In what ways can we plan the future via architecture and determine processes that will materialize as concrete environments, entities or events? Can we intervene architecturally or does reality have a ‘plan’, a blueprint that can only be articulated within time and space as a type suggesting specific ways of functioning on the basis of and within certain architectural forms? The examination of design methodologies in architecture reveals a noticeable shift in recent years in the application of various methods, as well as in their underlying intellectual perception of the future, and in the notion of the plan. One such method conceives of architecture as a predetermined entity, claiming that architecture has a plan, a programme that determines its emergence based on a specific type – a repetitive pattern relating both to form and to function – prior to its coming into being. Patterns emerge as a set of rules through which the specific type is formulated as a method that is applied in future planning. The other method focuses on the procedures of architectural becoming, attempting to release the emergence of the architectural entity from predetermined formal or functional typological definitions. Architecture is mobilized as a free flow into process-based, non-repetitive realities that create endless, differentiated and changeable entities.
These two methods have recently been located as intellectual opposites, reflecting a shift in the ways in which architecture is thought about and creates the future. In what follows, I will examine these methods briefly, and discuss their perceptions and conceptions of the future. My claim is that while it seems that only the predetermined procedure bases the emergence of architecture on the idea of type, the free-flow procedure, in fact, also refers to this idea. Each method, however, defines the idea of type in a slightly different manner: the first treats type as a closed and predetermined system, while the second refers to type as a flexible and changeable mechanism. These distinctions also determine the ways in which we perceive the performance of the individual human subject within the architectural realm as an interaction with the programmed environment. Before discussing these distinctions, however, it is necessary to elaborate on the concepts of programme, design method and intentionality.
The logic of design methods
Design assumes intentionality. Having to present a clear and definite design, architects apply methods that assist them in reaching a desired result. Usually, the episteme of the design process is based on expertise and techniques acquired through learning and experience, which are applied during the process. This notion, however, does not suggest that acquiring expertise and techniques is limited to institutionalized or professionalized circumstances, by individuals or groups. Any individual may acquire the necessary methods and techniques to mobilize a design process. Whether based on institutionalized, professionalized or other knowledge, to paraphrase Pierre Bourdieu, the desire to achieve a specific result leads the architect to apply certain methods in order to accomplish her or his aspirations.Footnote 1 Moreover, even when a method that allows freedom within the creative procedure is applied, there is a close relationship between the design method and the outcome. For example, within a Dadaist procedure, in which randomness underpins the creative method, there is a close relation between the method and the desired result.Footnote 2
The application of a specific method in a controlled or uncontrolled fashion does not, however, guarantee its predictability (even when the unpredictable functions as a method, as in the case of Dada). There is no way to monitor a process fully, to control and predict the end result, because it is likely that throughout the design process itself some so-called ‘accidents’, leading to unforeseen results, will occur. Paul Virilio discusses the duality of processes of this kind in his theory on accidents – ‘accidentology’ – claiming that ‘accidents’ are integral to an evolutionary process and are, in fact, only perceived as such by the human subject that cannot foresee them at the outset.Footnote 3 Once they occur and are observed, they become incorporated as part of an event or a process perceived to have gone awry.
Virilio's viewpoint may lead us to perceive the design process in deterministic terms. One might argue that perceiving the predicted and the so-called unpredicted accidental aspect of the design process as part of a preplanned evolutionary programme for architecture leaves no room for intentionality; everything is known and predetermined even if we are not aware of it. However, one may still argue that a nondeterministic aspect of a process is part of human decision-making. Thus intentionality is manifested through the ability of an agency to choose one process and not another. Launching a certain process will release a specific set of parameters for the evolution of architecture, whereas choosing another process will release a different set and will result in another form of architecture. Agency is manifested by the act of choosing a process rather than by controlling it. The method of design is intentional and directional since it sets the framework and limitation of an end result. It creates a spectrum of possibilities for events to evolve, a spectrum that is defined by limits.
Programmed types
Throughout architectural history we have witnessed two ways of referring to the question of type. From the Enlightenment to modernism, prevailing conceptualizations considered the notion of type to be an underlying structure of the architectural action, a regulator of the relations between the various architectural components: form, function, space and material. This concept is related to the architectural unit as an entity that has to be articulated following specified typologies, allowing the creation of a clear articulation of architectural entities based on language.Footnote 4 Types, as defined by the Enlightenment philosopher Denis Diderot in his Encyclopédie (1751–65), were considered in relation to the Platonic eidos as an ideal form that must be aspired to. Diderot used the Greek notion of the type as a copy, an image and a symbol; he claimed that types are a sort of model that will always remain copies, even if they attempt to become an ideal form.Footnote 5 Architects and archaeologists later referred to the idea of type as a means to arrive at the origin of an architectural entity. In his Dictionnaire d'Architecture (1788–1825) the French archaeologist Quatremère de Quincy, for example, referred to the concept of the type as an Ur-form, a fundamental form that allows one to decipher the origin of an architectural entity through an analysis of its evolution.Footnote 6 Types were seen as archetypes that provided means for understanding architectural expression, creating methods that will allow for their repetition.
The twentieth-century German-British architectural historian Nikolaus Pevsner referred to the idea of type as a mechanism for the classification of buildings. In his seminal study, A History of Building Types (1976), he classified buildings according to their function on the basis of an analysis of their programmatic and spatial organization.Footnote 7 Pevsner noticed that several building typologies had undergone evolutionary processes and were transformed into new entities, while maintaining their own type. His perception of the type as a pure category based on function and form restricted his vision and prevented him, on the one hand, from considering the possibility of a single building as a type in and of itself, and, on the other hand, from speculating on evolutionary processes outside the type itself. For him, various iterations within a type were a matter of refinement of the components within that type, and could not tolerate extreme deviations of the iterations from the main properties that constituted the type. Accordingly, the development of the prison-type was made by reconsidering the relation between the function of the building and its formal and spatial organization and articulation. Although it has changed over the years, the prison-type has maintained its basic configuration, enabling Pevsner to recognize the different iterations as belonging to the same type.
Regardless of whether the notion of the type referred to an ideal form or was used for classification, types were definite and stable and as such could provide a programme or a method that would lead to their concrete articulation. The development of a process based on a programme leading to a type made it possible to attain the familiar, articulate the desired aim and control the design. The tight relationship between form and function dictated a specific range of possibilities for utilizing the architectural environment. It proposed certain ways to perform within the architectural realm, according to the form–function relationship. Indeed, one could always break out of the prescribed and dictated use of the architectural realm and perform in a free manner. Nevertheless, the stricter the connection between form and function, the stricter the definition of the type became, making it more difficult to perform an independent nonprescribed event.
The perception of the concept of type as an objective led to an application of design methods that created a fixed environment for specific behaviours and performances. In this process, type is predetermined; thus this design method has attempted to avert the emergence of unexpected directions during the design process. Both the process and the end result are controlled and do not allow for ‘accidents’ that can result in an unexpected design iteration or use of the architectural realm.
Types in flow
With the advent of digital technologies, architects have started developing new design methodologies. Digitization has enabled the incorporation of a larger number of parameters in the design process than previously, thus leading to the establishment of new design methods. The ability, in what is termed parametric design, to define digitally intricate data on space allocation, usability and materiality provides a more complex way to approach the design problem at hand. Digitization also made it possible to explore more profoundly the old relationships between form and function in architecture.
In the course of this development, we have witnessed in recent years the emergence of genetic architecture – a simulation of genetic procedures from nature in digital architectural design.Footnote 8 Architects are searching for ways of interrelating form and function more freely and dynamically. Various forms of development existing in nature – for instance, morphogenesis – have provided models for an architectural consideration of these relations; because in evolutionary processes in nature, form and function are interrelated in a way that will result in an optimized use of the biological entity. For instance, an organ's form should ideally facilitate its optimal performance. Yet, at the same time, the form of the organ is free and dynamic, because once it becomes obsolete, the form and function adapt and change their articulation through evolutionary processes.
Adaptation, however, does not mean that the information initiating the articulation of an organ is lost at the moment it changes. In biology, the articulation of specific data into a specific organ is a negotiation between a genotype – the genetic data – and a phenotype – the context in which the genes come into play. Biological entities encompass a large amount of genetic data, of which only part is activated and articulated. Activating one set of genes rather than another brings about a change in the biological entity, an adaption of an organ to its new condition. The context, the phenotype, would determine the activation of specific sets of genes and the corresponding articulation of a biological entity.Footnote 9 The genetic material is considered part of one large mass of data, existing in a flow and transformed as a property of heredity, which occasionally, responding to a phenotypic condition, crystallizes into a clear entity, distinguishable from other entities.
On the basis of this logic, architects such as Greg Lynn and Karl Chu have used genetic as well as other computational algorithms to simulate bio-procedures of evolution.Footnote 10 Their aim was to break with prescribed and definite types and let architectural entities emerge by themselves. The algorithmic procedure allowed the creation of a flexible process in which the evolution of the architectural entity would not follow defined architectural programmes, forms or functions. Instead, new iterations of architecture would evolve, capable of adapting to new and changing conditions. Architecture would definitely not be considered the result of an exact and rigid type.
Yet, while architects such as Lynn and Chu attempt to break away from architectural typologies, they actually sustain a certain aspect of the idea of type within the evolution of architecture. The reference to the genotypic and phenotypic logic does not, in fact, fully dismantle the concept of type. In nature, each living entity within a type-category shares the same genes. Nevertheless, this does not mean that all manifestations will be identical. On the contrary, the sequence of genes in each and every living organism in the same type-group is different; therefore each of the iterations will be slightly different from its counterpart. The dissimilar sequencing allows for flexibility within the type. The type, which may be defined according to the genotype, sets the category and its limits; the sequence of the genes within a type would define the specification of the emerging entity. Within the limits of the type, or genotype, the sequencing is free. Accordingly, the concept of type, in this case, incorporates two meanings: a firm definition of type as a closed category and flexibility for variation to emerge within the type itself.
Similarly, in architecture, when Lynn and Chu set up and activate a digital design process, they work within the limits of a type, letting a specific iteration emerge. The emergence of the architectural entity follows a predefined pattern of given data. Due to the free process, however, this leads to an unforeseeable outcome. Following Virilio's notion of the accidental, architects have initiated processes in which the changing parameters define the directionality of the process, but without planning the outcome. Randomness is included as a parameter of these processes, so that, on the one hand, the process is linear and logical since the digital procedure is based on binary codification, while, on the other hand, the unpredictability of the random procedure does not allow for a human subject to analyse its logic. The architectural entity evolves as an articulation of specific data, which assumes a building type; nevertheless, the behaviour of the data within the type-category is unknown. The result is an open-ended environment that may allow multiple modes of performance within the constraints of the architectural type.
Types of the future
The two models and definitions of type in architecture assume different temporal structures. The programmed type is an atemporal structure, in which time, as a factor in cultural constructions, is almost nonexistent. Although time as a medium exists and leaves its mark, it does not exist as a parameter within the possibilities for change. There are fundamental parameters that do not take time into consideration as a notion of causality in emergence processes. The emergence of a type is not a matter of changing tenses, but rather a matter of origin, a repetition, without differentiation. In this model the future might propose the emergence of new iterations, yet they will all be part of a similar category, a refinement of old articulations.
The genetic-based type sees time as a dominant factor in the determination of an entity's emergence. In this process, time not only leaves its mark on reality, but in fact is also always in motion, is never stable, and does not allow the formation of fixed iterations as material articulations. Instead, time is in a relationship with larger processes as an interdependent medium, as part of a flow enlarging the possibilities within the emergence of new types. The future is that which is to become, which evolves; as such, its iteration and performance remain free.
