In The Arab Uprisings Explained, a group of leading—almost exclusively American—Middle East political scientists examine the crucial political changes and continuities in the region from late 2010 to 2013. The edited volume's ambition is high: beyond a mere mapping of the trajectories of Tunisia, Egypt, Bahrain, Syria, or Yemen, for example, it aims to explain the “speed and magnitude of mobilization across multiple countries and the divergent political outcomes” (p. 4; italics in the original). Marc Lynch builds his all-encompassing, well-written introduction around the differentiation of the Arab Uprisings’ three phases of initial mass mobilization, regime responses, and preliminary political outcomes. While this ideal–typical differentiation of the sequencing of the Arab Uprisings makes intuitive sense, many of the later chapters unfortunately do not easily relate to it—an almost classical shortcoming of edited volumes covering a broad thematic field. Following Lynch's introduction, Daniel Brumberg engages with different theories of transition that have been prominent in the comparative politics of the Middle East over the past decades. Brumberg critiques both the democratization-oriented studies of the 1990s and the “post-transitions literature” (p. 31) of the 2000s, in part for neglecting the importance of identity conflicts and their manipulation by a multiplicity of political actors.
The remaining fourteen chapters are divided into three thematic parts. Part 1 is entitled Regional and Cross-National Dimensions and encompasses four chapters. In “Diffusion and Demonstration,” David Patel, Valerie Bunce, and Sharon Wolchik show that protest practices such as mass sit-ins in central squares diffused from Cairo to Manama, Darʿa, Homs, and Sanaʿa. The authors contrast these dynamics in Arab countries with similar ones in Eastern Europe post-1989 and during the “Color Revolutions” from 2000 to 2005, emphasizing that the Arab Uprisings should be understood as a cross-national, regional wave of contention. Similarly innovative, Steven Heydemann and Reinoud Leenders study the learning and adaptation of different Arab authoritarian regimes. They convincingly argue that the Syrian regime drew important lessons from the failed counterinsurgency in Libya that informed its massively repressive strategy against the mass social uprising at home. Marc Lynch then discusses the role of old and new media in 2011 and after. He holds that while the Arab Uprisings took place in an Arab public sphere with an unprecedented shared media space, the use of new social media such as Facebook, SMS, or Twitter by activist youth did not replace—at least in the short to medium term—the societally more established and better organized opposition movements, such as the Islamists. Finally, Curtis Ryan examines the regional system in the Middle East. He couches the most important post-2011 shifts in regional politics—Egypt's decline, Syria's drastic transformation from prominent actor to central arena, the increased isolation of Iran, Israel, and Turkey, as well as the growing assertiveness of Saudi Arabia—in a broad historical overview, drawing interesting connections to the dynamics of the regional system in the 1950s/1960s and the 2000s.
Part 2 is entitled Key Actors. It includes well-informed studies on the three “usual suspects” of Arab militaries (Robert Springborg), Islamist movements (Quinn Mecham) and the role of elections (Ellen Lust) in the context of the Arab Uprisings. In particular, Ellen Lust's contribution stands out here for its region-wide, systematic analysis of the effects of elections on political stability and transformation. Part 2's added value lies in the inclusion of three often forgotten actor groups, namely, bankers (Clement M. Henry), labor movements, and organizations (Vickie Langohr), as well as the interaction of protestors and regime security agencies and the former's innovative use of space (Jillian Schwedler and Ryan King).
Part 3 addresses different dimensions of “Public Opinion.” In “Political System Preferences of Arab Publics,” Mark Tessler and Michael Robbins use the Arab Barometer public opinion surveys to illustrate that the majority of citizens in ten Arab countries favor both democracy and a separation of religion and politics. The value of the study is undermined, however, by the lacking comparability across cases: whereas some surveys were conducted before the beginning of the Arab Uprisings (e.g., in Bahrain, Jordan, Palestine), the ones in Egypt and Tunisia took place months after the respective regime changes occurred (cf. table 13.2 on p. 258). Michael Hoffmann and Amaney Jamal also draw on the Arab Barometer data, but focus more narrowly on the youth. Somewhat counterintuitively, they find that youth mobilization during the Arab Uprisings might have been caused primarily by perceived future opportunities rather than by grievances with the regimes (p. 291). Then, Nathan Brown uses the case of Egypt to engage with Timur Kuran's prominent “preference falsification” thesis. The author shows that contrary to Kuran's assumption, most Egyptians’ open criticism of President Mubarak was actually known, but their likely actions that would stem from this were not. Brown also stresses that constitutional demands figured very prominently in Egypt, quite contrary to a number of other Arab Uprisings countries. In the conclusion to the volume, Marc Lynch brings together the insights of the single chapters with a view on the preliminary outcomes of regime change (Tunisia, Egypt 2011–13), the transition of mass protest into protracted violence and war (especially Libya, Syria, and Yemen) as well as the restauration of authoritarianism (Egypt post-2013 and all eight Arab monarchies). He holds that contrary to some of the wide-ranging criticisms from either Middle East studies scholars or media pundits, the political science of the Middle East had actually grasped and addressed most of the dynamics that have come to the fore since late 2010 (pp. 313ff).
In sum, The Arab Uprisings Explained is one of the best contributions on the contemporary politics in the Arab Middle East, especially for the early period of mass mobilization and regime responses in 2011–13. It stands out in two important ways: first, it highlights new political dynamics such as cross-national protest diffusion or authoritarian regime learning that have been crucial in explaining the different political trajectories across the region and that have not been so thoroughly addressed; second, more than almost all extant studies of the Arab Uprisings, this volume explicitly tries to connect with disciplinary debates in mainstream political science. A number of chapters draw on a generalist theoretical vocabulary and adapt it to contexts in the Arab Middle East (e.g., Brumberg's critique of transitology, Brown's engagement with “preference falsification”) or they engage in systematic intraregional and especially cross-regional comparisons (e.g., Patel, Bunce, and Wolchik or Langohr), underlining a kind of comparative area studies perspective that combines the detailed knowledge of the cases with an attempt to systematically compare and, on this basis, to generalize. The strong orientation to speak to a political science audience beyond Middle East studies comes with a prize, however: Arabic sources have only been used in two of the fifteen substantial chapters (Heydemann and Leenders draw on Syrian proregime dailies, Langohr on documents by the Union Générale Tunisienne du Travail and Egyptian Trade Union Federation—and here only in passing). While one need not fetishize the use of primary sources, the next phase of post-Arab Uprisings studies should arguably engage even more with the multiple political perspectives in the Middle East in order to come to better conclusions about the longer term dynamics of contentious politics and regime trajectories.
