Joshua Chambers-Letson brings “a performance studies perspective” (4) to the past century of Asian American history in his new book A Race So Different: Performance and Law in Asian America. Chambers-Letson's interdisciplinary approach is unique in its concerted effort to maintain a horizontal dialectic between what he calls “‘social structure’ (the law) and ‘cultural representation’ (performance aesthetics)” (ibid.). Examining sites ranging from opera houses that produced Puccini's Madama Butterfly and concentration camps that incarcerated Japanese Americans to contemporary performances of the LA-based Cambodian American indie-rock band Dengue Fever, the book mostly succeeds in maintaining this dialectic, but at times only because the legal discourse recedes almost entirely into the background. Since Chambers-Letson considers a “wide range of presentational and communicative behaviors” – most of all “embodied acts of self-presentation” – as performance, he is able to argue that the law is no more impactful than performance, and that even aesthetic performances like the opera Madama Butterfly can “take on a legal function by serving as agents of the law” (6–7).
The book's title comes from an infamous statement made by Supreme Court Justice John Marshal Harlan in his 1896 dissent to Plessy v. Ferguson. Writing in opposition to the Court's majority decision maintaining the Constitutionality of legal segregation, Harlan rejected the unequal status of African Americans, but only by creating a “state of racial exception” for Asian Americans based on the assertion that ethnic Chinese constituted “a race so different from our own that we do not permit those belonging to it to become citizens of the United States” (9). Chambers-Letson shows how this legal state of exception continues to impact Asian Americans today, based both on a “juridical architecture” of Asian difference established in the nineteenth century and on the stare decisis system of US jurisprudence, “whereby a decision in a given case will determine future applications of the law” (11, 15).
Although he provides an overview of key legal precedents for Asian Americans in the US, most of A Race So Different focusses on the legal power of cultural performances that serve as compelling embodiments of otherwise abstract juridical ideas. For instance, in his chapter on Madama Butterfly, Chambers-Letson shows that the tragic nature of Puccini's Japanese heroine – who commits suicide so her white American lover will adopt their biracial child – emanates from her failure to understand the operations of US law (namely that as a Japanese woman she is not recognized as a legal subject under it). Chambers-Letson closes his chapter on Butterfly with the compelling insight that US legal cases quickly recede from public memory whereas Puccini's opera “continues to be one of the most popular performance works of contemporary culture,” not just in the US but around the world (66).
While many of his case studies are drawn from dominant culture that unsurprisingly reinscribes the racial exception of Asian Americans, Chambers-Letson also analyzes more resistant performances that might be seen as rehearsing and enacting “new practices in justice” (69). In his examination of Chinese American theatre artist Ping Chong's 1995 play Chinoiserie and in his examination of patriotic performances and photographic practices of Japanese American internees in the World War II concentration camps, Chambers-Letson provides an admirably nuanced reading of historical actors negotiating between complicity and resistance. However, he sometimes falls into the familiar pitfalls of masculinist Asian American discourse that literature scholar Elaine Kim identified two decades ago. In this, Chambers-Letson follows the critical precedent of writers like Jeffrey Paul Chan and Frank Chin, who ascribe far more efficacy and agency to male Asian Americans than to female ones. For example, Chambers-Letson refuses to find any agency or efficacy in the blackface performance of a Japanese American girl interned at the Tule Lake concentration camp (which was in California, not Utah as he erroneously states at 114), while a chapter later he identifies an outlandish amount of resistance in the quiet photographs that a male internee named Moriyuki Shimada took while incarcerated at the Heart Mountain camp in Wyoming. Likewise, Chambers-Letson refuses to indict the white men who founded the rock band Dengue Fever, despite the clearly orientalist impulse of casting a pretty, young Cambodian American songstress to lend the band “Khmer authenticity” (he instead writes that Dengue Fever are “infinitely more complicated” than an orientalist critique would suggest (178)).
Nonetheless, A Race So Different provides a model for interdisciplinary scholarship that combines the classic theoretical texts of many fields with rigorous archival and field research methodologies. Chambers-Letson's insistence on paying attention to cultural representation even when the legal realm shares the stage is an important intervention for academic discourse, and his book will be a welcome addition to the critical texts in American studies, theatre and performance studies, and legal studies.
