Avner Wishnitzer's excellent book brings illumination to a subject very little studied for the Middle Eastern world, and that is the night. Covering the long 18th century stretching from 1703 to the 1820s and focusing almost exclusively on Istanbul, with some discussion of Jerusalem, the book examines the impact of darkness on individuals, the fear and insecurity it induced and the dangers it conjured up, both real and imagined. It considers the role of the night in spiritual illumination, and what the night meant for the state, presenting it with both an obscurity it could not control and a murky world of illegal trade from which it benefited, as well as a canvas for the projection of power and piety, a backdrop whose illumination brought with it legitimation of sultanic power. The night also presented a world of illicit entertainment, where nighttime offered concealment and a cover for activities not acceptable in the light of day.
For many people in the Ottoman empire in the 18th century, night represented the time to withdraw, to be locked away in their homes and definitely not out and about on the streets. It was, to use Wishnitzer's phrase, a “disquieting” time. The night robbed people of their ability to see, and the deep darkness into which Istanbul, like other early modern cities, was plunged with the setting of the sun undermined people's sense of control, leaving them to rely largely or solely on their sense of hearing to understand and interpret what was going on around them. It is this “aural texture of the night” (17) that Wishnitzer sets out to reconstruct in the first section of his book.
Just as for its subjects, for the state too the night represented the realm of the unknown and uncontrollable, “the temporal frontier of its power” (47). Wishnitzer notes that although scholarship has been very aware of the geography of public order, its treatment of the temporal dimensions has been “cruder,” and, he argues, scholarship largely remains “night-blind” (47). It is this failure to engage with the challenges that the night specifically posed to the imposition of order that Wishnitzer also sets out to tackle. Blinded by the darkness, the guilds and neighborhood surveillance, the mainstays of the everyday network of urban order, were hampered in their ability to function, leaving the way open to illegal trafficking and illicit activity. The darkness of the night also provided an excellent arena for opposition and dissent, which “was more comfortable in the dark” (115). Undermined in its ability to control, the state at times turned to fear as a weapon of order.
At the same time, the state also benefited from illegal nocturnal activities, turning a blind eye to illicit trade and instead reaping tax revenue from it, as it did, for example, in the case of alcohol consumption. It is within this context, too, that one must understand the ambivalence toward the closing of taverns, for such “dens of disorder” at least on occasion were an integral support of the so-called forces of order. While drawing benefit from what was in theory not permissible but which flourished largely untouched under the cover of darkness, the state also found itself enmeshed in a complex web of interests and financial entanglements that bound forces of order and illegal trade together in a symbiotic relationship of mutual benefit over which the state was unable to exert effective control.
As Wishnitzer notes, however, it was not always the state's inability to act that left the field open for nocturnal illegality. The cover of darkness also provided the cover of assumed ignorance. In other words, it was much easier for the government to pretend that such activities were not taking place, leaving it to benefit from them in the case of provisioning, for example, which ensured supplies to the city outside guild control.
For some, the night was a time of entertainment, of freedom from the social norms that dominated the day. As Wishnitzer puts it, night was “more tolerant than the days” (82); it was in this respect “a space of ambivalence and ambiguity” (111). The concept of nightlife might not have existed, according to Wishnitzer, in the early modern Ottoman empire, but its reality certainly did, although, largely unnoted in the sources, its extent remains obscured, what we know being merely “the tip of a huge iceberg submerged in a sea of darkness” (84). It was the night that “facilitated transformations and transgressions hardly possible during the day” (101); under cover of darkness coffeehouses and hammams became taverns and brothels, and men seeking alcohol, gambling, and illicit sex could “cross into the mischievous and come back again, their respectability intact” (102).
Not all nighttime activity was linked to drunkenness or debauchery. “As the seen world faded into the dark, the unseen became more accessible” (143), and the night also was the setting for more spiritual activities involving contemplation, solitary introspection, and prayer. It also was the site of nocturnal conviviality as exemplified by the meclis (gathering) Wishnitzer argues that in such gatherings the night figured “not merely as a safe haven from hegemonic socioreligious norms” but also “served to cultivate intimacy and cement personal bonds among participants” (128).
Although the night provided cover for acts both beneficial and dangerous, it was the ability to dispel darkness that signaled the power of the state. Light and power went hand in hand. That the sultan through his nighttime entertainments could banish the darkness underlined his power, for “there is no better demonstration of sultanic power than the ability to turn night into day” (187). It was the tulip era and the grand vezirate of Damad İbrahim Paşa, Wishnitzer argues, that foregrounded the use of nighttime for both leisure and politics. Although accepting the view of scholars who have argued against a discrete tulip era and regard it as part of a continuum rather than a distinct period in itself, he nevertheless regards Damad İbrahim Paşa's term of office as “unique” and the tulip era as one that witnessed “a significant intensification of nocturnal sociability” (175). Illumination also was linked to piety, and the lighting up of the great sultanic mosques served to display graphically both the power of the sultan and his piety; with illumination came legitimacy.
In this the Ottomans were in many ways no different from their European contemporaries, whose rulers too turned to illumination to radiate power, to legitimate through extravagant light displays and to project themselves as rulers with the power to turn night into day. With this came the discourse of the Enlightenment, the metaphor of light for reason, and the idiom of the enlightened royal power. But, Wishnitzer warns, such similarities were “ultimately rather superficial,” as the Ottomans “continued to interpret light within long-standing traditions that if anything, turned eastward and not westward for inspiration. If light was to some extent a universal political language, it also had very local dialects” (175).
Wishnitzer's excellent exposition of the Ottoman night sheds light on such dialects and on the complexities of what happened after dark in the cities of the empire.
