At the dawn of the twentieth century, home economics emerged as a new field in education and social reform. Because home economists had much success as agents in the public sector, their value was quickly recognized by the private sector, too, and they were able to establish a presence in business.
The movement, which first centered in new academic departments in American universities, was educative at its heart, not just advocating classes, bulletins, and community outreach addressing science in the home, but also insisting that ordinary women and men adopt an investigative perspective towards everyday life. In pursuit of this goal, home economists worked in many social institutions, including schools, hospitals, state and national government agencies, and private enterprise.
Carolyn Goldstein's welcome new history of home economics, Creating Consumers, focusses attention on workers in the last two categories. She identifies business home economists as “mediators,” who served to interpret government and corporate interests to the consumer and the consumer to businesses and government agencies. In this dual role, Goldstein writes, they “facilitated exchange of information in multiple directions, not only from corporate organizations to consumers but also among manufacturers, power companies, government agencies, voluntary associations, women's organizations, and consumers themselves – a wide array of individuals, groups, and institutions” (11).
In doing this work, Goldstein argues, they helped to construct the consumer as well as to mediate between consumer and producer. In opposition to the contemporary stereotype of the “irrational female consumer,” home economists constructed an ideal of rational consumption which required individuals to assume and acknowledge the active status in relation to markets that cultural historians have found they in fact experience (39).
Goldstein's work is exhaustively researched in the archives of the Bureau of Home Economics, of the Journal of Home Economics and of the professional organization, Home Economists in Business, and in such trade journals as Electrical Merchandising and Textile World. By tracing separately the two tracks that home economists followed as mediators between producers and consumers – the government track and the business track – Goldstein is able to provide an important insight into how home economists functioned as professionals rather than as educators.
Much attention has been paid to the history of advertising and marketing, but Goldstein persuasively argues that home economists also played an important role in defining the average consumer in the formative period between the beginning of the twentieth century and the end of the Second World War. Home economists participated in defining the consumer to producers but also to herself, positing an identity that did not blindly serve the needs of the corporate producer.
Goldstein's most important contribution to the field of the history of home economics is in the three chapters that focus on home economists in private industry. Within the field there has been much less attention paid to this important cohort than to home economists in education and governmental work. Perhaps this has been because their enterprise seems less purely altruistic. This last possibility, of course, is what makes them so interesting. As evidence of the complexity of their position, Goldstein uncovers the fascinating “Experiment 63,” a satiric sketch written by members of the professional organization, Home Economists in Business, in 1936. “Experiment 63” was devised to give college home economics majors a glimpse of a day in the life of a typical home economist in business. In this case, the main character, Miss Welldone, an employee of the Bigger and Batter Advertising Agency, was assigned to the Bingo Beans account. Goldstein's thoughtful analysis of the skit finds that it “portrays home economists as diligent, proud, and loyal employees who work hard to serve their employers while helping to create and market high-quality products and services for consumers.” It also “suggests that business home economists worked in a world full of tensions,” as Miss Welldone has to create multiple appetizing recipes that all use beans while fending off an aggressive public-safety advocate and giving uncompensated health advice to a male colleague as well as casually pitching a new “million dollar scheme” to the corporate chief (136–37).
The tension inherent in representing both producer and consumer simultaneously, Goldstein argues, was only partly resolved in business home economists' “faith in ‘progressive’ big business, as well as their belief that they had something at stake in the process of producing” goods that were good for the public and in encouraging consumers to take an active role in their relationship with producers (173).
In the postwar marketplace, particularly by the 1960s, Goldstein argues that corporations had supplanted much of the work home economists had previously done by assigning research and dissemination work to marketing and advertising firms which were almost exclusively staffed with men. In addition, in a cultural shift, “the rise of the new paradigm of market segmentation created a context in which home economists' claims to represent ‘the woman's viewpoint’ lost much of their significance.” By the 1970s, Goldstein finds, “it proved untenable” for business home economists to maintain their professional use to corporations and they “witnessed a further erosion of their professional identity” (281).
