Defining religion as a distinct category of human experience once seemed quite simple. But times have changed. The familiar markers that used to divide the sacred from the profane are now blurred and disputed, leaving the impression that clarity can only be found at the extremes of all or nothing. As a result, not surprisingly perhaps, a thriving colony of hybrid cultural expressions has begun to move into this semantic no-man's land, often with an eye toward gaining some ideological, economic, political, or social advantage.
Faegheh Shirazi's illuminating study of the intersection between Islamic practice and consumer preferences offers a well-informed and carefully documented account of one prominent example of this phenomenon. She explores with sympathetic but critical expertise the global growth industry that has recently exploded to meet the demands of those who desire products certified as halal. Starting with a brief review of the ritual purity stipulations in the Qurʾan and sunna, she quickly turns her attention to the advancing trends that have created “the significant role of Islam as a commodified religion with piety as a marketing tool” (7).
She argues convincingly that the origin of this expanding multibillion dollar market follows, on the one hand, from the often problematic integration of increasing numbers of Muslims living in or visiting Western Europe and North America. At the same time, international exports are now widely available in bazaars that once offered primarily local products. Traditionally, within Muslim majority societies, observing halal was largely taken for granted and caused little overt concern. The dangers only arise outside of these settings where knowledge is needed and correct choices are necessary. In this way, “brand Islam” represents a contemporary reaction, an assertion of identity and solidarity which may or may not “guarantee the consumer a closer relationship to Allah” (198).
On the other hand, questions of halal vs. haram in this climate have prompted the emergence of a major field of contestation where competing claims to religious authority are asserted through pronouncements regarding what is permitted or prohibited. This has meant a tidal wave of fatwas, from many sources, some of questionable scholarly validity and others coming from a growing list of large prestigious organizations like the Islamic Food and Nutrition Council of America (IFANCA) based in Chicago, but with representatives around the world. IFANCA, whose symbol of approval, the Crescent “M,” appears on thousands of products, has been endorsed by several official governmental bodies including the Muslim World League of Saudi Arabia, the Majelis Ulama Indonesia, and the United Arab Emirates.
The particular commodities treated in detail by the author are well chosen, reflecting market sectors that have expanded to mass retailing and have, in general, become the most lucrative. She devotes the first two chapters, for instance, to food, before moving on to cosmetics, hair and skin care, then to dolls, games, and toys, onward to dress and fashion including veiling, and finally to sportswear, lingerie, and accessories. Along the way, she punctuates these specialized investigations with fascinating commentaries that illustrate a preoccupation with certain high end products; she does not neglect to mention that savvy entrepreneurs have discovered that consumers will pay more for the assurance of halal.
The fact that the purchasing of this merchandise overwhelming involves women and girls also receives frequent note, as Shirazi offers numerous and telling examples of “the patriarchal obsession with Muslim women's bodies” (178). At many points she also explores inconsistencies in the opinions and judgments that claim to derive from religious law. She points out, for instance, that many of the dress code regulations enforced by Iran's moral police are motivated by an animus against what is perceived as Western influence, and do not have their basis in tenants of Islamic jurisprudence. She also reports on a flourishing revolt in Iran that has given rise to an underground market in colorful and stylish garments that may also be displayed beneath the police radar at illegal fashion shows which mirror the couture expositions of Paris, London, or Milan.
Meanwhile, a number of multinational processed food corporations and many leading clothing manufacturers have embraced the appeal of halal. Specialty products have also gained ground, such as the beautiful abaya designs from the United Arab Emirates or the chic outer gowns with matching pants for which Turkey is known. Not surprisingly, the urge for creativity among some entrepreneurs also pushes the limits of acceptability since the concept of modesty is subject to variability. Thus certain new and usually smaller fashion houses, such as one called Amirah Creations, based in Brooklyn are finding successful niches that challenge stereotypes. For instance, it offers a line that reveals bare arms and upper torso, which the wearer may “Islamify” by adding a blazer. Another related characteristic of this entire movement is its use of the global reach of the internet. A substantial amount of Islamic commerce depends on the World Wide Web, not only for buying and selling but for advertising and most importantly for the heavy traffic in the information and the endorsement sought by those who seek to maintain a halal lifestyle.
The range and the depth of Shirazi's research into this commodification movement is impressive and her extensive footnotes and bibliography add to this study. But it is primarily an examination of collective behavior and shared attitudes. It does not attempt to explain the seismic causes and consequences of the ideological surge of recent decades across the Islamic world which has made the likes of orientalism, secularism, and fundamentalism into household words well beyond the groves of academe. In this sense, this book provides an excellent practical guide that amply answers the basic questions and will surely assist any further inquiries into this compelling unbounded emporium.
