Friedrich Flick (1883–1972), the architect of the firm whose history this book traces, and Friedrich Karl Flick (1927–2006), his successor and heir, are two of the most notorious figures in German business history. A sharp-elbowed self-made man, the elder Flick rose to prominence in the German coal and steel industries during World War I and the ensuing Great Inflation, played a prominent role in the creation of the massive United Steelworks (Vereinigte Stahlwerke) during the 1920s, and greatly expanded his own holdings in heavy industry during the Nazi era by supporting German rearmament and acquiring companies that Jews sold under duress. Following World War II, about two-thirds of his industrial empire fell behind the Iron Curtain, and an American Military Tribunal convicted him of war crimes and sent him to prison, from which he was released in 1950. He then rebuilt and diversified his holdings with the help of the Deutsche Bank to include large shares of some of Germany's most prominent enterprises, such as Feldmhle AG, Buderus, and Daimler-Benz, and passed the conglomerate on in 1972 to his third son, Friedrich Karl, who further extended the family-owned holding company until it embraced some sixty firms. The son also carried on the paternal practice of unscrupulous political bribery, in that the father's handsome donations to Himmler and the SS in the 1930s and 1940s were succeeded in the 1970s and early 1980s by the son's ample illegal contributions to West German politicians. The exposure of this activity in the so-called Parteispendenaffre only hastened the toppling of an already shaky financial pyramid. In 1985 Friedrich Karl sold the family's holdings to the Deutsche Bank for almost two billion dollars, and the name Flick disappeared from the German industrial landscape.
Because the Flicks' history combines commercial success and moral failure, scholars long have highlighted the father and son as epitomes of capitalist corruption in modern Germany. Nonetheless, recent years have seen something of a “Flick boom” in scholarship with the appearance not only of the book under review here, but also of even more massive studies by two research teams, one led by Norbert Frei (Flick. Der Konzern, Die Familie, Die Macht. Munich: Karl Blessing Verlag, 2009. Pp. 912) that covers essentially the same ground but is directed at a more general audience, and the other by Johannes Bhr that focuses on the Nazi era and includes a contribution by Kim Priemel (Der Flick-Konzern im Dritten Reich. Munich: R. Oldenbourg Verlag, 2008. Pp. xvi, 1018). These three volumes amount to an outpouring within a three-year period of 2,810 pages about the Flicks, more than half of which deal with 1933–1945 alone. The precipitant of this sudden deluge is not the appearance of numerous new sources—though a few relevant collections surfaced in East German and East European archives during the 1990s, many other important documents remain locked away in the vaults of several successor firms—but the confluence of three independently instigated projects. Kim Priemel's books is the revised and shortened (!) version of a doctoral dissertation submitted to the University of Freiburg in 2002; the Frei team's study stems from a decision in 2003 on the part of one of Friedrich Flick's granddaughters to finance an independent scholarly inquiry that would not only produce a book, but also compile an archive on the Flicks and their firms (now deposited at the Berlin-Brandenburgisches Wirtschaftsarchiv); and the Bhr team's book results from the decision of the Stiftung Preussischer Kulturbesitz to fund a work under the auspices of Munich's Institut fr Zeitgeschichte. Because Priemel's dissertation was completed earliest and available to both the Frei and Bhr teams, it is, in a sense, the ur-text of all three works.
What will scholars learn from this text that is new? Not much that changes the familiar broad outlines of either Flicks' personality, character, motives, and deeds, but a great deal that deepens our knowledge of how the two men and their principal aides operated. For instance, the early chicaneries, notably the Gelsenberg Affair of 1932, in which Friedrich Flick persuaded the Brning Cabinet to buy him out of a bankrupt firm with public funds, and the “aryanizations” of Hochofenwerk Lbeck and the Petschek coal holdings, receive clearer, more insightful, and more thorough analysis than heretofore. In the process, the reader learns how cleverly and assiduously the elder Flick inserted into contracts and memos tendentious explanations of his conduct that later could be used to legitimate it. Still, given the extensive research to which the voluminous record of Friedrich Flick's postwar trial has been subjected, much of the book reads like an authoritative codification of information and views on previously contested or incompletely understood topics, rather than the charting of unknown territory. The freshest material comes in the final 200 pages concerning the collapse of Flick's properties at the end of the war, the occupation and war crimes trial, and the resurgence and then decline of the Flick family holding company in West Germany. Priemel rightly characterizes as “shocking” the duplicity and evidence tampering in which both Flick senior and his defense team engaged at Nuremberg (p. 630), and he is appropriately merciless in cataloging the cold-blooded focus on a steady flow of investment profits, unimpeded by any other potentially inhibiting values, that accounted, along with a genius for getting the German state invested in the success of his undertakings, for both the growth of the Flick concern under four successive regimes (the Wilhelmian Empire, the Weimar Republic, the Third Reich, and the Federal Republic) and its ultimate collapse.
All in all, this book is a formidable achievement. It attests to the author's fine command of an enormous body of literature and documentation, shrewd judgment of the historical actors involved, and astute analysis of complicated corporate maneuvers, both strategic and financial. Whether the repugnant characters at the heart of the story deserve the labor Kim Priemel has put in to comprehending them is, of course, another matter entirely.
