These three textbooks cover similar content, but differ in the way they convey the information. Each textbook has chapters covering the economic underpinnings of trade law; the history of the World Trade Organization (WTO); a breakdown of the substantive obligations contained in various WTO agreements; the economic and non-economic exceptions to these obligations; social policy issues such as the impact of trade on developing countries; and an explanation of the WTO dispute settlement process. World Trade Law also has sections discussing the relationship between trade and investment, the environment, human rights, and health and safety, while International Trade Law contains an extensive discussion of modern trade issues from an economic perspective, as well as a comparative study of trade policy-making in the major economies.
In terms of approach, WTO Through the Cases presents the law largely through primary materials. International Trade Law follows this approach in relation to the technical rules, but supplements this with excerpts from contemporary debates between renowned experts. World Trade Law adopts a similar approach to International Trade Law in respect of presenting the technical rules, but contains extensive expository sections explaining the significance of the cases.
By using mostly primary materials, WTO Through the Cases equips students to work through lengthy case extracts and distil the technical rules for themselves. Accordingly, students acquire a flavour of the types of argument that parties raise and how the criteria established by the Panels and Appellate Body (AB) are applied to the facts at issue. For example, in Japan – Alcoholic Beverages, the European Community (EC) argued that shochu and spirits were like products because they essentially serve the same use. However, Japan challenged this assertion by raising facts that are likely to be little known to non-Japanese readers—for instance, sixty percent of consumers drink shochu during meals, but sixty-three percent drink spirits after meals. Additionally, forty-two percent of consumers drink shochu with hot water, compared to four percent who do so with vodka and one percent who do so with gin. The EC's argument and Japan's rebuttal show how several products can be said to be “like” each other at a high degree of abstraction, and how these prima facie similarities may be challenged if one were to zero in on the specifics.
Compared to WTO Through the Cases and International Trade Law, World Trade Law uses fewer extracts from Panel and AB reports for this discussion. WTO Through the Cases has supplemented the primary materials with some secondary materials, but its general lack of expository text may mean that students may not grasp all of the ideas that the authors had hoped they would.
The standout feature of World Trade Law is the comprehensive and meticulous manner in which it covers the technical rules of trade law and the practices of the WTO. For example, in the chapter entitled “Dispute Settlement in the WTO”, the authors begin by giving an overview of the different stages of dispute settlement and comment on various issues, such as the non-retroactive nature of compensation, the question of whether retaliation is meant to be a temporary measure to induce compliance or a means of rebalancing tariff concessions and other obligations that members had originally agreed to, as well as the limited efficacy of retaliatory measures, especially for developing countries. The authors follow this overview with an exhaustive examination of various procedural issues in dispute settlement. They comment on the types of complaint that can be brought; the measures that can be challenged; the right of other Member States with a “substantial interest” in the dispute to participate as third parties; the right of the Panels and the AB to receive unsolicited amicus curiae briefs; the principles of treaty interpretation applied by the Panels and the AB; and the lack of a remand procedure in the dispute settlement system. Given the scope of coverage, readers are likely to find guidance on most issues that have already found their way into the jurisprudence and practice of the WTO.
International Trade Law covers most of the issues concerning the WTO dispute settlement addressed in World Trade Law, but does so in a more concise manner, and highlights contentious issues that promise to have major implications for the future role and efficacy of the WTO dispute settlement process. For example, in the chapter entitled “General Exceptions: The Chapeau of GATT Article XX”, the authors include a debate between Trachtman and Pauwelyn concerning the role of non-WTO law in dispute settlement. At the outset, the authors highlight that the scope given to non-WTO law will have an impact on how trade objectives are weighed in comparison with non-economic goals. After excerpting portions from Trachtman's and Pauwelyn's writings, they provide a succinct summary of the two authors’ positions. They note that Trachtman argues that non-WTO law should have been explicitly included in the WTO treaty for it to be relevant, whereas Pauwelyn argues that non-WTO law has to be excluded for it to be carved out. The discussion proceeds to identify further difficulties that neither Trachtman nor Pauwelyn had addressed in the excerpts.
Both World Trade Law and International Trade Law seek to reinforce students’ understanding of the material by including review questions. International Trade Law also concludes most sections with summaries that consolidate the ratio of the cases into a few short paragraphs. Students will likely find these summaries extremely useful in helping them understand the cases. Moreover, it also includes hypothetical problems at the end of each chapter to test students’ application of the principles that they have learnt in the chapter.
In conclusion, we believe that World Trade Law is most appropriate for independent study due to its comprehensiveness. Even so, students are likely to find International Trade Law highly accessible and stand to gain much from the issues it raises about the grey areas and limits of current WTO practice and jurisprudence.
