An intriguing trend in North American theology over the past decade has been the willingness of certain evangelical, even fundamentalist, theologians to join conversations previously held in mainline theological circles alone. These theologians are grounded in scripture and formed by orthodox tradition, but bring to the table an appreciative yet critical familiarity with the fashionable thinkers of contemporary academic theology. In contrast to an analytically orientated and sometimes insular guild, which has too often ignored or dismissed them, one senses in these evangelical theologians a far more obvious desire to serve the lived Christian faith. Engaging the academic theological establishment on its own terms, they seek to reclaim the discipline as a vibrantly ecclesial (even pious!) undertaking, and not merely a scholarly one.
Does this trend point to an across-the-board change in the character and goals of serious academic theology? Time will tell. But if Michael Horton's new book, Lord and Servant, is any indication, then we have reason to hope it will. The book is an intricately argued, fresh and stimulating work, the second volume (following Covenant and Eschatology: The Divine Drama) in four-part undertaking. In a manner reminiscent of Barth's creative retrieval of elements from then out-of-fashion Reformed scholasticism, Horton draws on Reformed federal theology to develop the concept of covenant in original and highly evocative ways.
Horton's interlocutors include many names one would expect in current theological works of a certain philosophical cast: Levinas, Derrida, Ricoeur, Jean-Luc Marion, Mark C. Taylor, to name just a few. He also engages in critical and fruitful discussions with theologians such as Barth, Moltmann, Colin Gunton and Robert Jenson. But what is unique is Horton's effort to broaden the conversational circle by bringing the aforementioned thinkers into dialogue with that strand of Reformed thought represented by the likes of Peter Martyr Vermigli, Francis Turretin, John Owen, B. B. Warfield, Herman Bavinck, Louis Berkhof and Cornelius Van Til. Horton also demonstrates his federalist bona fides by thoroughly grounding his theology in the biblical narrative, employing the insights of scripture scholars as much as he does theologians and philosophers. He owes a particular debt to federalist biblical scholar Meredith Kline, but converses as well with Eichrodt, N. T. Wright, Brevard Childs and Walter Brueggemann.
Horton's primary concern is ‘that covenant is far more important as an architectonic scheme in scripture than is often recognised in dogmatics. It is not only a locus in scripture, but the environment within which the drama of creation, fall, redemption, and consummation unfolds’ (p. vii). Yet simply reclaiming ‘covenant’ as a concept will not suffice, because it can be distorted in individualistic, speculative and ahistorical ways. To avoid this, and to maintain the scriptural sense that the covenant has an external telos, Horton couples his consideration of covenant with eschatology, establishing the field of play for his four-volume project. Lord and Servant focuses on Christology and soteriology, but does so within a trajectory that stretches from the (eternal) covenant to the eschatological end. This gives the book a breadth that resembles a compact systematic theology, although Horton demurs in labelling it such. He calls his writing instead ‘a series of contributions to contemporary reflection’ (p. xiii). The description is apt, for it explains how the book can be in turn (and sometimes simultaneously) philosophical, constructive, polemical, historical, apologetic, biblical and – perhaps not surprisingly – occasionally disjointed.
A selective summary of Lord and Servant should illustrate these particular observations, while also describing its broader logic. The book's three main parts correspond to federal theology's assumption of three fundamental covenants, although Horton could make this correspondence more explicit. In his first part, ‘Lord’, Horton establishes terms by arguing how the biblical understanding of salvation is better characterised as ‘meeting a stranger’ than ‘overcoming estrangement’, phrases he borrows from Tillich and uses to exclude Neoplatonic Gnosticisms, ancient and contemporary. He builds on this theoretical prolegomenon by then undertaking an exegetical-theological consideration of how the ‘triune God is known in his works, not in his essence’ (p. 22), that is, by God meeting us in concrete, historical initiatives and not through our abstract speculation on the divine being. With these claims in place, Horton outlines how the eternal, intra-trinitarian ‘covenant of redemption’ serves as the basis and impetus for two historical covenants which God establishes with humanity in the economy of salvation. These are the prelapsarian ‘covenant of creation’ made with Adam and the ‘covenant of grace’ initiated just after the fall and fulfilled by Christ. With this covenantal framework in place, Horton begins his second part, ‘Servant’, by considering theological anthropology more fully (arguing for a relational and ethical rather than ontological understanding of the imago Dei) and the doctrine of sin (describing how humankind, represented in Adam, has failed its obligations under the covenant of creation). Only in his third part, ‘Lord and Servant’, does Horton turn to Christology and soteriology proper, although their basic outlines were implicit earlier. Christ serves as the faithful Son of Adam, fulfilling the covenant obligations that the first Adam did not and graciously sharing the benefits of that fulfilment with fallen humanity. Not surprisingly, for a self-consciously Reformed theologian, Horton also employs the munus triplex of prophet, priest and king to defend some traditional notions of atonement from modern critiques and to develop some intriguing and suggestive new understandings.
Given such an ambitious project and diverse number of conversation partners, specialists can expect to quibble with an analysis here or an interpretation there. Still, Horton's work displays such an abundance of intriguing insights that he can be forgiven the occasional mis-step. A more serious downside is that, with so many interlocutors, Horton's own thesis is too often obscured. Combine this with the fact that his writing style is often more cumulatively allusive than linear and his argument can sometimes be difficult to follow. One can only hope that Horton's third and final volume will feature more of his own constructive theology, more prominently and clearly expressed, because his is a voice worth hearing.
