The Spanish Civil War cast a long shadow over scientific endeavour within Spain, forcing many leading specialists into exile and subjecting the entire scientific community to a rigorous process of political and ideological purging, carried out from 1939 in the name of the military dictatorship of General Franco. This collection of essays provides many useful insights into the relationship of the Franco regime and its repressive policies on science with the concept of fascism and the experience of scientists in Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy.
Although most of the book is focused very much on Spain, it begins with an extensive and comparative survey of the relationship between science and other fascist regimes and of the broad historiographical contours of the three cases under scrutiny. This section, produced by Amparo Gómez, is one of the most stimulating, offering a critique of the notion of ‘pseudo-science’ in relation to fascism and focusing attention on the role (and type) of the state as a key determinant of scientific activity. Following the introduction, there are three substantive sections. The first has two chapters, one by Pere Ysàs and the other by Ismael Saz, which set the scene, providing full and up-to-date social and political background to the post-Civil War authoritarian regime, which veered unpredictably in its repressive strategies between theocratic nationalism and full-blown totalitarianism. Neither chapter looks explicitly at regime policies towards science, as such, and it is possible to take issue with use of the term ‘consent’ to encapsulate popular attitudes to political authority in the aftermath of bloody civil war, but state–society relations, the role of ideology and doctrine (particularly related to Catholicism) and the internal conflicts of regime politics (essentially between fascists and Catholics) are all clearly set out here and are necessary to a thorough comprehension of what follows.
The second section consists of three chapters which turn towards science by analysing aspects of its politics in the 1940s. It should be noted that, although the dictatorship endured until 1975, the period of study in this volume is largely that beginning with the end of the Civil War in 1939 and ending with cautious liberalization in the late 1950s. As this section demonstrates, the priorities in relation to science (and, indeed, culture in general) during this era were determined by the institutionalization of Franco's victory. Doctrinal rupture with the liberal positivism of the enlightened, pre-war, Second Republic (constituted in 1931) was based on a rhetoric of past glories which rejected the advances of the eighteenth century, as Antonio Canales and Margarita Santana de la Cruz make clear, and advocated a return to the high point of Catholic power two hundred years before. Importantly, the rupture also entailed a purge of the practitioners of positivist science, including a wholesale ejection of university professors considered to be suspect ideologically because they had been sympathetic to, or beneficiaries of, the pre-war democracy. The post-war political ‘purification’ was far more thorough than similar processes under Italian Fascism or Nazism in Germany, as the introduction makes clear. In the process, there were many opportunities for careers to be made at the expense of colleagues who were forced into exile or inactivity, something which was a feature common to other similar political situations. Rupture with the past also meant the establishment of new scientific institutions. Inmaculada Perdomo shows how, in particular, the liberal and enlightened Junta de Ampliación de Estudios (Advanced Research Board – JAE), established in 1907, primarily to allow promising students in the sciences and humanities to benefit from study grants to spend time in European universities, seminars and laboratories, was done away with and replaced in 1939 with the ideologically inspired – and almost wholly inward-looking – Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (Council of Advanced Scientific Research – CSIC), charged with developing a ‘National–Catholic’ science. In 1932, the JAE had inaugurated the Spanish National Institute of Physics and Chemistry and the biological Instituto Cajal, named after Spain's only – in those days – Nobel laureate, but their work was reoriented as part of the academic ‘scorched-earth policy’ (p. 279) of the new Franco regime after 1939 which included the sanction of many of the most active pre-war protagonists of experimental study.
The third section of the book focuses upon particular scientific disciplines, especially those with a clearly social dimension: eugenics, psychiatry, sexology and paediatrics (covered interestingly by Antonio Polo), as well as biological sciences. In the first of these chapters Raquel Álvarez considers critically the eugenic ideas and writings during the 1920s and 1930s of the internationally famous endocrinologist Gregorio Marañón (1887–1960), which are viewed here as a prelude to a resurgence of racial hygiene with the victory of Franco. Although Marañón was associated politically in the 1930s with the republican movement (albeit its most conservative section), his mild Catholicism, it is argued, shaped his relatively retrograde understanding and application of eugenic thinking. Whilst Marañón chose to live out the Civil War in Paris and returned to Spain only in 1947, other individuals benefited from the brusque political change of course brought about by the war. The fate of Spanish psychiatry lay, to a large extent, in the hands of the military psychiatrist and Francoist ideologue Antonio Vallejo Nágera, and the chapter by Rafael Huertas constitutes a brief survey of the outlandish blend of Catholic moralism, inquisitorial brutality and bio-typology which characterized Vallejo's theories and practices in the 1940s. Interestingly, the last chapter of the section, by María Jesús Santemases, provides useful biographical details about key figures within the traumatized scientific community partly extracted from the ‘political responsibilities’ files containing notes on their ‘culpability’ and demonstrating their surprisingly varied career trajectories after 1939. Finally, having maintained a close focus throughout, it is not clear how the single chapter in Section 4, authored by Brian Rappert and Brian Balmer, about science and governing WMD threats – however interesting in itself – fits into the essential aims of what is, overall, a valuable contribution to the literature on science under Franco.
