Scholars of tourism face a particular quandary: on the one hand they often feel a need to make a case that tourism should be taken seriously. This is perhaps easy when dealing with Jamaica or other tourism-dependent countries, but more difficult in nations that possess more diverse economies. Why shouldn't tourism deserve the same academic attention as sectors such as oil, agriculture, mining or automobiles? Done well, industry studies frequently tell us not only about the trajectory of a leading sector, but also about larger questions dealing with the state, class politics or development trajectories. Yet, on the other hand, tourism scholars frequently argue that tourism is not simply another industry but rather a special case. Tourism is not a single industry, but instead brings together several economic activities. Moreover, tourism goes beyond the usual questions of political economy. It is also almost always geared to the global market, where additional questions range from immigration policy (who requires a visa and who doesn't) to the overall image of the country that tourism officials, public as well as private, attempt to project abroad. In this sense tourism involves a conscious, deliberate message to the world involving national identity.
Dina Berger wades artfully into this realm in her brief historical account of the development of tourism promotion in Mexico in the early post-Revolutionary period. She convincingly embeds tourism into the larger political economy during the 1930s, a period of consolidation for the post-revolutionary Mexican state as well one of economic fits and starts. For tourism scholars of Mexico, Berger's position is revisionist. Most date the early tourism push, that ultimately led to Mexico's current status as the seventh busiest tourism destination in the world, to the presidency of Miguel Alemán (1946–52), the so-called ‘father of Mexican tourism.’ Not so, argues Berger, who points to interest in promoting tourism by both state and private sector actors as early as 1928, going through the Maximato and continuing through the nationalist presidency of Lázaro Cárdenas (1934–40).
Berger's meticulous research through government archival documents, speeches, letters and newspaper articles, demonstrates that indeed tourism was on the radar for state and private sector actors during this period. Two additional factors become apparent: first tourism was promoted primarily abroad, almost exclusively to the US market. Not only was domestic demand underdeveloped at this point; promotion abroad also reflected a need for foreign exchange. Second, the vast amount of both spending and promotion for tourism was aimed at the automobile market. Most early spending (which was actually quite small) went to infrastructure, primarily road building that would better connect the USA and Mexico, along with promoting services for automobile travellers.
Berger also shows how state and mixed public-private agencies and committees originated and progressed in fits and starts. A Pro-Tourism Commission (CPT) and successor Mixed Pro-Tourism Commission (CMPT) were formed as early as 1929. These commissions brought together state agencies that governed various aspects of tourism (customs, health) along with nascent business interests. In addition, the Banco de México, Mexico's central bank, created a Department of Tourism in 1928. Perhaps more significant than the department itself, which lasted just four years, is that it signified that tourism had powerful political patrons such as Alberto Mascareñas, Director General of the Bank, as well as a later director general, Luis Montes de Oca. The latter would become an indispensable booster for tourism to the country through his travels to New York, where he was connected to US banking and travel interests, as well as his government service at the central bank (1935–40) and as finance minister (1927–32). They and other leading government and private sector figures would be prominent in the formation of the Mexican Tourist Association. Pro-tourism Mexicans were joined in by US promoters (such as William Furlong), many of whom joined Mexican tourism boosters in forming the Mexican Automobile Association. Together they would press for infrastructure projects at home while providing the advertising and promotion as well as planning services that today is served by national tourist offices abroad, especially in the USA. Most significant, Berger argues, were the joint efforts of these players to change the image of Mexico from one of danger and barbarism, which prevailed in many Americans' minds at the time, to that of a modern, safe, welcoming nation. Much of this was accomplished through marketing abroad and providing junkets for foreign journalists, but efforts also included a dinner hosted by Cárdenas at Chapultepec Castle in 1938 for foreign hoteliers (pp. 76–7).
Berger's book authoritatively fills a gap in Mexican tourism studies, as most research to date has focused on the post-war period. Although some might contend that she overstates the impact of pre-war tourism promotion; tourism arrivals increased from about 24,000 in 1930 to the still relatively small number of 165,000 in 1941. But at the very least these efforts sowed the seeds for future growth. Most agree that one of the biggest limitations to growth of the industry prior to the war was structural. Hotel capacity in particular remained very limited. Yet Berger shows that promotion and providing infrastructure led to considerable hotel planning and construction during this time. A more thorough discussion of the politics of tourism during this period would have been helpful. While Berger convincingly demonstrates that powerful forces were interested in furthering the activity, less clear is the extent to which they fought and won battles over, for example, scarce government resources.
Berger devotes the final chapter to a discussion of the relationship between marketing and national identity in a manner that reminds us that tourism, while embedded in the larger political economy of a nation, constitutes so much more. Ultimately the book will appeal to not just tourism scholars, but those interested in Mexican development and post-revolutionary history.
