At a time when debates about the compatibility of Islamic theologies and law with democratic citizenship do not subside, Asef Bayat's Making Islam Democratic issues an authoritative reminder that citizens of Muslim-majority countries are in fact reconciling their religious identities with advocacy for human rights and democracy as we speak. Analyzing social-movement activism in Iran and Egypt between 1960 and 2004, Bayat illustrates the various ways in which local actors have made and continue to make “Islam democratic” irrespective of the kind of Islam governmental ideologies and state-sanctioned orthodoxies seek to impose. The voices of both street- and high-level politics are given a forum throughout the book; we read of women's-rights activists, student leaders, labor unionists, representatives of professional associations, petitioners, and parliamentarians. In different ways, they frame their appeals for transparent and accountable politics in Islamic terms, arguing for equality and civil liberties with reference to a repertoire of classical and modernist Islamic jurisprudential, theological, and philosophical arguments.
Bayat's analyses of these everyday struggles for democratic government in Iran and Egypt have particular appeal because they integrate three approaches all too often kept separate in contemporary studies of democratization: regime-type analyses, political theology, and social-movement studies. First, Bayat outlines the implications of the divergent regime types under which social movements in Iran and Egypt operate. These include the secular-authoritarian politics of Egypt, where autocrats have turned to co-opting political Islamists when politically opportune, and the theocratic but secularizing politics of Iran, where government increasingly resembles that of its secular-authoritarian neighbors while drawing on an official Islamic orthodoxy to repress democratically minded and other opponents. Second, Bayat analyzes the political-normative discourses these social movements invoke in order to frame their struggles in Islamic terms (and to thereby redefine concepts of Islamic justice). Third, he employs concepts of social-movement analysis to illustrate the dynamic of mobilization–repression cycles and other state–society interactions. Bayat succeeds in illustrating how political theologies inspire social-movement activism and how the regime type matters in circumventing and shaping the forms of and spaces for political activity. In both countries (whether nominally secular or nominally theocratic), the struggle for democratic reform is twofold: against the authoritarian state and against fundamentalist social forces that buttress both violent and nonviolent action with references to illiberal readings of the religious sources. While Bayat acknowledges the importance of religion in shaping the repertoire of political and ideational references, he persuasively shows how the privileging of literal readings of religion prevalent in so many contemporary reflections on Islam and democracy in Egypt and Iran falls into an essentialist trap. When other scholarly accounts seek to identify “authoritative” voices of Islam, Bayat lets ordinary believers speak for themselves. As he writes in the introduction,
Resorting to mere literal readings of scripture to determine the democratic thrust of a religion will not take us very far, . . . because individuals and groups with diverse interests and orientations may find their own, often conflicting truths in the very same scriptures. . . . We need to examine the conditions that allow social forces to make a particular reading of the sacred texts hegemonic. And this is closely linked to groups’ capacity to mobilize consensus around their “truth.” . . . The challenge is to give democratic interpretation material power, to infuse them with popular consciousness.
A book such as this could only have been written by a scholar deeply familiar with the societies he describes and analyzes and who has lived among and interacted with the very actors that drive these social processes. Bayat's account draws on a multitude of primary and secondary sources—including domestic and international news coverage, reports by local nongovernmental organizations, personal interviews, publications for the legal profession, and protest banners and petitions—that bring out voices represented in few other accounts of protest politics in the two societies. It is refreshing that the author portrays women as part of these struggles for systemic reform, and not only of those for women's rights. He shows how women also contributed to workers’ petitions for higher wages, students’ demands for freedom of assembly, and judges’ demands for meritocratic appointment practices. Advocacy for women's rights and gender-egalitarian exegeses of the religious sources is portrayed in conjunction with other rights campaigns, not as a separate endeavor. Bayat thereby departs from an unfortunate tendency in social-movement studies of the Middle East to analyze women's-rights struggles as if divorced from other street and elite politics.
Bayat has written a superbly crafted book that reorients scholarly attention away from essentialist debates about the compatibility of Islam and democracy—which all too often focus on a notion of Islam represented by a few self-proclaimed or state-sanctioned “Islamic authorities”—toward bottom-up social processes that “make Islam democratic” by virtue of their everyday sociopolitical activism. His book is indispensable not only for students of contemporary Iranian and Egyptian politics but also for those interested in the politics of social movements and the political-normative discourses they use (and redefine) to validate demands for democratic reforms.
