Introduction
In The Next Christendom, the historian Philip Jenkins made a paradigmatic statement: ‘[if] we wanted to visualize a “typical” contemporary Christian, we should think of a woman living in a village in Nigeria or a Brazilian favela.’Footnote 1 With this, Jenkins asserted that the centre of Christianity, including the Roman Catholic Church, had inexorably shifted ‘southward’ towards Africa, Asia and Latin America. Specific cases, such as the one discussed in this article, help shed new light on the larger picture and increase historical understanding of this shift.
The dawn of the twentieth century brought profound transformations in relations between church and state in most Latin American countries. Investments made by the Roman Catholic Church during the previous century, such as the establishment of the Latin American Pius College (1858) and the gradual improvement in training of priests, focused on the realities of South American countries and ultimately led to new forms of priestly action. This development manifested, on the one hand, the theological repositioning initiated by Pope Leo XIII (r. 1878–1903), and on the other hand, the territorial and administrative redefinitions implemented by Leo and his successor, Pius X (r. 1903–14). The Plenary Latin American Council (1899) is a further example of the implementation of these common norms.Footnote 2
Sérgio Miceli has observed that ‘at the end of the nineteenth and in the early twentieth centuries, patterns of relationships between church and state in Latin America and Brazil underwent profound disruption.’Footnote 3 In some cases, such changes resulted in situations of extreme conflict, such as in Mexico (1917) and Uruguay (1919), while in Venezuela, where the separation of church and state was only partial, considerable resources were allocated to subsidizing ecclesiastical activity.Footnote 4 In Colombia, Peru, Bolivia, Paraguay and Argentina, there was no formal rupture, thus ‘causing the Church to continue to receive institutional and financial benefits of all kinds in exchange for granting government authorities the power to interfere in the selection and appointment of ecclesiastical dignitaries.’Footnote 5 In Brazil, the separation of church and state was brought about by the Proclamation of the Republic in 1889, and was later reiterated in the first constitution of the new regime in 1891.
In the late nineteenth century, the Roman Curia began to establish direct contact with the countries of Latin America, both through official correspondence, encyclicals and apostolic letters, and through diplomatic representations.Footnote 6 Encyclicals were written for Peru, Chile and also Brazil.Footnote 7 In addition, in 1900, in what Lisa Edwards sees as a ‘redistribution of responsibilities more rationally and efficiently,’Footnote 8 new units of ecclesiastical administration were created simultaneously for several countries: Mexico gained seven new dioceses; Peru acquired four new ecclesiastical jurisdictions; and Chile and Venezuela each received two new dioceses.Footnote 9 The growth of the Roman Catholic Church in Brazil was such that, between 1890 and 1930, fifty-six dioceses, eighteen prelatures and three apostolic prefectures were created.Footnote 10
This process of change and expansion also brought with it a need for an increasing number of priests. However, these were not necessarily forthcoming in Brazil, whose population Joseph Burnichon characterized in 1910 as ‘a people moulded by Catholicism, still imbued with the Catholic faith, very attached to its religious traditions, but no longer supplying its clergy.’Footnote 11 This problem had long been recognized, for example in the instructions given to Monsignor Mário Mocenni, apostolic nuncio to Brazil in 1882. These ‘lamented the corruption and ignorance of the Brazilian clergy’ and recommended regular correspondence with local bishops, encouraging them to make use of the principles of the Council of Trent to encourage vocations. However, these instructions also anticipated the arrival of new priests from Europe to ‘eradicate the grave disorders of the [Brazilian] clergy and to instill in them the true ecclesiastical spirit.’Footnote 12 Indeed, at the end of the nineteenth century and in the first decades of the twentieth, a considerable influx of religious men and women crossed the Atlantic to Brazil.
Several authors have sought to explain what was happening in Brazil in this period. The anthropologist Roger Bastide referred to the process as ‘Romanization’, arguing that this was the period when the Catholic Church in Brazil was becoming a ‘Romanized Church’. Indeed, the new political regime in Brazil resulted in a movement in which ‘German Franciscans replaced Brazilian Franciscans … . Monastic orders, often persecuted or expelled elsewhere, emigrated from France, Belgium, or Italy … . They included French Lazarists, German, Italian, Belgian Benedictines or Franciscans.’ For Bastide, the result of this process was that ‘in becoming Romanized, the Church denationalized itself.’Footnote 13
Other authors have adopted the concept of ‘Romanization’, such as Ralph Della Cava in his Miracle at Joaseiro (1970). Cava spoke of ‘the systematic integration of the Brazilian church, on both an ideological and institutional level, into the highly centralized structures of the Roman Catholic church directed from Rome.’Footnote 14 The 1889 military coup, which proclaimed the Republic in Brazil and led to the 1891 Constitution, was a crucial moment, for it marked the end of the so-called ‘Padroado’ (patronage), under which the Catholic Church had, since the fifteenth century, been accountable initially to the Portuguese king and then, from 1822, to the Brazilian emperor, and not necessarily to the Vatican. Riolando Azzi, on the other hand, proposed the concept of a ‘Catholic Restoration’ to describe the period from the 1920s onwards.Footnote 15 He argued that this period, characterized by the strengthening of the laity alongside an increasingly organized political militancy, began to create a space for the political mobilization of Brazilian Catholicism.
In this article, I will suggest that there are reasons for agreeing more with the analysis of Della Cava than with that of Azzi. However, I also make use of another concept employed by Edward Wright-Rios in his study Revolutions in Mexican Catholicism (2009): that of ‘Catholic Resurgence’.Footnote 16 Through it, Wright-Rios emphasized the institutional dimension of the Catholic Church, which, since Pius IX, had manifested greater administrative centralism, and argued that priests and friars were figures with agency, whose social practices made a real impact in local contexts in Mexico. By considering the parallel transformations that occurred in Brazil, this article seeks to reveal the important interconnections between multiple aspects of the social history of the Catholic Church there.
This reconfiguration process, as will be shown below, was primarily a move toward occupying the peripheral areas of urban centres or territories that the Catholic Church had not yet reached systematically. Moreover, the presence of the Catholic Church in these areas was to be fundamental to the subsequent development of poor relief policies in the first half of the twentieth century in Brazil, an important consideration when shifting the focus from a history of the Catholic Church as centred on intellectual movements to one focused on the social practices of individuals and their interactions. Furthermore, the presence and impact of the Catholic Church, actively present on the peripheries of Brazilian urban centres before the advent of liberation theology in the 1960s and 1970s, is an historiographically underexplored subject.
This article seeks to shed new light on these developments by following the career trajectory of Casimiro Brochtrup (1868–1944), a Franciscan friar minor who arrived in Brazil from the newly united Germany in 1894.Footnote 17 For the purposes of this discussion, the periphery is understood as the areas of poverty surrounding the city of Recife, the capital of Pernambuco, a city which had considerable political importance during the period of Brochtrup’s activity (1894–1944), with the Catholic Church acting as a fundamental pillar of structures of power.
Missionaries from Afar
More than three dozen male religious orders entered Brazil between 1880 and 1930.Footnote 18 The arrival of these new orders of missionary priests, each under the jurisdiction of a specific rule, both ended the predominance of the secular clergy, and significantly changed the ethnic composition of Brazilian Catholicism. Indeed, Serbin’s analysis showed that 85.9% of regular priests in this fifty-year period had been born outside Brazil, and observes that, in consequence, ‘once again, being a priest in Brazil meant being white,’ in a multi-ethnic country that had officially abolished slavery in 1888.Footnote 19
This change in ecclesiastical profile had varying consequences in different Brazilian territories and local contexts, often reflecting the sometimes rigid outlook of priests who brought with them worldviews formed in completely different social, political and ecclesiastical contexts. The encyclical Litteras a Vobis, on clergy in Brazil, which was drafted by Leo XIII and addressed to the Brazilian episcopate in 1894, offers clues for understanding this process more clearly. Leo writes: ‘By our apostolic providence, we have determined to restore the original observance of your institutions from the losses of past times.’Footnote 20 For the pope, this restoration meant for religious a closer adherence to the rules of the relevant order, or a return to them. He concluded his words to orders and congregations with an affirmation: ‘the religious communities, both male and female, should be congratulated for receiving our commands willingly and for showing themselves ready for the restoration of the original institution of each one.’Footnote 21
A comparison of the general censuses of 1872 and 1920 shows that the number of Brazilian priests increased by 35.65% over this period, while the number of foreign priests increased by 89.11%; however, no distinction is made in this census data between secular clergy and those who were members of religious orders.Footnote 22 Pernambuco experienced a significant change in its social framework, which can help explain other features of the region. In 1872, there had been 235 Brazilian priests and eight priests or members of religious orders who had come from abroad. In 1920, the number of Brazilian-born members of religious orders remained the same, but the number of foreign members of religious orders had increased to 129. The population in total had increased by 23.46%, but the total number of members of religious orders increased by 49.32%.Footnote 23 This reflects the transformation in Pernambuco, especially after 1889, when new structures were created in the Catholic Church.
Religious orders and congregations in Brazil were also shaped by political upheavals elsewhere that led to a diaspora. According to data collected by José Oscar Beozzo, in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, 31.57% of the priests who came to Brazil were Italian, 26.31% were French, and 21.08% were either German or Dutch.Footnote 24 This migration was driven by a dual motivation: spreading Catholicism, and fleeing territories which were increasingly hostile to Catholic religious practices. The growth of religious orders in Brazil accelerated until the Second World War, although the rate of growth generally reflected the degree of anticlericalism in the order’s society of origin.Footnote 25
In Pernambuco, the influx was constituted by a range of different orders: Capuchins (arrival in 1841); Franciscans (1891); Congregation of the Priests of the Sacred Heart of Jesus (1893); Salesians (1894); Carmelites (1894); Benedictines (1895); Jesuits (1910); and Marist Brothers (1911). In order better to understand some of the nuances of this process, the case of the Franciscan friars coming to Brazil from Saxony (Germany), and in particular, that of Friar Casimiro Brochtrup, will now be explored.
The Province of the Holy Cross of Saxony Enters Brazil
In 1891, the Franciscan province of Saxony agreed to undertake a mission to Brazil. The number of Franciscan friars in Brazil had declined by 79% since the mid-nineteenth century, and it was therefore deemed necessary to bring priests to Brazil from elsewhere for the province of Santo Antônio do Brasil to be restored. Two of the order’s friars, Camilo de Lélis and Joaquim do Espírito Santo, requested that new priests might be sent to Brazil, initially for missions among the indigenous people. While the Italian province declined the invitation, the province of Saxony accepted it.Footnote 26
At this time, the province of Saxony was flourishing, with about 260 members and missions in the Netherlands, Belgium, the United States and China.Footnote 27 The first Saxon priests arrived in Brazil from Bremen on 25 May 1891.Footnote 28 Dom Amando Bahlmann recalled years later that the voyage was quite uncomfortable: ‘we were all very seasick, but almost every day we were able to celebrate Mass. With us, in third class, many Polish emigrants travelled.’Footnote 29 After landing in Salvador (Bahia) in the north-east, they travelled south, gaining an introduction to the Brazilian territory. A second missionary expedition arrived in Salvador in December 1891 with eight more friars; a third brought another sixteen in August 1892. The fourth expedition arrived in June 1893, the fifth in July 1894.
The friars who arrived in 1894 had more in common besides their dark brown habits and the rules of their order. Most of them had been born during a turbulent period in German history, in which successive wars had ultimately led to unification under Wilhelm I of Prussia and Chancellor Bismarck, who in the so-called Kulturkampf introduced a range of measures restricting or suppressing Roman Catholicism. This Protestantizing state project had prompted a reaction among Catholics who opposed it, and it was also condemned by the Vatican. After unification in 1871, the new German government expelled several religious orders from the country. The Province of the Holy Cross of Saxony was forced to move its headquarters to Harreveld in the Netherlands; it sent some of its members to the United States, where they founded a mission near Chicago, and others to China.Footnote 30 Another German province of the Friars Minor, Thuringia, also sent priests to the United States, in this case to New York City, in 1875.Footnote 31
The expedition to Brazil was seen as paralleling the mission to the United States. Friar Gregório Janknecht, one of the organizers of the Brazilian mission and the man who had led the work of the order in North America, wrote to his superior that the Brazilian mission ‘will be similar to the emigration to the United States in 1875’. Indeed, he believed that ‘in South America, we are given a field of action even more important and rewarding than in North America.’Footnote 32
The friars who arrived in Salvador from the Netherlands in 1894 were thus products of a turbulent period. Some had experienced the militarism of German unification first hand before joining the Franciscan Order: Friar Ciríaco (1855–1941) and Friar Nicolau (1867–1942) had both been honoured by Emperor Wilhelm I for their military service, Friar Casimiro Brochtrup too had served in the army. These personal experiences shaped their ministry in Brazil.Footnote 33
Friar Casimiro Brochtrup: Becoming a Missionary
Hermann Brochtrup was born on 10 March 1868, in Lüdinghausen, Westphalia, into a large but impoverished family of farmers.Footnote 34 He was educated at the local school and then enrolled in a teacher training college.Footnote 35 Called up for mandatory military service, he was not engaged in any military conflict, but he took the lead in caring for his comrades when some of them were afflicted with tuberculosis.Footnote 36 Unlike some of his colleagues who embarked for Brazil, Brother Brochtrup had had an independent life as a teacher before deciding, at the age of twenty-six, to become a Franciscan postulant.Footnote 37
His formational journey began in Germany and concluded in Brazil. On joining the order, Hermann received the name Casimiro in honour of the saint, recognized for his connection with the poor and the sick, who had lived in Poland between 1458 and 1484.Footnote 38 With this new name, the young Roman Catholic committed to becoming one of the agents of the Catholic Church in Brazil. His ministry in the country was predominantly focused on the north-east region, known as the poorest area of Brazil, where he worked in the working-class suburbs but also ventured into the hinterlands.Footnote 39
The position given to Casimiro Brochtrup by his superiors was that of missionary. His apostolic activity focused on evangelistic preaching in Santas Missões (‘Holy Missions’) in various regions of Brazil. He also left at least three written versions of ‘The Chronicle of the Mission of São Sebastião da Macaxeira’, a mission and social work foundation he established in Recife in 1926.Footnote 40
In one version of the Chronicle of Macaxeira, Brother Casimiro wrote: ‘Since 1918, I have led my life as a priest preaching missions and accompanying the bishops on Pastoral Visits.’ A year after his return to Recife in 1924, having spent six months on a preaching mission in the hinterland, he experienced something ‘like an inspiration from heaven’. This persuaded him that he should no longer work in the hinterlands, ‘where the people showed so much faith,’ but rather ‘seek out the poor workers of Recife, who living in shanty towns were completely abandoned spiritually and in danger of losing the Catholic faith, as the preachers of the nova-seita [new sect] persecuted them.’Footnote 41 Friar Casimiro’s sense was that the inhabitants of the shanty towns had been – or become – ‘abandoned’, not only in a spiritual sense, but also in relation to their poverty and morality.
In that same year of 1925, Friar Casimiro remembered: ‘I was called to confess a poor worker in the Cordeiro neighbourhood and found him in an illicit union with a woman with whom he had four children, and I sought to marry him to that woman.’Footnote 42 Since there were no obstacles to performing the ceremony, Casimiro asked the couple to arrange for some people to serve as witnesses, only to receive the objection: ‘Father, all the people in this street are adherents of the nova-seita.’Footnote 43 ‘These words,’ Casimiro wrote, ‘cut me to the heart, and with more insistence, I heard the voice of God within me: Decide to care for the poor workers of Recife!’Footnote 44 This voice, or inspiration, prompted him to ‘inquire about the spiritual state of people living in the “working-class neighbourhoods” (‘bairros operários’) of Recife’.Footnote 45 In December the following year, the friar would begin his social work in the city.
The question now was how to implement this vocation, but also to define the area in which he would operate. Casimiro’s first step was to obtain authorization to start the work. He recalled that the provincial, Fr Eduardo, ‘told me that there was no difficulty in obtaining this license,’ and simply to ‘make a written request to the Chapter stating your request’.Footnote 46 At the next meeting of their chapter, the friars of the Franciscan Province of Santo Antônio of Brazil approved Friar Casimiro’s proposal. However, the approval of the archdiocese of Olinda and Recife was still necessary, and it was this that confirmed where the project would be based. Although there was some delay in obtaining the license from the local prelate, Casimiro had already decided on the location for his work: Macaxeira, located in Recife’s Santo Amaro neighbourhood.
It was not the first time that Casimiro had been to Macaxeira. In a separate document, attached to the first version of his ‘Crônica’, there is mention of a holy mission he had been due to preach in Santo Amaro in 1924 by order of the metropolitan archbishop. However, due to the rainy season, it only lasted two days, as the priest fell ill: the rain was so heavy that ‘there was no dry place, but everything was wet so that he could not kneel at the time of the blessing.’Footnote 47 The suspension of this apostolic work led to a disagreement between the archbishop and the friar.
Brother Casimiro wrote in his Chronicle that the parish priest of Piedade, João Olympio dos Santos, when ‘asked by some ladies’, had mentioned the need for more diligent work in the area. This locality was described by Brother Casimiro as a space located ‘beside the Limoeiro line to the north of the cemetery [which] has about 800 shanties, and on the opposite side there are perhaps about 200 houses.’ This one section of a neighbourhood alone housed a considerable number of people. In the 1913 census, the Santo Amaro neighbourhood was the fourth most populous in Recife, with 16,697 people, and the third in terms of the number of shanties. In absolute numbers, Santo Amaro was the seventh of fourteen neighbourhoods in terms of literate population, and the sixth in terms of the number of people without formal education. Moreover, in the early twentieth century, the state of Pernambuco, and with it its capital, had experienced intense industrialization, with the number of registered industrial enterprises increasing from 209 in 1880, to 791 in 1919. The number of industries almost quadrupled across various sectors, particularly in food, textile, clothing and ceramics. A notable rise in urban migration accompanied this, as people fleeing drought in rural areas sought employment opportunities.
The notion of a ‘permanent mission’, a term coined by Brother Casimiro himself, indicated that his proposal was for a sustained ministry rather than for a short-term intervention, as was more common. The experience described above, when Brother Casimiro attempted to conduct the wedding of a ‘poor worker’ on the outskirts of the city but was unable to find witnesses because the worker’s neighbours belonged to the nova-seita, parallels the account of Father João Olympio, who warned that the youth were in danger of being corrupted by ‘barefoot preachers’ and ignorant propagators of harmful spiritualism.Footnote 48 These accounts highlight a growing concern over the influence of new religious beliefs and practices among marginalized populations, underscoring the challenge the Catholic Church faced in maintaining its presence and spiritual authority in urban outskirts.
At the same time, the terms used by both priests generalized and ‘othered’ people of different faiths or confessions, placing them in the position of a common enemy. Friar Casimiro couched his ministry in terms of a crusade confronting a social reality. This may be why the notion of a permanent mission seemed so apt. His social work initiatives were also a means by which he could confront the ‘new sects’.
The notion of nova-seita appears in Brother Casimiro’s ‘Crônica’ as a generic concept referring to the range of denominations, often Pentecostal, that had, he said, ‘opened worship houses on every street.’ In general, the term ‘new sect’ had a pejorative character, especially when referring to Protestant groups. An example of this is the insult hurled by a layman of the church of Penha at a woman who refused – or was unable – to contribute to the church offering: ‘You are a nova-seita, shameless! Even though you live near the church (of São Gonçalo), you have no shame.’Footnote 49 The Catholic press took a decidedly negative view of the ‘new sects’ and their practitioners. Similarly, an article on nova-seita in the magazine Maria claimed that ‘Protestantism is a kind of Proteus; it changes its form, doctrine, and faith everywhere and for anyone, giving nonsense. Now, readers, take a look. In Brazil alone, the following new sects have sprung up from Protestantism.’ It went on to list each of the Protestant groups operating in Brazil.Footnote 50
This debate illuminates the complex historical connections between the rise of Pentecostalism in Brazil in the 1910s and 1920s, and the socio-economic landscapes of urban poverty. The emergence and spread of Pentecostalism can only be fully understood by considering the specific conditions of Brazil’s urban centres, where marginalized communities often faced economic hardship, racial discrimination and social exclusion. Scholars such as John Burdick and R. Andrew Chesnut have explored the development and expansion of Pentecostalism through an intersectional lens encompassing class, race and gender dynamics.Footnote 51 Their studies reveal how Pentecostalism’s appeal and growth among urban populations were shaped by these intersecting identities, historically constructed and continuously negotiated within the framework of Brazilian society. This approach demonstrates that Pentecostalism was – and is – not merely a religious phenomenon, but also a social movement deeply embedded in the lived experiences of the urban poor.
The testimonies of Friar Casimiro are particularly valuable as they underscore the importance of re-engaging with the social history of the Catholic Church from an interreligious and interdenominational perspective. This approach involves recognizing the diverse religious expressions that emerged in impoverished urban settings and understanding how the Catholic Church interacted with, adapted to, or resisted these new forms of belief. Such analysis, which requires careful consideration of the different social positions occupied by marginalized communities in urban peripheries, helps us to empathize with their struggles and understand their search for meaning, community and social support. Revisiting these dynamics also sheds light on the complex interplay between religious institutions and the socio-economic realities faced by these communities, offering a more nuanced understanding of the role of the Catholic Church – and other religious groupings – in the broader religious landscape of urban Brazil.
Friar Casimiro and his ‘Permanent Mission’
Describing the large, rough construction situated among the shanties of the Macaxeira site, a journalist from the Jornal Pequeno wrote: ‘A crude wooden cross rises from the apex of an angle formed by two rafters, supporting the ridge, highlighting the facade of a shack, catching the attention of visitors to that poverty-stricken neighborhood.’ The building was a ‘misshapen house with irregular coverings, using a variety of materials,’ with a roof made of thatch and walls made of ‘wooden panels, boards of different shapes revealing their source, crates, and sacks of burlap’. It was surprising that such a fragile building had been able to withstand a winter.Footnote 52 On entering the premises, the journalist observed ‘a large space/room, half of the shack. A burlap curtain marks the division’. The other half was divided into two additional rooms with a similar makeshift partition. An altar stood in the centre. The journalist concluded: ‘There is both a chapel and a school.’ This setting formed the backdrop to Brother Casimiro’s social work.Footnote 53
The first mass of his new ministry was celebrated outdoors in February 1927, on a platform raised by about 80 cm; on it was a temporary altar and the image of St Sebastian.Footnote 54 Brother Casimiro’s work began by seeking ‘the healing of souls through daily worship and frequent preaching,’ but the engagement he had hoped for did not materialize. A school was therefore started in the shack housing the church, for, as Casimiro recognized, ‘catechism on its own would not yield a result if it did not start with education’.Footnote 55 He later recalled: ‘in February I started with two primary schools, soon increased to four. There was no school in Macaxeira, except for some private ones, which were there to exploit poverty.’Footnote 56 This pivotal move underscored Brother Casimiro’s realization that authentic spiritual engagement required a foundation of education, leading him to integrate schooling into his ministry in order better to serve and uplift the community of Macaxeira. Both the journalist’s brief narrative and the priest’s account reveal the precariousness of life for the inhabitants of Macaxeira at this time and the absence of any state provision for the area. Brother Casimiro’s approach for attracting people to his work was to offer a service to the community, since more than spiritual activities would be necessary to ensure the continuity of the mission.
The article in the Jornal Pequeno vividly described the Franciscan friar’s work in this poverty-stricken city area. Brother Casimiro sought resources to improve facilities and construct a church. The friar’s ministry provided social assistance, some of which should have been the state’s responsibility. It required funding, personal relationships, knowledge of bureaucratic intricacies, and an understanding of the operations of the state.Footnote 57 Brother Casimiro’s efforts sought not only to fulfil spiritual requirements, but also to address critical social needs, highlighting his ability to navigate complex state systems and rally resources for a mission that extended far beyond the church walls. As such, Friar Casimiro’s actions in his ‘permanent mission’ involved some of the social mobilization practices that had been recommended by the Plenary Latin American Council (1899), such as education and social care (along with a focus on rural ministry which was less relevant to his work).Footnote 58 The priest’s actions confirm the impression that, in those years, the Catholic Church was expanding beyond its historical frontiers to reach into territories located in peripheral areas. Brochtrup founded at least ten Catholic groups of various kinds. These ranged from associations, such as the Our Lady of Perpetual Help Association; the Ladies of Charity; and the Infant Jesus of the Children; to the League of the Most Holy Names of Jesus, Mary and Joseph; and the well-known Apostolate of Prayer.Footnote 59 These organizations provided a range of collective experiences, such as commemorations, celebrations and cultural exchanges. From the statistical yearbook of Pernambuco for the year 1930, it can be seen that there were 168 devotional associations across the forty-one parishes of the archdiocese of Olinda and Recife, an average of about four associations per parish. In addition, there were thirty-four brotherhoods, based in older parishes and mostly near Recife.Footnote 60 However, there was also significant growth of evangelical churches of different denominations in this area during this period, as well as traditional manifestations of Afro-Brazilian religions. For a state whose leaders were openly Catholic and conservative, work like that of Friar Casimiro was therefore timely.
In addition to ecclesiastical initiatives such as frequent communion, the establishment of associations, and the annual celebration of festivals, Brother Casimiro’s mission manifested a palpable concern with the long-term viability of Catholic engagement in the area. The idea of a ‘permanent mission’ involved more significant interaction with spheres of power, including the administrative elite, sometimes at the highest level. Friar Casimiro sought access to the public machinery of the state through the fostering of networks of relationship. He also attempted to establish strong relationships that were not dependent on those who held political power at any particular moment. While he was openly critical of some political leaders, he was also able to build up mutual relationships with them which could be sustained despite his criticism.Footnote 61 However, his primary focus was on establishing good relations with civil servants and other staff in public administration, and on establishing long-term relationships with those who were involved in the day-to-day implementation of political decisions. Through petitions, the acquiring of privileged information, and visits to local legislative offices, political activity in the territory became essentially the activities of the Catholic Church itself.
In 1937, after the political coup of the Estado Novo (New State), when Getúlio Vargas decreed a state of emergency and established a dictatorial regime, the scenario changed favourably for Brother Casimiro. The new governor of Pernambuco, Agamenon Magalhães, was a staunch Roman Catholic and chose the friar as his confessor. This relationship allowed the priest unrestricted access to the public sphere and its resources.
Friar Casimiro’s ministry in Macaxeira illustrates the significant impact that combining education and social services with religious work could have on marginalized communities. Recognizing that spiritual activities alone were insufficient for meaningful engagement, he established schools within the church’s modest facilities, understanding that education was essential for catechism to be effective. This approach addressed immediate needs and filled a void left by the lack of state services, demonstrating how the church could extend its influence beyond traditional spiritual boundaries to foster community development.
While his ability to navigate bureaucratic complexities and build relationships with political leaders like Governor Agamenon Magalhães was pivotal for securing resources, it also highlights the challenges inherent in relying on personal networks for community support. These connections enabled Friar Casimiro to advance his mission, but they also underscore the importance of having sustainable structures for social assistance that are not solely dependent on individual efforts. Friar Casimiro’s work reflects both the potential of religious institutions to effect positive change and the necessity for broader, systemic solutions to address the needs of underprivileged and underserved areas like Macaxeira.
Shaping the Landscape
One result of Brother Casimiro’s relationship to the new governor of Pernambuco was the transformation of the landscape of the former Sítio da Macaxeira (Macaxeira Ranch), including the replacement of shanties by houses. On 1 May 1941, the Santo Amaro neighbourhood celebrated the inauguration of a residential complex built with state resources, in partnership with civic and church agencies. The ‘Social League Against the Slum’, founded in 1939, sought to improve the quality of housing in the neighbourhood and to clear slums. The League’s regulations required applicants for the new housing to conform to regulations that aimed to improve living standards and morality. The celebration in 1941 also marked fifty years since the publication of Rerum Novarum (1891), the influential papal encyclical on social justice issues. The workers’ village was named Leo XIII in honour of the encyclical’s author.Footnote 62
Friar Casimiro may well have attended the ceremony. Housing was one of his areas of expertise, and Leo XIII Village was just a short distance from the church and São Sebastião elementary school. However, the new housing was not unproblematic. The building programme had been preceded by a long process of demolishing slums and draining flooded areas. In addition, the number of new houses was less than the number of slum dwellings demolished, which created a difficult situation. Nonetheless, the new housing in many ways represented the culmination of Friar Casimiro’s endeavours. Between 1926, when he began his social programme, and his death in 1944, the locality was almost completely transformed. The rural-urban landscape began to acquire masonry buildings instead of shacks and shanties. In this, the name of the Leo XIII Village represented much more than a tribute; this was a city project that sought to mitigate the hardships of life for a population which had been forcibly displaced from the shanty towns.
Friar Casimiro’s relationship with Pernambuco’s governor went beyond political patronage and their shared interests in the Catholic Church and its social doctrine. This is evident from an article written by Agamenon Magalhães after the friar’s death on 25 May 1944, in which he recalled:
Start here, Frei Casimiro told me, with your work against the slums. We responded to your appeal and began building the worker village … . The buildings multiplied, blessed by God and men, increasing the apostolic fervour of the missionary who was not afraid of poverty and lived through his sufferings.’Footnote 63
Magalhães was clearly influenced by Casimiro as his confessor, and he here associates Friar Casimiro’s ministry and his attempts at the ‘Christianization’ of the city with the implementation of the slum demolition initiative.
Similarly, the priest who became Magalhães’s confessor after Casimiro’s death, Fr Romeu Pérea, later described his first contact with the politician: ‘“Did you know Frei Casimiro?” asked the Governor. “I did,” replied the priest. Finally, he asked, “Was he a saint?”’ The priest replied that he thought he had been, claiming that Friar Casimiro’s role in opening catechism centres and setting up ‘sufficient straw chapels in which to gather children to learn the true meaning of life,’ made him the ‘true precursor of the so-called Social League Against the Shantytown.’Footnote 64 Pérea also reported that Brother Casimiro had come to be known as the ‘apostle of the shantytowns’, whose ministry was not in the remote corners of the country but rather on the urban front lines. The construction of Friar Casimiro’s reputation as a saint began very soon after his death, reflecting his renown during his life.
The chronicle book of the Santo Antônio Convent records that ‘on April 15 [1944], Frei Casimiro fell gravely ill. Despite the greatest care from doctors and sisters, our esteemed brother in the habit did not survive the illness, passing away, surrounded by his brothers, on May 25.’ The chronicler further wrote that with the death of their brother, a ‘truly pious religious and extraordinarily zealous worker of great mortification’ was lost. He added a reflection that the Franciscan himself would surely have endorsed: ‘It is better to take the poor out of the quagmire of misery and make them illustrious Brazilian citizens than to build a palace.’Footnote 65 In seeking to make this vision a reality, Friar Casimiro witnessed a key historical process in the construction of early-twentieth-century Brazil, in which religion and state were closely entwined.
Conclusion
In August 1952, eight years after Casimiro Brochtrup’s death in Recife, someone paid for the publication of a brief notice in the newspaper Diário de Pernambuco: ‘To Friar Casimiro, I thank you for the cause achieved’.Footnote 66 The Diário de Pernambuco was not at that time openly Catholic, as it once had been, but nonetheless published this reader’s words of gratitude. Similar testimonies to the effective intercession of the Franciscan friar appear in other newspapers, alongside thanks to other figures well known in the hagiographies and imaginations of Roman Catholicism more widely: St Anthony, Our Lady of Perpetual Help, Saints Cosmas and Damian.Footnote 67
Another tribute was recorded in the Diário de Pernambuco in July 1952, when the archbishop of Olinda and Recife visited the social institutions which had been set up by Brother Casimiro. He wrote: ‘It has been 25 years since Friar Casimiro, a true apostle of Recife, founded the monumental and indelible work among the poorest workers in the capital of Pernambuco. He lived among these miserable people preaching the holy Gospel in a life of sacrifices.’ The archbishop also noted that Casimiro had been accorded titles such as ‘pious,’ ‘charitable,’ ‘untiring,’ and ‘apostle.’Footnote 68 On the centenary of the friar’s birth, the famous Brazilian sociologist Gilberto Freyre called him ‘perhaps a saint’.Footnote 69 The life of Friar Casimiro Brochtrup, in the aftermath of the proclamation of the Republic in Brazil in November 1889, illustrates the way in which the dimensions of political sociability are steeped in religious practices (and vice versa) and show how personal relationships within a network enable the undertaking of large-scale actions that impact the social life of an impoverished community, as was the case with Sítio da Macacheira. At the interface between religion, politics and piety, there is a complex history that can be told through various angles: by examining the political influence of religious institutions – such as how the Catholic Church has shaped governance, legislation and social policies – but also by investigating social movements rooted in piety, exploring how grassroots religious movements have led to social change or political action.
This leads to a final methodological reflection: the importance of the parish dimension. Numerous researchers have pointed out the potential of this ecclesiastical unit. This perspective also leads us to perceive more clearly how the presence of the Roman Catholic Church between the late nineteenth century and the early decades of the twentieth century resides, above all, in territorial expansion. There was a numerical growth of churches and chapels and an intensification in community life. The proliferation of Catholic lay associations, associated with a growing dependence on a priest leading these groups, illustrates a more effective presence of multiple Catholicisms in the territories. On the one hand, the church had growing political capital, and on the other, it represented a central element of local political stability. All this preceded – but in some ways formed the foundation for – the development of a liberation theology.
Returning to where we started, Philip Jenkins’s recognition of the southward shift in contemporary Christianity requires research into the operations of the Catholic Church in peripheral areas as a long-term process. In Brazil, the occupation of these territories brought Roman Catholic social practices to the poorest strata of society. It is no coincidence that a survey published by the Datafolha Institute in 2019 on the demography of religions in Brazil found that 55% of Catholics consider themselves black and brown, 80% have no university education, and 67% earn up to three minimum wages. The story of Friar Casimiro Brochtrup helps to show why this is the case.
