David Sepkoski's new monograph is a signficant archival achievement. Few histories of twentieth-century evolutionary biology have moved beyond a consideration of the events of the mid-century evolutionary synthesis. Those that have have largely been written either by the practitioners themselves or by philosophers weighing in on the theoretical and logical state of evolutionary theory. Both are necessary perspectives, but they do not substitute for a historically grounded approach to this material. By giving us the institutional, intellectual and disciplinary developments that resulted in the emergence of palaeobiology as a new research agenda for palaeontology, Sepkoski has provided all scholars interested in the course of evolutionary theory with an invaluable history.
The book's main contention is that the new discipline of palaeobiology represented a ‘delayed synthesis’ as both an institutional and an intellectual extension of the ‘work’ of the modern synthesis of the 1940s. Although the core of the book focuses on developments in the 1970s, Sepkoski begins by setting forth a central problem that palaeontology had contended with since its earliest days. Though the fossil record ostensibly provides the best (and only) record of the actual course of evolutionary history, even in Darwin's time the fossil record was seen as only an incomplete and imperfect testimony to the history of life on Earth. Additionally, for much of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, palaeontology was considered merely descriptive of evolutionary history, rather than an inquiry into the character of the evolutionary process. It was in the labs of geneticists that one could see evolutionary change over successive close generations, not in the fossil remains of the geologic column. For the group of palaeontologists who came of age in the 1970s, this exclusion from the theoretical aspects of evolutionary biology was extremely frustrating. As these palaeontologists reframed what the evidence of the fossil record could and should be, they also a claimed a new identity as ‘palaeobiologists’ – theoretically motivated and quantitatively astute contributors to general evolutionary theory.
Rather than resigning themselves to the so-called imperfections of the fossil record, these palaeobiologists combined new perspectives and new quantitative tools that reframed the fossil record as a productive source of evidence for the nature of evolutionary change. Sepkoski describes three successive phases in what he terms the ‘rereadings’ of palaeontological evidence. In the first of these, palaeobiologists read the gaps in the fossil record not as unfortunate missing pieces, but as a testament to the real discontinuity in the tempo of evolutionary change. The most famous of these approaches, the theory of punctuated equilibrium authored by Niles Eldredge and Stephen Jay Gould, proposed that evolutionary change tended to result in a prolonged stasis in forms, which was then punctuated by rapid speciation. Thus they reread the lack of successive generations of gradually modified forms in the fossil record as positive evidence for a new model of evolutionary timing. A subsequent group of palaeobiologists (primarily Thomas Schopf and David Raup) utilized what Sepkoski describes as an ‘idealized rereading’. In this mode, palaeobiologists treated all the various taxa of the fossil record as a series of homogeneous data points and argued that evolutionary patterns were primarily the result of stochastic speciation and extinction events rather than produced by adaptation and selection pressure. Finally, these two models merged into a strategy of ‘generalized rereading’, which continued to be the dominant method through to the end of the 1980s. In these new evidentiary models, palaeobiologists proposed something novel and even radical – the truly significant features both of the way evolution worked and of the large patterns of evolutionary history could only be derived from palaeontological data. Population geneticists were missing the full picture.
This book is largely a story of a cohesive and self-consciously organized group of palaeontologists who carved out a new disciplinary space for themselves. Sepkoski is able to give such a clear and yet nuanced account of these transitions largely because of his immersion in and handling of the primary archival materials. For instance, Sepkoski's detailing of the authorship of punctuated equilibrium (easily the best-known episode from this history) is a fascinating and even gripping read. He utilizes personal papers – including correspondence, manuscript drafts and interviews of the main players (including Schopf, Eldredge, Sepkoski, Raup and Gould) in order to trace both a new mode of research and the institutionalization of palaeobiology. However, there are times when the history seems to beg a more explicit discussion of the nature of scientific evidence, particularly in relationship to the broader historical context of the 1970s and 1980s. During this period the fossil record played prominently in general cultural controversies about the validity of evolution itself, but this book leaves untouched the potential implications for these new and even unintuitive rereadings of palaeontological evidence. Although, for instance, the well-known appropriation of Gould's writings by American creationists is undoubtedly outside the primary narrative of Sepkoski's story, we can still wonder how palaeobiologists conceptualized the standards for and nature of evidence itself, even as they were calling into question what evidence counted for evolutionary theory. Even so, one of the most energizing and exciting aspects of the book is Sepkoski's suggestion that the book is meant as a foundation for anticipated future studies. One can hardly help reading Sepkoski's book and not have the desire to continue writing the story of evolution in the post-synthesis era. He has carved out an impressive story in the details of this group of palaeontologists, and made a significant contribution to histories of science concerned with the role of disciplinary formation in the shaping of theory and research agendas in the natural sciences.
