General Douglas MacArthur was one of the greatest generals in American history. He also was an aspiring liberator for Filipinos, a benevolent occupier of Japan, a timely savior for South Koreans, and a deadly enemy general for the Chinese and North Koreans. Few would challenge that MacArthur was a legendary military and political figure who left profound and lasting impacts on several Asian countries during and after the Pacific War. Yet he was equally a controversial leader who not only weathered both victories and defeats in battle, but also exhibited a conflicting image of reactionary and reformer. His openly defiant attitude towards leadership in Washington, DC also became occasionally troublesome. Hiroshi Masuda's book, MacArthur in Asia, presents original and painstaking efforts to recast MacArthur's successes and failures and to unravel hitherto unexplored dimensions of his personality and leadership mostly through the prism of his immediate staff, the ‘Bataan Boys (Gangs)’.
The book consists of 13 chapters spanning General MacArthur's career in Asia, from his appointment as Quezon's military advisor in the Philippines in 1935 to his dismissal as the Commander of the United Nations Command in April 1951, and can be broken down into four main parts. Part I (Chapters 1−2) opens with MacArthur's early career, his relationship with the Philippines, and the origin and profile of the ‘Bataan Boys’ who served as aides to the general across the Philippines, Australia, and Japan. Part II (Chapters 3−8) examines his activities from the onset of the Pacific War, the fall of Manila and withdrawal to the Bataan Peninsula, the humiliating evacuation from Corregidor to Australia, massive counterattacks, and his return to the Philippines (1941–4). Part III (Chapters 9−12) covers the surrender of Japan and ensuing occupation period. General MacArthur and his staff's role in the demilitarization and democratization of Japan, conflicts with the Truman administration over an early peace treaty with Japan, and MacArthur's occupation policy in the context of the advent of the Cold War are analyzed in a rich and comprehensive manner (1945−50). Lastly, Part IV (Chapter 13) is devoted to General MacArthur's role during the Korean War including the Inchon landing and his ultimate dismissal.
In his final chapter, Masuda makes an interesting analysis of General MacArthur as hero and attributes this to seven factors: (1) MacArthur's demonstration of unusual courage even at the risk of his own life; (2) decisiveness at the time of crisis; (3) faithful loyalty to superiors, subordinates, and the military ideal of justice; (4) dignity and charismatic personality; (5) superb intelligence; (6) competent leadership in setting goals, implementing plans, and recruiting able aides; and (7) unflinching conviction to what he believed was right and just. According to Masuda, however, General MacArthur was not without his weaknesses. He was too formal, introverted, and even sentimental to socialize well with others. Often hesitant to accept criticism, he was overly sensitive to personal attacks. His strong ego and ‘unconscious prejudices’ often led to wrong judgments of situation such as overconfidence in American military power and underestimation of the strategic intentions of North Korea, China, and the Soviet Union. and eventual setbacks and hard times. Equally critical was his arbitrary and hyperbolic decision-making style that aggravated the people surrounding him. Nonetheless, Masuda observes that MacArthur's strengths and merit far outweighed his flaws and shortcomings. When taken together, Masuda builds a truly multi-dimensional portrait of the famous general.
This volume is a praiseworthy and penetrating account of General MacArthur's career and life in Asia. Masuda should be commended for successfully weaving fragmented facts and oral testimonies into a well-articulated and factually intensive narrative, which I evaluate very highly in several respects. Above all, the book is rich and original in its historical accounts. The author not only tapped a wide range of primary sources on General MacArthur, but also effectively utilized oral interviews of the ‘Bataan Boys’. Their testimonies proved to be very valuable in deciphering the leadership style, personality, and actual maneuvers of General MacArthur. In so doing, Masuda, a prominent diplomatic historian in Japan, has opened the gate to new vantage points and insights into MacArthur. Although he does not hide his bias in favor of the general, as most Japanese scholars do, his analysis seems well balanced and trustworthy in examining MacArthur's successes and failures alike, his joys and anxieties, and his compliance and defiance. In the chapters on demilitarization and democratization of Japan, Masuda also reveals some provocative insights into the subtle interactions between the general and key Japanese political leaders at the time. Overall, the book is generally well written with an impeccable translation that reads very smoothly.
In terms of critique, however, space allocation seems at times problematic. Too much time is spent on MacArthur's escape from the Philippines and the subsequent battles on Bataan and Corregidor, perhaps owing in part to the author's own personal visits to Bataan and Corregidor. Meanwhile, very little attention is paid to a bloody battle in New Guinea and the February−March 1945 Battle of Manila that cost more than 100,000 civilian casualties. Especially, the battle of Manila calls for a close examination because General MacArthur and his staff are known to have committed some fatal tactical mistakes. Also, the author's claim notwithstanding, it is not clear how MacArthur and his staff's experiences in the Philippines affected the demilitarization, democratization, and purge policy in Japan, which deserves further inquiry. It is more so because Japan and the Philippines had completely different political, economic, and social contexts. Similarly, MacArthur's role in the Korean War draws very limited attention as well, despite the inter-related implications for the North Korean nuclear crisis today. For example, on 9 December 1950, after China's intervention in the Korea War, MacArthur requested commander's discretion to use atomic weapons in Korea, including submission of a list of ‘retardation targets’ requiring 26 atomic bombs. Given the gravity of atomic weapons and the ongoing controversy over their use both in and outside of times of war, Masuda should have delved into the nature of these issues and MacArthur's influence on them at some length.
Despite some minor lapses mentioned above, the book represents an outstanding contribution to the study of General MacArthur. Masuda has admirably rediscovered several competing images of General MacArthur by blending military history, diplomatic history, and political history through the eye of an Asian scholar. A must-read for students of diplomatic history, war history, international relations, and Asian politics.
