This book is a thesis for a doctorate in the Netherlands, and, as the author tells us, was written over several years due to many other important obligations. This might explain why the book is a very wide and very detailed presentation of a variety of topics related to modern welfare states and their development. It also explains why, in a short review, many comments on fine points have to be left out. The book shows an impressive knowledge and understanding, in a welfare perspective, of many elements and details of social security systems.
After the opening chapter, Chapter 2 gives a very detailed presentation of institutional theory. This chapter shows the author's in-depth knowledge of the subject and his ability to present a broad variety of theories which might be having an impact on social security. This is followed up in Chapter 3, where the focus, to a much higher degree, is on the relationship between social security and institutions. It includes a central and important distinction between formal and informal social security and a discussion of the interaction between rules and behaviour, including compliance with certain sets of rules and decisions. This is perhaps one of the most neglected areas of social security studies: formal rules and decisions concerning institutions need to be set against how these are implemented.
Chapter 4 sets the typological scene in a relatively classical fashion but a problem with the book is that the main part of the quantitative data is from the first half of 1990s. One can question how such data can inform us about present-day welfare states. For example, on page 225 it is argued that formal child care coverage is low and maternity and paternal leave is largely unpaid, but this has changed in many countries in Europe. The conclusion on page 248 that, despite the data indicating relative stable phenomena, it cannot be ‘translated into general welfare regime types’ is rather unclear. A typology is an indication not expected to be fulfilled in all details all the time.
Benefit dependency and poverty is the core of Chapters 5 and 6. Again these chapters show the authors very detailed and encompassing knowledge of the subject in question. The chapter also tries to establish what has been labelled a benefit dependency boost index. Included are central elements of demographic changes, labour market and institutional developments in an analysis of eight countries. This is used to argue that some systems are more favourable and better able to cope with growth in the number of social security recipients.
Another interesting element in the book is the construction of an institutional poverty risk index, using variables relating to old age pensions, unemployment, social assistance, disability, survivors and family befits. This is an appealing approach, attempting to cope with the many and very varied approaches to measuring poverty. Differences do not seem to be precise and are only related to differences among countries, indicating that regime effects are rather weak.
The recommendations from the book seem unsurprising. They are, for instance, that rights and obligations are not self-evident and that institutions are established to achieve a collective. Another, to my mind also a relatively common sense notion, is that it is important to achieve a relationship between ‘theoretical notions and operational criteria’ (p. 459). The criticism of the Laeken indicators – a set of common European statistical indicators on poverty and social exclusion – later on the same page, also seems not to have taken into account that the indicators were based on an academic study trying to combine knowledge of a theoretical character with sound empirical data. The poverty line of 60 per cent of mean income is thus a good combination of the various approaches in welfare state studies.
Despite the many good ambitions and that the calculations are indeed of interest, the book lacks updated material so that one can be sure that its conclusions still hold. It would also have been more readable if the book has been shortening with more focus on the specific contribution the book is trying to make. Several of the figures are interesting, but they are not simple to access and the links to the text and explanation are not always clear.
Allow me a comment not related to academic content. Given the price of the book, it is surprising that the binding is not better. My copy now has many loose pages.
