Relying heavily on judicial sources concerning freedom claims made by women in Havana and Rio de Janeiro during the 1870s and 1880s, this illuminating study places women at the centre of slaves’ emancipation efforts and shows how slavery, emancipation and freedom were gendered, in theory as well as practice. The enslaved and free(d) women who populate the pages of this book occupied the lowest rungs of their respective societies, yet they engaged with authorities, patrons and slave owners in protracted negotiations to claim their personal rights or those of their children. Camillia Cowling makes a convincing case that their actions were in many ways collective, as they were grounded in networks of communication and support that shared information, provided material assistance and facilitated contacts with institutions, authorities and sympathetic mediators. These collective efforts were linked to broader Atlantic debates about slavery and emancipation and helped shape social understandings of freedom, gender and citizenship. Humble and destitute these women were, but their actions were consequential beyond the relatively narrow limits of their own individual claims.
The book builds on the growing historiography of slaves and the law in the Americas to analyse how slaves and freed people of colour engaged with the law and contributed, through their actions, claims and sheer determination, to shaping legal developments and interpretations. Previous historians have already established that slaves challenged the gradualist approach crafted by legislators, who sought to reconcile emancipation with lingering fears about social control and racial contamination. It is also known that women were particularly active in this process. However, Conceiving Freedom makes several important contributions to the legal history of slavery and to the historiography of emancipation. To start with, the book not only demonstrates that women ‘were at the front line of daily battles for freedom that collectively helped speed and shape the end of slavery’ (p. 215), but goes beyond this to show that gender was central to urban slave life, to the legal culture concerning slavery and manumission, and to emancipation debates.
The intimate links between women, slavery and the law were certainly not new. According to the Roman principle of partus sequitur ventrem, it was through women that slavery was reproduced to begin with, as children followed the social condition of the mother. The passage of ‘free womb’ laws in Spain (1870) and Brazil (1871) reinforced the centrality of gender in emancipation conflicts and transformed women into key actors in those conflicts. The enslaved female ‘wombs’ that had been traditionally conceived as engines for the reproduction of slavery became spaces for the literal gestation of freedom, so motherhood, emancipation and freedom became inescapably linked. In turn, the meanings and social implications of slave motherhood and their children's ‘freedom’ were hotly contested. Elite thinkers, abolitionists, jurists, state officials and slave holders tried to shape those meanings and to define the limited freedoms promised by the emancipation laws, subjecting enslaved and freed mothers to new levels of scrutiny. But as Cowling shows beautifully, women seized the new legal spaces created by these laws, pushed hard to translate vague promises of freedom into concrete benefits for themselves and their children, and claimed the right to define motherhood and womanhood on their own terms. To many freedwomen who gave birth while still in captivity, motherhood meant first and foremost the right to enjoy the custody of their children. Slave owners frequently contested such rights, for maternal custody deprived them of the child's labour, to which they were entitled for a number of years, and also cast doubts on their own roles and obligations as alleged parental figures for the children under their tutelage.
The book also makes an important contribution to comparative studies of slavery. Much of the scholarship on slaves and the law in Latin America has been informed, explicitly or not, by comparative arguments that contrast the development of slave legal regimes in the region with the United States. Frank Tannenbaum's Slave and Citizen (1946) is the best known of these comparative studies. By focusing on two Iberian urban slave societies, Conceiving Freedom highlights some important differences between the legal regimes and opportunities in societies that, in traditional comparisons with the United States, are frequently assumed to be similar. For instance, whereas freedom claims in Rio de Janeiro were channelled through the courts, in Cuba slaves appealed to a variety of state institutions and officials. Manumission had been conceived as a slave's legal right since the 1840s in Cuba, whereas in Rio de Janeiro this did not happen until the passage of the Rio Branco Law of 1871. Abolitionists mobilised against slavery in Brazil, whereas their activities were considerably more muted in Havana, still under colonial rule.
Yet the similarities are overwhelming, beginning with the timing of the similar free womb laws that sought to regulate the process of emancipation in each case. Two of these similarities appear to be particularly important. First, manumission was widely practised in each of these societies, which were home to large communities of free people of colour. Second, as the author notes, Cuba and Brazil were ‘similar to one another (and different from many other slave societies) in that there existed a long-held assumption that enslaved people would, to some degree, participate in the law's implementation’ (p. 49, Cowling's emphasis). This assumption was grounded not on the letter of Iberian laws, but on the initiatives of countless slaves who, for centuries, had tried to transform abstract legal provisions into personal rights. The free womb laws widened opportunities for claims-making, but many such practices had deep historical roots. The author frequently stresses that claims and arguments took on ‘new resonance’ (p. 79) in the 1870s, or that they reflected ‘changing ideas’ about women, maternity, pity and charity (p. 97). In order to assess the scope of these changes, however, it is essential that serious research about these issues be carried out across longer periods of time, an invitation that historians should seriously consider.
Deeply researched and richly argued, Conceiving Freedom is a major contribution to the study of slavery, gender, emancipation and the law in Latin America.
