Hugh Pope has produced a lively and very readable account of the modern Turkic states—Turkey, Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Uzbekistan—and Turkish/Turkic minority communities in China, Europe, and the United States in an effort to explain the increasing involvement and influence of the Turks in international diplomatic and military affairs and global trade, business, and culture. He argues that because “together [the Turkic peoples] constitute one of the world's ten largest linguistic families, numbering more than 140 million people scattered through more than 20 modern states,” from China to the United States, “Turkic peoples can no longer be treated as marginal players on the edge of Europe and the Middle East, or crushed subjects of remote Sections of the Russian and Chinese domains, or distant allies taken for granted by the European Union and the United States. They are becoming noteworthy peoples and prosperous states in their own right, and are developing numerous new connections between each other” (pp. 16, 18–19). Following on his highly successful Turkey Unveiled: A History of Modern Turkey (Overlook Press, 1998), which he cowrote with Nicole Pope, Sons of the Conquerors focuses on the connections between Turks around the world and the potential benefits and drawbacks of increased contact and cooperation.
Using the late Turkish President Turgut Özal's pronouncement at a meeting of Turkic leaders in 1992 that “the 21st century will be ours” as his starting point, Pope sets out a series of vignettes gathered during travels in Turkey, Iran, the Caucasus, Central Asia, China, the Balkans, Europe, and the United States during the period from 1987, when Pope began reporting from Istanbul, to roughly 2005. Thus, the book is part journalism, part travel account. He draws on his experience of living in Istanbul for two decades and on his extensive linguistic skills (in addition to knowing Turkish, he read Arabic and Persian at Oxford). His observations are fair, and he is generous in his praise and forthright in his criticism.
Pope has distilled his experiences into six sections, each purporting to “reflect the collective qualities of the Turkic peoples”: their military vocation (section I); their strong, quarreling leaders (section II); their shared history and neighbors (section III); their pragmatic experience of the Muslim religion (section IV); their love–hate relationship with the West over issues like oil, corruption, and human rights (section V); and their conviction that the coming decades must bring better fortunes than the devastating experiences of the 19th and 20th centuries (section VI).
In section I, Pope argues that “the core genius of the Turks is military organization” (p. 25), evidenced by centuries of conquest by Turkic dynasties like the Mongols and Ottomans, and by the current Turkish military, defender of Turkey's secular democracy, which has taken on increasingly significant international roles, including Kosovo and Afghanistan. Pope also explores the problems inherent in the militarism of Turkish society, including human rights abuses and the stifling of dissent, and the difficulties of developing a civilian-controlled democratic system. Section II discusses the problems of development in the Turkic states. The third section of Pope's work covers the most territory, from the struggle of the Uygurs of China to maintain their ethnic and religious identity against the relentless onslaught of Chinese expansion into Xinjiang Province, to the story of Turks in North America. In section IV Pope recounts his observations of the Turks' approach to religion, which he sees as a pragmatic blending of material and spiritual, in which private piety allows room for public secularism.
Section V contains the most critical chapters in the book, covering the role of gas and petroleum in supporting oppressive regimes; the environmental devastation of cotton monoculture in Uzbekistan; the corruption at all levels of officialdom across the Turkic world; and human rights abuses in Turkey, the Caucasus, and Central Asia. Pope is direct in his criticism that all of the Turkic states are authoritarian, militaristic, and patriarchal, and “… in Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan and Kazakhstan, the region's easy oil money fuels an absolutist political culture … a situation that corrodes legitimacy, breeds corruption, discourages free enterprise and undermines the national sense of purpose” (pp. 291–92). Pope argues that the environmental devastation of Central Asia, like many problems confronting the peoples of the region, can only be solved if the Central Asian leaders cooperate with each other. “But they barely talked to each other. They all feared sharing, knowing that it would undermine their absolute and unearned monopoly of power” (p. 310). In section VI, in addition to issues of integration and assimilation of Turkic communities in Europe and the United States, Pope discusses expansion of ties between the Turkic states and the United States and the European Union.
Reading Sons of the Conquerors, one gets the feeling it would be great fun to travel with Hugh Pope. He is energetic and enthusiastic about meeting and talking with all kinds of people. Pope also has a great sense of humor and a keen eye for the ironic. Pope's writing style is clear and crisp, and he does a good job of setting the stage for each of his vignettes.
Sons of the Conquerors makes for an excellent read, but it is not a book that could easily be adopted for an undergraduate course. It is long, and although not quite repetitive, one does have the sense of whirling in place, without ever reaching any profound conclusion. At the end of the book, one may agree that the Turks cannot be ignored or taken for granted, but Pope does not say why this matters—does the rise of the Turkic world represent a challenge, or will the Turkic century mean prosperity and more opportunity for all?
