No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 16 June 2005
Spatializing International Politics: Analyzing Activism on the Internet. By Jayne Rogers. New York: Routledge, 2003. 184p. $96.95.
Recent anxiety about variable electoral turnout, falling party membership, and opinion polls depicting the disaffection of young people with politics has led some commentators to suggest that democratic politics in many countries is in crisis. While these concerns may reflect a significant dissatisfaction among citizens with their politicians and representative institutions, it may however be far too early to conclude that people have ceased to be interested in participating in the political arena.
Recent anxiety about variable electoral turnout, falling party membership, and opinion polls depicting the disaffection of young people with politics has led some commentators to suggest that democratic politics in many countries is in crisis. While these concerns may reflect a significant dissatisfaction among citizens with their politicians and representative institutions, it may however be far too early to conclude that people have ceased to be interested in participating in the political arena.
In her book, Jayne Rogers offers an alternative perspective of democratic participation through the adoption and creative shaping of the new communications media, such as the Internet. There have, of course, been numerous accounts of the potential use of the Internet to foster democracy and empower citizens. Yet very little empirical evidence has been found to support these utopian accounts in practice. Rogers's contribution to the debate is altogether more grounded in a cautious appraisal of the actual use of the new media by nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) for political activism. While aware of the potential of information and communications technologies (ICTs) to provide a valuable tool for NGOs both to challenge “official” public information and to offer alternative perspectives to an international online audience, Rogers thankfully resists the cyber-hype that has dominated much of the early debate in this field. As the title suggests a central concern of Spatializing International Politics is to foreground the limitations of the state-centric orientation of traditional international relations approaches and to develop a spatially theoretical model that can be applied to the behavior of international nonstate actors. The global and flexible electronic networks that offer many-to-many communication any time of the day, while not eliminating the dominant role of the nation-state in political analysis, do however offer new international dimensions for human interactions and access to contested and competing information sources.
The book is structured to provide, in the first part, a detailed critical exposition of spatial theorizing in IR and the weakness of these accounts as a means for understanding contemporary international political activism by NGOs, which utilize ICTs. Feminist writers have for some time provided valuable insights into the role of political spaces for legitimizing particular political practices and discourses. Rogers draws very effectively upon the work of these feminist scholars to make an argument for the possibility of respatializing IR models and perspectives to include nonstate actors as a component of the political arena, instead of simply “outside” the nation-state.
Chapters exploring the nature of the new media and NGOs are provided for those less familiar with these complex areas and are necessary for the author's later arguments. The central chapters, which provide case study material on the actual use of the Internet by political activists, may well be of most interest to many readers. An examination of four types of nonstate activism is undertaken on the basis of interviews with members of a number of NGOs within each classification. Rodgers draws her typology of NGOs according to what she describes as those largely concerned with “structural issues,” such as transnational NGOs, and independent online media, and those orientated around “issue-specific politics,” such as genetically modified foods and missile defense.
The author's findings give a compelling impression of an increasingly sophisticated adoption of the new media for very diverse objectives. The transnational NGOs studied, Amnesty International, Friends of the Earth, the Association of Progressive Communications, and One World, offer examples of clearly thought out and targeted application of the Internet. As Rogers remarks, “the gold-rush to simply have a presence on the Internet is over and many organizations are now using the technology much more strategically, designing online campaigns around specific goals” (p. 83). The independent media organizations, such as Squall, Indymedia and AlterNet, are similarly using the new ICTs to plan and coordinate their activities to achieve their objectives of providing alternative information sources that would not otherwise be available to a wider audience. The issue-specific activism also provides good accounts of the use of the Internet, as well as the differences to be observed between the pro- and anti-genetically modified foods combatants (the latter being required to use the media for more interactive repertoires of action) and the cultural differences in the missile debate between the Alaskan and UK activists (the former favoring Internet communications over the telephone dominance of the latter for mobilization).
The final chapters of the book provide an analysis of the importance of online activism for retheorizing the discourses of special politics. The author sensibly makes no grand claims for what remains a complex and contested domain. This book does, I believe, make a significant contribution to raising some critical questions about both the limitations of traditional models of IR and the challenges for the discipline to take seriously the changing spatial relationship and role of NGOs, significantly facilitated by new media, to shape future models of democratic governance.