Introduction
The decades immediately following the Second World War witnessed an intense preoccupation with the human mind as both a site of vulnerability and a frontier of possibility. Across Western societies, fears of psychological manipulation, popularly crystallised in the notion of ‘brainwashing’, coincided and intersected with an expanding faith in scientific professional psychology and behavioural expertise, as well as with the advent of new media technologies of persuasion, television in particular. In Scandinavia, these global anxieties and hopes found a distinctive expression and were also connected to ambitious and far-reaching ‘psychological defence’ programmes.
This article analyses how public discussions about brainwashing and automatons in Sweden and Denmark explored different ways to navigate the post-war social landscape between 1950 and 1970.Footnote 1 We trace the conceptual career and social anchoring of the term ‘brainwashing’ from its emergence amid Cold War anxieties about mental sovereignty and ideological coercion to its wider use in debates about the emancipatory yet alienating potential of modern technology. We examine the media and cultural narratives surrounding the term, the meanings and contexts attached to the image of brainwashing in public and scientific discourse and the ways these were tied to wider ideals of citizenship and resilience.
While most studies of brainwashing narratives focus on the ‘Red Scare’ in the United States, this article offers a Scandinavian perspective on the reception, development and circulation of brainwashing as a post-war concept and fantasy. Our contribution is not merely a regional footnote to an American story, but a re-scaling. Sweden and Denmark offer a distinct configurational dual logic of fear and fascination surrounding human programming within the modern social (dis)order. Importantly, we contend, the history of brainwashing must be understood against the background of the ‘Nordic model’ of consensual democracy, organised capitalism and universalist welfare.Footnote 2 This approach moves the analysis beyond the dominant freedom/slavery tropes in the US case towards the institutional, educational and media-technological ecologies through which citizenship was cultivated in Scandinavian societies. Moreover, it also allows us to challenge the traditional historiography of the golden years of the welfare state by focusing on their dark underbelly: the nightmarish terror of decapitated human robots or automatons.
This Scandinavian perspective should not, however, be mistaken for an assumption of regional homogeneity. Although Sweden and Denmark shared welfare-state languages of democratic citizenship and social resilience, the article will demonstrate that imaginaries of brainwashing were also shaped by different wartime experiences, alliances and institutional cultures.
We argue that Sweden and Denmark developed distinctive post-war imaginaries that blended dystopian fears about the fragility of the mind with an optimistic conviction in science's capacity to strengthen it. Such social imaginaries shaped not only defence strategies but also broader public conversations about individuality, mental resilience, civil protection, vulnerability and the future of democratic culture. Ultimately, the battle for the post-war mind sheds light on how small states navigated global tensions by rethinking the boundaries between politics, psychology and everyday life.
Approaching Brainwashing – Concepts, Methods and Histories
The ‘automaton’ remains a central idea in the Western imagination, encompassing everything from mechanical installations of automated movement to the simulation of animal or human life in robots, cyborgs and zombies.Footnote 3 Alongside the many machine-as-human narratives are the human-as-machine versions. While narratives of the former have often included a fascination with innovative technology and a pride in human scientific achievement, those of the latter have tended to reveal a dystopian vision. Here, the individual has been reduced to a machine and, in that process, is deprived of its freedom, independence and emotions: in essence, it is stripped of its humanity. This is a dark narrative about the end of independent critical thinking, and one with clear apocalyptic overtones about the extinction of human civilisation.
Several scholars have studied the public circulation of the automaton as a cultural or rhetorical figure by tracing its presence in public discourse, political debates, fiction and film of the Cold War period. Susan Carruthers, for example, refers to a ‘matrix of ideas, images and practices’ capable of transforming geopolitics into storytelling, while Scott Selisker writes of a ‘network of exchange’ in which fact and fiction intermingle.Footnote 4 In this article, we draw on such cultural-historical approaches, which are also represented in the broader field of Cold War cultural studies.Footnote 5 In addition, we have learned from the tradition of conceptual history the benefits of studying a concept or theme when it was first introduced, and of anchoring it in its historical context in order to trace how its meaning changes as it is used by historical agents in different situations.Footnote 6
In the following, we trace the tangled web of brainwashing and automatons through a variety of sources. Our investigation of newspapers has been based on digital searches in the Swedish and Danish Royal Libraries, both of which offer access to a wide range of digitised 20th-century newspapers.Footnote 7 Around 1950, the Swedish and Danish press systems were still largely characterised by newspapers affiliated with a specific political party, but from the 1960s, the trend was towards a predominantly publicist/commercial style with less overt party-political affiliation.Footnote 8 An important exception was the Communist newspapers. We have included newspapers of different political persuasions in this analysis to cover the broader societal debate, but this is not primarily an analysis of the party press. Our newspaper research has been supplemented by other materials, including published and/or translated scientific or academic books, novels, feature films and documentaries from the 1950s and 1960s. Rather than viewing these sources as separate and isolated discursive arenas, we consider them as different parts of a multidirectional conversation. It is in this knowledge circulation or ‘matrix of ideas’, we argue, that the topic of brainwashing and the figure of the automaton emerge and gain their potency and power. This matrix of ideas also takes the form of a social imaginary, to use Charles Taylor's concept: the broad and often implicit understanding of the way a given group of people collectively imagines their social life, encompassing shared expectations, values and norms, as well as the direction of travel and visions of the future.Footnote 9 We do not claim that brainwashing was the social imaginary of the time; rather, we contend that brainwashing was a powerful concept through which wider contestations over the intertwined dystopian and utopian imaginaries of modern science – its promises as well as its perils – were expressed between 1950 and 1970 in Denmark and Sweden.
Previous scholarship has predominantly focused on American cultural representations of automatons and brainwashing.Footnote 10 This historiographical dominance mirrors the general supremacy of US studies in Cold War history, but it also reflects the perception of brainwashing as a phenomenon that particularly threatened American ideals of individual autonomy and freedom. According to Matthew Dunne, ‘[c]oncerns about the state of modern individuality and personal autonomy have been recurring themes in American life, but during the early Cold War they took on a new poignancy when the concept of brainwashing ushered anxieties over Communist psychological warfare into the centre of the national discourse.’Footnote 11 Andreas Killen and Stefan Andriopoulos situate this new discourse on brainwashing in the ‘political demonology that invaded [US] political culture in the 1950s’, as a result of the panic generated by the Cold War.Footnote 12
Several researchers have suggested that the popularisation of the concept coincided with reports about captured US soldiers collaborating in prisoner of war (POW) camps during the Korean War, as well as some soldiers refusing to return home after the war. However, the concept was used for more than merely explaining this alleged betrayal. Brainwashing became a strategic fiction used by American politicians, the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) and other authorities as a propaganda tool to garner domestic support for deterrence and containment.Footnote 13 Selisker argues that in this cultural environment, the brainwashing narrative allowed Western media consumers to ‘see themselves as comparatively free thinkers in a democratic society, vis-à-vis the apparent unfreedom of democracy's enemies’.Footnote 14 Various understandings and definitions flourished (brainwashing, indoctrination and menticide being among the most popular), and it was precisely the plasticity, vagueness and instability of the concept that contributed to its success.Footnote 15
The Cold War threat was no less serious in Scandinavia, which was much closer to the Soviet Union geographically. While Sweden opted to maintain its successful policy of non-alignment, Denmark's experience of occupation by a totalitarian neighbour prompted the country to seek protection under the American nuclear umbrella. Both governments recognised (and sometimes openly admitted) that the Soviet Union was their main adversary, and there was discrimination against the communist parties, including the enactment of laws outlawing ‘fifth column’ activities.Footnote 16 But there was no equivalent to the mass paranoia witnessed in the United States during the 1950s. Like in other European countries, communist and socialist parties remained legal in Scandinavia throughout the Cold War, and they were also represented in parliaments for considerable periods of time. The Danish Communist Party flourished in the early post-war years due to its legacy of resistance during the Second World War. The Swedish Communist Party won more than 10 per cent of the popular vote in the 1944 election, although support declined significantly in the 1950s.Footnote 17
In Scandinavia, the welfare state narrative was arguably more important than the Cold War narrative.Footnote 18 Denmark and Sweden in the 1950s and 1960s were characterised by the rapid expansion of social democratic welfare states that were tax-based and universalist. The welfare state aimed to ensure the security and welfare of citizens through participatory democracy, publicly funded services, legally grounded rights and the redistribution of wealth.Footnote 19 Therefore, its goals went beyond mere material well-being to include normative values such as solidarity and principles of democratic and social equality.Footnote 20 The Scandinavian welfare states were understood as modern and progressive, implying a certain mentality that viewed change for the better as inevitable.Footnote 21
During the Cold War, Scandinavia cultivated the image of a ‘third way’ between US capitalism and Soviet-style communism.Footnote 22 Although Sweden and Denmark were culturally part of the Western bloc (and in Denmark's case also politically due to its membership of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) and the European Economic Community (EEC)), they were far less intimidated by the socialist East's goals of collectivity, equality and solidarity than their American counterparts were. Nevertheless, the Scandinavian welfare state placed a clear emphasis on the rights and responsibilities of the individual citizen. Regarding Sweden in particular, Henrik Berggren and Lars Trägårdh have referred to this system as ‘statist individualism’, highlighting the somewhat paradoxical intertwining of individual independence and state dependency under the main umbrella of fundamental values such as solidarity and egalitarianism. Meanwhile, Bo Stråth uses the term ‘individualism with solidarity’ to explain a special Nordic solution to modernity's tension between freedom and equality.Footnote 23
Analysing the conceptual career of brainwashing in the 1950s and 1960s thus brings together the study of Cold War culture and welfare state ideology, and addresses the key question of what it means to be an independent, responsible, rational and progressive human being and citizen in post-war Sweden and Denmark. What follows is an examination of three themes, to which we add a loose chronology. The first section discusses the initial conceptual instabilities in the early 1950s and the ideological disputes over whether ‘brainwashing’ was a uniquely communist practice. The second section focuses on the late 1950s to early 1960s, when the concept of brainwashing underwent a process of scientification, in which it was studied and quantified by academics. During this period, brainwashing also became tied to a critique of capitalism and advertising, among other subjects. In the third section, we focus on the significance of the emerging cultural representations of brainwashing in film, literature and theatrical plays of the period. In the concluding section, we consider how the social imaginary of brainwashing shaped the cultural context within which the Scandinavian welfare state citizen was constructed in public life.
Conceptual Instabilities and Power Struggles in Public Debate
Most Western commentators in the 1930s and 1940s took for granted that coercive mind control only occurred in totalitarian regimes. Reporting on events in Soviet Russia in the late 1930s, Western journalists wrote about veteran Bolshevik revolutionaries who had suddenly been transformed into submissive and self-incriminating automatons during the Moscow purge trials. In the Second World War, the Gestapo's interrogation of suspected enemies of the regime and captured resistance fighters in the occupied territories became equally infamous. The English-language term ‘brainwashing’ first emerged in the context of the Korean War in the early 1950s. It has been attributed to CIA operative and propagandist Edward Hunter, who translated the Chinese phrase ‘hsi nao’ (wash the brain).Footnote 24
The term ‘brainwashing’ did not immediately gain traction on the other side of the Atlantic. Scandinavian newspapers continued to use a range of familiar terms such as ‘propaganda’, ‘indoctrination’ and ‘mass suggestion’ (propaganda, indoktrinering and massesuggestion in Danish and Swedish) to discuss psychological warfare and to describe the enigmatic but growing conformity and apparent loyalty to communist ideals in Eastern Europe.Footnote 25 The reports underscored the totalitarian nature of these societies, the erosion of individual autonomy and free thought and the authority of leaders over ordinary citizens.
In the early 1950s, it became clear that something similar was happening behind the Bamboo Curtain, though, initially, Swedish and Danish newspapers did not make a connection between mass suggestion in Eastern Europe and China.Footnote 26 Western observers investigated the subject of ideological indoctrination in Chinese communist education, but they did not yet address the nightmarish deconstruction and reconstruction of personalities that would eventually become a key feature in the brainwashing debate in Sweden and Denmark.
It was not until the mid-1950s that Scandinavian newspapers began to use the new term ‘brainwashing’ (hjernevask in Danish and hjärntvätt in Swedish) more systematically, inscribing it in the ideological context of the Cold War. At the time, the term seemed well suited to making sense of the post-war geopolitical situation, in which ‘war’ was as much about spheres of influence and psychological warfare – winning hearts and minds – as it was about guns and missiles.Footnote 27 According to the editor of Information, a Danish anti-communist and pro-Atlanticist newspaper that began as a resistance publication during the Second World War, this marked a fundamental departure from earlier conflicts, with potentially even more devastating consequences. The communists’ treatment of prisoners in Korea had made clear that in modern war, the goal was the conquest of the individual soul: ‘… the prisoner should surrender not just in the sense of giving up but letting himself be transformed. Brainwashed!’Footnote 28
While this psychological warfare phenomenon now had a name, there was still a clear knowledge deficit, and many factors remained uncertain. Was everyone susceptible to brainwashing? Was it possible to recover? And how exactly was a person brainwashed? However, rather than limiting the new term's usefulness, its ambiguity and mystery seemed to make it even more appealing. Initial debates revolved around two partially overlapping issues: the first concerned an ontological uncertainty (what brainwashing actually was), and the second concerned competing ideological worldviews (who was guilty of brainwashing).
In Denmark, Hunter's ideas about Chinese brainwashing were introduced to media audiences in the autumn of 1953 through the paper Information. Correspondent Ole Vinding had taken a personal interest in the phenomenon after meeting Hunter at the Correspondents Club in Hong Kong. Drawing heavily on Hunter's books about Red China, Vinding traced the origins of brainwashing back to a traditional Chinese method of inducing extreme exhaustion until the victim became insane. He claimed that this approach had been scientifically refined by the Soviets through an abuse of Ivan Pavlov's theories of behaviourism and Freudian psychoanalysis, rendering earlier, more primitive methods such as torture superfluous. According to Vinding, brainwashing was carried out at Chinese universities through Marxist lectures and self-criticism sessions that resulted in ‘emotional coldness, automation and lack of willpower’. Most alarmingly, he argued, ‘[t]he human can be brought to the loss of their own self and be provided with an entirely new one through complete memory loss.’Footnote 29 In effect, brainwashing tore the mind apart and aimed to destroy the soul. These early reports of brainwashing laid the groundwork for descriptions of Chinese people as deprived of free will, thoughts and emotions, essentially conditioned into machines.Footnote 30 This orientalised version of brainwash likely thrived on an element of racism, stemming from fears of a ‘yellow peril’.Footnote 31
Around the same time, Sweden's liberal, social democratic and conservative newspapers also started to exploit the ‘yellow peril’ by linking brainwashing to communist China. In November 1953, for instance, Svenska Dagbladet reported on a group of Swedish travellers who displayed clear signs of ‘washed brains’ after visiting the Far East. However, it is unclear to what extent they were actually brainwashed during their trip, as the article ends by describing the travellers as ‘home Bolsheviks’ (hemmabolsjeviker) before they left Sweden.Footnote 32 Uncertainties about the exact meaning of the term and its use are also evident in other Swedish articles from the early 1950s, such as when the liberal evening newspaper Expressen reported on the McCarthyist brainwashing of Catholic children in the United States.Footnote 33
In the United States, the POW controversy had sparked a polarised debate about who was to blame for ordinary American boys succumbing to the enemy's ideology. Poor education, a lack of discipline and overly nurturing mothers were cited as contributing factors.Footnote 34 These ideas were based on the notion that susceptibility to brainwashing resulted from the lack of grounding in (a mythologised version of) American values and culture. This idea was popularised in Scandinavia by the British journalist Philip Deane, whose book Captive in Korea was translated into Danish and Swedish in 1953 and 1954 respectively.Footnote 35 Deane had visited Copenhagen to promote his book in October 1953, and correspondent Ole Vinding had been there to report on the event. Vinding informed his readers that Deane himself had managed to resist brainwashing attempts – but only thanks to the ‘protective powers of Western culture’.Footnote 36 Around the same time, a similar narrative of a robust Western cure against an Eastern infection emerged in a Swedish article in Svenska Dagbladet, which reassured its readers: ‘It may be hard to resist if you are exposed to “brainwashing” long enough, but once you have returned to a democratic country, its effects will soon wear off.’Footnote 37
The idea of brainwashing as a communist phenomenon was not without its critics. Ignoring the claims that Chinese citizens and Western guests were being brainwashed by the Mao regime, the Danish communist newspaper Land og Folk strategically focused on the POW controversy. ‘It does sound like a particularly nasty kind of torture, however in reality, it simply means that many of the former American prisoners, now being released, have lost faith in the United States’ just cause in Korea’, the paper argued. According to the paper, the prisoners had simply realised that communism was ‘the path of humankind to peace and progress’.Footnote 38 There was no ‘Oriental’ mystery about it. However, Land og Folk failed to explain what had happened in the camps or why and how the prisoners had changed their ideological views.
Swedish communist newspapers such as Arbetartidningen and Norrskensflamman took a different approach. In September 1955, actively shifting the focus to what was happening on American soil, Arbetartidningen published some articles about American military academies, where soldiers were allegedly forced into submission through both mental conditioning and physical torture.Footnote 39 Similarly, the Danish paper Land og Folk saw this as evidence of Western hypocrisy about democracy and freedom of speech.Footnote 40 Even liberal and social democratic newspapers discussed whether or not the American training to resist or undo communist brainwashing was too extreme and stressful for the recruits.Footnote 41 One paper asked: ‘Where is the border between training and torture?’Footnote 42
While the contemporary American debates on brainwashing emphasised the danger of ordinary citizens being brainwashed by sinister communist techniques, thus linking individual American psyches to national security, Scandinavian newspaper articles were characterised by a mixture of curiosity and fear.Footnote 43 This was partly due to the reassuring – albeit rarely openly acknowledged – assumption that brainwashing was something that happened ‘over there’ or far away. Most commentators presented the phenomenon as being geographically confined to the communist world. It happened to local populations and to Westerners who found themselves in the Eastern bloc. It was not, or at least not yet, perceived as something that endangered ordinary Swedes and Danes in their welfare cocoons.
Scientification and Broadening of the Brainwashing Phenomenon
By the mid-1950s, the initial vagueness surrounding the concept of brainwashing as the deconstruction and reconstruction of the soul gave way to a more practical and scientific perspective: the reprogramming of the brain. Psychiatrists and psychoanalysts now entered the scene. A particularly important intellectual contribution, widely discussed in Scandinavia, was the Dutch-American psychoanalyst Joost Meerloo's The Rape of the Mind: The Psychology of Thought Control, Menticide, and Brainwashing (1956). The book explored how systematic psychological manipulation could alter people's beliefs and behaviour through techniques of mass submission. Along his detailed examination of totalitarian regimes, Meerloo stressed that brainwashing could also occur in democratic societies.Footnote 44
The shift from soul to brain was accentuated by new scientific experiments with brainwashing in the Western bloc, initially mainly in the United States, but later in other countries, including Scandinavian. Attention focused on the neural effects of removing all sensory stimuli from the brain by completely isolating a person – a process referred to as ‘mental starvation’ (mental svält) in a Swedish newspaperFootnote 45 – and the ability to then feed the subject with new views and opinions. Journalists, enthralled by the spectacular results, reported on the so-called ‘isolation tank’, built by the American neurophysiologist and psychoanalyst John C. Lilly. As one Danish social democratic newspaper mused: ‘One can impart to him [the test subject] practically any beliefs, an entirely new ideology, a completely new perspective on society and people.’Footnote 46
In Swedish and Danish press reports, this scientific version of brainwashing led to a more confident tone. The phenomenon was no longer considered ‘Oriental’ or mystical, but rather something that could be explained by (Western) rational science.Footnote 47 However, this new interpretation brought the danger out of the communist sphere and closer to home since everyone, even Scandinavians, regardless of how firmly they held their beliefs and values, were potential victims of brainwashing. For the post-war Scandinavian social-democratic governments, whose visions of the modern welfare state were moving from desktop plans to practical implementation, the threat of a foreign power implanting in people an entirely new perspective on society was a nightmarish dystopia.
The definitions and plans of what was in Scandinavia known as ‘psychological defence’ are particularly important to consider here. In Sweden, the question of how to deal with the dangers of psychological warfare had been debated since the early 1940s. During this time, Swedish officers and politicians had begun using the term ‘psychological defence’ (psykologisk försvar) to refer to all matters related to resilience training for citizens. This discussion led to the establishment of the so-called Preparedness Board for Psychological Defence (Beredskapsnämnden för psykologiskt försvar) in 1954. The board included representatives from the media sector and the military as well as academics such as university professors in political science and psychology. One of the board's main tasks was to initiate and fund research in the field of propaganda and media effects. This included establishing a methodological framework for the scientific study of brainwashing and indoctrination that was clearly anchored in the behavioural sciences, mathematical theory of communication and quantitative methods. Psychological concepts and conditions such as the spirit of resistance (motståndsanda) and the will to defend (försvarsvilja) were also subject to quantification.Footnote 48
In 1958, two members of the Preparedness Board's research section wrote a report on the ‘main methodological principles’ relating to brainwashing and indoctrination. In this report, they discussed the scientific basis of indoctrination starting with Pavlov's renowned experiments.Footnote 49 Although the report was not widely circulated among the public, it testifies to the commitment of governmental agencies to these issues, as well as the strengthening of the connection between science, industry and defence at this time. This evolving discourse on psychological warfare and defence reflects a process of scientification, defined by sociologist Peter Weingart as when ‘the use of and claim to systematic and certified knowledge produced in the spirit of “truth-seeking” science becomes the chief legitimating source for activity in virtually all other functional subsystems’.Footnote 50
In Denmark, the authorities took a slightly different approach to psychological preparedness. Although the Swedish initiatives initially served as inspiration for the formalisation of Danish civil defence measures aimed at boosting popular resilience and resistance spirit, Denmark did not develop comparable theoretically informed research programmes. Instead, Danish efforts were directed towards more concrete and practical objectives, such as building an organisation capable of maintaining the flow of information, sustaining public trust in the authorities, countering rumours and maintaining calm and public order during times of war or crisis; the latter was perhaps the main priority. Consequently, Danish psychological defence was more operational, administrative and practice-oriented than its Swedish counterpart.Footnote 51 Different geopolitical vulnerabilities and alliance statuses arguably played a role here, as did the stronger Swedish tradition of social science research and its interplay with politics. Another reason, however, may lie in the different historical experiences of the Second World War. Having spent five years under German occupation, the Danes developed in the early post-war era a practical, perhaps even cynical, approach to what was necessary in times of crisis. Conversely, the Swedes, who had no recent experience of war, were freer to indulge in abstract theoretical debates.
In Sweden, the exploration of psychological defence did not remain confined to the delegates of the Preparedness Board but spread to wider circles. One indication of this is the large number of international books on brainwashing that were being translated into Swedish in the 1960s. These included, for example, O. John Rogge's Why Men Confess, J. A. C. Brown's Techniques of Persuasion: From Propaganda to Brainwashing and Theo Löbsack's Die unheimlichen Möglichkeiten oder Die manipulierte Seele: Von der Gehirnwäsche zum gesteuerten Gefühl.Footnote 52 Such translation practices were essential to the scientification process, anchoring key concepts of psychological warfare and psychological defence in the Swedish language and disseminating objects of scientific research in wider social circles and public debates. Alongside books by Swedish academics and circulating non-translated books, they formed a foundation for the circulation of knowledge on the topic of brainwashing and indoctrination, engaging the reading public through introduction and contextualisation by Swedish academics.Footnote 53
The book that received the most attention in Swedish media was the British psychiatrist William Sargant's 1957 Battle for the Mind: A Physiology of Conversion and Brain-Washing, which was translated and published in Swedish the following year.Footnote 54 In the book, Sargant actively linked issues of mind control to the emerging discussion about the dangers of religious cults, advertising and public relations. His views were widely quoted and discussed, for instance, in a lengthy 1957 article in Göteborgs Handels- och Sjöfartstidning, in which the Norwegian professor of psychiatry Ørnulv Ødegård argued that modern psychotherapy was based on principles similar to those of brainwashing. The modern ‘treatment of mental illness is closely related to political brainwashing and religious conversion’ because all rely on ‘the dissolving effect of emotions on the behavioural patterns in the brain’, Ødegård wrote.Footnote 55
Sargant's book appears to have been mentioned only once in the Danish press – in the Swedish translation. Even if the issues it dealt with were frequently debated, the practice of translating foreign scientific works on mind control was less common in Denmark. Instead, the Swedish translations were often imported to Danish libraries. Given the similarity of the languages, a Swedish version would have been considered accessible enough for Danish scientific readers. However, Danish publishers saw a market for dramatic novels on the subject or spectacular journalistic accounts like Deane's, which appealed to a different kind of audience, who were more interested in the entertainment than scientific value of the work.
In the late 1950s, scientification legitimised references to brainwashing in discussions about other social issues. An important debate concerned the growing influence of science and technology and the role of humans in this context. This debate was characterised by a duality: on the one hand, there was a fascination with the revolutionary possibilities of new technologies; on the other hand, there was a fear of human hubris in creating machines that were, or would become, more powerful than humans. New inventions such as the ‘electron brain’ (elektronhjerne, a 1950s name for a computer in Danish) or photocell systems for remote control of motors were hailed as the path to a better future. ‘Man must be robotised’, read a symptomatic headline in the Danish social democratic paper Aktuelt in 1959.Footnote 56 At the same time, the figure of ‘the robot man’ or ‘the human robot’ was frequently invoked, used not only to describe an ideologically brainwashed person but also more generally as a dystopian figure in a mechanised and alienated society of the technologised future. Dreams and nightmares intertwined.
Relatedly, there was an emerging debate about mass media and advertising, which was often condemned as commercial brainwashing that turned people into ‘receptive robots’.Footnote 57 Trivial entertainment offered by modern mass media such as cinema, glossy magazines and television was considered dangerous because it made people complacent, lazy and selfish – the antithesis of the responsible, independent and creative citizen. Advertising was seen as the ultimate manifestation of this ‘dumbing down’ trend. Communists in Sweden and Denmark generally considered advertising harmful due to its association with consumerism, capitalism and the United States. While non-communists shared this view, they considered it dangerous mainly because it challenged the democratic welfare state. In a letter to the editor of Social Demokraten, former Danish social minister K.K. Steincke railed against ‘advertising that appeals to people's selfishness, vanity, craving for pleasure, desire to buy and urge to possess’ and that had ‘affected people's habits, nerves and entire outlook on life’. Such advertising, he argued, had encouraged people to ‘whine about taxes’ and prioritise private consumption over the collective, solidaristic contributions needed to sustain the welfare state. But, Steincke concluded his letter,
how would these disgruntled people actually have fared in the past, be faring now or fare in the future without the colossal sums devoted by the public authorities to child welfare, schools, universities, other educational institutions, combating disease and affordable hospital care, as well as public transport, road maintenance and so on …Footnote 58
Prominent cultural figures also participated in the Swedish and Danish debates on brainwashing and advertising. In the spring of 1957, Swedish writer Sven Lindqvist published a series of critical articles in the weekly magazine Vi on the dangers of advertising. Here, he argued that advertising was a ‘terror of the soul’ and bore a striking resemblance to the brainwashing employed by totalitarian states.Footnote 59 Meanwhile, in Denmark, the famous designer and social critic Poul Henningsen complained that the ‘new “depth-psychological” capitalism is an intestinal worm that burrows into people's brains’. He believed it turned people into slaves and worked exactly like brainwashing: ‘It can be used to make people confess to things they haven't done, but it can also be used to make them buy things they don't want, believe things they've never believed,’ Henningsen argued.Footnote 60
These debates were underpinned by the idea that the success of the modern Scandinavian welfare state depended on the simultaneous development of material welfare, in the sense of prosperity, and cultural and spiritual welfare, in the sense of wellbeing. However, Henningsen, Lindqvist and other commentators argued that prosperity had brought emptiness, superficiality and unhappiness. Problems such as depression, alcohol abuse, anxiety and the use of psychopharmaceuticals like restenil or amphetamine ‘holiday pills’ were becoming increasingly prevalent among the otherwise thriving middle classes. This made them an easy target for brainwashing attempts, whether ideological, consumerist or religious. People risked becoming automatons or spare parts in the wonder machine of modernity's complicated technological and social development, and this threat to welfare (in both senses of the word) was as serious as the nuclear bomb, Henningsen argued.Footnote 61
For participants in these debates, all evils originated in the United States, where big business had become a new kind of dictator. Pretending to work for the nation, it sought only profit. It had taken control of the cultural sector, deceiving politicians and the public alike, rendering them oblivious to the danger and systematically diminishing the intellect of the population, turning them into automatons. A part of this discussion also concerned ‘Americanisation’ as a threat to the social order. Coca-Cola, pin-ups, cartoons and jeans were all seen as symbols of the same hyper-individualistic, brain-dead and anti-social capitalist lifestyle.Footnote 62 The threat might not yet have taken hold at home to the same extent, but it was clearly on its way, the critics warned.Footnote 63 Free art, research and media were needed to save Scandinavian style (social) democracy.
In fact, the Scandinavian critique of mass media and advertising reflected similar trends in American debates.Footnote 64 There was a transatlantic fear of modern social disorder, leading to a loss of rationality and autonomy, and thus to an incapacitation of democracy. In Sweden and Denmark, however, the danger was not only framed as the erosion of individual autonomy but also of collective citizenship, thereby endangering the welfare society, as the quote from Steincke above clearly expresses.Footnote 65 The human robot, alienated from society by relentless capitalist and consumerist brainwashing, no longer cared to pay his taxes for the benefit of the society as a whole, and had forgotten that he had prospered from (and was dependent on) social benefits such as free education and healthcare.Footnote 66
A distinction can be observed between the debates in Denmark and Sweden. While concerns regarding the threat to individual autonomy were more explicitly subordinated to a greater emphasis on welfare in Sweden, the Danish discourse afforded equal significance to the concepts of freedom and welfare. A characteristic example appears in an interview with the Danish social democratic Minister of Education, Julius Bomholt, in 1956. According to Bomholt, individual freedom and collective welfare were closely linked. It was the double experience of Nazism and Stalinism that ‘… provided us with a deeper understanding of the significance of individual freedom, without fundamentally altering our concept of solidarity … [which] in this context, refers to the socialist idea of human liberation from coercion and exploitation, positively expressed through an active humanism’.Footnote 67
Again, a possible explanation for this inter-Scandinavian difference may be the Danish experience of occupation from 1940 to 1945, whereas Sweden had no recent experience of unfreedom. Another important aspect, also discussed in previous research, is that welfare ideology and its entrepreneurs maintained a more prominent position in Sweden compared to Denmark because of the Swedish Social Democrats’ traditionally stronger political hegemony. The Swedish Social Democratic Party (SAP) had governed continuously since 1932, giving it the political space to build a comprehensive, universalist welfare model with the firm support from the trade union confederation. In contrast, Danish social democrats more often governed in coalition or minority positions and had been constantly forced to bargain with agrarian and liberal parties, producing a welfare state that, while still largely universalist, retained room for a bourgeois-liberal counterweight and ideology of freedom.Footnote 68
In Sweden, it was even possible, at least in the 1960s when the discourse of brainwashing became even more widespread, to discuss some of the potentially constructive or even positive effects of programmed citizens. When the issue of young criminals arose in the early 1960s, one newspaper article reported on ‘educational and highly democratic brainwashing’ at a youth correctional facility with a remarkable turnout. Two years later, another article interviewed a doctor and superintendent of the Royal Medical Board who considered the brainwashing of difficult young people to be a possible method of rehabilitation.Footnote 69 Swedish newspapers also used the idea of positive brainwashing to describe the main challenge posed by the so-called ‘H-Day’, the national right-hand traffic reorganisation (the letter ‘H’ standing for ‘right’ or ‘right-hand’, höger), which took place in Sweden on 3 September 1967. ‘All left-side thinking should be erased’, as one paper put it.Footnote 70
By the 1960s, debates about brainwashing had expanded beyond Cold War politics to encompass broader social concerns, but its ideological and military dimensions remained prominent. The Vietnam War renewed attention to ideological brainwashing in ‘hot’ wars, and Danish military circles expressed concern about the use of brainwashing in modern warfare, acerbated because the issue of psychological warfare and disinformation had emerged as a key feature of the global Cold War. Officers argued that soldiers who were indifferent to the society in which they lived would be more receptive to propaganda and, ultimately, more inclined to surrender.Footnote 71 They therefore called for civic education as part of psychological defence: soldiers needed to understand and value the Nordic welfare model if they were to resist attempts, whether domestic or foreign, to undermine it. This educational task was considered particularly urgent for younger generations, both soldiers and civilians. Officers portrayed young people as complacent, arguing that those who had grown up without material hardship took the welfare state for granted and lacked motivation to defend it. They were (perceived to be) more likely to endanger it due to their ignorance and lack of appreciation; hence, they were more in need of education and, indeed, a strengthened psychological defence.
Artistic and Fictional Accounts of Brainwashing
Fictional accounts played a significant role in shaping popular conceptions of brainwashing, as the power of the automaton lies more in the nightmare than in the physical reality.Footnote 72 The effectiveness of the brainwashing discourse stemmed from people's belief in the phenomenon. In the context of the Cold War and the growing international flow of media content through television in particular, the cultural texts of brainwashing spread across borders, providing transnational dystopian imaginaries of totalitarian society and unfreedom. In its typical version, a new kind of technology is introduced that enables a dictator to control individuals with disastrous results. A few individuals who are somehow able to resist or break free from the power of brainwashing take up the fight against totalitarian slavery, even within their own minds.
Fictional accounts of brainwashing appeared in literary novels, theatre productions and radio plays, often being adapted from one format to another. In the late 1950s, three key international works portrayed the nightmarish reality of brainwashing, all of which were discussed and critiqued in Sweden and Denmark. First, in 1956, came the first feature film adaptation of George Orwell's science fiction novel Nineteen Eighty-Four. It clearly fed the brainwashing discourse with its references to the ‘Thought Police’ and the mind control campaign to which the main character Winston Smith was subjected and by which he was eventually broken. Like the film adaption of Orwell's previous novel Animal Farm, this was secretly funded by the CIA.Footnote 73 When the film premiered in Sweden in 1957, some critics remarked on the great difficulty of adapting Orwell's original and rather gruesome story of brainwashing.Footnote 74
Second, the science fiction author Aldous Huxley, who was already considered an expert on brainwashing and totalitarian societies due to his 1931 novel Brave New World, offered a contemporary commentary on brainwashing and drugs in the non-fiction sequel Brave New World Revisited. It was published in 1958 and translated into Swedish and Danish the following year. While the book received less attention in Swedish newspapers,Footnote 75 Danish newspapers published several of Huxley's opinion pieces on the subject.Footnote 76 In 1961, the author also visited Copenhagen to deliver a lecture, in which he claimed that his (rather than Orwell's) dystopian visions seemed to be prevailing, as homogenisation and conformity would be achieved through brainwashing and propaganda, not threats and terror. Technological advances, particularly in mass communication, were causing unwanted centralisation, and humanity was becoming a cog in the machine.Footnote 77
A third key work in the social and cultural depiction of brainwashing in the late 1950s and early 1960s was the neo-noir psychological film thriller The Manchurian Candidate, which tells the story about the Korean War veteran and brainwashed sleeper agent Raymond Shaw. Directed by John Frankenheimer and based on a 1959 book by Richard Condon, the film premiered in March 1963 in Sweden and a month later in Denmark.Footnote 78 Not surprisingly, given the subject matter, the Danish communist paper Land og Folk dismissed it as a ‘waste of time’.Footnote 79 In contrast, the liberal newspaper Jyllands-Posten seized the opportunity to lecture its readers on the phenomenon of ideological brainwashing and highlight the dangers posed by ‘the forces working hysterically and hypocritically to ruin their own society’.Footnote 80 This was a thinly veiled reference to the contemporary peace movement which liberal and conservative Cold Warriors often accused of deliberately or unwittingly aiding the enemy.
However, the Scandinavians did not only import brainwashing fiction. They produced it, too. One example is the 1960 novel The City that Resisted (Byen der ikke adlød) by Niels E. Nielsen, one of Denmark's most significant science fiction authors.Footnote 81 In this novel, a Cold War-like conflict has divided the world into two opposing blocs, and the opening pages relate the capitulation of an unnamed democratic city-state to its totalitarian opponent, the Central Union. The Central Union's social scientists have developed the ultimate superweapon: a brainwashing machine called the Stig. The novel exhibits classic traits of international brainwashing fiction: the Stig leaves no physical scars when it destroys an individual's old personality and rebuilds an entirely new one. Moreover, the novel's protagonist, Peter Daniel, reluctant leader of a resistance movement, is soon caught and subjected to the Stig. The main scientist eventually develops moral scruples, and in the end, he secretly rescues Daniel by giving him keywords that restore his memories, a plot reminiscent of The Manchurian Candidate.
Although set in the future, the book was a commentary on contemporary society. With the novel, Nielsen (himself a member of the Home Guard) condemned the complacency of those who, persuaded by enemy propaganda to ignore danger, failed to fight for democracy. The book also drew on contemporary critiques of social science, yet it was imbued with the techno-fetishism of the time, playing on the duality between possibilities and threats. The enemy was described as a ‘technified rocket army’ that attacked while the remote-controlled floor cleaner, an object of wild fantasy in 1960's Denmark, hummed in Daniel's kitchen. An ‘intravision’, like Orwell's ‘telescreen’, connected prison inmates and officers, ‘the cosmovision’ (television) was at the same time the means of deceiving people into defeatism and bringing them the truth and hope, and of course the Stig is a dream machine for a better world turned into a nightmare. Indeed, contemporary audiences read The City that Resisted as a warning. One review stated that even if Nielsen did not have the authority of Orwell and Koestler, the book presented a necessary and dire warning of a potential dark future.Footnote 82
A Swedish example of brainwashing fiction was Ivan Oljelund's The Water of Truth (Sanningsvattnet), published in 1962.Footnote 83 Quite unlike the Danish novel, Oljelund's book was light-hearted with a humorous tone, described by one reviewer as ‘a joking utopia’, which was symptomatic for the general reception of the book in the Swedish press.Footnote 84 It tells the story of Dr Peter Nimbus, a chemist who discovers a truth serum which makes the individual free, natural, honest and sincere. Oljelund's novel thus depicts the cheerful flip side of brainwashing, introducing a miracle drug that liberates individuals and has a brief but positive effect by turning society upside down (the defence minister turns out to be a radical pacifist, and the social democratic minister of finance cuts taxes).
Taken together, these cultural texts amplified the perceived threat of brainwashing by combining dystopian fantasies with real-world sociotechnical concerns about totalitarian control, psychological manipulation and the misuse of science. But they could also, like Oljelund's novel, suggest constructive and liberating effects of drugs and mind control, approaching the contemporary scientific discussion of the effects of drugs on mental health. This interplay of fact and fiction created a powerful cultural matrix or social imaginary that both reinforced and challenged the nightmarish vision of the human automaton as a profound threat to individual autonomy and social integrity.
Scandinavians between Conformity and Individuality
In this article, we have analysed Swedish and Danish imaginaries of brainwashing in the early Cold War era. We have argued that these imaginaries were not only tied to East-West ideological and military contests. They also reflected deep uncertainties about the nature of human agency, autonomy and the role of technology in shaping modern life. Our perspective has underscored the duality of modernity, where every promise of advancement carries with it a shadow of disruption, alienation or control.
In the early decades of the Cold War, brainwashing was considered the mental equivalent of the atomic bomb: total war taken to the extreme. At first shrouded in ‘oriental’ mysticism, the phenomenon later intertwined with discussions of modern science, heightening its sinister nature. It went beyond mere susceptibility to propaganda or mass suggestion, and beyond crude physical torture; rather, souls and brains were destroyed and rebuilt. Brainwashing linked the mysterious indoctrination of POWs and ordinary people in China with the mass suggestion of the Soviet Union and its allies. In doing so, it revealed a power dynamic that effectively transformed individuals into automatons and mechanised entities.
The spectre of brainwashing emerged as a potent symbol of dystopia in Swedish and Danish public cultures. It appeared in newspaper columns, in policy debates, in educational spheres, in popular science writing, and it was widely discussed in the expanding realms of radio and television. Although often inspired by high-profile international events such as reports on communist re-education camps in the Korean War, images of brainwashing did not merely imply strictly military or geopolitical threats, but also deeply existential ones. The independent, rational Scandinavian citizen was frequently depicted as being vulnerable to covert psychological warfare that could undermine democratic values.
As the concept of ‘total defence’ in Scandinavia developed to include ‘psychological defence’, authorities and experts sought to protect populations from panic, propaganda and manipulation. Pamphlets, training exercises and public information campaigns emphasised the importance of remaining calm, disciplined and in control of one's emotions. These were considered essential civic virtues in an age of atomic peril, ideological confrontation and misinformation. Thus, psychological preparedness thus became a central component of a discourse of resilience, revealing how civil defence planning penetrated everyday life and reconfigured understandings of citizenship in a post-war welfare state.
The fear of brainwashing was not only directed at the communist enemy. From the late 1950s and onwards, the discussion of brainwashing broadened from the narrow confines of the Cold War to encompass ethics and religion, advances in new medicine and neurology, the technical development of new media and the impact of advertising and commercialism. The topic appeared in popular fiction as well as in discussions about the direction of behavioural science and education and in philosophical treatises on the concept of human free will.
Yet, as our analysis has shown, these dystopian imaginaries co-existed with, and were sometimes offset by, a robust techno-optimism characteristic of the early post-war era. The 1950s and 1960s saw the consolidation of psychology as a scientific and professional field, and the potential it offered to enhance human decision-making, communication and emotional stability resonated strongly in Sweden and Denmark. There was widespread enthusiasm for mental testing and personality assessment, and new therapeutic methods flourished. Psychological expertise became integral to schools, workplaces, the military and social welfare institutions.Footnote 85 The belief that modern behavioural science could help forge resilient, enlightened citizens aligned neatly with broader Scandinavian and social democratic narratives and values of rational planning, social engineering and progressive governance.
Matthew W. Dunne has argued that brainwashing debates in the United States were essentially about American anxieties about modern individuality and personal autonomy.Footnote 86 The idea of ‘slavery’ was a key feature of these debates, and Susan Carruthers has shown how this Cold War mindset drew on a particular American tradition of perceiving any infringement of individual freedom as ‘slavery’.Footnote 87 Our analysis of the Swedish and Danish cases reveals that, while negative imaginaries echoed US Cold War tropes, they were reconfigured within a welfare-state project. While debates in Sweden and Denmark also revolved around notions of freedom and unfreedom, they were framed very differently. There, the threat of the brainwashed individual was a danger not only to free will but also to the community and the collective ideals of the democratic welfare state as the ideal path to progress, peace and prosperity. Questions of enslavement, entrapment and containment were subordinated in Scandinavian narratives, particularly in the Swedish ones, whereas freedom and welfare assumed more of an equal significance in the Danish context.
In the 1950s and 1960s, brainwashing was a social imaginary that served to explain and link the multitude of nightmarish threats to the Scandinavian dream of welfare societies populated by informed citizens. At a time of rapid technological change, geopolitical uncertainty and ideological conflict, brainwashing sparked an important social debate about what it meant to be an independent, responsible, rational and progressive member of society. The brainwashed automaton, a dreaded concept, was contrasted with the autonomous and rational welfare state citizen who was actively engaged in the democratic process. The welfare state's emphasis on education, psychological resilience and social welfare was seen as a bulwark against the dehumanising forces of brainwashing, whether of political totalitarianism or commercial manipulation. However, in Swedish and Danish public discourse, the informed citizen was no less ‘socially engineered’ as a responsible individual. It is therefore interesting to underline the apparent individualist strain within the framework of what is often called the ‘Nordic model’ of welfare societies, not least since the responsibilities and duties of the autonomous and self-sufficient citizen seem to have been at the core of Scandinavian discourses on brainwashing and human automatons. In Sweden and Denmark, we argue, narratives of brainwashing were embedded in ideas of a psychological defence, or even ‘psychological welfare’, to counter psychological warfare. Total defence meant protecting every citizen by the efforts of every other citizen. In other words, it was about freedom of thought, but within specific parameters that favoured social stability and conformity.
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to thank Professors Johan Östling and Thorsten Borring Olesen for their thoughtful and sustaining comments on earlier versions of this draft. We also want to thank the editor and anonymous reviewers for their incisive and exacting reading of the manuscript.
Funding statement
This article is the result of research projects funded by the Crafoord Foundation (grant 20210610) and the Swedish Research Council (grant 2019–02664).
