Commercially grown sugar cane has earned a distinctive reputation for transforming more than the soil on which it is cultivated. Such commonly used expressions as ‘sugar enclaves’, ‘sugar colonies’ and ‘sugar plantation societies’ imply not merely the establishment of individual sugar-producing units, but their proliferation and pivotal place within the socio-economic and political systems of specific areas. In the Caribbean islands the sugar industry controlled much of the economy of entire European dependencies, such as Barbados, Jamaica and Saint-Domingue, in the colonial days. Intense competition over the acquisition of suitable land to grow sugar even shaped inter-imperial relations across the archipelago. In short, the sugar industry exerted considerable power, one that extended far and wide within and beyond its immediate environment.
Gillian McGillivray's Blazing Cane tracks this phenomenon in Cuba from the last third of the nineteenth century to the onset of the Cuban Revolution. The first three decades of this period began with the anti-colonial struggle that eventually fuelled the movement for the abolition of slavery. Although the insurgents succeeded in keeping the Spanish army in check, in 1898 the United States intervened militarily, putting an end to the protracted war and derailing José Martí's vision of ‘Cuba Libre’. On top of that, the interventionist Platt Amendment of 1902–34 and indirect US neocolonial economic hegemony further exacerbated the unresolved tensions generated during the Spanish colonial era. The tense, divisive climate would come to shape affairs in Cuba during the first half of the twentieth century.
The book argues that sugar figured prominently in the class struggles and the convoluted course of state formation that Cuba followed during the period. Geography was a factor in these developments. Until about 1850 sugar dominated mainly the Havana–Matanzas corridor, which possessed the largest plantations and the bulk of the enslaved working population. The central region was brought into its circuit from that point forward. The eastern provinces came in a distant third, but this changed measurably following the infusion of US capital after 1898. In time, the inevitable frictions over the acquisition of land, capital and labour accompanying the expansion of sugar intensified regional rifts, which came to a head during the 1868 Grito de Yara. In due course separatists turned to an effective tool borrowed from the arsenal of the slaves' day-to-day forms of resistance: torching the estates of pro-Spanish planters. Nevertheless, many of the stated objectives of the uprising remained largely unfulfilled at the conclusion of Spanish rule. Thus, the socio-economic fissures and cane fires increased up to the eve of the Cuban Revolution.
Given the large social and economic distance between the various segments of the Cuban population – imperial officials, peninsulares, Creoles and castas; planters, small farmers, peasants, native workers, coerced labourers, and free immigrants from several global origins – it would appear that their class antagonisms should have reached the boiling point hit during the Grito de Yara and Cuban Revolution at other points in the history of the island. Of course, the post-1820s concentration of Spanish military and economic power in Cuba and Puerto Rico goes a long way in explaining this apparent détente. Without ignoring this powerful deterrent, McGillivray offers another contributing dynamic: the operation of unwritten, yet widely understood, implicit understandings between various opposing groups that kept conflicts from flaring up into island-wide insurgency. In another study published some years ago, Cuba, 1753–1815: Crown, Military, and Society (University of Tennessee Press, 1986), Allan Kuethe hinted at one such informal arrangement in the post-1762 British occupation of Havana, when the Bourbon Crown bestowed aristocratic titles and other concessions on Cuba's colonial elite in exchange for the loyalty of its members. As McGillivray shows, by tacitly putting aside their long-term political aspirations in favour of temporary but hefty economic benefits, planters in effect entered into an uneasy but mutually rewarding ‘colonial compact’ with their superiors in government between 1780 and 1902. Similarly, by engaging in a ‘patron's compact’ (1902–32), hacendados and colonos also yielded power to their US neocolonial bosses in return for guarantees of a ‘safe’ economic environment in which they and their US capitalist allies thrived.
The author carefully documents the alluring influence of sugar as a power broker in all these deals. Convinced that sugar profits would plunge without unfree labour, both sides – planters and imperial functionaries – had a vested interest in keeping enslaved Africans, coolies and Yucatecan captives in check. In the same way, the ‘patron's compact’ allowed sugar barons and colonos to collect handsome profits with minimal government intervention. Thus they curtailed cane fires, strikes, unionisation drives and other forms of workers' activism by establishing and nurturing patron–client relationships within their local communities, which functioned as veritable ‘company towns’. The rural caudillos controlled sugar plantation workers by offering them parcels of land, provisions, jobs, pay rises, promotions, decent living accommodation, health care, credit and access to a variety of job perks – cultural halls, swimming pools, billiard rooms, sport teams, and schooling opportunities – in order to secure their compliance. Those who complained of unmet promises, unpaid wages, workplace exploitation and human rights abuses were unceremoniously discharged, escorted out of the premises or brutalised by the Guardia Rural. As the author notes, such devices have been documented elsewhere in Latin America, as in the ‘pan o palo’ administration of Porfirio Díaz in Mexico.
The ‘populist compact’ (1932–59) was an attempt to stay the course in an age of plummeting sugar prices and the widespread mobilisation of key sectors of Cuban society. The failure of the patrones to deliver the social welfare, urban renewal and modernisation programmes that had kept them in business during the first 30 years of the twentieth century sparked the emergence of countless civic associations committed to various causes, such as women's rights, workers' unions and cultural regeneration. Opposition political parties championing communism, nationalism and the end of US control of Cuba also date from this period. McGillivray contrasts the patron's carefully orchestrated ‘peace’ of the 1902–32 years with the ensuing confrontational and rebellious atmosphere. As the patron–client bonds of dependency began to weaken, populists sought to mend the unravelling social fabric of Cuban society through a combination of persuasion and force. Fulgencio Batista tried the former, but in the end his co-optation tactics became more authoritarian, leading to unprecedentedly high levels of government corruption, oppression and dictatorship, which laid the groundwork for the subsequent revolutionary alternative.
Blazing Cane has made an important contribution to the history of sugar and the world it produced, sustained and transformed in Cuba during a critical historical juncture. It broadens the historiography of the Cuban plantation system by going beyond the insular vision that privileged the western region and its important early role in the sugar revolution as it resurfaced in the Hispanic Caribbean during the eighteenth century. It adds the central and eastern regions to the analysis, enlarging the geographic picture to show how the growth and expansion of the sugar-cane industry rose to national ascendancy. It examines with a hemispheric lens the processes by which sugar came to play a pivotal role in Cuban society, economy and politics, to reveal the larger North American and Latin American context in which the expansion of United States capital is set against the backdrop of caudillismo and populism. Finally, by concentrating on the key dynamic sector of the economy, the work adds new insights to help explain the knotty shifts and twists of Cuban politics that would eventually lead to the 1959 Cuban Revolution.
