Human rights scholars and practitioners working on issues concerning violence against women find themselves in a quandary. On the one hand, there is reason to rejoice, as the struggle against violence against women has attained a high rank on the international human rights agenda in the past two decades. On the other hand, there is much scepticism, as a lot of the rhetoric denouncing violence against women is not yielding concrete results. In the words of Alice Edwards, the response to violence against women within the international human rights system has been ‘mixed and, at times, arbitrary, superficial, and inconsistent’ (p. 4). How to maintain momentum, build on existing gains, yet also transform the human rights system with its deeply imbedded inequalities? This book presents an astute portrayal of the application of international human rights law to violence against women, and offers some concrete ways to move forward.
Edwards's focus lies on the jurisprudence of UN treaty bodies, with occasional excursions into the case law of other bodies and courts protecting human rights. This book is a revised version of her doctoral thesis as completed at the Australian National University. With this book, Edwards establishes herself as an international-law expert on violence against women. The book is thoroughly researched, carefully edited, and accessible. The scope of the work is ambitious, as it deals with procedural and theoretical issues alike regarding the treatment of violence against women under international human rights law. As it also includes many reflections on the protection of women's human rights more generally, one could almost use this book as a source book on feminism and international law.
The book has a clear structure. First come three introductory chapters. The first two of these chapters are largely theoretical. In Chapter Two, Edwards explores four feminist critiques of international law: (i) absence of women and women's voices, (ii) human rights as ‘men's rights’, (iii) the public/private dichotomy, and (iv) essentialized women. Thus, Edwards shows that she masters a wide variety of feminist analysis of international law. By grounding her book in these theories, she ensures that it will be worthwhile not only to international lawyers, but also to feminist legal theorists. Chapter Three covers familiar territory, namely the practice and procedure of the international human rights treaty system. The focus here is not so much on violence against women, but on the ability of the system to protect women's rights in general. The added value of devoting an entire chapter to this topic is not immediately apparent.
Then come the three central chapters, in which Edwards explores the application of three established human rights norms to the issue of violence against women: the right to equality and the related prohibition of discrimination; the prohibition of torture and other cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment; and the right to life. Starting with the right to equality in Chapter Four, Edwards discusses the feminist strategy to cast violence against women as sex discrimination. She is fairly critical of this approach and thus paves the way for one of her most interesting suggestions for future improvement: presenting violence against women as sex discrimination, Edwards writes, ‘reinforces inequality under international law by subjecting women to additional legal burdens . . . . This makes the [said] strategy at best a stopgap measure to the eventual enactment of a specific treaty or provision on this issue’ (p. 183). I will briefly return to the suggestion to enact a specific treaty below. Chapter Five explores treaty bodies’ interpretation of the prohibition of torture in relation to violence against women.Footnote 1 There is a strong focus on rape in this chapter, which is prompted by the emphasis on sexual violence in the human rights treaty system. Arguably, Edwards does not problematize the system's preoccupation with sexual forms of violence against women enough. Alice Miller has contended that ‘a “hyper-attention” to sex perversely operated to exclude attention to other aspects of harm’.Footnote 2 So, what about forms of harm that are not primarily sexual? What role does the prohibition of torture and inhuman or degrading treatment play, or could it play, in the context of economic harm to women, for example? Chapter Six concerns the right to life. Edwards convincingly shows that the acrimonious debate surrounding the question of when life begins troubles the feminist strategy of casting violence against women as a right-to-life issue. Yet, at the same time, she is also positive about the role of the right to life in campaigns to end violence against women: in her view, the right to life ‘needs to be one of the rights included in any strategy to combat violence against women’ (p. 303).
The choice to centre the book on these three strategies has advantages as well as disadvantages. An important advantage is that it can provide a useful overview for practitioners who need to come up with their own strategy in handling a specific case of violence against a woman; to my knowledge, such an overview did not exist before. A disadvantage is that there is no comprehensive discussion of the different types of violence women face and how these call for different kinds of legal response. The emphasis is on the different genealogies of legal strategies to combat violence against women, not on the myriad forms of violence itself. Thus, the discussion of specific forms of violence that have garnered considerable attention of late, such as trafficking and gendercide, is rather brief and dispersed throughout the book.
The concluding chapters include some creative thoughts on how the work of the UN human rights system can be improved in relation to addressing violence against women. In Chapter Eight, Edwards discusses procedural, interpretative/conceptual, structural, and substantive reforms. This once again underlines the complexity of the problems that characterize the current approach to violence against women. Edwards's two most notable recommendations are (i) to create a single unified treaty body that would, at a later stage, be turned into an international human rights court; and (ii) to establish a protocol that specifically addresses violence against women.
The book's biggest drawback, in my view, is that it is quite repetitive. It could have been more concise, especially since only a small portion of it is devoted to the actual analysis and commentary of human rights law that concerns violence against women. Edwards gives an overview of the different treaty bodies’ interpretations of relevant human rights provisions, without really drawing lessons from this: she could have done more work on interpretative ‘best practices’. But the scarcity of pages devoted to actual jurisprudence also points to something far more troubling: despite the enormous extent of the problem, the number of women who find redress and protection through the human rights treaty body system is very limited.
A major strength of the book is Edwards's thoughtful engagement with what can be described as the central dilemma of feminist legal scholars – how to radically change the legal system while working with(in) it.Footnote 3 In the specific context of the topic of this book, Edwards calls this the ‘conundrum of gender mainstreaming’: ‘the more that women work within the structures of existing law and institutions, the more the power and sexual inequalities inherent in the system can be reinforced’ (p. xii). Gender mainstreaming ‘continues to treat women unequally under international law, supports the gender bias in the system, and prevents any deeper transformation’ (p. 306). The conundrum of gender mainstreaming runs as a common thread through Edwards's story. Her approach to the conundrum is both pragmatic and reflective. Probably influenced by her work in the field of policy with organizations like the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees and Amnesty International, she contends that women's rights advocates must continue to work within the mainstream. Her aim, as I read it, is to strengthen ‘the human rights house’ (p. 343) rather than to demolish it. Towards the end of the book, Edwards expresses her wish that ‘this book will make policy- and decision-makers as well as feminist activists and strategists sit up and reflect on what the strategies employed to date really mean for women’ (p. 320). This book surely accomplishes that goal.
