Fall of 2007 will remain etched in the memory of all my colleagues as a period when each one of us, individually and collectively, turned a new leaf in our lives. Over the past two weeks, the six of us international fellows arrived separately in Washington, D.C., to take part in the U.S. Congressional Fellowship program of the American Political Science Association (APSA).
Our backgrounds were diverse, experience varied and countries different, but our purpose was one—to derive maximum advantage and make the most of the splendid opportunity that came our way. What could have been more exciting than the prospect of working with the lawmakers of the United States and the institution, the U.S. Congress? The period being the run up to the year when America elects its president was a bonus.
September 6 was the day we were waiting for, eagerly, ever since we got the news of our selection to be on the 2007–08 Fellowship. It was a Thursday and an assembly at the School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS) of the prestigious Johns Hopkins University signaled the start of a two-month seminar series designed especially to prepare the international fellows on how “the Hill” works.
There could not have been a greater start. Even though each one has had our own understanding about the functioning of the Congress, it was really the seminar series of Professor Charles Stevenson that kindled our curiosity further and peeled off the layers around the way things work on Capitol Hill.
The seminar series was not a traditional classroom affair but rather an interaction. Adding excitement to the learning process was the once a week Brown Bag lecture, modeled to be an active interplay of theoretical propositions and practical application. Every speaker was a hands-on person and carried to the class his or her experiences on the way Congress functions.
For those of us who were not homebred political watchers, the learning process became swift as the class went through its paces through the exercise series allowing us to imbibe from the group of American Congressional Fellows and some students enrolled with SAIS
These were important ingredients for the international fellows, who, in their own way, began to explore and expand their understanding against the backdrop of the latest exposure to theory and practice. For the majority of us, it took us a while to figure out why the Congress was indeed the only institution of its kind.
“As a SAIS graduate myself, I have to admit that Prof. Stevenson's class is definitely one of the best classes I have ever taken at SAIS. With more than 20 years of first-hand experience working on the Hill, Prof. Stevenson is not only highly knowledgeable and very passionate about the subject matter; he is also a very engaging and entertaining lecturer. His in-class assignments are also very useful in preparing us for real work on the Hill. For the Brown Bags, he invited a great variety of interesting speakers, ranging from the election campaign manager, lobbyist, congressional staffers, budget expert, and even the House speaker's counsel. All of them had fascinating stories to tell, complete with valuable Congressional insights…” This is how Jaithai Upkarnitikaset, a young Thai diplomat and Asia Foundation Fellow described the experience.
A few of the Fellows—three to be precise—had first-hand experience of life in the United State. Floriano Filho, editor-in-chief of a Brazilian television channel telecasting Senate proceedings, went to college in Columbia University; Jaithai Upkarnitikaset, a young career diplomat from Thailand, earned her spurs at the SAIS; and Immanuel Steinhilper, previously a policy advisor in the German Foreign Ministry, spent one year of his undergraduate studies at a college in Chicago 10 years ago.
These three helped the rest of the group to integrate faster in a new environment. The bright economist in Claudia Martinez Garcia from Mexico had a different perspective from that of young and energetic Denys Bazilevych, a product of the Orange Revolution now working in the office of Ukraine's president.
As for me, I brought to the Fellowship decades long journalistic experience of working with politicians and parliamentarians in India.
If the three members' earlier stints in the United States were in pursuit of academic excellence for the careers ahead of them, the current tenure, for all of us, was to juxtapose our biases and accumulations over the years with the way the United States looks at the world. As mentioned earlier, the presence of other international and home scholars at these seminars enabled everyone to look at the distinctions from different prisms and not altering the larger picture.
Each of us brought to the class a perspective that allowed the others to appreciate and not necessarily agree with the standpoint of the countries we represented on issues, contentious or otherwise, and fix them in regional or continental parameters. In turn, the viewpoint of American and international scholars gave us a deeper understanding on the world of geopolitics.
There was no penalty for prejudices. There could not be a better example of the way the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution is respected, and as Immanuel puts it: “You may be critical of America in many respects, but one of its historical strengths is its unparalleled ability to attract the most interesting people from all over the world. You can learn only so much from books and studying. Having people from around the globe sitting with you in one classroom is priceless. All of us bring great experiences to our fellowship program. Moreover, by sharing them with others, we augment them. I very much appreciate that we are a group of fellows.”
The exciting phase was yet to start. Each day of the week started with a new discovery. Each of the Fulbright Fellows had a host institution in one of the many Universities in the Washington, D.C. area and had different work schedules. The most challenging part was that there was no set syllabus or any particular academic regime to follow. We were free to explore.
Floriano decided to make use of his time here to pursue his favorite themes on the U.S. Congress, its trade policy, and the U.S.-Brazil bilateral flow of services and goods, particularly bio-fuels, digital contents, airplanes, autos, steel, soy, and cotton.
Although a trained economist, Claudia is here on a three-pronged mission, each addressing a professional, national, and academic interest. First, the science and technology issue she is working on back home; second, the contentious issue of migration the resolution she feels has advantages for both Mexico and the United States; and last, U.S. budgetary process.
Just as it is for Jaithai and Immanuel, my thrust area is the role of the U.S. Congress in shaping foreign policy. For Jaithai it is a natural extension of her role as a career diplomat especially since she came here straight from the U.S. Desk at her office in Bangkok.
Immanuel is a political scientist by thought and at heart with foreign policy being in its core. Having worked with the German Foreign Ministry advising it on a wide range of issues including its relations with the European Union, he ideally would like to work on a foreign policy related issue without being fussy about his future role on the Hill.
As for Prasad, the pursuit emerged from a raging debate back home in the light of the India-United States agreement on civilian nuclear cooperation. Division within political parties and policy-makers over the accord and discussions often led to a question, why should Parliament in India, like the U.S. Congress, not play a greater role in shaping foreign policy even though the Constitution does not envisage such a function.
Working in President Viktor Yuschenko's Secretariat that deals with cabinet relations, Denys uses his attachment to American University to research combating corruption. He feels that the United States has found an effective way to “civilize corruption” in the form of lobbying since no country has been able to eliminate the word “corruption” from its lexicon—it is impossible even in theory. In Ukraine, people still undermine the true role of lobbying and often comparing it with bribing, he says.
Denys describes his feelings of the experience: “Regular discussions with Prof. Thurber, perusing study material for the course: European Public Affairs and Advocacy Institute, which he directs twice a year, offers a rich number of sources covering procedure, techniques and specifics of lobbying both in the U.S. and Europe. Access to the library's resources at American University has allowed me lessons to draw a more vivid picture of the nature of lobbying and how to replicate it in Ukraine …” Other than Prof. Stevenson's classes, there was no going back to the classroom. Each of us was free to work on our specific areas of study and draw from resource materials in the libraries of Johns Hopkins University or our host institution.
It was not long before we found out that instead of confining ourselves to classic textbook readings and drawing on conventional library resources there was the cornucopia that Washington, D.C., offers, with think tanks being top of the heap.
One of the fascinating aspects of our early days was to figure out for ourselves the changing national mood over the Iraq war. Before we arrived in the United States, all of us had a fair idea of the hostility President George Bush's administration was facing at home, but now we had an opportunity to witness it from the ringside. The debate was between two distinctly identified pursuits “Change the course versus stay the course.” It was impossible for politically sensitive Fellows not to be drawn into this vortex, and at the first available opportunity we found ourselves at the Woodrow Wilson Center for a discussion on “Is Congress Resurgent on War Powers?”
What could be more exciting than to have a representative from each political party, Vic Snyder (D-Ark) and Todd Akin (R-Mo), interact with the audience and a panel comprising Karen Young of The Washington Post and Matthew Green of Catholic University?
It was an experience of a different kind, at least for this writer. As a political correspondent I thought the seminar, having Congressmen from either side of the political divide, contained less verbal duels than I expected. When I came out of the seminar, the bipartisanship exhibited by the two politicians, I surmised, was that these two responsible members of the Congress were keen to lower the political temperature on the Iraq war. I immediately flagged that this was one area—a compulsion of a Congressman or Congresswoman in taking a stand on issues or why they preferred to vote or not on issues they proffer is close to their hearts—that needs detailed study.
Immanuel described our exploratory visit to the seminar series succinctly: “Do not to miss the larger picture, Washington, D.C., is a great place to be in, if you want to follow debates on any current issue. The enrichment activities have complemented our experience in the class.”
An international journalist like Floriano is of the view that these activities are valuable in terms of both academics and learning opportunities and offer a window to broaden the network of international fellows. A fine demonstration of the APSA catch phrase, “Networking a World of Scholars.”
Encouraged by Prof. Stevenson, the group started visiting the Hill. This expansion in the range of our activities became the most rewarding experience straightaway. Coming out of the confines of our classroom, we found ourselves taking a seat in the Committee Hearings and watching the Senate and House proceedings.
With assistance from our American Fellows, we were able to shortlist hearings where one could have a feel of politics at play. A long line of people waiting to get a seat on the Senate hearing on the U.S.-Peru Free Trade Agreement impressed Floriano, especially since one of the American Fellows on our program did not anticipate it would attract that much attention. “The hearing on consumer protection regarding Chinese imported toys was not as packed but the ‘gotcha’ questions put the Consumer Department chief in a very uncomfortable position,” was Floriano's experience.
One of the most interesting hearing's was the House Committee on Foreign Affairs mark up on a resolution on the “Armenia Genocide,” which to I went with Immanuel and Denys. The impressive turn out of people both in favor and against the resolution gave us a feel of the emotive pull of this contentious issue.
Seats filled up quickly after the doors of the committee room were throw open. To accommodate the overflow, the committee staff requested the rest to move to another room and follow the proceedings on television. It was easy for the three of us in the alternate viewing room to spot people supporting the resolution that condemned the 1915 Turkish regime for killing more than one million Armenians and those opposed it on the grounds it was not the current violation of human rights it is being made out to be.
We were witness to the dynamics of domestic and district politics versus the constraints of diplomacy before and after it. On the day of the mark up, President George Bush appealed to the lawmakers to restrain from passing the resolution stating it would affect current relations with Turkey, a key ally in the Iraq war. The lawmakers had their own understanding and soon after the committee passed the resolution, Turkey recalled its ambassador for consultations.
From here on events kept unfolding and this was just the beginning.
