Knowledge of film and film music history has grown significantly in the last several decades. Many important books, articles, recordings, and DVDs, along with a growing number of online digital research sources, have profoundly expanded our understanding of film music. So many histories, textbooks, readers or anthologies, thematic monographs, collections of essays, and other studies have appeared recently that they represent a small flood of books. Twenty years ago, with diligence it was reasonably possible to be familiar with most of the scholarly literature on film music; today one must be even more vigilant if one wishes to remain current. This is a good thing, of course, since it indicates a strong, healthy field that is of importance and interest to scholars, readers, and film enthusiasts of different ages and nationalities. The eight books reviewed here include two fairly traditional histories; one innovative textbook; two different anthologies of readings on film music history; a volume in a new series on music for film, television, and media; and two recent books in a decade-old series on individual film scores. Although all these materials can be used as teaching materials, they are also intended to be used as reference sources, as well as narrative studies of various aspects of film music composition, production, and reception. The authors and editors are both younger and longer-established scholars—many leading authorities on film music—from music, film studies, and other related fields, although music scholars dominate the list of authors and editors. Together their books represent a significant achievement in film music scholarship.
As James Wierzbicki explains in the Preface to his Film Music: A History, his book “is not the history of film music . . . it is a history” (xiii), a scholarly narrative intended to cover the use of music in motion pictures since the beginning of the form in the 1890s up to the new millennium. Although Wierzbicki follows the common historical periodization of film music history, he does not focus on what he calls “great film scores.” Rather, he emphasizes the study of film music in the context of social, cultural, and technological developments, particularly as it relates to the Hollywood film industry. For Film Music: A History, and for his jointly edited collection of readings on film music in the accompanying volume, The Routledge Film Music Sourcebook (also reviewed in this essay), Wierzbicki has mined both obscure and familiar sources of information, and his work is based on a deep understanding of films and their music. Although his two books can be used as teaching materials, especially for advanced film music classes, Film Music: A History is not presented with all the illustrations, musical examples, sidebars, glossaries, and listening outlines that typically accompany undergraduate music textbooks. Rather it is as he initially states: a narrative history. His writing style is felicitous and readable, and although the book is based on a real knowledge of critical theory, it wears its theoretical underpinning lightly, which the general reader may well appreciate.
Wierzbicki divides his book into four main parts, after a brief Introduction/Chapter 1. Part I: “Music and the ‘Silent’ Film (1894–1927)” begins with Chapter 2, which outlines the origins of motion pictures from 1894 to 1905. He points out that the oft-cited beginnings of the use of music in early cinema—to mask the noise of the projector, to add warmth to the scenes, or to “embellish action and expression of emotion with affectively appropriate instrumental accompaniment” (13)—may not be totally accurate. The author believes that the “evidence shows that this ‘typical’ music for silent films resulted only after a period of evolution that was as quirky as it was contentious” (13). Chapter 2 covers the developments in cinema in both Europe and the United States, highlighting the international nature of films and the international competition between film producers, from the infancy of what would become a major worldwide industry. The rest of Wierzbicki's book is primarily devoted to the Hollywood industry in its mature state; more discussion of film music in its international context in later chapters would have been welcome.
The “nickelodeon” period of the exhibition of short films, circa 1905–1915, is presented in chapter 3, and chapter 4 looks at the advent of the feature (full-length) film between 1915 and 1927, the “classic period” of the silent film era. This time in silent film history, although short, was the most artistically substantial period before the practical application of a viable sound film process. However, because of space limitations, Wierzbicki allots the “classic” silent film only twenty-one pages and focuses on cue sheets (also addressed in the previous chapters) and film music anthologies and handbooks, as well as on D. W. Griffith's The Birth of a Nation of 1915. The remainder of the “golden age” of the silent film—with its many important films, technological and artistic developments, film scores, directors, and performers—is touched on lightly in the last section, “Common Practice.” Wierzbicki's coverage of film music history is thus slanted towards the sound film, with three-quarters of the book devoted to that period in film history. In comparison, Mervyn Cooke's A History of Film Music, with 510 pages of narrative, devotes less coverage to the silent film, in part because Cooke deals with film music more globally and his book presents a larger range of themes.
In part II, “Music and the Early Sound Film (1894–1933),” chapters 5–7, Wierzbicki gives a full account of the development and evolution of sound in cinema from the early Edison invention of the Kinetophone to the sound-on-film and sound-on-disc systems. He lucidly demonstrates just how long and complicated the development of a viable method of synchronized sound was, with the many inventors and film producers competing for success. Ultimately, the sound-on-film rather than the sound-on-disc method triumphed, and Wierzbicki highlights the fierce battle between competing technologies and their supporters and the artistic and mechanical failures and successes of early sound film (1928–1933). Much was at stake financially and artistically, and the advent of the sound film would profoundly change the Hollywood film industry, and, gradually, the motion picture industry throughout the world.
Part III: “Music in the ‘Classical-Style’ Hollywood Film (1933–1960),” comprising chapters 8 and 9, represents the heart of Wierzbicki's book. These chapters cover the highpoint of the Hollywood studio system in the 1930s and 1940s and the beginnings of its unraveling in the 1950s. Along with a discussion of the creation and development of the studio music department—made up of staff composers, conductors, arrangers, copyists, and orchestras—the author discusses musical and aesthetic quality in the classic Hollywood film score, as well as foreign musical influences in Hollywood, especially with the film music composed by prominent European composers such as Miklós Rózsa. Wierzbicki bolsters his narrative with pithy quotes from contemporary film music critics and writers.
Part 4: “Film Music in the Post-Classical Period (1958–2008),” chapters 10–12, focuses on developments since the decline of the Hollywood studio system, when film production changed radically over time, as did the world of film music composition and performance. Although I appreciate the careful attention that Wierzbicki paid to the early history of the use of music in motion pictures in the United States, his book would have benefited from greater and more detailed attention to recent developments—especially since this more recent period has seen great musical and technological experimentation and change. This wish aside, Wierzbicki's Film Music: A History is a fine and very useful addition to the list of book-length film music histories and has much to offer that is fresh and original.
Although the title of Mervyn Cooke's A History of Film Music merely reverses the title of Wierzbicki's volume, the two books are very different. Wierzbicki focuses his history primarily on the Hollywood film industry, whereas Cooke takes a global approach, covering national and international trends in the United States, Europe, Japan, the Soviet Union, India, and elsewhere. At about 300 pages, Wierzbicki's book is much more concise than Cooke’s, which exceeds 550 pages. Wierzbicki's history is mostly organized chronologically and does not significantly emphasize the work of individual composers. Cooke arranges his book thematically rather than chronologically, and gives substantial attention to the work of important film music composers such as Max Steiner, Alfred Newman, Hanns Eisler, Georges Auric, and Ennio Morricone.
Neither book includes a significant amount of detailed musical analysis or musical examples, because they are intended for the general reader as much as for the musically trained specialist. Although Cooke begins his history with a brief overview of music in the silent film era, he moves quickly to his main topics, some of which are new in this type of overarching, general history, especially his coverage of music for documentary films, cartoons, and television; opera on film; and non-European or non-U.S. film music. Given the audiovisual nature of film and the importance of studying sound and images in relation to film, it is surprising that each author's publisher seems to have limited the number of images reproduced in their respective books. Both books would have benefitted from greater visual representation.
Wierzbicki's and Cooke's different approaches are equally valid, complementary rather than competitive, especially since they differ in structure and purpose. Both books can be used productively in undergraduate and graduate-level classes, although they may contain too much material for a one-semester non-music-major course, especially at the undergraduate level.
Even at 550-plus pages, Cooke's A History of Film Music is not exhaustive—this would be impossible to accomplish in a single book, nor would this be advisable. No film music scholar has yet attempted any feat similar to that accomplished by Richard Taruskin in his six-volume magisterial set The Oxford History of Western Music (Oxford University Press, 2005), although as film music scholarship continues to develop and mature among scholars around the world, I can well envision that a large-scale multi-authored global history will be written one day. Cooke's book represents an engaging and well-written approach to tackling this daunting task and could serve as a model, albeit on a smaller scale, for this type of comprehensive global history.
A History of Film Music is divided into twelve chapters, ranging from the earliest days of motion pictures to the present. Each of Cooke's chapters contains between four and thirteen separate sub-sections, and some chapters are divided into larger sections; for example, chapter 9, Global Highlights, discusses the Soviet Union, India, Italy, and Japan, as representative national traditions, providing brief but useful summaries. Countries as disparate as South Africa, Mexico, Argentina, Australia, and China all have their own significant cinematic histories, but are not represented in Cooke's book, likely due to space limitations. Still, I would have welcomed coverage of at least one Latin American film music tradition. Mexico could have served as a case study, given its rich tradition of film exhibition, film production, and film music for more than a century, and also since Hollywood produced its own Spanish-language films throughout the 1930s, often starring Mexican performers, for the U.S. Latino, Latin American, and Spanish markets.Footnote 1
Even while stressing non-U.S. film music—with a substantial chapter devoted to British film music (the author is Professor of Music at the University of Nottingham)—Cooke gives plenty of attention to the use of music in the Hollywood film industry. Chapter 1 focuses on the silent film and its music, primarily in the United States. Chapter 3, on Hollywood's Golden Age, emphasizes those prominent film composers—Steiner, Erich Wolfgang Korngold, Franz Waxman, and others—who were mostly European émigrés and who worked within the Hollywood studio system from the 1930s through the 1950s. Chapter 5 covers post-World War II Hollywood film scores and their composers, especially Bernard Herrmann. And chapter 12 emphasizes U.S. film scores in recent decades, during which time, Cooke notes that “Paradoxically, as the commercial world shrank, so the global village left its colourful mark on film music in one of the very few fresh scoring trends to emerge in the 1980s: a pervasive use of ethnic instruments and voices” (504). He also points out that North American film studios account for only about one-tenth of the 4,000 films made each year around the world, with the majority of films being made in India, China, and the Philippines. Today, two-thirds of all theatrical films originate from Asian countries. Given these facts, it is important for more studies such as this to further our understanding and appreciation of music in a global cinematic context.
James Buhler, David Neumeyer, and Rob Deemer's Hearing the Movies: Music and Sound in Film History is very different in structure and content than recent histories of film music, especially those by Wierzbicki and Cooke. Rather than offering a traditional narrative history, it stresses the technological functions of sound in film, with useful pedagogical features: extensive images, notated musical examples, timelines and analytical listening guides, side bars, a glossary, and guidelines for writing about film music. A companion website is also available. Buhler, Neumeyer, Deemer, and their publisher, Oxford University Press, have paid special attention to the needs of both students and instructors in putting this book together. Hearing the Movies can serve as a primary text in classes in film music, film production, and sound design, and readings from this book can also supplement readings from Wierzbicki's and Cooke's books, and other studies, to provide a richer synthesis of history and practice. Knowledge of musical notation, while very helpful, is not a prerequisite for understanding Hearing the Movies—the listening guides will be clear to a wide readership, musician and non-musician alike.
Hearing the Movies is divided into three main parts and fifteen chapters (with two interludes connecting parts II and III). Part I, “The Sound Track and Film Narrative: Basic Terms and Concepts,” provides a frame for the rest of the book. Part II emphasizes “Music, Film Form, and Film Style” and part III is devoted to “The Sound Track: A Technological History.”
Part I, with four chapters and an interlude, provides a very useful explication of the principal components of the film soundtrack, with music being only one of several elements. In Chapter 1, the image track, sound track, and film narrative are amply introduced with excellent practical applications to familiar films (Sleepless in Seattle and Good Will Hunting); these and the other case studies of individual films, along with their accompanying listening guides, are a significant feature of this book. Musical elements that are particularly reflected in film are carefully introduced in Chapter 2, and music as part of, or separate from, the film narrative is the focus of Chapter 3. The temporal aspect of film music is covered in Chapter 4 (“Music, Sound, and Time”). The two interludes, “Writing about Film Sound” and “Writing about Film Music,” are especially useful, with guidance on how to write about a film's entire soundtrack—both music and other sound components. Part II (Chapters 5–9), with its emphasis on film form and film style, explains the technical language and components of filmmaking, especially as they relate to the soundtrack. Here too, well-chosen films serve as case studies, and useful listening guides illustrate the films.
In part III (Chapters 10–15), the authors give a historical overview of the U.S. film industry, from the silent film era to the present day, with an emphasis on the Hollywood studio system and its successors. Again, Hearing the Movies emphasizes the main technological and artistic changes of the past century. The authors vividly demonstrate that film production and film music creation, once the domain of a comparably small group of professionals and corporate producers, are now accessible (via YouTube and other websites) to a much wider world of filmmakers, composers, and producers. As Buhler, Neumeyer, and Deemer point out in the afterword to their book, “Software applications that are easily accessible today allow anyone with a modicum of expertise to work with the same tools that professionals use. . . . [N]ot only are audiences much more knowledgeable about how films are made or how songs are written, they can do it themselves—what was once fantastical is now commonplace” (421).
Those of us who have spent years doing research on film music are grateful to the editors of two recent valuable collections of articles on film music for bringing together important writings from different sources, many of which were previously difficult to access. Just as James Wierzbicki and Mervyn Cooke have written their own important histories of film music, they have also edited separate yet complementary readers on film music. Wierzbicki is the lead editor, assisted by Nathan Platte and Colin Roust, of The Routledge Film Music Sourcebook. Mervyn Cooke edited The Hollywood Film Music Reader, published by Oxford University Press. Both volumes are organized in a similar fashion: after an introduction, each editor (or editorial team) presents readings on the complete range of film music topics, from the silent film era to the present day (or close to it); each reading is preceded by a gloss, or historical explanation. Unlike Cooke's A History of Film Music, which emphasized film music on a global scale, his Hollywood Film Music Reader focuses on just what the title indicates. On the other hand, The Routledge Film Music Sourcebook includes readings on international film music trends, by writers such as Dmitri Shostakovich and Georges Auric. Both collections are of the same approximate page length (The Routledge Film Music Sourcebook has a larger page size and more print on each page), although Cooke's collection has fewer entries than does the Routledge volume (thirty-one versus seventy-four articles). The articles in Cooke's volume are usually longer and focus primarily on Hollywood's Golden Age. Wierzbicki, Platte, and Roust's collection—which features mostly shorter articles—includes a larger number of more recent articles, and their book spans the silent film era to the present. Cooke's collection is enlivened by photographs related to the individual readings; Wierzbicki, Platte, and Roust's volume does not include images. Taken together, these two readers present fascinating views of what music composers, producers, performers, critics, and scholars thought and wrote about this lively art from 1910 to 2010. These anthologies can be used very productively as reference works for general readers and specialists, and as teaching materials for courses on film music.
Music in the Horror Film: Listening to Fear, edited by Neil Lerner and published by Routledge, is a collection of twelve essays by leading film music scholars; it is the first book in the relatively new Routledge Music and Screen Media Series. Lerner also edits this series, with seven volumes published to date. As the series title indicates, these books are dedicated to various genres of film music and music for the screen in its variety of forms, including video games, television, and new media.Footnote 2
Despite film scholars’ interest in the horror film, surprisingly, Music in the Horror Film is one of the first books to discuss the music of this genre.Footnote 3 Lerner's collection shows how music composed for horror films and for horror sequences in other film genres—unlike much other film music—is primarily intended to discomfit and frighten audiences. Suspense as enhanced through music is a key element of most films, but in the horror film it is heightened in order to keep the audience's emotional response intensified. For film audiences, there is something satisfying in being terrified by both realistic and unbelievable horror sequences, especially since terror is a vicarious feeling in the context of what the audience knows is the unreality of the film medium. The essays in Music in the Horror Film vividly emphasize the many different ways that film composers, screenwriters, and directors have represented and elicited horror. In the best of these films, such as Psycho, Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, and The Exorcist (all covered in this book), the terrifying and horrific are integral to the scenario and are presented in dramatically logical and compelling ways. Violence is rarely gratuitous in these artistically superior films. However, in the less-inspired horror film, especially those with multiple sequels issued mainly to capture box office revenue, violence and other terrifying acts may provide the audience with a quick rush of adrenaline, but ultimately can dull the senses.
One of the most valuable contributions of Lerner's Music in the Horror Film is how it makes the reader think deeply about the various roles music plays in horror films; it shows how horror sequences with music are represented in many different genres, besides the typical “slasher,” supernatural, or vampire film. The collection also explains how the horror genre freed film composers in their use of non-tonal or tonally adventurous musical languages. Composers exploited the use of atonality, unresolved dissonance, and experiments in orchestration, among other musical and sound design techniques, to create the sense of unease and terror that are explored in the different case studies throughout Music in the Horror Film.
In “Mischief Afoot: Supernatural Horror-Comedies and the Diabolus in Musica,” Janet K. Halfyard examines the melodic and harmonic use of the tritone in the hybrid form of the horror-comedy, especially in the context of Danny Elfman's scores for Tim Burton's films, showing how representations of horror and the devil are heightened by specific musical means. Julie Brown's “Carnival of Souls and the Organs of Horror” examines the use of the organ in horror films from the silent film era to later periods; examples include The Phantom of the Opera (1925), Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (1931), The Black Cat (1934), and Carnival of Souls (1962), which, as Brown explains, is the “ne plus ultra of horror movies with an organ” given that the central character is an organist and that its soundtrack consists exclusively of organ music (1). Lerner's contribution, “The Strange Case of Rouben Mamoulian's Sound Stew: The Uncanny Soundtrack in Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (1931),” shows specifically how music and sound design “took on an enhanced role in the film's creation of dread and revulsion for the audience” (55). Like its predecessors Dracula (1931) and Frankenstein (1931), Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde made sparse use of music, with two important exceptions: “a groundbreaking sound collage . . . and a non-diegetic version of a waltz from earlier in the film reappears” (56).
The other essays range widely, exploring children in horror films (contributed by Stan Link), as well as the music of Psycho (Ross J. Fennimore), The Last House on the Left (Joe Tompkins), The Exorcist, (Claire Sisco King), The Shining (David J. Cooke), The Fog (K. J. Donnelly), A Nightmare on Elm Street (James Buhler), the Dracula films (James Deaville), and The Sixth Sense and The Others (Lloyd Whitesell). All the chapters can be assigned productively as readings for various types of film music classes, and will interest film music scholars and fans alike. This is an excellent, useful, and much needed collection. Lerner has done film music scholarship a great service in bringing together the work of leading scholars from music, film, and media studies.
In addition to Lerner's Routledge Music and Screen Media Series, another important series on film music is the Scarecrow Film Score Guides, published since 2003 and edited by Kate Daubney. The series now includes fifteen books, most on scores for North American films, although the series is designed to include books on films from around the world.Footnote 4 These volumes usually follow a five-chapter structure: 1) a summary of the composer's musical background and biography, 2) the composer's film scoring language or technique, 3) the historical context for the film, 4) the context for the musical score, and 5) an analysis of the film score, with copious musical examples. Photographs from the films or of film composers are occasionally included.
The Scarecrow Film Score Guide series is an excellent addition to the growing literature on film music, and is well edited by Daubney. Most volumes run from about 150 to 250 pages, making them relatively affordable and thus attractive as supplemental or primary texts for courses on film music and related topics. Although each book is grounded in the latest scholarship and critical theory, the series is designed for both general and specialist audiences, and the books generally eschew jargon or overly technically language, although musical analysis does play a prominent role. The musical analysis is written in a way that readers with at least some technical musical knowledge should be able to understand the discussion.
The two books reviewed here, by David Neumeyer and Nathan Platte (on Rebecca) and Mariana Whitmer (on The Big Country), examine films representing two different genres: “the ultimate women's picture” (Neumeyer and Platte, 46), and the western epic, respectively. These studies also look at the careers of two film composers, each with different compositional styles in film scoring. These composers were born in the first and second decade of the twentieth century, one in the United States and one in Germany. Franz Waxman (1906–67), composer of the music for Rebecca and dozens of other Hollywood film scores—including The Bride of Frankenstein and Sunset Blvd (1950)—was one of the wave of European émigré composers that arrived in the United States in the 1930s as a result of the rise to power of Hitler and National Socialism. Waxman flourished within the Hollywood studio system, first as a contract composer at Universal, MGM, and Warner Brothers, and later as a freelancer. Once established in Southern California, he happily remained there. Jerome Moross (1913–83), a New Yorker and sometime Southern California resident who scored The Big Country, worked within the Hollywood studio system as an orchestrator and composer but preferred writing music for the concert hall, considering “his work in Hollywood an unpleasant, albeit necessary task,” although he came “to see the positive aspects of film scoring” (Whitmer, 1). The directors of these films, Alfred Hitchcock (Rebecca) and William Wyler (The Big Country), were two of the most important figures in twentieth-century cinema, and the films analyzed in these books were among their most significant works.
Film composer Elmer Bernstein considered Waxman “the most adventurous of all the European composers” active in the Hollywood studios (12). Waxman was born in Königshütte, Upper Silesia, Germany (now Chorzów, Poland), and began his musical career in Berlin, accompanying singers and playing in nightclubs and cabarets. He was a pianist and arranger for Weintraub Syncopators, the German jazz band that appears in Josef von Sternberg's famous film Die blaue Engel (The Blue Angel, 1930), with Marlene Dietrich. After several years in Germany working for the UFA studio (1930–33), and a year in Paris (1933–34), he arrived in the United States in 1934, and was signed as an arranger for Universal (1935–36). He was soon given the plum assignment to write the music for The Bride of Frankenstein, which would become one of his most important scores. He worked at MGM (1932–42) and was loaned to David Selznick for several films, including Rebecca. His last period as a studio staff composer was at Warner Bros. (1943–48); thereafter, he worked as a freelancer, while at the same time writing concert music and directing the Los Angeles Music Festival (1947–66), which he founded.
In their book on Rebecca, David Neumeyer and Nathan Platte show how Waxman's American career paralleled the history of the development of the sound film in the context of the “classic” Hollywood studio system. Waxman arrived in Southern California in 1934, by the time sound film techniques and scoring had improved significantly from the earliest days of the medium in the mid-1920s. After his arrival, he wrote continuously for film into the 1950s. The authors include an excellent, succinct discussion of Waxman's film scoring techniques, and how they fit in with the Hollywood studio department model, explaining his typical orchestration style and sound (favoring strong color contrasts tied to the film's narrative) and his stylistic development before and after Rebecca (for which he was nominated for an Oscar). Neumeyer and Platte also highlight Waxman's use of motivic development in his score to Rebecca, quoting the composer regarding the use of recurring motifs in the representations of individual characters and dramatic situations as well as the use of groups of musical motifs for cinematic purposes. According to Waxman: “In concert music, variations are usually written around a single theme. But in film music, where there are many themes, the variations turn out to be variations on a group of themes” (16). Waxman believed that “motifs should be characteristically brief, with sharp profiles” (17).
David O. Selznick, the producer of Rebecca, was known for his hands-on approach to film direction and scoring and his “film-as-high-culture ethos” (xvi). Neumeyer and Platte describe the history of Selznick's involvement in the creative process during the overlap between the creation of Gone with the Wind (with music by Max Steiner) and the production of Rebecca and the creation of Waxman's film score. Since Waxman had other commitments to fulfill, he had to leave for another project before Rebecca was completed. As a result, Selznick's music executive Lou Forbes had to make changes and additions to the score, following Waxman's guide and using some of his music. Despite this situation, the authors identify a remarkable stylistic continuity and excellence in the underscoring of Rebecca (xvi).
The analytical chapter in Neumeyer and Platte's book is intended to be used while viewing the film. DVD timings are included along with music cues in the many tables given in the book. The musical examples that graphically illustrate the listings and descriptions of these music cues appear beneath the discussion. In addition to the usual components of the Scarecrow series described above, Neumeyer and Platte's book also includes three very useful appendices: Waxman's scoring notes for Rebecca, a summary of edited cues, and a “music notes resumé” from 1940. As with all the other volumes in the Scarecrow Film Score Guides series, Franz Waxman’s Rebecca is designed to be as useful as possible to readers from a wide variety of backgrounds who wish to understand, at a deep level, the important role given to music in motion pictures.
Although Jerome Moross was never completely comfortable in Hollywood, he nevertheless worked there steadily from 1940 through the 1960s, also writing for television. Born in Brooklyn in 1913, Moross began composing while a teenager. He befriended Bernard Herrmann, to whom he would remain close until the latter's death. The two budding composers encouraged each other and sought out opportunities to engage with older composers of concert music such as Henry Cowell and Aaron Copland. Cowell introduced them to the music of Charles Ives, and Copland encouraged Moross to be active in the Young Composers Group, which Copland had founded, and which introduced Moross to the music of other contemporary New York composers. His work in radio and theater—Moross served as musical director in a short run of performances of Kurt Weill's Threepenny Opera in 1933—led him to other work for the stage and for ballet, and, beginning in 1940, to a career as an orchestrator and arranger for Hollywood films. After eight years of working in these capacities—in between his work in New York writing concert music and ballet scores—in 1948, Moross composed his first original film score, for Close-Up. This was followed by a series of assignments as a freelance composer and orchestrator. He also collaborated with other composers on Southwest Passage (1954), in a kind of “group composition, which George Antheil termed the ‘composite score system’” (14).
Moross's first important film assignment was for William Wyler's The Big Country (1958), starring Gregory Peck, Jean Simmons, Charlton Heston, and Burl Ives. (The job was first offered to Aaron Copland, who turned it down.) It remains Moross's best-known and most appreciated film score. The Big Country was filmed using the new Technirama wide-screen process (a Cinemascope competitor) and brilliant, color-saturated Technicolor cinematography. The title of the film is appropriate as it was indeed big in many ways: big stars, big advance publicity, a big scenic background, and a long running time.
According to Whitmer, The Big Country was a “problematic film from its very inception . . . the plot didn't satisfy the traditional conventions of the Western, introducing characters and situations that were beyond the genre” (53). The transformation from the original short story to screenplay was a difficult one, and “Wyler's production team, the critics, and audiences did not readily understand the film, and film scholars have largely ignored it” (53). The length of the preliminary version of the film presented a challenge to Moross, as did the many changes in the editing of the film. In addition, there was friction between film editor Robert Swink and Moross regarding the placement of music. Wyler did not appreciate Moross's work, even though the score is what is remembered about the film (53). Whitmer provides compelling reasons why this is so.
The Big Country has been compared to several iconic westerns, including High Noon (1952), Shane (1953), and Giant (1956), examples of the new, mature western of the 1950s, in which story development was as important as action. The Big Country has an underlining theme of pacifism, and the main character, Jim McKay (Gregory Peck), is an easterner and thus an outsider, and refuses to fight his rivals. Peck, who brought the original story to Wyler's attention and served as one of the producers on the film, described the story as an “anti-macho Western” (65).
Whitmer ably places the film in the context of the history of the development of the western genre, making a strong case for reevaluating The Big Country. Moross composed forty-one music cues, of which thirty-three are heard in the film, writing for an orchestra of ninety studio musicians. He brought to the composition of the score his background in writing concert music, an interest in writing narrative music, and his “affinity for American popular musical idioms (such as blues, folk, and jazz)” (99). The Big Country “offered Moross the opportunity to compose large musical gestures to complement the spectacular scenery” (99). According to Whitmer, “Moross regarded each scene as though it were part of an opera to which he supplied appropriate music to enhance the emotional and dramatic content. The music needed to tell the story as much as (if not more than) the dialogue” (100). Whitmer also highlights Moross's use of rhythm. In the standard western, the rhythmic aspect of the film score is usually straightforward, maintaining a consistent beat with little syncopation. However, in The Big Country, “few of the metric constructions . . . are straightforward and it is in the formulation of rhythms where Moross's distinctively American style is most notable. Almost every cue features vibrant, off beat rhythms, usually reiterated in an unrelenting manner” (102). Whitmer believes that Moross's emphasis on vibrant rhythms came from his engagement with American popular music.
Whitmer's observation of the mixing of the popular and classical elements in film scoring reinforces the nature of composition in the Hollywood studio system of the 1930s through the 1950s. The popular element always existed alongside the concert music or “classical” style, and from the early days of film scoring. All of the books reviewed here, although they have different purposes and focuses, reinforce this same binary emphasis. All of the authors and editors examine this hybrid compositional technique as used in the wide range of film genres and individual films they analyze.
