How can the disruptive effects of theatre help us come to terms with insecurity both on- and offstage? Jenn Stephenson's provocative, theoretically rigorous contribution to the field, Insecurity: Perils and Products of Theatres of the Real, poses this question and many more. Insecurity tackles “theatres of the real”—a term that Stephenson adapts from Carol Martin's definition (performances that “claim specific relationships with events in the real world”) to include site-specific theatre that directs attention to the iconicity of space (7)—in the age of postreality. Grounded in the concept of insecurity, the book argues that whereas the inclusion of real words, space, and bodies in the theatre should supposedly increase epistemological security and documentary “truth,” the opposite is true.
The book comprises eight chapters, the first (“Introduction”) and last (“Coda: Theatres of the Real in the Age of Post-Reality”) of which situate the project geographically, theoretically, and historically. Stephenson selects a handful of recent Canada-based case studies that variously tap into the tradition of documentary theatre and the staging of real people, testimonies, and histories onstage. The book makes the claim that a by-product of theatre of the real is profound insecurity, and posits that audiences seek realness as a desire for connection in the midst of uncertainty and to grab onto something solid in a precarious world. The core distinction, she claims, between “millennial theatres of the real and their more traditional documentary predecessors lies in profound postmodern, poststructuralist doubt” (10). Stephenson argues that although the theatre of the real promises authentic encounters, these are not possible; instead performances “meditate on that impossibility and the conditions under which a singular secure real fails to manifest” (17). Her analysis of twenty-first-century realness as a desire for commodities points to the evolution of this genre of performance and the impact of late-stage capitalism on the form.
Chapters 2 and 3 engage with autobiographical performance and “real people.” In Chapter 2, “Real People Part 1,” Stephenson considers James Long and Marcus Youssef's autobiographical improvisational performance collaboration Winners and Losers, where the performer-creators rank the merits of a random list of people and objects, with audiences left to consider the real-world implications of the contest. Stephenson posits that performances such as this one propel audiences into a space of what Ulrike Garde and Meg Mumford call “productive insecurity” (15), which allows audiences to reflect, question, and critically engage with uncertainty in the world (46). By doing so, these performances provide a space to reassess ethical landscapes in and out of the theatre. She builds upon this notion in Chapter 3, “Real People Part 2,” where she takes up the autobiographical performances Polyglotte, 100% Vancouver, and RARE, all of which, she argues, fail in their goal of exposing audiences to a true “Other” but still lead to productive insecurity by showing the impossibility of truly knowing strangers through the autobiographical encounter.
Chapter 4 addresses the value of real words in the remediated verbatim theatre performances Seeds and 300 Tapes. Stephenson moves beyond the common analysis of verbatim theatre's complicated relationship to the truth and situates her argument in Liz Tomlin's challenge to “consider how the specific strategies employed to manage epistemological uncertainty operate to support (or undermine) issues . . . that are raised by the staging of this source material” (95). Stephenson brings the performances back to the book's core argument for productive insecurity by highlighting the moments where the text is mutated through human factors and errors to suggest that realness resides not in the document but in the shared act of the documentary creation process.
In Chapter 5, Stephenson considers the insecurity of the real in space- and site-specific locations by looking at two audio-walk works: Garden/ /Suburbia, by Melanie Bennett and Hartley Jafine, set in the Lawrence Park neighborhood of Toronto, and Landline, by Dustin Harvey and Adrienne Wong, a site-generic work mounted in Canadian and international locations. She posits that by combining autobiographical storytelling with pedestrian movement, these plays question the possibility of secure relationships with the self and place.
Chapters 6 and 7 explore real bodies. In Chapter 6, “Real Bodies Part 1,” she looks through the lens of the fictional and immersive Counting Sheep and Foreign Radical to show that engaging in a physically immersive reality can offer an alternative form of what can be known or felt in performance. In Chapter 7, “Real Bodies Part 2,” she digs deeper into authenticity by taking the case study of the 2007 immersive performance of Everyman, which took place in a church basement in Ontario and placed a solo audience member in the role of Everyman. Stephenson argues that when a single person is confronted with an immersive experience, a heightened awareness of the actors’ bodies, breath, and elements that are otherwise insignificant creates a space for the spectator to look inward, thus manifesting insecurity that “touches the existential” (21).
With the rise of right-wing nationalism and anti-intellectualism in many countries across the globe, Stephenson's insightful and moving coda feels particularly relevant to the current sociopolitical climate. She speaks to the trend, particularly in the first and second decades of the twenty-first century, where neoliberal ideas have led to posttruth, favored feelings over facts, and validated white supremacy and fringe alt-right groups. Although concerned with how the theatre of the real will respond and ultimately survive, her acceptance of insecurity ultimately provides hope. Even if this book was written prior to the coronavirus pandemic, Stephenson's coda presents deep theoretical analysis that is easily applicable to the current crisis. Overall, her attention to detail in her research is impressive and her book is brilliantly executed. Insecurity: Perils and Products of Theatres of the Real is a necessary and valuable contribution to the field of theatre studies that will have a place for many years to come.
