The upheavals that have roiled the MENA region since December 2010 generated a plethora of studies aimed at understanding how and why Middle Eastern societies “kicked back,” seemingly suddenly, against long-entrenched authoritarian regimes. The aim of Popular Politics is broader: to write “a history of transgressive mobilization in the Middle East and North Africa,” that is, to show that the dynamics of contention between state authorities and opposition groups have been an essential feature of the history of the region for more than two centuries. Applying crisply formulated analytical concepts to seventy-five (!) different historical episodes that range from millenarian movements in Morocco and tax revolts in the Mashriq, to labor and women's movements in Egypt, to attempted coups in Saudi Arabia and Shiʿia activism in Bahrain, the author puts forth a nuanced account of popular politics that complements top-down, elite-centered histories. Its main case studies and underpinning arguments will be useful for both broad survey courses and more focused and theoretically-inclined ones, as well as for interested scholars.
The book is divided into five sections—a lengthy introduction and four well-defined historical periods—along with a conclusion that recaps the author's main points. The introductory section presents some of the competing approaches to the study of the Middle East, including Marxism and historical sociology, cultural history and gender, as well as their limitations. Following a lengthy discussion of classic social movement theory and the uses of Gramsci, the author lays out his guiding themes, which challenge the three main frameworks in which protest has been understood: (neo-) Orientalism which holds that protestors are Muslims and Arabs reacting against the West; theories of capitalism and modernization that understand protest and mobilization as an outgrowth of socio-economic change; and post-colonial theory that sees protest as an effect of colonial discursive inscription. Instead, he emphasizes: the notions of hegemonic expansion and contraction which enable, or alternatively undermine the abilities of elites to attain the required legitimacy and acceptance of their domination of societal elements; the different circumstances in which mobilizing opposition projects arise and operate; and the resulting impact, which goes far beyond a simple success or failure equation. Intellectuals, whether secular or Islamic, he emphasizes and subsequently demonstrates, play a mediating role between hegemonic contraction and the content and repertoires of the mobilizing project, helping define the meaning of hegemonic contraction and diagnosing what is to be done about it. Agency, initiative, contingency, and culture all contribute to shaping outcomes.
Part 1 of the book (“Millenarianism, Renewal, Justice, Rights and Reform, 1798–1914”) covers the long nineteenth century, during which the hegemony of the region's three main Islamic dynastic states (the Ottoman Empire, Khedival Egypt and Qajar Iran) was under threat and transformed in numerous ways, but never entirely replaced. Part two (“Patriotism, Liberalism, Armed Struggle and Ideology, 1914–1952”) addresses the contentious politics unleashed by the shattering or capitulation of the dynastic Islamic states and the emergence of new forms of mass politics and national political community. Part three (“National Independence, Guerrilla War and Social Revolution, 1952–1976”) surveys the heyday of pan-Arab and Leftist revolutionary mobilization during which the European empires were pushed back, national independence and wealth redistribution was achieved in some states, and new forms of authoritarianism took hold. Part four (“Islamism, Revolution, Uprisings and Liberalism, 1977–2011”) discusses the emergence of new forms of contentious mobilization, both Islamist and liberal. One noteworthy conclusion in this last section is that the new media that emerged was by itself less important in shaping the outcomes of mass mobilization than the ways it was used, and to what ends.
The book's focus is on the Arabic-speaking world, particularly from 1914 onwards. The author frankly acknowledges that a book of this scope will be full of omissions, while hoping that these do not negate his key arguments.
Nonetheless, some of the omissions, and some of the interpretations, are problematic. Although passing reference is made to the Armenian question that bedeviled the Ottoman state in the years before World War I, no mention at all is made of the Armenian genocide, despite its lasting consequences and continued relevance. The Turkish Republic, a site of almost continuous contentious politics since its establishment and a crucial actor in regional politics, especially in recent days, is entirely absent. Some allowance is made for Iran, but only one sentence is devoted to the Green Movement's dramatic, albeit failed challenge to the regime in 2009. The author's entirely negative view of the Zionist movement and the state of Israel results in his employing a single, highly problematic and tendentious source to describe the consequences of the 1948 war for Palestinian Arabs.
Mohamed bin Abdelkrim's five year revolt in the Moroccan Rif region during the 1920s is analyzed extensively. But his Berber ethnicity, and that of his supporters, is given short shrift, and an uninformed reader would be surprised to learn that Abdelkrim is an iconic figure among both modern-day Rifians and the broader Amazigh identity current in North Africa; the latter's absence from the book, apart from a single phrase, is to be regretted.
The author's reluctance to incorporate ethnic identification into his analysis is made even more apparent by the absence of the Kurds, who have engaged in almost continuous struggle against hegemonic state authorities in Turkey, Iraq, Syria, and Iran for nearly a century. Indeed, the emergence of a pan-Kurdish “space”—culturally, politically, economically, and regionally—not to mention a quasi-independent Kurdish state in northern Iraq, is one of the defining features of the Middle East region in recent years, and deserves much more than a passing reference. One hopes that a second edition of the book will address these shortcomings.
