Into the opening of the final book of his Ecclesiastical History (EH), Eusebius wedges a lengthy speech he himself had recently delivered for the opening of the new basilica at Tyre before the city's bishop Paulinus (10.4.2–72). This massive chunk of self-referential direct speech has long struck readers of the narrative as an intrusion, as does the announcement in the book's preface that Paulinus was also to be the dedicatee of the entire EH — a fact we learn here for the first time. Abrupt though speech and dedication may seem, James Corke-Webster argues they fit perfectly with the two structuring themes he identifies in this excellent monograph: they celebrate a vision of a Christian community founded on fundamentally Graeco-Roman principles, and they showcase the tight relationship between that community and the Roman Empire.
C.-W.'s book is divided into three parts with a total of eight chapters, to which he adds a substantive introduction and conclusion aimed to prove that the EH ‘deserves a reputation as one of the most surprising, entertaining and impressively constructed writings in classical antiquity’ (9). Part I consists of two chapters that introduce first Eusebius and then the EH. Eusebius is presented as the product of an eastern educational background particularly influenced by the Alexandrian school of Clement and Origen. Though he lived through the ‘Great Persecution’, most of his life was spent in the persecution-free half-century prior to 303. This was a world plagued more with economic, military and social crises than religious violence, and it was these concerns that Eusebius felt Christianity had arrived to address. The EH was a product of its author's mature years, composed sometime between 306 and 326. Rather than commit to any of the many hypotheses for multiple ‘editions’, C.-W. follows Aaron P. Johnson (Eusebius (2014), 104–12) in assuming a single ‘publication’ around 324–325. This choice governs much of what follows, for C.-W.'s EH can be given a stronger teleological arc as ‘a narrative designed to climax by presenting the possibility of a Christian emperor’ (61). His is thus a fundamentally unified EH consisting largely of a series of ‘biographical pearls strung out across’ post-incarnation time (76). This story is told through the church's actors, above all its bishops and intellectuals, whose virtues shone as essentially consonant with Classical norms and whose influence showed them to be the proper heirs of the Roman tradition.
Part II features four chapters on Christian intellectuals, ascetics, families and martyrs. The EH proceeds through a series of philosophical biographies designed to showcase the sophistication of its thinkers, but also their importance as institutional leaders, the star example being Origen who, C.-W. shows, is recast as a far more political animal than he actually was. Eusebius’ attitude to asceticism is similarly establishmentarian. He follows Clement and explicitly distances himself from Origen, equating ascetic practice with sōphrosynē (136) rather than renunciation or self-mortification. So too with the family, whose virtues the EH extols from its beginning by emphasising Jesus’ relatives as the earliest leaders of the church. For Eusebius, the family's object was to deploy paideia for the cultivation of eusebeia, a virtue fully aligned with Roman pietas (173). Eusebius’ martyrs are similarly tamed, deprived of the defiance characteristic of the Acta martyrum and made instead to suffer quietly in the face of ranting governors, or even to flee persecution, should that be of more benefit to the community.
Part III explores Eusebius’ vision of the Church and its role in the Roman Empire. As to the former, the EH constructs a church built on leaders whose qualifications are rooted simultaneously in apostolic succession (as Irenaeus) and educational pedigree (as Clement and Origen). It is also an institution welded together by epistolary networks that stretch back to Jesus’ correspondence with Abgar of Edessa (EH 1.13). As such, it constitutes a fundamentally Roman social structure which Eusebius is careful to present as perfectly aligned with imperial interests. The church had only ever suffered under tyrants, while right-minded emperors are seen to have promoted it. Unsurprisingly, Eusebius — and C.-W. — conclude with Constantine, proof that the entire trajectory of the EH was arcing toward Christian rulership.
C.-W.'s narrative impressively updates our understanding of why the EH is worthy of attention and praise. His comprehensive vision and tidy structure make the book readable and cogent, even if they do not always jibe with the rather more chaotic impression I derive from reading the EH, and especially the material in books 8–10. Eusebius’ bricolage approach, along with inconsistencies in the transmitted text, have spawned the various theories of compositional disunity that C.-W. eschews. This frees his hands to craft a more determinate Eusebius, one whose history tells the grand narrative of a textually constructed empire perfectly prepared to enthrone the Christian ruler. The text is largely clean (but note ‘Inconium’ for Iconium at 112, 114 and 131), and the bibliography deep — but largely Anglophone and thus missing important work, particularly by Italians (V. Neri, I. Ramelli, I. Tantillo).
