}} = (h_{2}/h_{1})_{\textit{sim}}$ in (c)] and the (±) % deviation ranges are marked by the dotted magenta lines.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Parity plot for the fractional energy dissipation obtained from theory and numerical simulations for four different liquid types: Newtonian, power-law, BP and HB liquids.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Variation of the fractional energy dissipation with respect to the upstream liquid head (${\unicode[Arial]{x0394}} E_{s}/E_{s,1}$) as a function of (a) the upstream Froude number Fr1 at a fixed fractional thickness of the shear zone ($\,\eta _{o}=0.5$), and (b) $\,\eta _{o}$ at fixed ${\textit{Fr}}_{1}(=5)$. Both the plots are shown for four different values of n (n = 0.1, 0.4, 0.7 and 1).

Figure 13

Figure 12.Contour plot of ${\unicode[Arial]{x0394}} E_{s}/E_{s,1}$ in ${\textit{Fr}}_{1}$ vs $\eta _{o}$ plane for n = (a) 0.1, (b) 0.4, (c) 0.7 and (d) 1. The magnitude of ${\unicode[Arial]{x0394}} E_{s}/E_{s,1}$ is shown by different colours specified in the colour bar beside each figure. Some of the isocontour lines of ${\unicode[Arial]{x0394}} E_{s}/E_{s,1}$ are also shown by the grey solid lines.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Specific energy diagram for different (a) n at k = 0.04 Pa sn,$\,\tau _{o}$ = 0.05 Pa, L = 4 cm, hin = 0.025 cm, uin = 0.45 ms−1; (b) k at n = 0.4,$\,\tau _{o}$ = 0.05 Pa, L = 4 cm, hin = 0.025 cm, uin = 0.40 ms−1; (c) $\,\tau _{o}$ at n = 0.4 and k = 0.04 Pa.sn, L = 4 cm, hin = 0.025 cm, uin = 0.40 ms−1. The path followed by the fluid in each case is O–A–B–C, where O represents the inlet, A is immediately upstream of the jump, B is immediately downstream of the jump and C is the exit point, assumed to be at a critical state.

Figure 15

Figure 14.Variation of the steady-state free surface (x vs h) and yield surface (x vs ho) profiles for different (a) n at k = 0.04 Pa sn,$\,\tau _{o}$ = 0.05 Pa, L = 4 cm, hin = 0.025 cm, uin = 0.45 ms−1; (b) k at n = 0.4,$\,\tau _{o}$ = 0.05 Pa, L = 4 cm, hin = 0.025 cm, uin = 0.40 ms−1; (c) $\,\tau _{o}$ at n = 0.4 and k = 0.04 Pa sn, L = 4 cm, hin = 0.025 cm, uin = 0.40 ms−1. Points O, A. B and C represent the inlet, upstream of the jump, downstream of the jump and exit, respectively.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Variation of $\eta _{o}$ as a function of (a) n at k = 0.04 Pa sn,$\,\tau _{o}$ = 0.05 Pa, L = 4 cm, hin = 0.025 cm, uin = 0.45 ms−1; (b) k at $\,\tau _{o}$ = 0.05 Pa, L = 4 cm, hin = 0.025 cm, uin = 0.40 ms−1 for n = 0.4 and 1.0; (c) $\,\tau _{o}$ at (n = 0.4 and k = 0.04 Pa sn) and (n = 1 and k = 0.0008 Pa sn) for L = 4 cm, hin = 0.025 cm, uin = 0.40 ms−1.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Contour plot of the specific energy (Es) throughout the channel for different (a) n at k = 0.04 Pa sn,$\tau _{o}$ = 0.05 Pa, L = 4 cm, hin = 0.025 cm, uin = 0.45 ms−1; (b) k at n = 0.4,$\,\tau _{o}$ = 0.05 Pa, L = 4 cm, hin = 0.025 cm, uin = 0.40 ms−1; (c) $\,\tau _{o}$ at n = 0.4 and k = 0.04 Pa sn, L = 4 cm, hin = 0.025 cm, uin = 0.40 ms−1. Different levels of specific energy are indicated in the colour bar beside each plot. The solid grey lines denote the isocontours of Es with the corresponding values. The dashed black curve in panels (a), (b) and (c) represent the jump location $x_{j}$ vs n, k, and$\,\tau _{o}$, respectively. The supercritical (upstream) and subcritical (downstream) regions are on the left- and right-hand side of the line in each figure.

Figure 18

Figure 17.Effect of n on (a) the fractional head loss across the jump, ${\unicode[Arial]{x0394}} E_{s}/E_{s,{\textit{in}}}$, and (b) the scaled jump location, $x_{j}/h_{\textit{in}}$ (black curves), and jump strength, $h_{2}/h_{1}$ (red curves), for different ${\textit{Re}}_{\textit{in}}$ at ${\textit{Fr}}_{\textit{in}}=8, \textit{HB}_{\textit{in}}=0.3$ and $L/h_{\textit{in}}=160$. Effect of n on (c) ${\unicode[Arial]{x0394}} E_{s}/E_{s,{\textit{in}}}$ and (d) $x_{j}/h_{\textit{in}}$ (black curves) and $h_{2}/h_{1}$ (red curves) for different $L/h_{\textit{in}}$ at ${\textit{Fr}}_{\textit{in}}=8 , \textit{HB}_{\textit{in}}=0.3$ and ${\textit{Re}}_{\textit{in}}=180$.

Figure 19

Figure 18.Effect of n on (a) the fractional head loss across the jump, ${\unicode[Arial]{x0394}} E_{s}/E_{s,{\textit{in}}}$, and (b) the scaled jump location, $x_{j}/h_{\textit{in}}$ (black curves), and jump strength, $h_{2}/h_{1}$ (red curves), for different $ \textit{HB}_{\textit{in}}$ at ${\textit{Fr}}_{\textit{in}}=8, {\textit{Re}}_{\textit{in}}=180$ and $L/h_{\textit{in}}=160$. Effect of n on (c) ${\unicode[Arial]{x0394}} E_{s}/E_{s,{\textit{in}}}$ and (d) $x_{j}/h_{\textit{in}}$ (black curves) and $h_{2}/h_{1}$ (red curves) for different ${\textit{Fr}}_{\textit{in}}$ at $L/h_{\textit{in}}=160 , \textit{HB}_{\textit{in}}=0.3$ and ${\textit{Re}}_{\textit{in}}=180$.

Figure 20

Figure 19.A plot of the shear stress versus the shear rate of the test liquids obtained from the rheometer.

Figure 21

Figure 20.Schematic representation of the experimental set up.