Jan Cohen-Cruz's latest book offers an approach to community art that is distinguished not by its technique or amateurism, but by the level of its engagement with the people most affected by the subject matter of the work. Cohen-Cruz argues that organizational skill and activist competence are a crucial, though undervalued, component of community art. The cases presented in the book, all from the US, interestingly tell the reader about the processes that led to the final production, and discuss problems that were encountered by the performance groups. These range from prison theatre projects to border patrol performances, to educational theatre and cultural revitalization initiatives. Methodologically, the study clearly calls for an engaged community theatre/performance scholarship that is sensitive to these webs of relations, where artist–activists not only create theatre productions, but also organize community gatherings, do advocacy work or participate in local council activities. The study locates community art in terms of being both a call and a response: a call to the creative activation of locally available resources, as well as a creative response to social calls (p. 111). The study further considers the training requirements and demands of a socially engaged theatre artist in the US, which, she suggests, should combine craft, scholarship and community experience, and incorporate a collaborative approach between higher-education institutions and community training initiatives.
The book presents an assessment of debates around the concept of applied theatre, including questioning the status of community-based theatre in the debate around amateur versus professional theatre. Anyone interested in scholarship around the Theatre of the Oppressed will be familiar with Cohen-Cruz's previous publications (Playing Boal: Theatre, Therapy, Activism, 2005; and A Boal Companion: Dialogues on Art and Cultural Politics, 2006, co-edited with Mady Schutzman). The present book introduces a critical appraisal of the limits of the Theatre of the Oppressed, suggesting that Boalian theatre principles must be imaginatively adapted and not blindly followed as a textbook. It gives instances of how this is being done in urban US contexts, highlighting the work of community theatre/performance groups, who complement Theatre of the Oppressed techniques with a variety of experimental, experiential and creative forms. This includes testimonial performances, video projects, puppetry and dance. It is commendable that Cohen-Cruz foregrounds initiatives that are likely to be regarded by theatre scholars as marginal or amateurish.
The book left me with the impression that while there are some insightful and critical points raised in it, it could have been more forcefully and compactly argued in the form of one or two articles. It becomes diluted and overly anecdotal at times, and the workbook sections at the end of each chapter, with exercise suggestions and recommendations for instructors, do not provide much added value.
