Gabriela Fried Amilivia's accomplished work is an invaluable contribution to the modest, yet growing, body of literature to focus exclusively on the evolution of memory in post-dictatorship Uruguay, which has tended to occupy a secondary role in both theoretical and critical debates to its larger neighbour across the Río de la Plata. This study therefore gives the flurry of activity and interest in commemoration since the mid-1990s in Uruguay the nuanced attention it duly deserves, taking its place alongside Eugenia Allier Montaño's work on sites and practices of memory, Francesca Lessa's seminal study of transitional memory and justice and Mariana Achugar's coverage of memory and subjectivity beyond ‘the usual suspects’ to incorporate the Uruguayan military. Adopting an ethnographic approach to the intergenerational transmission of trauma in families of those affected by state terrorism, Fried responds to the regional and domestic upsurge in memorialisation, whilst illustrating the laborious and complex struggles precipitated by the continuing return to violent pasts more than thirty years after the dictatorship ended.
Although there are a number of contributions on generational transmission of memory in Uruguay, most notably by Cara Levey and Ana Ros, Fried's work differs in a number of ways: first, the highly personal approach, grounded in sociology, psychology and cultural theory, which illuminates the perspectives and experiences of those affected by dictatorial rule; second, the comparative approach to memory across different generations straddling both dictatorship and post-dictatorship periods. Indeed Fried considers those born in the 1920s–1950s – the protagonists of the dictatorship period – alongside the voices of those born during the 1960s and 1970s – those belonging to what Ros calls the post-dictatorship generation. What emerges is an intensely rich and moving study of memory, arguably a reflection of the blending of Fried's personal and professional positions as a member of the latter generation and a scholar and active contributor to academic debates.
The book's introduction opens with a powerful quote from Uruguayan writer and playwright Carlos Liscano. Moreover, the excerpt serves as a warning that silence and oblivion are also forms of memory that continue to permeate the present, justifying Fried's nuanced approach to the transmission of memory as one necessitating discussion of the lapses and silences as much as utterances and explicit references to the past. This is immediately followed up with the first of Fried's many lengthy interviews, this one with Ester, who was a child when her parents were ‘disappeared’. Recounting this childhood experience as an adult, her words serve as a reminder of the intensely personal nature of memory and its persistence long after the temporal parameters of dictatorship as well as the distinct ways in which children and adults process traumatic events. Soon, Fried's voice follows, framing Ester's words within the wider political and cultural silencing and impunity characteristic of post-dictatorship Uruguay. Employing the term ‘waves of memory’, she reads these personal accounts against these various shifts in public memory over time.
This approach is sustained throughout the book and further considered in Chapter 1, where the author sets out the concept of ‘intersubjective’ spaces that are located within the interstices of private and public interactions and are examined in order to trace the transmission of memory both intergenerationally and intragenerationally. In contrast to other studies that tend to look at memory as articulated through territorial sites (Achugar; Levey) or in published works (Ros), Fried's focus on the intersubjective permits insight into that which is not necessarily public or private memory before it intrudes on the public sphere. She sensibly views memory as a two-part process, encompassing its transmission from the protagonists or witnesses (through explicit practices such as storytelling and confessions to more oblique practices such as naming) to its receivership by subsequent generations. What is remembered and digested by the latter is thus quite distinct from what the former might transmit to them. This process is not necessarily a smooth or harmonious one. As Fried points out, such memory, intimately connected to trauma, can become an anchor instead of a compass; rather than allowing society to move forward, we may be dragged back to the past.
Indeed, as Chapter 2 suggests in its discussion of social frameworks of memory, the specific trajectory of the Uruguayan transition from dictatorship to democracy – as well as the totalitarian nature of dictatorial rule in Uruguay – shaped the evolution of such traumatic memories, leading to a silencing or relegation of memories to the private sphere. The Uruguayan post-dictatorship is thus instructive for other tightly controlled democratic transitions (such as Brazil, Chile and Spain). However, Fried avoids detailed historical narrative of the dictatorship and its aftermath, but traces the ‘waves of memory’ within which her primary and theoretical research is framed, in order to show the highly unstable backdrops of memory and justice in post-dictatorship Uruguay.
The following two chapters turn to a body of rich ethnographic and testimonial analysis, showcasing exhaustive interviews with a range of participants across generations. Chapter 3 focuses on the multiple ways in which relatives of Uruguay's desaparecidos (the disappeared), often the ones who assumed responsibility for the latter's children, transmitted aspects of the past to these children. The chapter places voices from different generations in relation to one another as each struggles to cope with the long-lasting impact of disappearance and lack of closure surrounding it. In contrast, Chapter 4 considers the survivors as those who lived to tell the tale but were profoundly affected by torture and prolonged incarceration. Here, their strategies for survival and resistance – both while imprisoned and upon release – are juxtaposed with insight into the information their children received and processed about the past, and their own attempts to spare their parents traumatic re-encounter with the past. Together, the two chapters point to a complex constellation of experiences and mechanisms to transmit and process the past: encompassing cases in which children of political prisoners and desaparecidos were told the truth, others in which there was only partial disclosure and others in which deceit and denial surrounded disappearance. Fried deftly places the lapses, silences and omissions within broader top-down reconciliation and silencing, showing how the stigmatisation of political activism inhibited the public articulation of such experiences, features of the Uruguayan post-dictatorship context that have changed in recent years.
Indeed, the final chapter, aptly titled ‘Unsealing the Wounds’, returns to the socio-political framing of personal narratives, to place them within the recent shift in public memory politics in Uruguay and the landmark breakthroughs in truth and justice since 2005, highlighting key junctures such as the 2009 referendum to annul Uruguay's amnesty law and election of political actors more favourable to addressing the past. Pointing out that impunity and societal forgetting have lingered in Uruguay three decades after the end of dictatorial rule, Fried ends on an optimistic note, indicating that the will to remember lives on in subsequent generations.
