History of physics, and history of science in general, has traditionally been written as an account of how theories have evolved in interaction with experiments. David Kaiser's historiography is different, as he does not see modern theoretical physics as a competition between rival theories but instead as ‘a story ultimately about crafting, deploying, and stabilizing the tools that undergird everyday calculations’ (p. 6). Other authors, notably Andrew Warwick, Ursula Klein and Peter Galison, have similarly emphasized tools, diagrams, pedagogy and day-to-day calculations, yet Kaiser's book is the first to present a detailed analysis of how such elements may account for a large part of theoretical physics in the decades following the Second World War. Kaiser focuses on the dissemination and uses of Feynman diagrams, which is a particularly rewarding choice because these diagrams permeated (and still permeate) nearly every branch of physics.
Kaiser has organized his book into three parts. He starts by analysing how the Feynman diagrams spread and why they were received so differently by physicists working at different locations. Because he is not so much concerned with the creation of theories and techniques as with their dispersion and diverse representations in local communities, his main sources are not scientific articles but rather the young physicists' notebooks and course notes. He has spent much effort in finding sources of this kind, and his innovative use of them adds a fresh perspective to the book. The second part concentrates on what was spreading – that is, how physicists understood and transformed the diagrammatic techniques. For example, Feynman and Freeman Dyson held different ideas about the diagrams, and Kaiser traces this ‘split’ and its consequences in fascinating detail. In the third part he takes up the role of textbooks in the dissemination of the Feynman diagrams and examines why physicists continued to work with the diagrams, even in fields unrelated (or seen as opposite) to the diagrams' original motivations. With regard to textbooks, Kaiser documents that they played no role in the rapid dispersion of Feynman diagrams, which depended much more strongly on local interactions such as personal contact, seminars and face-to-face training. He also argues that the common conception of textbooks as shrines of finished science is inadequate and, in this case, wrong. The textbooks on Feynman diagrams that appeared from 1955 onwards contained no finished or stabilized theory, and they did not halt a continuation of diagrammatic diversity.
The title of the book, Drawing Theories Apart, relates to an article Bruno Latour wrote in 1986 (‘Drawing things together’), in which he argued that diagrams and like types of inscription are mobile yet immutable entities. Although inspired by Latour to some extent, Kaiser emphatically denies the immutability of diagrams. On the contrary, it is a leading theme in the book that Feynman diagrams are highly plastic, malleable tools, and that they owed their tremendous success to this inherent plasticity. Indeed, by centring his account around Feynman diagrams and related diagrammatic techniques, Kaiser is able to cover a substantial part of modern theoretical physics, including quantum field theory, dispersion relations, many-body theory and strong interactions. I found his detailed account of Geoffrey Chew's ‘democratic’ programme of strongly interacting particles (so-called bootstrap theory) to be particularly valuable. This episode in the history of modern physics has traditionally been seen as a competition between two rival theories – quantum field theory versus S-matrix theory – but Kaiser argues that it was really about calculational tools and techniques, not theory. He further suggests that Chew's S-matrix programme was not simply defeated by the new standard model of elementary particles, as many of the S-matrix techniques lived on within the standard model.
Is Kaiser right about what theoretical physicists do? According to him, they are preoccupied with calculations, not with comparing theories or paradigms. He goes as far as recommending that the category of ‘theory’ (a term he prefers to put in inverted commas) should be avoided in the historical analysis of modern physics. I must admit that I find this to be an extreme view with little justification. Kaiser wisely applies his anti-theory view only to the case of theoretical physics, and to Feynman diagrams in particular, but even in this case I find it questionable.
Quibbles with this anti-theoretical stance aside, Drawing Theories Apart is a rich, original and most recommendable contribution to the history of modern science. It skilfully integrates social history with conceptual history, a technical mastery of Feynman diagrams with a broad and novel perspective of the historicity of the diagrams. Kaiser knows his physics and discusses, when it is relevant, the scientific details of his subject in a lucid and authoritative way. Although some sections of the book are scientifically demanding and will not be understood by non-physicists, they are not of essential importance to the book's argument. Drawing Theories Apart will surely be studied by historians, sociologists and philosophers of physics, but its readership should not be restricted to these groups. It has much to offer also to readers with no background in physics.
