Gargantuan in size and ambition, with contributions from twenty-nine different scholars, Early Modern Theatricality paints a vivid picture of the present state of the field and offers compelling evidence of its future vitality. The book's energy is astounding. Taken together, the essays offer an array of approaches to some of the thorniest questions raised by the study of early modern drama, and of theatre in general: How do theatre and theatricality differ from other kinds of cultural performance? Who are the agents of theatrical production, and how does dramatic meaning get made? How can we talk about those aspects of performance that, by and large, pass unrecorded in print (i.e., gesture, silence, physicality)?
The collection's answers to these questions are too numerous, and its interests too wide-ranging, to constitute a coherent project or program, but in this sense, too, it could be said to mirror the field. As editor Henry S. Turner puts it, the study of early modern drama as something performed, rather than as something printed, is currently experiencing an “omnivorous profusion” of (admittedly, still largely historicist) critical interests (2). Most of the essays in this collection are historicist in bent, though they also draw on performance studies, and many point out the need to move beyond the limits of both. This entails paying more attention to the distinctiveness of theatrical form on the one hand, and, on the other, resisting the recent critical tendency to overextend the category of “performance” until it is all but emptied out of meaning.
The book's design invites sampling. Each contributor has chosen a key word through which to explore early modern theatricality as he or she understands it (to name a few: “Lines,” “Source,” “Games,” “Mobility”). Many of the essays are clearly taken from larger projects, and most are conciliatory toward the critical traditions in which they intervene, but there are also a few swashbucklers: of the latter, my favorite is Paul Menzer's, which rails against the tyranny of the line and calls on us to understand theatricality “not as a harmony of print and performance but a balance of spatial and durational phenomena” (132). It is not always clear how, exactly, we are to put some of the proposed methodological shifts into practice, but that is almost beside the point. The book is intended to “capture the energy” of the present critical moment, and (as Menzer's essay makes explicit, and many others imply) to offer a performance-oriented answer to recent work on printed drama by laying the groundwork for “theoretical and methodological innovation of the type that has characterized the study of . . . the history of the book” (Turner, 3).
Collectively, the essays point several possible ways forward. Many are interested in form, variously defined: for example, in how dramatic genre, plot structure, and character were shaped by the architecture of the theatres themselves (Richard Preiss), or by the performance practices that took shape within them. Others track how specific dramatic tropes (the “micro-forms” [460] of poverty, in Robert Henke's case) moved between different texts, or across cultures and performance traditions (Susanne L. Wofford, Anston Bosman). Paul A. Kottman's “Duel” compares Hobbes and Hegel's “philosophical dramaturgy” (in which the life-and-death struggle is the “dramatic predicament” [410] out of which life, as something valued, emerges) to Shakespeare's socially embedded “theatrical dramaturgy” (421), an argument rooted in formal specificity. William N. West's excellent “Intertheatricality” asks us to think not about “plays,” but about “playing” (156): he encourages critics to read “horizontally” (154), looking for references that “thicken” (155) across the “network of theatre” (156).
West's essay (for me, the best in the book) is one of several to consider the audience's part in the production of theatrical meaning. Many, but not all, of these audience-oriented essays are phenomenological in their approach. Gina Bloom's “Games” and Erika T. Lin's “Festivity” consider how early modern audiences acquired various “competencies” (191) as commercial theatregoers, while Ellen MacKay finds in onstage female audiences' seeming incompetence a model of theatricality as robustly, enthusiastically involved rather than decorously divided from the action. Evelyn Tribble's “‘ecological’ model of theatrical skill” (177) would consider audiences' familiarity with feats of athleticism (fencing, dancing) incorporated into the stage action, while Michael Witmore's “Eventuality” (a term he uses to describe a moment in a performance, whether scripted or accidental, that does not seem to follow by necessity on what has come before) points out “the reflexive capacity of spectators to ‘jointly sense’ what might have been otherwise” (400). Bruce R. Smith, who introduced the concept of historical phenomenology to the study of early modern drama, argues for the critical utility of a “phenomenology of ‘scene’” (111)—a surprisingly multivalent early modern term that seems to be all but made for the present critical moment.
What is missing from the collection, and is perhaps conspicuous in its absence, is any sustained attention to the author. (An exception is Madhavi Menon's “Desire,” which argues for a specifically “Shakespearean theatricality” more attentive to the nonmaterial, absent body's role in the production of desire than that of any of his contemporaries [343]—a claim I find intriguing, if not wholly convincing.) This is a deliberate choice, and one that makes sense, given how long author-centered approaches dominated the study of the period's literature. But surely the dramatist, along with the audience, the players, the space of the stage, and the growing body of theatrical material out of which an early modern dramatic tradition was taking shape, participates in the making of dramatic meaning. It should be possible to consider authors as agents without according them too much authority.
This is less a complaint about the book than it is an observation about where we are, and about where the study of early modern drama might be headed. Early Modern Theatricality invites such musings, both in its scope and in its electrifying energy. For this reason, especially, it is an indispensable contribution to the study of early modern drama.
