Tocqueville famously argued that “democratic man” would always be a separated creature, disconnected from a set of relationships of the sort that were at least provided by an aristocratic order, living (in Mitchell's terms) “lonely, delinked, and homeless in an ever-changing world” (109). Mitchell takes this stance as the basis for a personal exploration of the twinned gaps that separate his generation of the late 1960s from that of his current university students, and that which separates the young people he teaches at Georgetown University from those he encountered at his university's extension in Doha, Qatar. In each instance his reading of Tocqueville's Democracy in America, along with texts by Plato, Adam Smith, and Marx, constitutes the common touchstone through which he engages the two groups of students in a wide-ranging discussion—including aspects of sexuality, the relative merits of different governmental forms, and the meaning of sin and suffering—that test the students' responses to the situations in which they imagine themselves to be set. The result is neither a formal survey of attitudes nor a controlled experiment in response to identical texts. Rather it is a highly personal account of the problems and prospects outlined by Tocqueville measured against the students' classroom thoughts and the author's impressions of them.
In the course of describing his teaching Mitchell offers a clear synopsis of a number of Tocqueville's central points. Nevertheless, Mitchell's approach may seem rather thin in several key respects. It is thin, first, in its reading of Tocqueville, for while it is not possible from the book alone to tell precisely how Mitchell presents the Frenchman's arguments it is clear that he emphasizes the isolation of the individual over Tocqueville's reciprocal emphasis on the ways in which Americans counter their isolation through participation in voluntary associations and national institutions. For Tocqueville not only said of man that democracy “constantly leads him back to himself alone,” but “I remarked a hundred times that, when needed, [Americans] almost never fail to lend faithful support to one another,” that “Americans of all ages, all conditions, all minds constantly unite,” that “they seek each other out,” that “in democratic countries the science of association is the mother science,” and that in regard to the family “democracy loosens social bonds, but it tightens natural bonds. It brings relatives together at the same time that it separates citizens.”
Given his emphasis on those aspects of isolation in Tocqueville's analysis Mitchell sees his American students' use of computers and social networks as evidence that “in their outreach to their ‘friends,’ they live within themselves” (67) and that “in their friendships and in their romantic life, it scarcely occurs to them that they should arrest an affection that their heart declares” (55). He argues that for these young Americans “irrespective of the personal struggles they endure, the social and historical struggle of ideas is largely over, and all that remains is to implement ‘social justice’” (73). Moreover, the students do not appreciate that they live in a world of mutual indebtedness (89), engaging in “sexual intimacy without the burden of reproduction: a formula by which the current generation proclaims that it owes little or nothing to future generations” (135). Instead, “many of them want to go into ‘financial services’—that euphemism for making money without producing anything” (111), further underscoring that “what occurs in many of our colleges nowadays amounts less to higher education than to ‘higher certification,’ perhaps even ‘higher stupefaction’” (76).
At times, however, Mitchell appears to contradict himself: “One of the remarkable things about my students on the main campus is how many of them ‘herd’ together in groups rather than break apart, publicly, into couples” (128)—an observation he could have followed up by considering whether “hook-up” culture is a sign of loneliness or “herding” a sign of conviviality. He also complains that American students know little of suffering (an odd view to hold about modern adolescence) and that they seek no religious depth in this regard given that, from his own Christian perspective, “when I look at my young students . . . who among them will have faith strong enough to declare that their suffering is a testimony to God's glory” (149), or recognize that “religion is the deepest thing” (175) and “our lives must be made with a view to and from Eternity” (176). He even indicates (rather like Tocqueville) that absent such a religious emphasis “I suspect liberty in America cannot long be saved” (178), especially if religion is reduced to some generalized “spirituality.”
Mitchell's description of the students in Doha risks being perceived as equally thin. He presents his students in Doha as exclusively embedded in family structures and says nothing about the ways in which individuals in the Arab world must create networks of obligation that are not readily passed from one generation to the next. Doha, it should be remembered, is a very atypical place even in the Arab world, a country that is wholly reliant on foreign laborers who can never become citizens. The result is less a nuanced analysis of the reaction of students to the full array of Tocqueville's observations and more an exercise in limited stereotypes. Perhaps his Arab students do “recur either to dreamy ideas about a past that cannot be retrieved or to revolutionary ideas that dispense with the whole of their inherited history” (40), are “neither quite able to embrace nor repudiate the world that is now upon them” (38), and “approach Tocqueville's Democracy in America with a sense of urgency . . . for few things are more haunting to them than the specter of loneliness” (43). But far more detail or reference to others' studies of the region would go a long way toward supporting such assertions. One might at least inquire whether the Doha students' rejection of democratic “liberation” is due to their inability to “imagine living in a world that presupposes infinite possibilities” (52) or because they have thus far benefited from the superior position men of the region possess over their subordinates.
Indeed, since we never learn about the number and origins of the Arab students Mitchell taught, whether any of them were women, or whether the author speaks Arabic, it is difficult to credit his impressions as more incisive than those of many American academics who never penetrate the cultures of the students they encounter in an American branch university or as a Fulbright teacher unfamiliar with the host culture.
Being so personal the book can only be judged personally. Certainly it is written in an engaging manner and the very idea of such a comparison through the reading of common texts is inviting. But not every reader will identify with the author's constant reference to his own loneliness (“the lonely delinked condition is upon us all,” 188) and that we all require “the forbearance necessary for admission into heaven” (111). Ultimately readers will have to approach this book measuring it against their own teaching encounters and decide for themselves whether its vision of American democracy and its students resonates with their experience. Whatever their appraisal, readers who are interested in Tocqueville, Middle Eastern cultures, and the vicissitudes of student life will undoubtedly find in Mitchell an interlocutor with whom a conversation on such matters is well worth their while.
