This book is the final product of a leading scholar who devoted his life to studying modern Sudan. Robert Collins' academic interest in Sudan dates to the 1950s, and he published extensively on a variety of related topics. Approaching his final days, as he hints in the preface, he set out to write a comprehensive composition integrating his major observations and studies into one general introduction. The result is admirable, a book of coherently presented, detailed information revolving around a clear main thesis and written in an academic yet often nearly poetic style.
The main thesis is that modern Sudan, an enormous land with rich human diversity, has never benefited from the leadership and the pluralist political system it needed. It is around this misfortune that Collins narrates the history of the last two centuries through various periods and vicissitudes.
Ancient and medieval history of bilād al-sudān, Collins asserts, was just a mere distant background to the modern story, which actually began with the Egyptian conquest of 1820. Chapter 1, “The Making of Modern Sudan: The Nineteenth Century,” explains how the occupiers established Khartoum and introduced institutional government over the vast areas roughly corresponding to today's Sudan. Ottoman–Egyptian rule lasted over sixty years, during which the occupiers were being transformed from Turkish-speaking Ottomans into Arabic-speaking Egyptians, but in Sudanese memory this era has remained the Turkiyya. Indeed, during this period the northern parts of the new Sudan were connected to the future Middle East and to orthodox Islam as religion and state. The next period, the Mahdiyya, saw the emergence of a local independent government that destroyed the mixture of modern and traditional methods of rule. The Mahdists' messianic interpretations of Islam drove them to redefine Sudan as a state led exclusively by the Islamic-Arab north. These two periods of the 19th century presented the two major options that compete until today—an all-Sudanese system or a northern Sudanese domination legitimized by Islamic (and Arab) radicalism.
Chapter 2, “The Anglo–Egyptian Condominium,” discusses another period of foreign rule and another attempt to build an all-Sudanese system, but this time the same vision was shaped by an emerging Sudanese nationalism and its added dimension of a Sudanese African identity. The attempt to build a system compatible with the country's diversity continued after independence. Chapter 3, “Parliamentary and Military Experiments in Government, 1956–1969,” analyzes the struggle between an all-Sudanese multiparty system and military centralization around Khartoum, couched now by secular, revolutionary ideologies. Collins does not conceal his opinion that only pluralism can bring progress and that for a representative system to succeed a leadership of integrity has to develop. As he puts it:
Sadly, no Sudanese political leader emerged after independence as a competent and effective national leader who could overcome his sectarian, ethnic, or regional loyalties to convince the complex diversity of the Sudanese to support a national agenda. The most intellectual, cosmopolitan, and politically sophisticated Sudanese appeared to have a perverse capacity to produce leaders of limited abilities, arrogance without restraints, and avarice without shame. Obsessed with their own personal pride and power, these petty men were prisoners of their own narrow, ethnic, and regional interests whose concept of leadership was debased by cynical party manipulation greased by nepotism, privilege, and often hard, cold cash that made a mockery of parliamentarian government. The Sudanese, universally admired for their charm, warmth, hospitality, and humane virtues despite the paradox of appalling atrocities, deserved much better (p. 92).
Collins is of the opinion that the main driving forces behind history are capable personalities in leading positions, and he was therefore hopeful that Jaʿfar al-Numayri would lead Sudan on the road to constructive openness (p. 301). He details the story of al-Numayri's rule in two chapters. In Chapter 4, “The Heroic Years, 1969–1976,” he describes the adoption of a progressive constitution and the stabilization of the regime through an autonomous arrangement with the non-Islamic south. “The president had demonstrated a national leadership that the Sudanese deserved,” Collins writes (pp. 123–24). Yet, in Chapter 5, “The Years of Dismay and Disintegration, 1976–1985,” he concludes that “unfortunately, at the height of his popularity and prestige [al-Numayri] became intoxicated by the prospects of absolute authority and in the future began to lose his way” (p. 125). Collins goes on to describe the results of the ruler's growing inclination to authoritarianism, mysticism, and political Islam. “The more he received divine guidance, the less he needed to observe the constitution” (p. 125) he laments, narrating the general deterioration spearheaded by the renewed war in the south in 1983.
The book continues along the same pattern. Chapter 6, “The Transitional Military Council and Third Parliamentary Government,” covers the years 1985–89 and is followed by Chapter 7, “The Islamist Revolution: The Turabi Years, 1989–1996,” and Chapter 8, “The Bashir Years: Beleaguered and Defiant, 1996–2006.” In combination, these chapters repeat and detail that same vicious circle in which the country, lacking authentic leadership, saw pluralism defeated by personalities seeking exclusive, centralized hegemony. Hasan al-Turabi, like the Mahdi in his time, strove for cultural and political unification and worked to position Sudan as a leader of the greater Islamic world, in contrast to those striving for a multicultural system derived from African concepts, local popular religiosity, and Western and other formulas of political decentralism. Sparing no harsh criticism for al-Turabi, Collins' hero is John Garang of the South, “the only Sudanese leader in the history of modern Sudan who for twenty-five years consistently advocated, plotted, and fought for a democratic, secular, and unified Sudan . . . He will be remembered for that vision as a national leader for all Sudanese” (p. 271). Chapter 9, “War and Peace in Southern Sudan,” and Chapter 10, “Disaster in Darfur,” describe the price that the Sudanese continue to pay for the failure to build a regime of openness and pluralism.
In Collins' view, the main issue in human affairs is identity, and Sudanese modern history is about contrasting concepts of self-identification. However, in analyzing this pivotal theme, Collins integrates other vital aspects: economic developments, social changes, cultural trends, sectarian interests, personal ambitions, global factors, and the involvement of neighbors. All these dimensions are woven into an excellent composition that will remain essential for students of Sudan. Refusing to toy with political correctness, Collins writes like a lover of Sudan and of the Sudanese, painfully frustrated before bowing out. Robert Collins, a pillar of Sudanese historiography, passed away on 12 March 2009.
