The question whether or not the United States is an empire lies at the heart of the historiography of the nation's foreign relations. In this meticulous and engaging book, James G. Morgan seeks to explain the development of the idea of US imperial power by focussing on the group of scholars usually referred to as the “Wisconsin” or “revisionist” school. In doing so, he not only underscores the significance of scholars such as William Appleman Williams and Walter LaFeber, but also provides some thought-provoking insights into the connections between their scholarship and the anti-imperialist activism of the 1960s and 1970s New Left.
The opening chapters of Into New Territory discuss the process by which the Wisconsin school succeeded in bringing the concept of “empire” into the mainstream of US historiography. Morgan emphasizes the significance of the intellectual milieu provided by the University of Wisconsin–Madison (UW), and particularly its History Department, where a radical tradition of scholarship developed that sought inspiration from the Progressive historical thinking of Frederick Jackson Turner and Charles A. Beard. Morgan's arguments therefore strike a chord with other recent monographs on the topic, such as David Brown's Beyond the Frontier: The Midwestern Voice in American Historical Writing (2009) and Matthew Levin's Cold War University: Madison and the New Left in the Sixties (2013). The book goes on to analyse the context in which Williams wrote his two most famous books: The Tragedy of American Diplomacy (1959) and The Contours of American History (1961). From these classic texts emerged a core argument about the links between US foreign relations and the desire amongst policymakers, businessmen and a considerable number of ordinary Americans to forge an “Open Door” for economic expansion, an impulse rooted in a Weltanschaung forged around the concept of the frontier and its links to American exceptionalism. Morgan pays close attention to Williams's ideas, and perceptively suggests that his brand of “psychological determinism,” rooted as much in intellectual as in diplomatic history, meant that he was a kind of patriotic radical, who believed that “American leaders were mostly well-intentioned and truly believed American values could help less-developed nations,” even as he mercilessly critiqued their actions (94). In making this case clearly and coherently in a public climate of consensus about the US role in the world, and in inspiring a host of talented followers unafraid to challenge and nuance his ideas (LaFeber, Thomas McCormick and Lloyd Gardner amongst them), Williams and the Wisconsin school were undoubtedly important in establishing and popularizing debates about the imperial dimensions of US diplomacy.
The second half of Morgan's book is dedicated to the more original aspect of his research: the complicated relationship between the Wisconsin school and anti-imperialist activism. The author argues that, whilst they shared certain similarities, we should not lump the revisionists together with the New Left. Instead, we should clearly delineate between three separate groups: Wisconsin historians (Williams, LaFeber, etc.), New Left historians (key amongst them Gabriel Kolko, Harry Magdoff, early-career David Horowitz, and other scholars who had little or nothing to do with UW), and New Left activists (particularly those involved with Students for a Democratic Society and other groups opposed to the Vietnam War). In Morgan's telling, the New Left was far more willing to embrace both the intellectual and the political underpinnings of revolutionary Marxism than were the Wisconsin scholars. This led Williams and others into conflict with radical students at UW: although the protestors admired the revisionists, “they ultimately abandoned the Wisconsin critique of US imperialism in favor of a more Marxist–Leninist approach” (161). Alongside a detailed comparison of the language of SDS activism and that of revisionist scholarship, this observation leads Morgan to conclude that the intellectual and political traditions of anti-imperialist scholarship are multifarious, and cannot be summarized using the “New Left” moniker alone.
However, in describing the New Left as “Marxist–Leninist,” and therefore essentializing the goals of a diverse and complex set of social movements, Morgan's analysis slips into the kind of “declensionist” scholarship on the 1960s that has been effectively criticized by, amongst others, Van Gosse in his book Rethinking the New Left: An Interpretive History (2005). Furthermore, though it is perhaps uncharitable to criticize a book too heavily for the absence of certain manuscript collections from its bibliography, it is worth noting that the author has not quoted from the William Appleman Williams papers at Oregon State University, which may have provided even more insight into that signal historian's intellectual development and divergence of opinions with the New Left. Overall, though, Morgan has produced an insightful and much-needed book that is a key addition to the literature on twentieth-century US historical writing.
