In 1870, fewer than 9,000 African Americans lived in the upper midwestern states of Iowa, Wisconsin, and Minnesota. Leslie Schwalm's new book explores the meaning of emancipation to this relatively small group of people. However, this is no parochial study. Emancipation's Diaspora is ambitious and rewarding, making tangible the personal and political impact of slavery beyond the South and beyond 1865.
Schwalm's first four chapters address the experience of race in the Upper Midwest before the end of the Civil War. She draws on an impressive array of newspaper evidence, court records, and archival sources with all the care she demonstrated in her first book on African American women in Civil War Era South Carolina.Footnote 1 Although slavery was formally prohibited throughout the Northwest Territory, sojourning masters brought enslaved men and women into the region well into the nineteenth century. Moreover, manumitted individuals worked for their former owners under apparently coercive conditions. Given this context, Schwalm argues that state black laws “were not a replacement for slavery but rather expressions of the same ambition to exploit, coerce, and dehumanize people of African American descent” (27). Thousands of black men and women challenged midwestern law and practice when they traveled north during the war. Schwalm documents how former slaves grasped at migration—so often forced on them before—as a tool of liberation. By shifting their physical “location,” she maintains, African Americans unleashed white northerners' anxieties over their social “place” (83).
Scholars of the late nineteenth century should not ignore the opening chapters of Emancipation's Diaspora. Schwalm insists that slavery must anchor historians' understanding of Reconstruction. Her redefinition of the Upper Midwest as a region vindicates this approach. Schwalm follows women who fled slavery in Missouri and congregated at the contraband camp at Cairo, Illinois. She introduces freedmen who gathered at Keokuk, Iowa to serve in the 60th United States Colored Infantry and spent a miserable sixteen months occupying Helena, Arkansas. The Mississippi River facilitated emancipation's diaspora, ensuring that the Midwest was not a backwater isolated from slavery.
Readers of this journal will be more interested in the two chapters Schwalm devotes to how black Iowans, Minnesotans, and Wisconsinites built communities and claimed citizenship after the war. Although other historians have studied northern states during Reconstruction, none begins with the insight that they too faced emancipation.Footnote 2 Characteristically attuned to gender, Schwalm gives women a primary place. Within the African Methodist Episcopal Church, for example, they raised funds and founded parishes alongside men, despite their exclusion from the pulpit. A few cases of female congregants accusing churchmen of sexual misconduct suggest that some women resented the double standard of the church's increasingly rigid Victorian gender norms. Meanwhile, African American men “articulated and performed a new black manhood that was increasingly predicated on citizenship and equality among men” (164). Among other things, they organized fraternal organizations. By 1872, Prince Hall Masonry had created networks of mutual support and empowered men to claim public space in dramatic fashion when they appeared in ceremonial regalia. Masonry also became a site of black challenges to white exclusion. In 1870, the white Grand Lodges of Iowa and Ohio lifted bans on black membership, but individual lodges continued to exclude African Americans.
However skillfully Schwalm portrays African American striving, her treatment of the postwar period does not have the force of earlier chapters. Institutional archives seem not to yield the intimacy of her wartime sources, and Schwalm's narrative can be predictable. African Americans doggedly challenged white racism, winning grudging legal concessions but failing to dislodge discrimination. Schwalm minimizes white support for black citizenship, although she acknowledges that courts and legislatures in Iowa, Wisconsin, and Minnesota upheld educational rights, and black men secured the franchise in these states before the ratification of the Fifteenth Amendment in 1870. One need not accept white midwesterners' self-satisfied “fiction” that they supported African Americans to explore its utility. In choosing to portray the glass of racial justice as half empty, Schwalm misses the opportunity to tease out the nuances of northern whites' attitudes toward Reconstruction, a historiograpical challenge of enduring significance.
The final chapter of Emancipation's Diaspora reaffirms the value of focusing on the African American experience. Emancipation Day celebrations, pension claims, and obituaries testify that black midwesterners resisted the sentimentalized memory of slavery that prevailed during the late nineteenth century. In their memoirs, former slaves Moses Mosely and Samuel Hall rejected the notion that slavery had been a benign institution or that its end had brought African Americans full citizenship. Slavery was, Schwalm proposes, their “ground zero” (263). African Americans rallied around its painful memory to steel themselves for further struggle.
Schwalm calls for the re-centering of American history around slavery. Of course, scholars of sectional reconciliation, work, and race in the Gilded Age North have hardly ignored the institution. Works by David Blight and Amy Dru Stanley come to mind, as well as the corpus inspired by David Reodiger's Wages of Whiteness.Footnote 3 The contribution of Emancipation's Diaspora is, however, distinct. Schwalm achieves a geographical and chronological reorientation through her remarkable rendering of the grief, joys, and longings of ordinary people.
