More than 200 years ago, in 1817, David Ricardo published his major work On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation. Arguably, his most enduring and well-known legacy is his theory of international trade, which he outlines in chapter 7, “On Foreign Trade.” This is widely seen as the first account of the theory of comparative advantage—a theory that in a modern form is still prominent in international economics and which might well be the economic theory with the greatest share of approval among economists. Most introductory textbooks to economics have a chapter on Ricardo’s theory of comparative advantage and a so-called Ricardian model of international trade. However, textbooks refer to the history of its field often to justify modern theories and not to depict a former theory in an accurate way in its historical context. It might therefore come as no surprise to historians of economics that there are huge gaps between Ricardo’s own theory and its presentation in today’s textbooks, as has been pointed out by quite a few scholars. The edited volume Ricardo and International Trade tries to extend this research with the aim, as the editors state in their introduction, to challenge “traditional views on Ricardo’s international trade theory from a variety of angles, promoting new developments in Ricardian trade theory” (p. 1) by presenting “the cutting-edge of the research on Ricardian trade theory” (p. 4).
The endeavor of this edited volume is promising. It includes contributions by many long-standing Ricardo scholars. Encouragingly, it opens the English-speaking world to the rich tradition of the study of Ricardo in Japan, parts of which have been inaccessible to scholars not fluent in Japanese—six out of the thirteen contributions are written by Japanese scholars. The essays of this volume are divided into three big parts: “Ricardo’s ‘Four Magic Numbers’ and Beyond” (referring to Ricardo’s famous example of England and Portugal trading cloth and wine), “Money and/or International Values,” and “Controversies over Ricardian International Trade Theory and Policy.” But the division is less clear-cut than is implied by these three parts.
In his Principles, Ricardo devotes twenty-two pages to his chapter on foreign trade. It is, of course, integrated into his broader economic theory, which is based on the labor theory of value. He starts this chapter by asserting some similarities between foreign and home trade. First, foreign trade cannot “increase the amount of value in a country,” but it will “increase the mass of commodities, and therefore the sum of enjoyments” and thus “the happiness of mankind” (Ricardo [Reference Ricardo and Sraffa1817] 2004, pp. 128, 132). Second, international trade does not affect “the general rate of profits in the country” per se, a statement directed against Adam Smith. The rate of profits is affected only if foreign trade leads to a change in the price of subsistence commodities and thus to a change in the (subsistence) wage rate.
Notwithstanding these similarities, Ricardo affirms that a separate theory of international trade is necessary, because capital cannot move internationally as easily as it does domestically. Thus, the labor theory of value cannot be applied to trade between countries: “The same rule which regulates the relative value of commodities in one country, does not regulate the relative value of the commodities exchanged between two or more countries” (Ricardo [Reference Ricardo and Sraffa1817] 2004, p. 133). He illustrates this with his well-known example of England and Portugal. Although Portugal can produce the traded amounts of wine and cloth with a lower quantity of labor than England can, Ricardo shows that it is beneficial for both countries if Portugal exports wine while England exports cloths, because both countries benefit by saving a certain quantity of labor and still being able to get the same amount of both commodities. Domestically this would not have been the case, since production of both cloth and wine would have moved to the region that would produce each with the lowest amount of labor and capital. In this example, he uses the nation as the unit of analysis and shows that both nations benefit from international trade.
The second half of Ricardo’s chapter on foreign trade is devoted to the monetary side of international trade. Here, he also analyzes the effects of behavior on the individual level of consumers and merchants. Ricardo is aware that consumers are interested only in the price of a commodity, not the quantity of labor needed to produce it. Thus, the comparative advantage of each country has to be transformed into absolute price differences. To this end, Ricardo discusses the effects of the flow of specie resulting from the discovery of a new production process of wine in England, so that “it should become her interest rather to grow it than import it” (Ricardo [Reference Ricardo and Sraffa1817] 2004, p. 137). England would stop importing wine, while Portugal would still import cloths. Instead of wine, however, Portugal will export gold to England to pay for the cloths. Relying on a form of the quantity theory of money, Ricardo argues that the price level in England rises and the price level in Portugal falls, until both countries have balanced trade again. Or—another possibility Ricardo considers—if international specie flows lead to similar domestic prices that do not allow for a profitable export of either commodity, trade ceases and “both countries [find] it their interest to make their own wine and their own cloth” (Ricardo [Reference Ricardo and Sraffa1817] 2004, p. 140). Although specie flows do not affect the quantity of labor needed to produce a commodity, they change the value of money and thus the (money) price of commodities in both countries. In this way, Ricardo shows how the actions of individual consumers and merchants lead to the situation he had illustrated with his famous example, in which both countries gain from trade.
The authors of the edited volume agree that most modern presentations of Ricardo’s theory are misleading. Especially his example of England and Portugal including the “four magic numbers” is misinterpreted, by using unit labor costs or units produced per time and by a comparison of a situation of autarky with one of trade. This is discussed by several contributions. There is also agreement that James Mill and his son John Stuart Mill, who are the subject of quite a few articles, were the first to misinterpret Ricardo, laying the groundwork for later misrepresentations of Ricardo’s theory—something that has been discussed in some detail in the existing literature. Fortunately, the monetary side of Ricardo’s theory, which is often neglected, is also the focus of several articles. Besides these topics, Ricardo’s theory is compared with the work of contemporaries such as Thomas Robert Malthus, John Ramsay McCulloch, Henry Thornton, and of course Robert Torrens, whose role in the development of the theory of comparative advantage has led to some discussion among scholars, a discussion Andrea Maneschi addresses in his article. Additionally, there are rational reconstructions of Ricardo. Neri Slavadori and Rodolfo Signorino use a Kaldorian framework to graphically reconstruct Ricardo’s theory, and Yoshinori Shiozawa tries to derive a new theory of international values based on Ricardo.
As I have already alluded to, there are many overlaps between the contributions, and a reader will stumble across the same quotation of Ricardo, but also of John Stuart Mill, quite a few times. These repetitions make reading all articles at a stretch a bit tedious. I would have wished for less repetitions and a greater variety of topics instead; the lack of variety is paralleled by the absence of women authors. The last article of the volume, by Masaharu Hattori, is refreshing, because it introduces an entirely new topic: Ricardo’s role in the Committee on Agricultural Distress of 1821, of which he was a member (a fact surprisingly hidden in an endnote of this article). Hattori discusses Ricardo’s writings of that time, his address to Parliament, and his correspondence against the background of the debates related to the committee. Unfortunately, the article loses its focus a bit by going beyond this time to depict the discussion in the late 1820s when Ricardo was already dead, and in the end, it remains unclear what role Ricardo played exactly in the committee and the revision of the Corn Laws in 1822, which at least partly resulted from the committee’s work.
Nonetheless, I would have wished for more similar articles that shed light on less-explored aspects of Ricardo, such as his politics and how it was influenced by his economic theory. Regrettably absent altogether is a historical contextualization of Ricardo’s work on trade, as has been done recently, for example, by Matthew Watson (Reference Watson2017), who puts the cloth–wine trade between England and Portugal in its historical context—a trade that was at least partly established and enforced by the Methuen Treaty. It is surprising that the Methuen Treaty is mentioned only once in an endnote in the whole edited volume, although Ricardo’s example of trade between Portugal and England is widely discussed. In contrast to Adam Smith, who cites the whole treaty in his Wealth of Nations to argue against the disguised protectionism of such trade treaties, Ricardo himself does not refer to the Methuen Treaty. However, the audience for which Ricardo was writing was likely to recognize the trade Ricardo used to illustrate his theory and they might also have been familiar with what Smith wrote about this trade.
A narrow focus provides, however, the opportunity to have an interesting discussion among scholars. Alas, this opportunity is missed. Although there are many overlaps between the articles, the authors do not engage much with each other—even though most papers were, according to the introduction, presented at two conferences and thus the authors must have been aware of the other papers. And there are apparent disagreements among the authors. For example, Jérôme de Boyer des Roches argues that the mechanism Ricardo relies on to describe international specie flows is not the price-specie flow, but the competing gold points mechanism developed by Henry Thornton. According to de Boyer des Roches, Ricardo had opposed Thornton’s gold points mechanism in his early works, but changed his mind by the time he penned his Principles. However, in the previous chapter, Gilbert Faccarello claimed that Ricardo used “a Humean-like specie-flow mechanism” (p. 105) in his Principles. And two chapters later, Shigehiro Naruse combines Ricardo’s early writings on international flow of specie with his Principles in order to understand Ricardo’s theory of comparative advantage, implying a consistency of Ricardo’s early and late thoughts, which de Boyer des Roches refutes. In this instance, as in others, there is apparent disagreement among the authors, but there is no discussion of the arguments made by other contributors, from which, I think, the edited volume could have greatly benefited.
A last point I want to mention is that the press seems to have been rather thrifty with copy-editing, both regarding typos as well as a consistent form, culminating in the index entry “Hume, Davie.” All my rather critical words should not diminish the value of the single contributions, and a reader who wants to have an overview of the current scholarship on Ricardo’s theory of international trade is well advised to read at least some of the articles. However, the repetitions among the articles imply a diminishing return of new insights gained by reading a further contribution.
