The aim of this book is to shed light on Iranian women's status and condition through a glance at their lives and activities from the 19th century to the present. It is a collection of ten essays and also contains a chronology and an introduction.
Guity Nashat analyzes the institution of marriage under the Qajars, arguing that religion, not the state, played the official role. The most common type of marriage, she argues, was the consanguineous one encouraged by the law of inheritance. The author affirms that, for poor families, marriage was the best survival strategy for their daughters. She also argues that some upper class women, especially those of the harem, managed to influence their powerful husbands. Shireen Mahdavi writes about the encounter between European women travelers and Iranian women under the Qajars. She underlines Europeans' erroneous perceptions of Iranian women, who are often portrayed as passive and subordinated in travelers' accounts. She argues that these accounts are marred by value judgments and that some women, especially in the court, were powerful while some others, who had a romantic vision of the West and had a Western model in mind, struggled for women's literacy and emancipation.
Mansoureh Ettehadieh analyzes the emergence of the women's movement during the Constitutional Revolution, arguing that women's high illiteracy, their financial dependence on men, and the ambiguity of Islamic laws were among the factors impeding the expansion of the movement. Under Reza Shah, the women's movement was placed under the control of the state. This finding, along with the politicization of women's issues under the modernizing Pahlavi states, became the main obstacles to the movement's development. This argument, however, is challenged by Mahnaz Afkhami, who praises the national and international activities of the official Women's Organization of Iran (WOI), created in 1966 and led by Princess Ashraf, the Shah's twin sister. Afkhami, who was the WOI general secretary between 1970 and 1978, mostly relies on her personal experience and information to describe the organization's interactions with the royal court, the government, and the clergy. She thus presents WOI's state feminism as the crystallization of the women's movement in Iran and qualifies its leaders as the movement's leaders. Despite the rich information provided, the contribution suffers from lack of critical arguments and often exaggerates the extent of WOI's activities and popularity among ordinary women. Likewise, Haleh Esfandiari praises the progress of the women's movement under the Pahlavis and the undertakings of women members of the Parliament and the Senate to improve the legal status of women. She also briefly discusses women members of the Islamic Parliament during the Iran–Iraq War and concludes that it was thanks to women's achievements in the 1960s and the 1970s that they could resist the regressions imposed by the Islamic republic, which wanted to send women back to domesticity.
Ziba Mir-Hosseini divides the current religious discourses on women into three categories: traditionalist, neotraditionalist, and modernist. Although gender equality and women's rights are absent from the first discourse, the second is sensitive to gender debates and to secular and religious women's criticisms of the shariעa's patriarchal prejudice. The modernists, the author argues, advocate gender equality.
Two contributions deal with women's participation in the labor force. Fatemeh Etemad Moghadam argues that, despite the increase in women's education, for ideological reasons the Islamic regime recognizes their employment primarily in activities derived from female sexuality and reproductive labor, such as child raising and household labor. For Amir Mehryar, Gholamali Farjadi, and Mohammad Tabibian, the share of women in the labor force remained steady, with a slight rise in the three decades before the revolution, but declined in the 1980s, especially in rural areas, before rising again in the 1990s. Contrary to Etamad Moghadam, who stresses the Islamic regime's segregation policies, these authors highlight cultural impediments toward middle class women's participation in some sectors of the economy—considered by their families as unsuitable for women—to explain women's low labor-force participation activity rate. They further argue that gender segregation policies in the aftermath of the revolution boosted women's employment in the public sector. According to the authors, higher numbers of female university graduates will increase unemployment rates in the coming years, and to find employment, women must change their perceptions of suitable jobs.
The last two contributions concern rural and tribal women, who are much less studied than their urban counterparts. Erika Friedl and Lois Beck both write about changes and continuities in rural and tribal women's perceptions. Government-launched literacy and birth-control campaigns, along with a market-oriented economy, have had important consequences in the lives of younger women, inspiring hope for women's better future, despite persisting hardships.
Overall, the book lacks originality because most of the essays are revised versions of previously published materials. Moreover, the book does not provide a balanced and coherent picture of women's lives, experiences, and struggles during the past two centuries as evidenced by the uncritical essays that deal with Mohammad Reza Shah's period. Finally, it is not clear why two essays, often overlapping, are devoted to women's low labor-force participation while the book contains no specific contribution that treats social and cultural spheres in which women's presence is quite high. Despite these shortcomings and although this collection cannot be considered an original contribution to the field, it still is likely to be of interest to nonspecialists.
