No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 February 2005
This is a powerful book that documents and examines the horrible exploitation of labor in contemporary China, particularly the vulnerable migrant workers from rural areas. The bulk of the book is the compilation of more than twenty investigative stories that Chan selects from the Chinese language newspapers and journals published in China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan. All the investigative stories were written by Chinese reporters—some took great risks to do it—and translated into English by Chan and her collaborators. For each case Chan provides a short introduction and “comment” to help the reader comprehend the materials in context and to clarify certain references. In several cases Chan also gives follow-ups to the stories.
This is a powerful book that documents and examines the horrible exploitation of labor in contemporary China, particularly the vulnerable migrant workers from rural areas. The bulk of the book is the compilation of more than twenty investigative stories that Chan selects from the Chinese language newspapers and journals published in China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan. All the investigative stories were written by Chinese reporters—some took great risks to do it—and translated into English by Chan and her collaborators. For each case Chan provides a short introduction and “comment” to help the reader comprehend the materials in context and to clarify certain references. In several cases Chan also gives follow-ups to the stories.
The book has nine chapters. In addition to the introduction and conclusion, there are seven chapters each covering a particular subject: forced labor and violations of shop-floor labor standards, corporal punishment and physical assaults, violations of occupational safety and health, violations of the right to work, violations of the right to organize and collective action, indentured labor abroad, and workers' resistance. Twenty-three cases are presented, and together they constitute a horrible picture of the brutal labor abuses that took place in China in the last decade of the twentieth century, when China was rapidly transforming itself from a planned economy to a market economy in the process of accelerating globalization. Reading through these stories, one can see that the availability of millions of young rural migrant workers desperate for jobs, the profit-crazed foreign investors (many are actually from Taiwan and Hong Kong) seeking the best and cheapest labor, officials at different levels of the Chinese bureaucracy competing with each other to lure foreign investment to their own region—so much so that they were willing to compromise even the basic labor standards: all these elements constitute the context in which Chinese laborers became vulnerable to various violations of their basic rights.
The brutal realities of labor abuses revealed by the investigative stories are horrifying, and some cruelties are so extreme that they are beyond belief. In one case, the manager of a Taiwanese shoe factory locked a female Chinese migrant worker in a dog cage with two wolfhounds. The Chinese worker, who was suspected of stealing a roll of sticky tape, was “( . . . ) shaking from head to foot, her face ashen white” (65). In another case, a group of Chinese seafarers, who had won support of the dock workers at the port of Ravenna, Italy, for their fight against their abusive European bosses, found their basic rights denied and their money confiscated by the Chinese authorities when they returned to their motherland. Moreover, the group leaders were detained for two years without trial, and eventually prosecuted under the Chinese legal system for “leaking state secretes” (that is, telling the truth about their low wages)! They were found not guilty only after several pro-labor Chinese agencies became outraged and intervened, and the International Labor Organization took the case seriously and brought pressure upon the Chinese government (174–185).
How could foreign investors treat these Chinese workers in such cruel ways? One article from the Taiwan Footwear Industry Bulletin (a magazine for Taiwanese footwear manufacturers) that Chan includes in the book provides some hints at their logic and justifications. The article, published in 1997 in response to the exposure of the inhumane treatment of Chinese workers, admits that “various violations of the Labor Law ( . . . ) are very common among foreign-invested enterprises in China, in particular in the more labor-intensive manufacturing industries” (52). But it complains against the Labor Law in mainland China, seeing it as “a hindrance for capital to increase production efficiency,” and it reports that “One Taiwanese businessman says that commending workers in order to induce self-respect in them is not a useful means to increase productivity. It seems that the more direct and primitive the method, the more effective it is” (53).
Then why does the Chinese government not do more to protect the workers? The stories in the book suggest, as also pointed out by Chan in her introduction, that the Chinese state is not monolithic—some agencies are pro-labor and try to provide protection for workers, while others ignore violations of labor rights. In some cases, the labor-capital disputes became an issue of national pride and eventually settled according to law and regulations, after they were reported in the media and got the attention of government agencies. But in many cases, particularly at the lower levels—the counties, townships, and villages—the local authorities connive with management to exploit labor. To lure foreign investment, the local authorities are eager to modify the labor standards, to deregulate factories' internal security forces, and to arrange police protection and cooperation for foreign investors. Their obsession with growth rate and profit come ahead of their concern for Chinese workers' basic human dignity.
In her conclusion, Chan briefly reviews the historical relationship between the “five core labor rights” and non-core rights in the international labor movement and makes some suggestions for strategies to help the Chinese workers—particularly the very vulnerable migrant workers. According to Chan, in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the international labor movement began by fighting for basic labor rights such as “a living wage, limited work hours, and a right to rest,” (227) nowadays seen as “non-core rights” in the developed countries. After World War II, however, the international trade union movement has been championing five “core labor rights”: freedom of association, the right to organize and bargain collectively, a minimum age of employment, no forced or slave labor, and a prohibition against discrimination. In recent years, Chan contends, international organizations concerned with Chinese labor have focused on the core rights, and mainly on the first two. “References to Chinese labor rights over the past two decades have generally been restricted to complaints about barriers to forming trade unions, the imprisonment of specific labor activists, or prison labor” (229). Chan argues that this may not be a realistic way to help the tens of millions of Chinese workers who are suffering various forms of exploitation and abuse, and she calls for an understanding of the reality in China, and for a realistic and practical strategy. She argues:
For migrant workers in China, for instance, what rights are the most concrete and most urgent to them? They want to be paid regularly, on time, and to be paid at least US $2 a day (not $2 an hour) rather than $1.50 a day. Workers want to retain their human dignity, to have some leisure time (not the luxury of paid vacations as stipulated by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights), to be free of occupational hazards that threaten their lives and limbs, and to be free from fear of being put into detention centers for not having the right residential (hukou) papers. (233)
As this review goes to print, reports abound in both the Chinese and foreign press that, as the Chinese Lunar New Year begins on February 1, millions of Chinese migrant workers—particularly the construction workers in big cities—are engaged in protests because they have not been paid for months and as a result are unable to go home for New Year family reunions. Without unions, without contract, these workers have little chance to redress their grievances through official channels. Nevertheless, it is reported that the Ministry of Construction is aware of the seriousness of this issue and it has ordered payment of wages due to the workers. The Ministry also suggests that responsibility to pay workers on time be included in workers' contracts with their contractors. These reports seem to support Anita Chan's argument that exploitation of labor is indeed an urgent issue in China and that protection of the very basic labor rights should be the priority of organizations desiring to help Chinese workers. If these organizations developed realistic and pragmatic strategies based on a clear understanding of the realities in China, as Chan tries to do in her book, they may be able to offer an effective help to improve conditions for Chinese workers.