It is not an exaggeration to say that jihad is the most frequently invoked concept among the Islamic religious doctrines and the most misrepresented. This international obsession is a dream come true to many extremists in the Muslim domain, like Muhammad Abdessalam Faraj, whose disappointment with the lack of interest in jihad among Muslims led him to write in 1981 a book entitled Jihad: The Neglected Duty. In light of what was termed as “the global war on terror,” jihad moved from a neglected doctrine to an omnipresent part of the political discourse, decorating almost every form of speech on security, Islam, the Middle East, and related subjects.
Faisal Devji's Landscapes of the Jihad is a welcome edition to the ever-expanding literature on jihad in its newly acquired context, namely, violence in the name of Islam. Although the book is hard for the average reader to follow, the analysis provided surpasses many other contributions to the literature. The author challenges many arguments within the generally accepted theoretical framework of violence perpetrated by extremist groups such as al-Qaʿida and its associated groups. Devji's very approach to this violence is novel and quite out of the ordinary. Instead of the prevailing approach to studying al-Qaʿida, which focuses on its violence, Devji states that “violence is not even the most important thing about [al-Qaʿida] jihad.” The most important characteristic is “its fragmentation of traditional structures of Muslim authority within new global landscapes” (p. xvi).
The main question before Devji pertains to the way “Islam becomes a global phenomenon in Al-Qaeda's jihad” (p. xv). Hence, the author makes the unthinkable—although not necessarily untrue—comparison between al-Qaʿida and other movements such as Greenpeace and the antiwar movement. Global effects “bring together allies and enemies of the most heterogeneous character, who neither know nor communicate each with the other, and who in addition share almost nothing by way of a prior history” (p. 12). By this proposition, Devji rejects any link between al-Qaʿida's global activities and any local struggle or a cohesive ideology or even any religious consistency. Indeed, members of al-Qaʿida, he notes, are often behaving in a manner inconsistent with piety. For instance, some of the participants in the 9/11 attacks “do not seem to have been averse to consuming alcohol, gambling in Las Vegas or attending a lap-dancing club in the days before their final flight” (pp. 16–17). This, according to Devji, is a pattern common to those who participate in al-Qaʿida activities.
According to Devji, al-Qaʿida control over the consequences of its actions is very limited because such control is beyond al-Qaʿida's means. Therefore, Osama bin Laden expresses his admiration for the perpetrators of the 9/11 attacks but denies any role in or responsibility for their actions (p. 4). In this sense, the author argues that the acts of al-Qaʿida “depart from the realm of intentionality by relinquishing control over their consequences.” Therefore, these acts become “ethical acts,” like those of movements that enjoy global presence, such as the environmentalist and the antiglobalization movements (p. 160).
The book also surveys many texts written by Osama bin Laden and other participants in al-Qaʿida activities, such as a will allegedly written by Mohammad Atta. Although a close reading of these texts is often successfully attempted, sometimes the author misses the original intent of the writers, substituting his own reading of certain details. For instance, Devji points out that al-Zawahiri “often expresses surprise at how the Egyptian or Pakistani authorities broke laws that he himself did not respect and would have willingly broken.” According to the text he cites, al-Zawahiri describes the Pakistani government's decision to deport several naturalized citizens before the courts finish examining their petition as a “total disregard for Pakistani law and the Pakistani constitution” (p. 116). Contrary to Devji's argument, al-Zawahiri is indeed attempting to highlight the hypocrisy of the Pakistani government, for it is one thing when he breaks the law, for which he has no regard, and quite another thing when the Pakistani government breaks its own laws, upon which its own legitimacy is established.
The book does not offer a bibliography, but there are eleven pages of notes indicating the sources, which include a few monographs but mainly Internet sources with a full range of quality and credibility. From the sources, it appears that the author lacks knowledge in Arabic, hence the occasional flawed reading of texts for which the originals were not accessible to the author. However, the book provides a new approach to the question of al-Qaʿida and other terrorist groups, which makes it valuable reading.
