In the middle of this meticulous history of the diamond industry's emergence in World War II-era Palestine, David De Vries memorably relates one of its Jewish workforce's greatest anxieties. The cutters and polishers who handled the small gemstones feared that they might drop them on the factory floor and then be unable to find them. Losing the stones often forced the employees into debt, especially if they were apprentices. Imagining skilled laborers scouring the shop floor on hands and knees, desperately searching out the gleaming twinkle of the most precious stone in the world—all so that they could avoid the debt burden of recompensing the factory owner—might remind one momentarily of a scene out of a John Steinbeck novel. Indeed, the diamond workers, who became a strident source of Jewish labor militancy, railed hyperbolically against the “feudal” terms of their employment, even comparing it to “slavery” (p. 145). Stressful as their days were, however, diamond workers were the labor aristocracy of Palestine. Reliant on the brutal colonial exploitation of miners in the Belgian Congo and elsewhere that made their trade possible (noted here without much comment), they earned wages on average 50 percent higher than fellow Jewish industrial workers and over 250 percent above Arab industrial workers (p. 82). Moreover, in keeping with the ethnic enclave culture of diamond work in the Low Countries on which it drew, the British made sure that this highly profitable industry was the preserve of Jews alone in Palestine, thereby affording the Yishuv's diamond workers great economic opportunities disallowed to the indigenous Palestinians.
The story of the diamond industry's remarkable and tumultuous rise in Palestine in the 1940s is richly told in this volume. While most of the literature on diamonds has focused on miners, finance and mining firms, merchants and trading companies, and, of course, the symbolism and consumption of diamonds as luxury commodities, De Vries examines the neglected social history of diamond cutting and polishing. He also seeks to contribute to a number of other fields, including historiographies on the Palestine Mandate and the Yishuv and the analysis of relations between state, capital, and labor in Zionist history. While industry-specific studies like Diamonds and War are a rarity within the corpus of work on the Yishuv, De Vries sets his sights not only on tracing the development of the diamond sector, but also rather pointedly on emphasizing the central role of British authorities in creating and protecting it.
Previous works on capital and labor in Jewish Palestine have tended to elaborate the now familiar story of Labor Zionism's compact with economic liberalism in the 1930s, whereby the former clinched its political preeminence within the movement while muting its socialist leanings. Reflecting on the erasure of the colonial state within this narrative framework, De Vries argues that the highly articulated apparatus of Mandate-era Zionist institutions has acted, through a kind of rearward projection, as a stand-in for the subsequent state of Israel, which is presumed in this view to be the relevant baseline for analysis (p. 10). Here De Vries is too cautious in leveling his critique. The occlusion of the colonial state is a problem within the literature on the Yishuv because Zionist discourse and mythology have long erroneously claimed that the establishment of Israel was solely the fruit of Jewish hands, and that it was erected in spite of, and not with the help of, the British. Nevertheless, he suggests that recently the place of the colonial state in Zionist history, particularly in the economic realm, has begun to be more openly and fully explored. Mustering a plethora of archival materials from Israel, the United Kingdom, the United States, and The Netherlands, as well as other sources, Diamonds and War amply and persuasively contributes to this body of work.
The diamond cutting and polishing business arrived in Palestine as a result of the Nazi occupation of the Low Countries. As the war engulfed key production centers in Antwerp and Amsterdam, Britain, the De Beers mining cartel, and Belgian exiles close to the industry steered the flow of diamonds away from Nazi-occupied Europe. While Britain was concerned to keep industrial-grade diamonds from aiding the German war effort, it also saw in the diamond business a ready source for acquiring the U.S. dollars it needed to sustain vital imports and finance the war. Officials of the Jewish Agency and Jewish entrepreneurs made the case that the Yishuv was the natural candidate to replace the Low Countries, not least because of the traditional and trusted ethno-religious basis of the industry. Much to the consternation of the Jewish Agency and its allies, the British chose Oved Ben-Ami, a liberal capitalist affiliated with the Zionist right and a newcomer to the diamond business, to manage the special wartime monopoly that was created. Palestine's industry was to be tightly controlled and its growth limited so as not to jeopardize the anticipated postwar revival of the diamond business in the Low Countries.
As the head of the Palestine Diamond Manufacturers’ Association (PDMA), the sole authorized importer of rough diamonds, Ben-Ami exercised great power over the local industry, and earned a reputation as an authoritarian and paternalistic manager. The PDMA pursued a strategy of workforce selection that was meant to preempt labor from concerted action, but the financial success of the diamond firms was too much to ignore. Diamonds became the fastest growing sector of Palestine's economy, with exports mushrooming from £P 25,000 in 1940 to £P 2.6 million in 1943. Moreover, the irregular wartime conditions conduced to impressive annual profit rates of 30–40 percent. Diamond workers responded with a succession of strikes from 1941 on that secured many gains for the workforce. Paradoxically, these same gains intensified the postwar crisis in the industry when the American market dwindled and Belgium returned to the business and underbid Palestine's firms. The contraction that followed was just as precipitous as the industry's meteoric rise, and with the additional complication of the Palestine war of 1948, the diamond business shrunk to one-fifth of its peak size. Faced with possible oblivion, the Jewish Agency and subsequently the Israeli government stepped in to bail out the beleaguered diamantaires and rescue the diamond sector. As De Vries underscores, the heritage of colonial state intervention during the war years greatly informed the views of its successor, which exhibited significant openness toward the role of private capital in society, in contrast to its Labor Zionist forebears’ skepticism and combativeness.
Diamonds and War convincingly shows that the partnership between diamond entrepreneurs and British rule “contributed to the economic buildup of the Yishuv and its increasingly advantageous position vis-à-vis the Arab economy” (p. 180). Ironically, however, it fails to narrate and take seriously the exclusion of the Arabs from the enterprise. This critical subject does not receive any substantive discussion, leaving the reader without a clear explanation of why the majority population was barred from the industry. A second, interrelated problem with the text concerns its almost single-minded focus on the war years and after. De Vries, whose narrative is ultimately framed foremost by studies of the Yishuv, concludes that the colonial state's shepherding of the diamond industry represented a “novel interventionist approach” to economic development that also aided Zionism (p. 41). While there were novel aspects to this episode of state intervention, British authorities tipping the economic scales in Zionism's favor was hardly one of them. Missing from the picture this study provides is a more penetrating sense of prewar British economic policy. For instance, Barbara Smith's The Roots of Separatism in Palestine (1993), which De Vries cites, compellingly catalogues and analyzes myriad policies in the 1920s that conferred economic privileges and advantages on the Yishuv. By drawing too firm a separation between the prewar period and the 1940s, Diamonds and War skates past and obscures important continuities in patterns of imperial governance, including the tendency to favor and promote the economic interests of the Yishuv over the Arabs. It is thus an unfortunate oversight that this valuable study, which breaks new ground with regard to our understanding of both the Yishuv and the Mandate, does not engage in greater dialogue with prior scholarly literature that has adduced similar overarching findings.
