This dissertation argues that the federal government played an essential role in the shaping of the western economy. American expansion necessitated not only that land be opened up, but also that the regional economy be reorganized. Specifically, the federal government did so in three ways. First, the military wrested control of the western economy from the tribes of the Northwest Territory through warfare, both during the Indian wars of the 1790s and later during the War of 1812. Second, the federal government sponsored the construction of roads throughout the region. Finally, colonial agencies of the federal government attempted to transform the Native American economy from one focused on fur trading to one centered on sedentary commercial agriculture.
Historians have not viewed the region in such economic terms before.1
Recent scholarship has tended to focus on political relationships. See, White, Middle Ground; and McConnell, Country. Eric Hindraker has approached the region from an economic perspective by looking at trade as an extension of imperial policy, but we have reached very different conclusions regarding the period considered in this project. See Hinderaker, Elusive Empires. Other regions have received more attention regarding their economic transformations. See, for instance, Prucha, Broadax; White, Roots; Worster, Rivers; Limerick, Legacy; and Usner, Indians.
Turner, “Significance”; Wildes, Anthony Wayne; Horsman, Frontier; Nelson, Anthony Wayne; Sword, President Washington's Indian War; Hurt, Ohio Frontier; and Gaff, Bayonets.
Weslager, Delaware Indians; Edmunds, Potawatomis; Van Kirk, Many Tender Ties; Howard, Shawnee!; Carter, Life; Rafert, Miami Indians; Sioui, Huron-Wendat; and Sleeper-Smith, Indian Women.
This argument has been made very creatively in recent years. See, Cronon, Changes; Anderson, Creatures; and Coleman, Vicious.
Francis Paul Prucha has most successfully presented this thesis, but without a substantial integration of a Native American perspective. See Prucha, Broadax.
Andrew Cayton argues that the federal government played a significant role in shaping Ohio's political world. See, Cayton, Frontier Republic. Eric Hindraker likewise contends that governmental decisions affected the economy of the Great Lakes Region. This dissertation differs significantly from Hindraker in that he believes the American government helped create a flourishing western economy by not interfering in its development, while this project argues that the federal government became directly involved in that economy. Hinderaker, Elusive Empires.
See, for instance, Taylor, Transportation Revolution; Goodrich, Government Promotion; Scheiber, Ohio Canal Era; Sellers, Market Revolution; and Malone, Opening the West.
Settlers who moved west of the Appalachians during the 1770s and 1780s ran afoul of an economy controlled by Native Americans, including the Shawnee, Delaware, Wyandot, Ottawa, Miami, among many others. At the risk of overly simplifying this economy, it can be fundamentally described as a fur-trading, semisubsistence economy. Villages and tribes jealously guarded usufruct rights to vast territories and the furbearing game therein. Although tribes of the Old Northwest negotiated territorial boundaries north of the Ohio River, Kentucky largely remained contested hunting ground between northern, as well as southern tribes, such as the Cherokee and Chickasaw. As warriors and hunters, men defended territorial claims and supplied furs and meat for their families and villages. Native American women supplemented this trade with intensive agricultural production of corn and other vegetables. These foods facilitated the economic and political relationships that bound trader and empire to these communities, as well as provided food for hunting and warfare expeditions.
Americans who moved across the Appalachians sought to reconfigure the western economy by redefining the landscape. Where Native Americans saw hunting ground and contested territory, Americans saw wastelands. Settlers and speculators sought to transform earth into a commodity, selling it off to become farmland and grazing pastures. As settlers and artisans moved to Kentucky and along the Ohio River Valley, they fostered an increasingly diversified economy built on commercial agriculture. But from a Native Americans perspective, settlers illegally seized contested land. They took up valuable space and displaced game, making their efforts to secure a livelihood more difficult. From the start, these two economies chaffed against each other, often violently. By the 1780s, an extended property war gripped the region.
As settlers moved into Kentucky and along the Ohio River valley during the 1770s and 1780s, Native American warriors targeted the newcomers' property. They stole and shot horses, cattle, sheep, and hogs. They burned or destroyed fields, homes, tools, merchandise, and other property settlers brought with them. Warriors hoped to make life for the emigrants financially burdensome and to force a reverse migration. But their efforts proved only marginally successful and emigrants continued to flood into the region. Still, the American economy there sputtered as militias drew valuable manpower from productive practices, and frequent warrior incursions caused widespread and expensive damage to farmers.
To retaliate Native American raids, settler militias responded in kind, destroying Native American fields, villages, and property. These expeditions undermined the livelihood of those villages by destroying their ability to produce food and furs for themselves. In response, especially by the early 1790s, dislocated villages of different tribes began to form larger composite communities, farther from American settlements. These new towns provided residents with a number of benefits, including greater agricultural productivity to support the war effort and greater protection from American incursions.
During the 1780s financial problems, disorganization, and lack of power prevented Congress—at this point under the Articles of Confederation—from enacting a strong western policy. Instead, defense of the frontiers was left to the states and, in the case of Kentucky and the Ohio Valley, local militias. Ratification of the Constitution gave the American government greater authority to wage war, a power they quickly utilized. During the first half of the 1790s, the United States ramped up its presence in the West but failed in two campaigns to end the conflict.
Despite continued difficulties the military had in acquiring supplies, especially food, the regional economy responded to the extended federal presence in the West. Farmers and merchants began to produce crops and livestock known to be in demand by the military. And the State of Kentucky began to fund internal improvement projects designed to deliver goods from the Bluegrass Region to Cincinnati and the Ohio River, even before it made efforts to improve transportation networks to the East. Nevertheless, the regional economy continued to limit military options in the region. Poor roads and short supplies prevented troops from deploying for an extended campaign far from their supply source.
Still, in 1794, when Major-General Anthony Wayne attacked the northern tribes, he found success because the western economies had changed in two important ways. First, the American economy had expanded adequately to sustain the military for a large, but short campaign. Second, by forming composite communities, Native American had concentrated their productive power and left them exposed to greater economic destruction. As a result, when American troops overran their communities, they razed thousands of acres of crops needed to support families and warriors. Wayne's army shattered the economic heart of the Native American resistance and peace soon followed. Federal military intervention ended the property war and forced the western tribes to relinquish a sizable chunk of their territory (approximately two-thirds of present day Ohio) when they signed the Treaty of Greenville in 1795. These new lands quickly opened up to settlers, speculators, and a revitalized American market economy.
In the decade and a half following the war, trade and immigration to the West increased remarkably. An expansion in the number of roads stretching through the region facilitated the movement of people and goods. Although private toll roads opened up, post roads proved more important to the region. An initial jagged web of post roads constructed in the West during the early 1790s expanded rapidly through 1815, when 5,933 miles of post roads connected communities from Pittsburgh to the Mississippi River, and from Tennessee to the hearts of Ohio and Indiana. Postmaster Generals argued for road construction in the West, pointing to the economic benefits these transportation routes brought to the region. In fact, the Post Office was more willing to construct roads to in the West than in the East because they anticipated greater population and economic growth there.
If the western economy had only just sprouted by 1790, it blossomed after the turn of the century. In southern parts of Ohio, corn, wheat, and rye fields stretched along river valleys and aside roads crisscrossing the territory. Cattle, which had been transported west during the late eighteenth century to support burgeoning populations, began to be driven east over the Appalachian Mountains to markets as far away as Baltimore. Still, a large portion of this interregional trade went to New Orleans. Farmers and merchants in the Ohio Valley conducted millions of dollars worth of trade to the gulf city before the United States acquired the Louisiana Territory from France in 1803. After the Louisiana Purchase, this traffic increased multifold. Even more remarkable was the fact that more than two-thirds of trade goods from the Ohio Valley were destined for ports outside of the United States, including many in the West Indies, South America, and the Iberian Peninsula. The Ohio Valley economy had stepped into the world.
Even as the federal government made efforts to bolster the western economy in the parts of the region that it directly controlled, it also attempted to transform the economy in Native American territory. Colonial agencies—such as the Indian Agency, the factory system, and territorial governments—prodded chiefs to change their subsistence strategy. One method they deployed was to try and draw Native American men into debt through the fur trade. Once in debt, American strategists believed individual Native Americans would either need to adopt commercial agriculture to pay off the debt or the tribe would have to relinquish land to clear the balance due. Either way, the United States planned to alter the economy on land yet unceded.
Native Americans, of course, largely resisted these efforts. To adopt yeoman farming techniques required them to depart radically from traditional productive practices. Agriculture had historically been a female occupation and Native American men recoiled at the idea of taking up women's work. Despite the failure of the United States to accomplish a sweeping transformation of the Native American economy, its efforts succeeded in dumping large amounts of money into the West. Much of this money tended to end up in the hands of American traders and merchants who sold manufactured goods and other items to the tribes.
By 1807 the market economy had expanded north from the Ohio River and it began to encroach again on Native American hunting areas. Thinning game populations caused, in part, by American expansion only further disrupted a Native American economy that had been languishing since the 1790s. As a way to reconcile widespread economic and social change, Native Americans increasingly embraced an internally driven millennialist movement. Spiritual leaders argued that in order to rejuvenate their society and religion, tribes needed to restructure their economy by rejecting American trade goods and returning to so-called traditional productive practices.
The most notable of these prophets was Tenskwatawa (Shawnee). At first, Tenskwatawa found open ears among tribes closer to the Mississippi River. But by 1810, continued land cessions convinced many reluctant hawks that the United States represented an impending danger to their economy. What had been a war of words became a military conflict in 1811 when William Henry Harrison moved against Tenskwatawa's settlement at Prophetstown, the opening salvo of the War of 1812. When the dust settled in 1815, the new Native American confederacy and its British allies had been defeated, but the former suffered more by the loss. The results of the war left little land in the Northwest for the tribes to pursue their fur trade economy. Most of the defeated villages in Ohio and Indiana decided to move west. The disruption of their part of the region's economy, as in 1794, again led to the expansion of the market economy in the Northwest as speculators, merchants, and settlers capitalized on seized lands, and the federal government constructed more roads.
This dissertation was completed in 2005 in the Department of History at the University of Cincinnati, under the direction of Wayne Durrill. The author would like to thank Geoffrey Plant for providing invaluable guidance in this project, as well as Christopher Phillips and Andrew Cayton for serving on the dissertation committee and providing insightful comments on the final draft.
