INTRODUCTION
The plunder of cultural property and its return to rightful owners continue to be a major issue in the international public arena. States, public and private museums, and scholars worldwide continue to grapple with the complex questions that arise out of efforts to restore such property, and especially cultural property that was plundered as spoils of war and nationalization. As succinctly noted by one scholar, “The controversy and debate of returning cultural property have reached new heights and intensity.”Footnote 1
In the last decade, claims involving Nazi-looted art and other cultural property have taken center stage, with Holocaust survivors or their heirs seeking return of such cultural objects from museums, galleries, and private collections throughout the world. In 1998, the United States hosted a multinational conference in Washington DC—the Washington Conference on Holocaust Era Assets—to focus on the issue. The conference led to the adoption of the Washington Conference Principles on Nazi-Confiscated Art.Footnote 2 In June 2009, the Czech Republic, holding the rotating presidency of the European Union, hosted the Prague Holocaust Era Assets Conference to “assess the progress made since the 1998 Washington Conference on Holocaust Era Assets in the areas of the recovery of looted art and objects of cultural, historical and religious value.”Footnote 3 That conference resulted in the issuance by the 46 participating states of the Terezin Declaration, “urg[ing] that every effort be made to rectify the consequences of wrongful property seizures, such as confiscations, forced sales and sales under duress of property, which were part of the persecution of these innocent people and groups, the vast majority of whom died heirless.”Footnote 4 The Terezin Declaration noted specifically the “wholesale looting of Judaica and Jewish cultural property” during the Holocaust and “encourage[s] and support[s] efforts to identify and catalogue these items which may be found in archives, libraries, museums and other government and non-government repositories, to return them to their original rightful owners and other appropriate individuals or institutions according to national law, and to consider a voluntary international registration of Torah scrolls and other Judaica objects where appropriate.”Footnote 5
One method to resolve the issues of cultural property displacement has been for states where the property is located to enact legislation setting out the mechanics for the return of the cultural property. In 1998, Russia's parliamentary body passed legislation that effectively nationalized art and other cultural objects seized by the Soviets at the end of World War II while providing a limited means for countries and family heirs to recover cultural valuables. The Russian Federal Law on Cultural Valuables Displaced to the USSR as a Result of the Second World War and Located on the Territory of the Russian Federation,Footnote 6 which President Boris Yeltsin reluctantly signed in 1998 and President Vladimir Putin signed as amended in 2000 (hereinafter collectively “the 1998 Cultural Valuables Law”), appeared on the surface to provide a legal and orderly remedy to the long-simmering claims by states and nonstate agencies against the former Soviet Union (and now the Russian Federation) involving cultural spoils of World War II found on Soviet (and now Russian) territory. The rule of law, however, has not fared well in Russia,Footnote 7 and this includes the actual implementation of the 1998 Cultural Valuables Law.
This article does not deal with the failings of the 1998 Cultural Valuables Law.Footnote 8 Rather, its focus is on an alternative remedy for the resolution of disputes involving (1) cultural property plundered during World War II and currently located in Russia, and (2) disputes involving properties held by Russia that had been nationalized following Russia's earlier revolutionary upheavals. This alternative remedy is the filing of suits in American courts against the Russian Federation for the return of such properties. This alternative is made possible through an American law known as the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act of 1976 (FSIA).Footnote 9 As will be further discussed later, this federal law in force since 1977 allows American federal and state courts to decide a suit against a foreign state and its related entities when the suit falls within one or more of the enumerated exceptions to sovereign immunity of the FSIA.
In 2008, the United States Court of Appeals in Washington DC ruled that the orthodox Jewish religious organization Chabad could proceed with its litigation for the recovery of its sacred texts located in Russia because Russia did not possess sovereign immunity to the suit under the FSIA. The 2008 appellate decision in Chabad v. Russian Federation is just the latest round, and surely not the last, of an epic struggle by Chabad to recover its collection of revered and irreplaceable religious books and manuscripts seized and nationalized in the aftermath of the Bolshevik Revolution and additional materials seized during the Second World War.
This case is significant not just because of the plaintiff's indefatigable efforts to recover religious texts presently located in Russia, which has involved appeals by several U.S. presidents, congress, and the U.S. Helsinki Commission, and legal battles in the Soviet Union (and the Russian Federation) and the United States, but also because of its precedent for others who seek to recover plundered cultural property.
This article will discuss the Chabad v. Russian Federation litigation, filed in the shadow of the 1998 Cultural Valuables Law. The first section will provide the historical background to the case. The second will discuss the legal efforts by Chabad to obtain restitution from the former Soviet Union. The third section will discuss the legal and nonlegal efforts to do the same through the Russian courts, while the fourth will discuss the litigation in the United States and analyze the 2006 and 2008 opinions of the American courts hearing the case. In its concluding part, the article will briefly note the precedent that Chabad v. Russian Federation sets for lawsuits against other sovereign states and their institutions seeking the return of looted cultural property.
HISTORICAL BACKGROUND
The plaintiff, Agudas Chasidei Chabad of United States (“Chabad”), is the worldwide umbrella entity for the orthodox Jewish movement called Chabad-Lubavitch, which has over 3,300 institutions in 65 countries. The word “Chabad” is a Hebrew acronym for chachma (wisdom), binah (comprehension), and da'at (knowledge).Footnote 10 Chabad is an over 200-year-old Jewish organization that follows and teaches the spiritual tenets and religious directives of Rabbi Israel Baal Shem Tov and seven successive generations of spiritual leaders referred to as rebbes (or rabbis).Footnote 11
Beginning in 1772, the rebbes collected and held for the benefit of the organization's members religious writings that consist of a collection of rare and irreplaceable rabbinic books, archives, and manuscripts on Chabad Chassidic philosophy, Jewish religious law, prayer, and tradition. This “Library” consists of more than 12,000 books and 381 manuscripts. These rare books and manuscripts were used by the rebbes as the textual source for their religious teachings and were acquired through contributions from all over the world.Footnote 12
In 1915, during World War I, the fifth rebbe, Rabbi Shalom DovBer Schneersohn, was forced to flee from the western Russian village of Lubavichi (now in Smolensk oblast) to Rostov-on-Don. He placed the Library (35 wooden crates) for safekeeping in a privately owned warehouse in Moscow. During the Russian Revolution of 1917, Bolshevik revolutionaries seized the warehouse containing the Library,Footnote 13 and the Library was physically transferred to the Rumiantsev Library (later the V. I. Lenin State Library) in 1924. The following year, the Soviet government denied the application by the sixth rebbe, Rabbi Shalom DovBer Schneersohn, for the return of the Library.Footnote 14
The sixth rebbe began compiling a new collection of sacred books and manuscripts from donations made throughout the world and from funds that came primarily from the United States.Footnote 15 In 1927, after being arrested and sentenced to death for collecting money for Jewish schools (the death sentence was commuted to exile under pressure from Western governments),Footnote 16 the sixth rebbe fled the Soviet Union for Latvia, then an independent nation, taking the new library and archival manuscripts with him. He became a Latvian citizen and then again moved with the new Chabad library and manuscripts to Otwock, Poland, where he established his new religious school (yeshiva in Hebrew).Footnote 17
On 1 September 1939, Nazi Germany's armed forces invaded Poland from the west, and a few weeks later the Soviet Union's armed forces invaded Poland from the east. With the assistance of the United States government, the sixth rebbe escaped to the United States.Footnote 18 After arriving in New York, the sixth rebbe established Agudas Chasidei Chabad of United States as a New York religious corporation, with headquarters in Brooklyn.Footnote 19
When the sixth rebbe fled Poland, he was unable to take with him most of the archival books and manuscripts collected since 1925 (hereafter referred to as the “Archive”). Prior to his departure from Warsaw in 1939, the sixth rebbe wrote a letter to Rabbi Chaim Liberman, the librarian of the Chabad-Lubavitch library, stating: “I have no apartment, and I find myself living with friends with my entire family in one room; consequently, I have no space for the books which Agudas Chabad loaned me for study. I would be pleased if Agudas Chabad were to take these books back.” After escaping to Latvia, the sixth rebbe wrote to Rabbi Jacobson in New York: “Please write, or better still, telegraph the American Consul at Warsaw that he take over the library of Agudas Chabad (of the U.S.) and of Rabbi Schneersohn—for I have told them that a part of the library is the property of Agudas Chabad of New York and a part is mine.”Footnote 20
In 1946, the sixth rebbe wrote a letter to Dr. Alexander Marks stating,
Manuscripts: Three large boxes full of aged manuscripts were confiscated, as mentioned, by the Nazis…. These manuscripts are registered under the names of the Rabbis, members of Agudas Chasidei Chabad, Rabbi Israel Jacobson, and his son-in-law Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Hecht, both American citizens, (who are) the official owners of this property. Books: Several thousand books, among them many ancient books of great value and vary rare. These books are the property of Agudas Chasidei Chabad of America and Canada.
At some point during the Second World War, Nazi German agents seized the manuscripts that compose the Archive from the Chabad yeshiva in Otwock, Poland. In 1945, Soviet armed forces found the Archive in a castle in Poland and transported it to Moscow. The Archive was placed in the top-secret Soviet Central State Special Archive—Tsentral'nyi gosudarstvennyi osobyi arkhiv SSSR (TsGOA) in Russian—formally established in Moscow in March 1946. The Archive now consists of a collection of handwritten teachings comprising more than 25,000 pages.
POSTWAR RESTITUTION EFFORTS IN THE SOVIET UNION BY CHABAD FOR THE RETURN OF THE LIBRARY AND ARCHIVE
Chabad Commences Efforts for Return of the Library and Locates the Archive
Since the Soviets kept the holdings of the TsGOA Special Archive secret, Chabad was not able to locate the Archive for decades. In June 1992, the Special Archive was renamed the Center for the Preservation of Historico-Documentary Collections—Tsentr khraneniia istoriko-dokumental'nykh kollektsii (TsKhIDK) in Russian.Footnote 21 In March 1999, the TsGOA/TsKhIDK trophy holdings became part of the neighboring Russian State Military Archive (RSMA in English)—Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi voennyi arkhiv (RGVA) in Russian.Footnote 22 Because the early surveys or lists of archival fonds relating to Jewish documents in TsKhIDK/RGVA did not fully identify all of the Jewish holdings,Footnote 23 Chabad was not able to confirm that the Archive was at the RSMA until 2004.Footnote 24 A two-page description of the Archive (fond 706k) appears in the 2005 guide to Jewish fonds among the trophy holdings in RSMA, and reportedly several other related documents are to be found in other fonds.Footnote 25
Over the years, the Library was similarly hidden away among the vast holdings of the V. I. Lenin State Library, which since 1992 has been called the Russian State Library (RSL in English)—Rossiiskaia gosudarstvennaia biblioteka (RGB) in Russian—and not catalogued.Footnote 26 In the 1980s, Chabad identified originals from the Library in the Lenin Library, and the seventh rebbe, Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, commenced an effort to recover its contents. The seventh rebbe appointed a five-person delegation in late 1990 to secure the return of the Library to Chabad's central library in New York.Footnote 27 Chabad also formed the Jewish Community of Lubavitch Chassidim (JCLC, or “Community”) as its representative in the Soviet Union.Footnote 28
In 2000, after the fall of the Soviet Union, the director of Chabad's central library in New York, Rabbi Shalom Dovber Levine, traveled to Moscow and conclusively identified at least 4,354 books belonging to the Library. Stickers saying in Hebrew “Lubavitch collection,” were placed on the 4,354 books. RSL officials, however, stopped Rabbi Levine from fully examining the collection. He was not allowed to examine books contained in the RSL's “old book” section, nor was he permitted to see any of the 381 manuscripts from the Library.Footnote 29
Chabad Goes to Court in the Soviet Union
On 6 September 1991, Soviet President Mikhail Gorbachev ordered the V. I. Lenin State Library to return the Library to Chabad, but the director of the Lenin Library refused to comply.Footnote 30 On 26 September 1991, the JCLC petitioned a Soviet arbitration court of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic (RSFSR) (Case No. 350/13) for an order directing the return of the Library. The Lenin Library opposed the JCLC's claim, arguing that it was “not being legally founded, since Chabad, the Religious Jewish Hasidic Lubavitch Community is not the owner of the disputed collection of books and manuscripts, in view of its acquisition of a status of National and State property.”Footnote 31 The Soviet arbitration court ruled against the Lenin Library and in favor of Chabad. In a Decision of 8 October 1991, it first noted:
[T]he Schneerson Library is comprised of the books of theological and liturgical nature, in ancient Hebrew, collected by several generations of Lubavitch Rabbis. Said books and manuscripts were taken to a library in 1921, pursuant to a mandate of the former People's Commissar on Education. The documents provided did not confirm the fact of Schneerson Library acquiring a status of National property. The disputed collection of books and manuscripts also cannot be declared ownerless, as for a number of years, starting from 1922, the owner of books and manuscripts applied to various bodies of the Soviet State, requesting their return.Footnote 32
The Soviet court further observed “that the Seventh Lubavitch Rabbi also confirmed that the Schneerson Library belongs to the communal property of the entire Agudas Chassidei Chabad movement.”Footnote 33 The state arbitrators decided:
To declare the Claim of Chabad, the Religious Jewish Hasidic Lubavitch Community, for the return, in kind, of the collection of books and manuscripts, known as the Schneerson Library, valid and granted. To bind the V. I. Lenin State Library to return within one month the Schneerson Library to Chabad, the Religious Jewish Hasidic Lubavitch Community.”Footnote 34
The staff of the Lenin Library, however, refused to comply with the court's ruling and return the Library to Chabad on the grounds that a “precedent is established—the pillage of the collections of the [V. I. Lenin] Library is started.”Footnote 35
The Lenin Library and the attorney general of the RSFSR appealed the 8 October 1991 decision on the grounds that the Library had allegedly been nationalized. On 18 November 1991, the chief state arbiter of the RSFSR, V. V. Grebennikov, concluded that the owner of the Library was indeed the sixth rebbe. Upon JCLC's request, Grebennikov ordered the Lenin Library to transfer the Library immediately to a Jewish institution within Russia selected by Chabad. The 18 November 1991 decree stated, “Argument as to the statutory limitation which may have precluded consideration of the case filed by the Community is hereby denied.”Footnote 36 The chief state arbiter continued:
Thus, the Arbitration Court is not obligated to consider the matter of legal ownership of the Schneerson Library by either the Community or the State (represented by the Lenin State Library), since evidence on file in this case does not contain any basis upon which assumption can be made that the aforementioned collection belongs to anyone other than the Lubavitcher Rebbe. Furthermore, careful examination of the case file indicates, that the relationship between the Community and the Lubavitcher Rebbe are of confessional nature and cannot be regulated by general Soviet laws. This conjecture is further reinforced by the assertion made by Community's representatives that they do not insist on the transfer of proprietary rights [to the “Library”] to the Community.Footnote 37
In consideration of the Community's request, the chief state arbiter ordered the “Lenin State Library to transfer the entire collection of books and manuscripts known as the Schneerson Library to the Jewish National Library (third party which was incorporated into the case as Co-Petitioner—see ruling of 11/15/1991).”Footnote 38 The Jewish National Library (Natsional'naia evreiskaia biblioteka in Russian) is part of the State Classical Academy of Maimonides—Gosudarstvennaia klassicheskaia akademiia imeni Maimonida in Russian (formerly known as the Jewish Academy of Maimonides)—a Jewish-based university in Moscow that appeared as Chabad's co-petitioner in the suit. The chief state arbiter ordered the physical transfer of the “Schneerson Library” to commence on November 18, 1991, and ordered the Jewish National Library to accept the disputed collection into its custody for safekeeping. The decree also stated: “Considering existing complications and various interpretations of the term ‘The Schneerson Library,’ the parties are instructed to ensure that experts from both sides partake in the transfer of the aforementioned collection.”Footnote 39
When Chabad's delegation sought to effectuate the transfer from the Lenin Library to Maimonides Academy's Jewish National Library in Moscow, the Lenin Library staff members again refused to comply. On 20 November 1991, Chabad's representatives began a hunger strike in the hallway of the administrative entrance to the Lenin Library, demanding enforcement of the ruling. Two days later, the Lenin Library closed its doors due to the praying of Chabad's rabbis. The Chabad delegation was taunted with anti-Semitic slurs and threats of violence and the Lenin Library's security forces attacked the Chabad representatives.Footnote 40 The ultra-nationalist Moscow newspaper Zemshchina wrote: “Hasidic manuscripts from the Schneerson collection … kept in GBL [Lenin State Library] belong to the Russian people as incontestable evidence of the ritual crimes of Talmudic Yids.”Footnote 41
LITIGATION AND DIPLOMATIC EFFORTS IN POST-SOVIET RUSSIA
Russian Court Proceedings
The following month, on 25 December 1991, the Soviet Union dissolved and was replaced by the Russian Federation. On 29 January 1992, Russia's deputy chairman ordered the newly renamed RSL to transfer the Library to Chabad's representatives, but a Russian State Library representative incited an anti-Semitic mob and shouted death threats through a bullhorn to prevent the Chabad delegation from retrieving the Library.Footnote 42 These threats and extralegal measures were followed by further action in the Russian legal system.
On 14 February 1992, the deputy chief state arbiter of the Russian Federation, B. I. Puginskii, nullified the previous court orders that mandated the RSL's relinquishment of the Library and closed the case.Footnote 43 Chabad asserts that it never received notice of any appeal to the deputy chief state arbiter, and that the deputy state arbiter lacked authority to revoke the 18 November 1991 order of his superior, the chief state arbiter.Footnote 44 Puginskii's decree of 14 February 1992 purportedly relied on “newly discovered evidence in this case” including a “letter received from the Ministry of Culture of the Russian Federation dated November 25, 1991 (ref. No. 19/22–29), which stated that neither the Ministry of Culture of the Russian Federation, nor the Moscow City Cultural Committee, has received an application to register a legal entity under the name ‘The Jewish National Library’ ‘Maimonides House.’”Footnote 45 In addition, Puginskii's decree stated that “the Government of the Russian Federation has adopted a resolution calling for the transfer of Schneerson Library to the Maimonides State Jewish Academy (Decree No.157-p issued by the Government of the Russian Federation on 1/29/1992). The aforementioned Government Resolution must be recognized as an independent and in no way associated or based upon the decisions made by the State Arbitration Court of the Russian Federation.”Footnote 46 The deputy chief state arbiter's decree concluded:
In accordance with Art. 15 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, as well as Art. 30 of the Law on Ownership in the Russian Federation, the right to demand recovery of one's property from third party(ies) maintaining illegal possession of said property, is reserved exclusively for the rightful owner of disputed property or his/her heir apparent. As is evident from documents on file in this case, the Community has not provided evidentiary proof of having ownership rights to the Schneerson Library. This fact is also supported by the Ruling made on November 18, 1991 by the State Arbitration Court of the Russian Federation, which sought to re-examine the earlier Ruling. Hence, the Community has no authority to file suit seeking physical transfer of the property.Footnote 47
AGREEMENT BETWEEN YELTSIN AND BUSH AND SUBSEQUENT POLITICAL EFFORTS IN RUSSIA AND THE UNITED STATES
On 17 February 1992, Russian President Boris Yeltsin made a commitment to U.S. President George H. W. Bush, through Secretary of State James Baker, that the Library would be returned to Chabad.Footnote 48 Two days later, the Supreme Soviet of the Russian Federation abolished the 29 January 1992 “transfer” order and decreed that “the safety, movement and use of the holdings available to the [RSL be effectuated] solely on the basis of the legislation of the Russian Federation and the provisions of international law” and mandated that the Supreme Soviet “shall speed the development of draft laws which ensure the State protection and safety of the national heritage of the Russian Federation.”Footnote 49 Chabad contends that this 1992 decree divested Russian courts of jurisdiction to hear Chabad's claims.
On the evening of 6 April 1992, Chabad's synagogue and office in Moscow were firebombed. The building was also defaced by a swastika near the front door along with the words “Kill the Jews.”Footnote 50 On 15 April 1992, the U.S. Department of State issued a statement supporting the return of the Library to Chabad and deploring the attacks: “We are also disturbed by the attempts of anti-Semitic groups to defame the Lubavitchers by linking their desire for the return of their property to ancient, scurrilous myths about Jewish rituals.”Footnote 51 On 31 May 1992, all 100 U.S. Senators sent a letter to President Yeltsin requesting that he fulfill his commitment to release the “Schneerson-Agudas Chabad collection.”Footnote 52
The intervention of American officials, to date, has brought little success, with Russia releasing a mere eight volumes of the Library.Footnote 53 In 1993, Vice President Al Gore was able to secure one book from the collection, which he delivered to Chabad. In 1994, during a summit in Moscow, seven volumes were turned over to President Bill Clinton. Efforts during the George W. Bush presidency also came to naught. As Gregg Rickman, President Bush's U.S. special envoy to monitor and combat anti-Semitism, explained, “When in Moscow as the U.S. special envoy to monitor and combat anti-Semitism, I asked the curator of the collection for permission to take at least one volume back as a goodwill gesture. My request was denied.”Footnote 54 Referencing the language of the Terezin Declaration made at the conclusion of the Prague Conference in 2009 for nations “to return [looted Judaica and Jewish cultural property] to their original rightful owners and other appropriate individuals or institutions according to national law,” Rickman stated: “If Russia can attend international gatherings like the Prague Conference and agree to its declarations, it should abide by them in deed…. Russia should return the Schneersohn collection, just as every other country is expected to return their looted property.”Footnote 55
CHABAD GOES TO COURT IN THE UNITED STATES
Proceedings in the U.S. District Courts
On 10 June 2004, after confirming that the Archive was being held at the RSMA, Chabad delegation members sent a letter to President Vladimir Putin, the minister of foreign affairs, and the minister of culture and mass communication requesting the return of the Archive to Chabad in New York.Footnote 56 No reply was ever received by Chabad. Faced with the inability to receive justice in Russia, either through courts or through diplomacy, Chabad filed suit on 9 November 2004 in the United States seeking the return of both the Archive and the Library. The suit was filed in Los Angeles, in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, and sought recovery of Chabad's entire collection of sacred books and manuscripts that are being held in Russia. Named in the complaint as defendants were the Russian Federation, the Russian Ministry of Culture and Mass Communication (after 2008, the name was changed simply to the Russian Ministry of Culture), the RSL, and the RSMA (hereinafter collectively “Russia”).Footnote 57 (Since all parties in the litigation and the American courts used the English abbreviations RSL and RSMA in referring to these two Russian defendants, these will be used in the following discussion).
Chabad brought its claims against Russia under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act of 1976 (FSIA). As a general principle of both international law and domestic laws of all nation states, foreign states are immune from suit in national courts.Footnote 58 The same immunity is provided to foreign states and state-held entities under U.S. federal law pursuant to the FSIA.Footnote 59
Prior to the Second World War, sovereign immunity was absolute, and foreign states were wholly immune from litigation in U.S. courts. After World War II, the absolute rule of sovereign immunity gave way to the so-called restrictive theory, whereby a sovereign engaged in a nonsovereign capacity (a commercial venture being the prime example) could be liable in the same way as a private entity engaging in that capacity. This restrictive theory of sovereign immunity was codified by Congress in the FSIA. Section 1602 of the FSIA, titled “Findings and declaration of purpose,” states: “Under international law [today], states are not immune from the jurisdiction of foreign courts insofar as their commercial activities are concerned, and their commercial property may be levied upon for the satisfaction of judgments rendered against them in connection with their commercial activities.”Footnote 60
Under the scheme established by Congress in the FSIA, a foreign state and its related entities enjoy a presumption of immunity to suit in American courts (28 U.S.C. § 1604); and this presumption is defeated when the plaintiff proves that the suit falls within one or more of the exceptions to sovereign immunity specifically enumerated in the FSIA. The most common exceptions are those found at 28 U.S.C. § 1605(a)(1) through (a)(7). These seven leading exceptions cover not only commercial activities of sovereigns but also other instances when Congress felt that foreign states should not enjoy immunity in American courts. Moreover, the FSIA distinguishes between the state and its ministries (called “political subdivision” in the FSIA) and state-run and state-owned entities (called “agency or instrumentality” in the FSIA). The latter, as defined in 28 U.S.C. § 1605(a)(3), enjoy less immunity under the FSIA than the state itself. Last, if the suit falls within at least one of the exceptions, Congress has provided that “the foreign state shall be liable in the same manner and to the same extent as a private individual under like circumstances.”Footnote 61 Distinguishing between the foreign state and its agencies, the same provision makes foreign states immune to claims for punitive damages but permits such punitive damages against the state's agencies and instrumentalities.
Chabad argued that its suit falls within the “expropriation” exception of the FSIA, set out at 28 U.S.C. § 1605(a)(3). This exception, in relevant part, provides (with brackets and bold added by the authors):
(a) A foreign state shall not be immune from the jurisdiction of courts of the United States or of the States in any case—
… .
(3) in which [A] rights in property taken in violation of international law are in issue and[B][1] that property or any property exchanged for such property is present in the United States in connection with a commercial activity carried on in the United States by the foreign state; or[B][2] that property or any property exchanged for such property is owned or operated by an agency or instrumentality of the foreign state and that agency or instrumentality is engaged in a commercial activity in the United States ….
As is evident, subsection (a)(3) has two clauses. The first clause requires that the expropriated property must be taken in violation of international law ([A] above) and must “be present in the United States” in connection with the foreign state's U.S.-based commercial activity ([B][1] above). For this suit, the first clause was not available to Chabad because both the Library and the Archive are present in the Russian Federation. The second clause of the “expropriation” exception—dealing with expropriated property being held by “an agency or instrumentality” of the foreign state—has less stringent requirements. Like the first clause, it also requires an expropriation in violation of international law ([A] above); however, the second clause ([B][2] above) does not require the expropriated property to be present in the United States. Instead, it simply provides that for American jurisdiction to exist the agency or instrumentality holding the disputed and illegally taken property “is engaged in a commercial activity in the United States.” The rationale for the less stringent requirement of the second clause is that the latter entity is not the foreign state itself but its agency or instrumentality, and so it is fair to make that agency or instrumentality subject to an American lawsuit, even if that lawsuit involves expropriated property located outside of the United States.
On 2 May 2005, Russia moved to dismiss the lawsuit on jurisdictional grounds. Russia first argued that American courts lacked jurisdiction to hear the case, citing sovereign immunity protection under the FSIA. Russia also argued even if jurisdiction exists under the FSIA, the suit should be dismissed because (1) the act of state doctrine barred the suit, and (2) Russian courts provided an adequate forum to hear this dispute, and so the case should be dismissed under the doctrine of forum non conveniens in favor of having the dispute resolved in Russia.
The act of state doctrine is a judge-made doctrine by which U.S. courts, even though they might possess jurisdiction over a case, will decline to hear the case on grounds of judicial prudence, because their hearing of the case might negatively impact the foreign relations of the United States. The U.S. Supreme Court in 1897 set out the so-called classic formulation of the doctrine as follows:
Every sovereign state is bound to respect the independence of every other sovereign state, and the courts of one country will not sit in judgment on the acts of the government of another, done within its own territory. Redress of grievances by reason of such acts must be obtained through the means open to be availed of by sovereign powers as between themselves.Footnote 62
Therefore, even if a U.S. court has jurisdiction to hear the suit, the court can still dismiss the suit on act of state grounds if the suit seeks to challenge an official act of a foreign state done within its own territory.
Like the act of state doctrine, forum non conveniens is also a judge-made doctrine under which the trial judge has the discretion to dismiss a case in favor of a more adequate and convenient foreign forum.Footnote 63 As will be shown later, Chief Judge Royce C. Lamberth partially accepted Russia's act of state defense and wholly rejected the forum non conveniens defense. His primary focus, however, was the initial and critical question of whether Russia possesses sovereign immunity to the suit.
Confronting Chabad's argument that no immunity exists under the FSIA's second clause “expropriation” exception in Section 1605(a)(3), Russia did not dispute that the RSL and the RSMA are “agencies or instrumentalities” of the Russian Federation under the FSIA. Russia also conceded that rights to property are indeed at issue in the suit, “inasmuch as Plaintiff's claims of right to the Library and the Archive are placed in issue by Plaintiff's complaint.”Footnote 64 Rather than challenge Chabad's ownership rights, Russia argued instead that Chabad could not establish that the property was (1) “taken in violation of international law,” or (2) was “owned or operated by an agency engaged in commercial activity in the United States”Footnote 65—both which were required under the second clause of Section 1605(a)(3) to defeat Russia's presumptive sovereign immunity to the suit. Russia argued, first, that “under the facts alleged by Chabad, the ‘taking’ of the ‘Library’ occurred when the Rebbes were Russian citizens and [Russia] was, by definition, not in violation of international law.”Footnote 66 In support of its lack of commercial activity argument, Russia submitted declarations, stating that the “RSL does not engage in any commercial activity in the United States” and the “RSMA does not engage in any commercial activities in the United States.”Footnote 67
Jurisdictional discovery and other investigations revealed that, contrary to Russia's assertion, both the RSL and RSMA indeed engage in U.S.-based commercial activities. Chabad's counsel located catalogs on the Internet of numerous U.S. publishing companies offering for sale in the United States microfilm of holdings at the RSL and the RSMA. Chabad then issued subpoenas to these companies and obtained copies of the contracts and royalty records reflecting payments to the RSL and the RSMA for sales of microfilm worldwide, including in United States. One of the contracts between the RSMA and Primary Source Media, an American company, expressly acknowledged in its “Sovereign Immunity” provision that “the activities contemplated by this Agreement are commercial in nature rather than governmental or public.”Footnote 68 Chabad then took the deposition of Vladimir N. Kuzelenkov, director of the RSMA. At his 20 June 2005 deposition (which was taken in by video-link from California to Moscow), Kuzelenkov was shown this contract. When Chabad's counsel showed Kuzelenkov the acknowledgment in the contract that it was “commercial in nature” and asked, “Do you see it in front of you?” Kuzelenkov responded, “Unfortunately, yes.”Footnote 69
Chabad also served written discovery on the defendants. In response to an interrogatory asking the RSMA to state all facts to support any contention that the Archive was nationalized, the RSMA responded, “Due to the passage of time and the change in government, Russian State Military Archive is presently unable to determine the circumstances under which the Archive was acquired and consequently whether the Archive has been nationalized.”Footnote 70 That interrogatory response was verified under penalty of perjury.Footnote 71 Chabad's deposition of Director Kuzelenkov revealed, however, that the RSMA has a “book of incoming materials into the archive, the act of transmission.”Footnote 72 Chabad promptly demanded the production of this book, which stated that the Archive was received in September 1945 from “Germany (a small settlement called Welfelsdorf).”Footnote 73 (As will become evident later, the reference is to the village of Wölfelsdorf [now Polish Wilkanów], near Habelschwerdt, in Lower Silesia, which became part of Poland under the terms of the Potsdam protocols in August 1945.)
Director Kuzelenkov also testified that he and Deputy Director Korotaev had prepared certificates in July 2004 confirming that Chabad's Archive was received in 1945 as “trophy documents.” The certificates further state that RSMA fond 706/k houses documents from “Schneerson Iossel Itzka” and “contains 98 units dating from 1907–1935, all totaling 10,530 pages.” The certificates also state that a “[s]ignificant part of the Fond (40 units containing total of 5,757 pages) are manuscripts, including printed, that have been written by Schneerson on various religious subjects: creation of Chasidism, Chasidic traditions, rituals and religious practices, Jewish religious and spiritual values, biblical scenes, religious education, etc.; religious text, recitals, memoirs.”Footnote 74 Thus, Chabad was able to establish that the Archive was brought to Moscow in 1945 as “trophy documents,” notwithstanding the RSMA's assertions in written discovery that it was “unable to determine the circumstances under which the Archive was acquired.” Moreover, based on copies of the Archive that Chabad obtained prior to the lawsuit, Chabad believes that portions of the Archive can be found at the RSMA not only in fond 706, but also in fonds 707 (finding aid—opis 1, 2, & 3), 709 (opis 2), 717 (opis 1 & 2), 1325, and 1326.Footnote 75
On 14 July 2005, the federal court in Los Angeles transferred the case to the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, holding that under the FSIA the appropriate venue for the suit was in Washington DC. There, the case was assigned to Chief Judge Lamberth.Footnote 76 In a supplemental brief before Judge Lamberth, Russia argued for the first time that Chabad had no vested rights in the subject property on the grounds that Chabad was incorporated in 1940 and has never had physical possession of either the Library or the Archive.Footnote 77 Chabad responded by arguing that, prior to the Soviet Union's and Nazi Germany's unlawful seizures, the collection was always held by the rebbes for the benefit of Chabad's worldwide followers, and the sixth rebbe's correspondence from 1939 through 1946 states the Archive belongs to Chabad.Footnote 78
Russia also argued in its supplemental brief that the case should be dismissed because Russia is an adequate alternative forum. Russia asserted that the defendants were amenable to process in Russia; “the Russian Federation permits litigation of the subject matter of this dispute; Plaintiff previously prosecuted a similar action in Russia from 1991–1992”; and that the dismissal of that action was simply because Chabad brought its claims in the wrong Russian court. Russia also argued that the “true remedy Chabad seeks is delivery of the Library and Archive” and “[t]his Court's ability to provide that remedy is doubtful.”Footnote 79 Chabad responded by arguing that the FSIA provides the court with the power to attach “any property” in aid of execution of a judgment against a foreign state's agencies and instrumentalities, and that Russia had failed to satisfy its burden to show that Russia is an adequate alternative forum. According to Chabad, “The fact that Chabad filed a claim in the Soviet arbitration court nearly 15 years ago is not evidence that a Russian court today is an adequate alternative forum.” Chabad further argued that the Duma's February 1992 decree barred any litigation in the Russian Federation to recover the collection.Footnote 80
On 4 December 2006, Judge Lamberth issued his ruling. He first granted Russia's motion to dismiss Chabad's Library claim because he found the “violation of international law” element of Section 1605(a)(3) missing for the Library claim. Notwithstanding Chabad's allegations that the rebbes always held the Library in charitable trust on behalf of Chabad (even prior to Chabad's formal incorporation in 1940), Judge Lamberth concluded that the taking of the Library by the Soviets in 1917–1921 did not violate international law because the Library was taken by a state from its own citizens, which ordinarily does not amount to a violation of international law. According to Judge Lamberth, because the “owner” of the Library was the fifth rebbe and he was a Russian (and then Soviet) citizen until his death in 1920, and the sixth rebbe was a Soviet citizen until at least 1927, the taking of the Library by the Soviet Union did not amount to an international law violation. Judge Lamberth also concluded that the “orders and rulings issued in 1991 and 1992 cannot be read as giving Chabad ownership of the Library and Chabad should not be able to predicate its taking claim on them.”Footnote 81 He also held that the act of state doctrine independently barred Chabad's claim for the return of the Library, ruling that Chabad's claim for the return of the Library sought to challenge the expropriation actions of Russia conducted within its own territory, making the claim nonjusticiable under the act of state doctrine.Footnote 82
Judge Lamberth, however, reached an entirely different conclusion with respect to the Archive. He first concluded that “the Nazis' taking of the Archive clearly violated international law” and “the Soviet Army's 1945 seizure and appropriation of the Archive from its Nazi captors as spoils of war was also a taking in violation of international law.” Judge Lamberth also concluded that the sixth rebbe's correspondence from 1939–1946 established that “even before he was forced to leave the Archive behind in Poland, the Sixth Rebbe did not consider it to be his personal property, but had rather held it ‘in trust for the benefit of the religious community of Chabad Chasidism.’”Footnote 83
Judge Lamberth also concluded that the RSMA had engaged in commercial activity in the United States; Chabad was not required to exhaust remedies in Russia before bringing its Archive claims in U.S. federal court; Chabad's Archive claim was not barred by the act of state doctrine because both the Nazis and the Soviets took the Archive outside of their respective territories; and rejected Russia's argument that the case should be dismissed on the grounds that Russia is a more adequate forum. The court commented, “Having conducted jurisdictional discovery and presented their oral arguments, the defendants had ample opportunity to make a showing of the existence of an adequate alternate forum. However, the defendant's conclusory statements about the adequacy of a Russian forum fall short of the required showing for forum non conveniens.”Footnote 84 The court also noted that “[t]he defendants appear to be suggesting that this Court should divest itself of jurisdiction because if it rules against the defendants, they may refuse to abide by its judgment. Such an argument is an affront to this Court and does not militate in favor of dismissal on the grounds of forum non conveniens.”Footnote 85
Chabad's Legal Victory before the U.S. Court of Appeals
Since Judge Lamberth handed each side only a partial victory, both Chabad and Russia appealed his decision. On 13 June 2008, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia, handed Chabad a complete victory by (1) reversing Judge Lamberth's decision dismissing that part of Chabad's action seeking to recover the Library, and (2) upholding that part of his ruling allowing Chabad to continue litigation in U.S. courts for the return of the Archive. The three appellate judges found that U.S. law allows Chabad to pursue both claims to the Library and the Archive in U.S. courts. In its opinion, the appellate court also clarified the standards by which future plaintiffs could seek the return of cultural valuables under Section 1605 (a)(3), the “expropriation” exception to the FSIA.Footnote 86
The DC Circuit first examined how much evidence Chabad had to present at the jurisdictional stage of the litigation in order to be allowed to go forward under the expropriation exception of the FSIA. The appellate court rejected the notion that Chabad had the burden of proving each and every element of the expropriation exception by a preponderance of the evidence at the jurisdictional phase. Instead of requiring a mini-trial to establish subject matter jurisdiction, the DC Circuit held that for the case to continue past a jurisdictional challenge, the plaintiff need only place “in issue” a claim that is substantial and nonfrivolous that the defendant (or its predecessor) has taken the plaintiff's rights in property (or those of its predecessor in title) in violation of international law. However, in order to satisfy the commercial activity nexus of the second clause of the expropriation exception, the plaintiff must establish by a “preponderance of the evidence”Footnote 87 that the agency or instrumentality that owns or operates the property at issue—here the RSL and the RSMA—is engaged in a commercial activity in the United States.Footnote 88 The appellate court found that Chabad at this stage of the proceedings presented adequate evidence that both the RSL and the RSMA engaged in sufficient commercial activity in the United States to satisfy this requirement of the expropriation exception. As the court explained:
Both the RSMA and the RSL have entered transactions for joint publishing and sales in the United States easily satisfying these standards. At the time of the filing of the suit in November 2004, the RSMA had entered contracts with two American corporations for the reproduction and worldwide sale of RSMA materials, including in the United States. District Court Decision, 466 F. Supp. 2d at 21. One set of contracts was with Primary Source Media and allowed the American firm to publish, among other items, papers of Leon Trotsky and other documents relating to the Russian Civil War. The contracts include provisions waiving sovereign immunity, specifying that the activities described in the contract are “commercial in nature.” Agreement on the Granting of Rights to Publish Archival Documents art. 14. By the year 2000 the RSMA had received $60,000 in advance royalties. See Declaration of Joseph Bucci [p.] 8; see also Royalty Advance Statements, Primary Source Microfilm. Another contract with Yale University Press provides for the “joint preparation and publication of a volume of documents entitled The Spanish Civil War” and garnered RSMA a $10,000 royalty advance in the year of the contract. The RSL has also contracted for cooperative commercial activities in the United States. For example, it entered into agreements with Norman Ross Publishing (later succeeded by ProQuest), arranging for that firm to sell an encyclopedia and to produce and distribute “microcopies” of various RSL materials (in exchange for a 10% royalty payment to the RSL). One such contract has already yielded RSL over $20,000 and another over $5000.
Thus, the court found that Section 1605(a)(3)'s commercial activity requirement is “plainly satisfied.”Footnote 89
The DC Circuit also concluded that the “expropriation” exception's second clause—that the agency or instrumentality owns or operates the property at issue and is engaged in “a commercial activity” in the United States—does not require “substantial” contact with the United States. More critical, under the plain language of the expropriation exception as applied to agencies and instrumentalities of the foreign state (here the RSL and RSMA), the court found that the second clause did not require that the property at issue be present in the United States in connection with a commercial activity carried on in the United States. The plaintiff need only prove by a preponderance of evidence that the commercial activity engaged in by the agency or instrumentality involves a particular commercial transaction or act in the United States.Footnote 90
The DC Circuit also held that Chabad's claim that the Library was taken by the Soviet Union in 1917–1925 and then retaken by the Russian Federation in 1992 was not insubstantial or frivolous.Footnote 91 The DC Circuit noted that after Chabad obtained favorable rulings in the Soviet court system in 1991, Chabad's efforts were frustrated shortly after the collapse of the Soviet Union through Russian officials' physical action (i.e., inciting anti-Semitic mobs at the steps of the RSL) and through governmental decrees and a ruling by the deputy chief state arbiter purporting to overrule the rulings of the chief state arbiter. The DC Circuit's opinion provides that a plaintiff can assert claims that a successor state can “renew” an earlier taking in violation of international law through extrajudicial and dubious conduct.
The DC Circuit also rejected Russia's argument that Chabad's claim to recover the Archive should be dismissed for failure to exhaust remedies in the Russian Federation. The DC Circuit noted that nothing in Section 1605(a)(3) suggests that a plaintiff must exhaust foreign remedies before bringing suit in the United States. International law, they ruled, only requires exhaustion of remedies when one nation sues another nation on behalf of a citizen (i.e., nation vs. nation litigation) and not in a private litigation between a private party and a foreign nation. The DC Circuit also rejected Russia's argument that the FSIA's expropriation exception's language, “taking in violation of international law,” subsumes a requirement that a plaintiff exhaust foreign remedies before bringing suit in the United States.Footnote 92 Moreover, the appellate court concluded that even if Chabad was required to exhaust its legal remedies in Russia with regard to the Archive (Russia conceded that Chabad exhausted its legal remedies in Russia with regard to the Library), the purported remedy provided by the 1998 Cultural Valuables Law is not adequate. Under Article 19(2) of the 1998 Cultural Valuables Law, the disputed cultural property may only be returned on the claimant's “payment of its value as well as reimbursement of the costs of its identification, expert examination, storage, restoration, and transfer (transportation, etc.),” without specifying rules for calculating value. The DC Circuit noted that “Russia's mere willingness to sell the plaintiff's property back to it could not remedy the alleged wrong.”Footnote 93
The DC Circuit also examined whether the act of state doctrine prevented American courts from examining Chabad's claims against Russia and concluded, contrary to Judge Lamberth, that the act of state doctrine presents no bar to Chabad's claims to recover the Archive nor the Library. As explained earlier, the act of state doctrine requires that the act of the foreign state be done on its own territory.Footnote 94 The appellate court noted, however, that Nazi Germany took the Archive from the sixth rebbe's yeshiva in Otwock, Poland, and the Soviet armed forces took the Archive from the Wölfelsdorf castle in Lower Silesia (which by then had become part of Poland as a result of the Protocols of the Potsdam Conference). Thus, the court found that the act of state doctrine did not apply to the Archive claims because the acts of taking were not done within the territory of the Soviet Union. With respect to Chabad's claim that the Library was “retaken” in 1992, the three judges relied on another U.S. federal law, the Second Hickenlooper Amendment, which bars application of the act of state doctrine to seizures occurring after 1 January 1959.Footnote 95
Finally, the DC Circuit rejected Russia's argument that the district court will likely be unable to afford Chabad the relief it seeks, namely, possession of the Library and Archive. The district court characterized this argument as an “affront.” Under the FSIA, 28 U.S.C. § 1609, “the property in the United States of a foreign state shall be immune from attachment arrest and execution except as provided in sections 1610 and 1611 of this chapter.” Chabad cited the FSIA provisions that allow attachment of certain Russian government property in the United States, 28 U.S.C. § 1610(a)(3), (b)(2), and argued that they would give it leverage over the defendants, enhancing the likelihood that Russia or its courts will respect a judgment of the U.S. courts.
Section 1610(a)(3) provides that the
property in the United States of a foreign state … , used for commercial activity in the United States, shall not be immune from attachment in aid of execution, or from execution, upon a judgment entered by a court of the United States … if the execution relates to a judgment establishing rights in property which has been taken in violation of international law… .
When a judgment creditor seeking to attach the property of a foreign agency or instrumentality such as the RSL and the RSMA, however, there is no requirement that the attached property be “used for a commercial activity in the United States” as there is when a party seeks to directly attach the property of a foreign sovereign. Under Section 1610(b)(2), “any” property in the United States of an agency or instrumentality of a foreign state may be seized so long as that agency or instrumentality is “engaged in a commercial activity in the United States.”Footnote 96 Based on these statutes, the DC Circuit agreed with Chabad that it was “plausible” that the district court could use its powers to attach property of the defendants after entry of a final judgment to coerce them to return Chabad's Library and Archive.Footnote 97
The Case Returns to Judge Lamberth, and Russia Pulls Out of the Suit
After prevailing completely before the court of appeals, the case was remanded back to Judge Lamberth. In mid-December 2008, Chabad learned that a few manuscripts from the collection were being offered for sale in Israel. Chabad promptly sought and obtained a preliminary injunction from Judge Lamberth requiring the Russian defendants to secure, protect, and preserve the entire collection until the entry of a final judgment in the case.Footnote 98 A failure by Russia to comply with the preliminary injunction could constitute a contempt of court. While there appears to be little case law on contempt proceedings against foreign states or their agencies or instrumentalities where, as here, the district court has exerted jurisdiction over the defendants, Judge Lamberth likely has the inherent and statutory authority to punish such contempt and to ensure compliance with his preliminary injunction.Footnote 99
On 13 March 2009, over four years after the filing of the lawsuit, Russia filed an answer to Chabad's original complaint.Footnote 100 In the answer, Russia alleged that “[b]ecause Plaintiff fails to identify the specific materials it alleges to constitute the ‘Library,’ ‘Schneersohn Library’ or ‘Lubavitch Library,’ the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to whether the materials alleged by Plaintiff to be the ‘Library;’ are coincident with the materials at the RSL.” Russia admitted that the RSMA is in “physical possession of certain materials that may constitute a portion of documents allegedly maintained by Rabbi Joseph Isaac Schneersohn,” but denied other allegations on the ground that Chabad “fails to identify the specific materials allegedly constituting the ‘Archive’ or the portions of that alleged ‘Archive’ that are in the possession of the RSMA.” Notably, in contrast to its prior claimed ignorance of the circumstances surrounding the acquisition of the Archive, Russia now admitted that “materials Plaintiff alleges to be part of what Plaintiff defines as the Archive were included with materials transported by the Soviet Union after World War II and were and remain stored at the RSMA.”Footnote 101
Thereafter, Chabad served discovery requests as to the merits of the claims, including requests of defendants to immediately update the limited jurisdictional discovery previously provided. Defendants refused to engage in discovery and, instead, on 26 June 2009, filed a Statement with Respect to Further Participation, informing the court that they “declined to participate further in this litigation” and “believed this Court has no authority to enter Orders with respect to the property owned by the Russian Federation and in its possession, and the Russian Federation will not consider any such Orders to be binding on it.” A motion was simultaneously filed by Russia's attorneys, Squire, Sanders & Dempsey, LLP, to withdraw as counsel of record for defendants. That motion was granted on 26 October 2009.
The following day, on 27 October 2009, in response to Chabad's motion for an entry of default against all defendants, Judge Lamberth ordered the clerk to enter a default against the Russians, noting that default was proper because “the defendants have willfully refused to continue in this litigation.”Footnote 102 In its default order, Judge Lamberth directed Chabad to seek next a default judgment. In nonlegal parlance, this means that Chabad will now be able to argue the merits of its case before Judge Lamberth (the FSIA prohibits jury trials for suits against foreign statesFootnote 103) in order to seek a judgment against the Russian Federation and its co-defendants. On 5 May 2010, Chabad filed a motion for entry of a default judgment against the Russian defendants. As of this writing, the resolution of the motion for entry of a default judgment has yet to take place.
CONCLUSION
The appellate ruling awarded the Chabad community a significant legal victory in its fight to recover missing parts of its sacred collection, since the appellate judges gave the green light for the dispute to be heard and resolved by an American judge. Nonetheless, the dispute with the Russian Federation over the Library and the Archive is far from a final resolution. Should Chabad prevail in making a prima facie case sufficient to warrant the entry of a judgment under the FSIA on its Library and Archive claims, it must then proceed to enforce the judgment. This begins another stage in the litigation process, since, as noted earlier, enforcement of U.S. judgments against a foreign state (the Russian Federation), any of its political subdivisions (the Ministry of Culture) and agencies and instrumentalities (the RSL and the RSMA) is governed by another set of provisions of the FSIA.Footnote 104 These provisions set out the conditions by which Chabad can attach Russian assets found in the United States in aid of execution of a judgment rendered pursuant to the expropriation exception of the FSIA. The general rule of the FSIA with regard to enforcing judgments explicitly states: “[Foreign states'] commercial property may be levied upon for the satisfaction of judgments rendered against them in connection with their commercial activities.”Footnote 105
A judgment that allows Chabad to seize defendants' other property in the United States may conclusively convince Russia to give Chabad what it ultimately seeks: the return to Chabad of the Library and the Archive. Thus, the appellate ruling in Chabad v. Russian Federation pushes Chabad a bit closer to reaching its goal of retrieval of the Library and Archive.
The appellate ruling also provides a significant precedent for other claimants that choose to turn to American courts for relief against sovereign states and their governmental institutions for the return of looted cultural property. Both Judge Lamberth and the DC Circuit appellate judges demonstrated through their rulings that if a U.S. court is presented with the right set of facts, viewed by the court as sufficient to bring the dispute surrounding the looted cultural property within the FSIA Section 1605(a)(3) expropriation exception to sovereign immunity, or even another exception, the court will not shy away from allowing the dispute to be heard in the United States. It will do so even if the cultural property itself is outside the jurisdictional power of the U.S. courts and being held by a foreign state in its own territory.
The precedential value of the 2008 Chabad appellate decision is buttressed by an earlier decision of the U.S. Supreme Court involving a suit for the recovery of Nazi-looted art. In 2004, the Supreme Court in Republic of Austria v. Altmann Footnote 106 handed Holocaust heirs seeking return of looted cultural objects being held abroad by a foreign sovereign its first major victory when it ruled that the FSIA should be given retroactive application. In Altmann, an heir to five Gustav Klimt paintings being held by a government museum in Austria and earlier looted by the Nazis sought to bring her suit within the expropriation exception to sovereign immunity of the FSIA. The claimant argued that the FSIA exception is applicable even though the Klimt expropriations took place during the Nazi era, prior to the enactment of the FSIA in 1976. Austria argued that it possessed absolute sovereign immunity to the suit, based on pre-FSIA law. The Supreme Court ruled against Austria, finding that the FSIA and its exceptions should be applied retroactively and therefore applicable to expropriations that took place prior to the FSIA's enactment. This ruling, of course, allowed Chabad to argue in its suit against Russia that the expropriation exceptions likewise applied to the expropriations of its sacred texts during the Bolshevik Revolution and World War II. The Chabad ruling, in turn, will embolden other claimants to bring their claims in American courts.
The Altmann and Chabad cases and further litigation that surely will follow from these decisions demonstrate that when foreign governments are unwilling to resolve long-simmering disputes involving looted cultural property, U.S. courts may provide an alternative viable forum for the resolution of these disputes.
Editor's Note
As this IJCP issue was going to press, on 30 July 2010, after 5 1/2 years of litigation, Chief Judge Royce C. Lamberth of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia issued an eleven-page “Memorandum Opinion” with a summary of the case of Agudas Chasidei Chabad of United States, Plaintiff v. Russian Federation, et al., Defendants, Civil Action No. 05-1548 (RCL), which concludes that the “Plaintiff has met its burden of proving a prima facie case against defendants and has established its right to relief by evidence satisfactory to the court. For the foregoing reasons, plaintiff Agudas Chasidei Chabad of United States' Motion for Entry of Default Judgment Against All Defendants [79-1] shall be GRANTED.”
A separate court “Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion For Entry Of Default Judgment Against All Defendants” was issued on the same date, requiring the Defendants “to surrender to the United States Embassy in Moscow or to the duly appointed representatives of Plaintiff Agudas Chasidei Chabad of United States the complete collection of religious books, manuscripts, documents and things that comprise the ‘Library’ and the ‘Archive’ presently being held by the Defendants at the Russian State Library and Russian State Military Archive or elsewhere… .”
The Plaintiff was further ordered “to report back to this Court within thirty (30) calendar days of the date of this Order, and advise the Court on the progress of securing a return of the ‘Library’ and the ‘Archive’…”
(The “Memorandum Opinion” (Document 81), available at https://ecf.dcd.uscourts.gov/cqi-bin/show_public_doc?2005cv1548-81, and the “Order” (Document 80), were entered on 30 July 2010 in Agudas Chasidei Chabad of United States v. Russian Federation, Case No. 05-1548 (RCL), United States District Court for the District of Columbia.)
