Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 June 2005
This article examines bioethics in Tanzania, particularly in relation to the HIV/AIDS epidemic for the following reasons: First, not only is HIV/AIDS the most alarming health problem in most parts of Africa, but the complexity of issues involved in medical and research ethics (codes of conduct and standard guidelines, conflicting rights and responsibilities, and issues of distributive justice) clearly illustrates the various levels of problems that bioethics—more precisely, both professional medical ethics and research ethics—faces in a poor, developing country. The article defends uniformity in the general, international bioethical guidelines but calls for wider discussion in their applicability in different economic and social conditions by claiming that in the present debates the issues of distributive justice, culture, and individual professional judgment have been tangled together in a manner that tends to justify double standards in practice. To avoid this confusion there is a need to find a more coherent approach to bioethics that brings together the normative requirements set by international guidelines, national policy planning, social ethics, and professional medical ethics.I thank particularly Dr. Louis Mlingi, Tanzanian Occupational Health Service, and Dr. Pekka Nokso-Koivisto, Tanzanian Occupational Health Service and the Nordic Clinic, for their insightful views and for sharing their personal experiences in the issues of medical ethics in Tanzania in relation to their participation in our development ethics project funded by the Finnish Academy of Science 2000–2003. Some of the empirical examples are collected from our medical and healthcare ethics training in Lindi, Southern Tanzania with the Finnish funded Professional and Civic Ethics Project (CPEP), 2003. In addition I am grateful to professor Zul Premji, Muhimbili University College of Health Sciences, Dar es Salaam, for his advise on research ethics in Tanzania.
This article examines bioethics in Tanzania, particularly in relation to the HIV/AIDS epidemic for the following reasons: First, not only is HIV/AIDS the most alarming health problem in most parts of Africa, but the complexity of issues involved in medical and research ethics (codes of conduct and standard guidelines, conflicting rights and responsibilities, and issues of distributive justice) clearly illustrates the various levels of problems that bioethics—more precisely, both professional medical ethics and research ethics—faces in a poor, developing country. The article defends uniformity in the general, international bioethical guidelines but calls for wider discussion in their applicability in different economic and social conditions by claiming that in the present debates the issues of distributive justice, culture, and individual professional judgment have been tangled together in a manner that tends to justify double standards in practice. To avoid this confusion there is a need to find a more coherent approach to bioethics that brings together the normative requirements set by international guidelines, national policy planning, social ethics, and professional medical ethics.
To understand the context of bioethical issues in a developing country that is in social transition, some brief background information on Tanzania is useful. Tanzania is an East African country located by the Indian Ocean with a population of more than 35 million (2004 estimation). It has a high mortality rate due to HIV/AIDS, poverty, various infectious diseases, and other curable illnesses. Life expectancy at birth for the total population is 52.26 years (male: 51.32 years, female: 53.23 years). Population growth in 2000 was estimated to be 2.57%, and infant mortality was 80.97 deaths per 1,000 live births. Total fertility rate was 5.51 children born per woman. Forty-five percent of the population is younger than 14 years old and only 3% lives to be over 65.
Tanzania1
The United Republic of Tanzania is a union state formed in 1964 between mainland Tanganyika and Zanzibar islands. Tanganyika became independent in 1961 from a United Kingdom-administered United Nations trusteeship and Zanzibar became independent December 19, 1963, from the United Kingdom. Tanganyika and Zanzibar united in 1964 to form the United Republic of Tanganyika and Zanzibar.
Tanzania is still one of the poorest countries in the world. Poverty is most severe in the countryside, where about 40% of the population lives below the basic needs poverty line. Illiteracy rates are high and the overall quality of education remains low, particularly after the transition from a socialist one-party system to multiparty democracy and market economy with full or partial privatization of most of the state industries and services.2
Tanzania's economy is heavily dependent on agriculture, which accounts for half of it gross national product, provides 85% of its exports, and employs 90% of the work force. Topography and climatic conditions, however, limit cultivated crops to only 4% of the land area. Industry is mainly limited to processing agricultural products and light consumer goods.
Against this background it is easy to surmise that for a poor country like Tanzania some of the main ethical problems in medical practice and healthcare, as well as in medical research, are related to the lack of adequate resources and the wide imbalance, locally and globally, of their distribution. The deficiency in resources creates problems in prioritizing and raises the following questions: Should more resources and energy be put into prevention of diseases or into the treatment of those already ill? On the treatment of which diseases should the health policies and services focus? Should they concentrate on treating curable diseases such as malaria, diarrhea, and bilharzias? Or should they invest more resources in treating the patients with incurable diseases such as HIV/AIDS and related symptoms (such as various opportunist infections)? How can a poor country organize healthcare policies and services in a manner that gives people, to the degree possible, fair access to severely limited resources?
The scarcity of resources is often related to the aforementioned corruption in all fields of public life, not only in government and law, but also in education and healthcare services. Lack of resources and corruption together further generate unprofessional behavior and a diminished concern for professional ethics. Thus, the problems with inadequate resources overlap with other ethical issues in medical practice such as the enforcement of medical codes of conduct.3
It should be noted here that the salaries of medical professionals—particularly in public healthcare—are relatively low (compared, e.g., to salaries of various other professionals or doctors working in private or international hospitals). This has fueled unprofessionalism in the form of corruption in the healthcare sector in Tanzania.
The application of international codes of medical conduct faces three major challenges in Tanzania. First, people working in healthcare and, in general, at medical facilities in the poorest regions may be doing various tasks and holding responsibilities that are beyond their level of training and professional skills. Many paramedical professionals (such as nurses, pharmacists, and laboratory technicians) particularly in remote, rural areas have received their basic medical training “on the job.”4
In rural Southern Tanzania, for instance, paramedicals such as nurses and pharmacists (and, in the most extreme cases, even long-time receptionists) may have ended up being asked to perform professional medical tasks and procedures, such as prescribing medicine to patients or testing patients for various infections, and, thus, they have been given medical responsibilities beyond their level of competence that they may not wish to assume.
Despite the practical problems in their enforcement, there are various mechanisms in place that support medical ethics in Tanzania. First, there are international regulations. Second, there are national laws (such as the law forbidding abortion and the sexual offence act that, e.g., makes female genital mutilation, rape, etc. illegal) and national policies (such as the National HIV/AIDS policy that guides national strategies to combat the epidemic). Third, there are the local belief and values systems and their related social ethics (e.g., traditions prohibiting women from eating eggs when pregnant). Often these different norms are inconsistent with each other, or their value base may appear to clash. With the simultaneous political and economic transition from collectivist socialist economy to more individualist market democracy, the values and practices in health, healthcare, and human well-being in general become confused: Cultural and traditional claims are tangled together, and the requirements of a market economy are set against the collectivist promotions of public health as well as the protection of individual rights.
International regulations governing medical research, healthcare, and medical practice, such as the Nuremberg Code (1947), Declaration of Helsinki (WMA, 1964 amended 1975, 1983, 1989, 2000), International Guidelines for Ethics Review of Epidemiological Studies (CIOMS, 1991), International Ethical Guidelines for Biomedical Research Involving Human Subjects (CIOMS, 1993, revised 2002), Universal Declaration on the Human Genome and Human Rights (UNESCO, 1997), Operational Guidelines for Ethics Committees that Review Biomedical Research (WHO, 2000), Ethical Consideration in HIV Preventive Vaccine Research (UBAIDS), and other similar documents are meant as general guidelines. As the revisions and amendments to these documents show, these guidelines have undergone various changes as thinking in the area continues to evolve, and thus they cannot be taken to provide absolute moral principles to be applied unreflectively. Their most important value is in providing some guiding principles and strategies for medical professionals, scientists, politicians, bureaucrats, policymakers, and government functionaries as well as other professionals who daily have to make medically relevant decisions.5
See Tangwa GB. International regulations and medical research in developing countries: Double standards or differing standards? Notizie di Politeia 2002;XVIII:46. National laws may or may not be based on these international recommendations. In Tanzania, for instance, abortion, though rigorously prohibited by law, is performed clandestinely, and hospital records show increasing numbers of women admitted to hospital for (incomplete) abortion. One reason for this is that maternal mortality rates are on the increase due to illegal abortion, frequent pregnancies, high parity, and women having children at ages recognized as high risk for pregnancy.
However, the main question in relation to the application of these international guidelines in poor countries like Tanzania and, more widely, in the developing world at large, has been the dilemma of whether we should accept that the same norms and standards are not directly applicable in very different economic and social contexts. If this claim is accepted without serious questioning, the use of double standards can be defended as acceptable and morally justifiable, even if in many cases they are based on lack of resources due to unequal global and local distribution. This claim against a universal application of international bioethics guidelines could be further (falsely) supported by an appeal to cultural rights and the demand that we should adopt altogether different standards based on the differences in our cultural backgrounds and belief and value systems. In general the question would then be whether two (or more) wrongs make it “right.”
The main questions that arise in relation to international normative principles of professional medical ethics in Tanzania are the following: Can the principle of doctor–patient confidentiality be violated in the interest of the public good or if doing so can save “innocent” lives on utilitarian grounds? Do local, traditional ethical norms that call for individual social duty and social solidarity actually give permission to violate such individualistic principles in the name of “the good of the community”? Do the international donor requirements give local governments or individual healthcare professionals the right to ban or abolish established traditions, if and when these traditions and practices are seen as hazardous to health (such as female genital mutilation)?
What makes these ethical questions and related value issues even more complex is the fact that in Tanzania, as well as in other African countries, there is still a large number of foreign physicians—as well as native healthcare professionals who have been trained in the West—working in both international hospitals and local medical facilities. Many medical professionals have their own views on how best to apply individualist (Western) medical ethics in various local contexts. In contrast, many people, particularly in rural Tanzania, are still relying on traditional medicine and traditional healers, whose ideas of ethics and healthcare practice in general are very different from those who have Western education, training, and resources. This mixture of practices and values as well as modern and traditional normative guidelines fuels the double standard in bioethics in Tanzania. If the patient is a rich expatriate who can afford to be treated in a private (often internationally funded) hospital, the strictest medical ethics standards are followed. However, the same doctors (maybe in their pro bono work) may relax their standards considerably in public healthcare institutions and with local patients who are not in the position to expect or request more stringent observance of medical ethics due to their own lack of education, awareness of providers' professional obligations and duties, resources to pay for even the most basic services, or lack of resources offered by their healthcare facilities; or who are themselves relying on the more traditional collectivist values and would rather rely on the “professional” authorities to make decisions on their behalf.
Because medical practice and medical research are interrelated in bioethics, it is important to understand the status of research ethics in Tanzania. The main problems in medical research have to do with community benefits, whether we talk about HIV/AIDS, malaria, or other research related to drug treatment development. Although it is generally argued that standards applied to research conducted in the developing world should be the same as those in developed countries, often researchers may compromise stricter requirements to accommodate what is usually available in underdeveloped settings.
To clarify the international normative requirements and their regional, national, and local application in Africa, there have been recent attempts to raise awareness about ethical issues, particularly in biomedical research. For instance, the Pan-African Bioethics Initiative (PABIN) is contributing to the global dialogue in relation to the International Cooperative Project on Best Practices in Health Research. The Initiative aims at ethical capacity building by examining and improving human subject protections in health research in Africa and by focusing on the operational procedures and the substantial issues that affect ethical review in Africa. It will also try to develop a relationship between investigators and ethics communities in Africa and review and discuss specific ethical issues arising in the context of guidelines and their effect on health research practices (e.g., the use of controls in clinical trials and the availability of product following research). A further goal is to examine the quality assurance standards and procedures used to develop health research projects, as well as the methodologies in Africa for applying international guidelines. In addition, the Initiative will consider the most feasible African approach to accrediting ethics review committees.6
PABIN also holds conferences and workshops in collaboration with the African Malaria Network Trust (AMNET). Proceedings of the Third PABIN Conference, 28–30 April 2003, Addis Ababa 2003. Report available at http://www.who.int/sidcer/fora/en/pabin3rd.pdf.
The National Health Research Forum in Tanzania is a mechanism composed of partner institutions in health research and their representatives. It bases its functions on the Essential National Health Research (ENHR) strategy, which ensures that evidence-based information is utilized correctly in the policy and decisionmaking process, thus enhancing the provision of better and more equitable health to the population. The Forum is a consultative and advisory body to policy and decisionmakers as regards health research coordination through its efforts in undertaking the collaboration and dissemination of health research results. It is a nonpolitical, nonreligious, voluntary body dealing only with issues of health research and development in the country. Goals of the Forum are as follows:
The National Health Research Ethics Committee,7
The National Health Research Ethics Committee is composed of representatives of the following organizations: the Commission for Science and Technology (COSTECH), The National Institute for Medical Research (NIMR), Department of Zoology of the University of Dar es Salaam, Muhimbili University College of Health Sciences (MUCHS), Christian Social Services Commission (CSSC), The Muslim Council of Tanzania (BAKWATA), Kilimanjaro Christian Medical Centre (KCMC), Ministry of Education, the media, Ministry of Health (MoH), Human Rights Centre, Ministry of Community Development, Women Affairs and Children, Tanzania Gender Networking Programme (TGNP), and Mbeya Referral Hospital.
The HIV/AIDS epidemic and related ethical dilemmas provide a good example of local problems in applying global ethical standards to the main health emergency in sub-Saharan Africa. Although HIV/AIDS is a global threat, according to the UNAIDS/WHO 2004 figures, the situation is still most severe in Africa and in those countries that, due to a lack of resources, are least able to deal with the epidemic. On a global scale, in 2003 more than 5 million people were newly infected with HIV worldwide. Of these, 4.2 million were adults and 700,000 were children below the age of 15 years. This brings the number of people living with HIV/AIDS around the world to more than 40 million. In the same year, more than 3 million people died of AIDS worldwide. Out of these, half a million were children below the age of 15 years. Since it was first diagnosed in 1981, HIV/AIDS has killed more than 20 million people worldwide.
Although HIV/AIDS is a global health challenge, infections are still concentrated largely in countries least able to afford the care for infected people.8
UNAIDS and WHO AIDS Epidemic Update, December 2003 and UNAIDS 2004 Report on the 4th Global AIDS Report. Reports available at http://www.unaids.org/en/default.asp.
In comparison to other East African countries, in Kenya an estimated 2.5 million of the over 30 million population are living with the virus, yielding an adult prevalence of 15%. It is estimated that from Uganda's over 24 million population, 600,000 were HIV positive. Although all countries have National AIDS Control Programs and Policies, which aim to hold back the epidemic, only Uganda's wide efforts have been able to produce clear results in fighting the spread of HIV/AIDS. WHO. World Health Organization Reporting on HIV and AIDS. AIDS: Images of the Epidemics. WHO, 1994. USAID. Country Profiles HIV/AIDS, Tanzania, Uganda, Kenya. Washington, DC, 2004, http://www.usaid.gov. UNAIDS. 2004 Report of the Global AIDS Epidemic. Geneva: UNAIDS, 2004, available at http://www.unaids.org.
The situation is most severe among young people, and the gender inequality is related to the fact that women, and especially young women, are more prone to infection than men. UNAIDS/WHO notes that women are 1.2 times more likely to get the infection than men. According to National AIDS Control Programme data, for example, HIV prevalence rates in Tanzania among male blood donors increased from 5.3% in 1992 to 8.7% in 1999 whereas among females it increased from 5.9% in 1992 to 12.6% in 1999. For 1998 and 1999 the prevalence across age groups for males ranged between 5.2% for the age group 15–19 and 10.1% for the age group 30–34 whereas for females it ranged from 7.0 to 14.9% for age groups 50–54 and 35–39, respectively. Similar trends have also been observed in other sub-Saharan countries.10
Flemming A. The next generation and AIDS. AIDS 1994;4; United Republic of Tanzania (URT), National Policy on AIDS. Dar es Salaam, Government Printer, 2001. AIDS in Africa is taking a center stage also in the global political arena as Western governments became increasingly concerned that the epidemic could lead to the emergence of radicalism and the undermining of emerging democracies when people lose their lives, health, and hope, while large number of people are being marginalized and stigmatized. The decision by pharmaceutical companies to withdraw their patent suit in South Africa after the mid-April 2001 world protests was an important step toward wider access to HIV/AIDS treatment though the drugs are still in most cases much too expensive for people in developing countries.
Data about AIDS cases in Tanzania remain incomplete and inconclusive as a result of underreporting due to the limited access of large segments of the population to healthcare facilities where the diagnosis of AIDS could be established. The underestimation of AIDS cases in Tanzania, for instance, is also due to the low efficiency of surveillance systems, the general lack of facilities for the diagnosis of AIDS, the reluctance of most Tanzanians to volunteer for HIV testing, and the delay by the government in acknowledging the severity of HIV infection until 1988. Despite these problems, the figures above show a disquieting situation that calls for united and coordinated efforts to fight the disease. In this context, dealing with the epidemic requires a comprehensive bioethical approach that includes a national HIV/AIDS policy that not only structures health priorities and addresses socioeconomic and medical issues, but also takes into account wider ethical and legal questions, such as professional medical ethics, social ethics related to various cultural traditions, policies, and related legal sanctions on testing, prevention, and treatment. The extension of ethical aspects of the situation is important because HIV/AIDS control requires more than just individual behavioral changes. It requires a multifaceted strategy in medical codes of ethics, in medical and healthcare policies as a whole, in the evaluation of cultural traditions and practices, and above all in increased and fair distribution of resources.
One main ethical dilemma in HIV/AIDS policies and practice as well as in professional medical ethics is the aforementioned conflict between the protection of individual rights and the promotion of public health. Many doctors and healthcare professionals in East Africa, for instance, face a dilemma when the ethical principles of autonomy in relation to the requirement of respect for privacy and confidentiality clash with the demands of social responsibility in the form of protecting those yet uninfected, particularly when the latter would require medical practitioners to reveal test results to a patient's family. Medical professionals may also have to determine whether to obtain informed consent from the patient for testing or to conduct the test routinely, even if the patient does not want to know his or her health status.
In the end, the final decisions are left to medical and healthcare practitioners, because the national policy on HIV/AIDS gives a rather superficial coverage to the main ethical questions. The policy provides for both voluntary and linked testing and anonymous and unlinked testing of individuals. Individuals who go for voluntary and linked testing are provided with pre- and posttest counseling and are encouraged to inform their sexual partners of their test results or to invite them for counseling prior to being informed of the test results. The general experience, however, seems to be that many individuals do not disclose their test results to partners or family members, nor do they want anyone else to disclose them. One reason for this is the wide stigmatization of people living with HIV/AIDS. The disclosure of infection could lead to domestic violence and/or abandonment, unemployment, and social isolation. Particularly because Tanzania is still a widely patriarchal society, if a woman is infected it is easy for a man to take advantage of the disclosure and blame her for infecting him. This has led to further discrimination of women that leaves them even more vulnerable.11
Baylies C. Perspectives on gender and AIDS in Africa. In: Baylies C, Bujira J, eds. AIDS, Sexuality and Gender in Africa. London: Routledge, 2000.
Other situations where the codes of confidentiality and informed consent do not seem to be sufficient in dealing with the HIV testing and individual's health status are related to the current Tanzanian policy and practice in relation to blood donors. If blood donors are found to be HIV positive, they are not informed about their sero-status. At some hospitals blood is drawn from HIV positive donors and then discarded; at others, they are told that they have the wrong blood type or that their hemoglobin levels are too low for them to become donors. This policy is based on the fact that the current rapid tests frequently used in screening donors lack precision. Most hospitals lack the facilities and equipment for confirming test results. Furthermore, conveying test results requires extensive counseling before and after testing. Again, the capacity to offer these counseling services is lacking at most of the local hospitals in Tanzania.12
Ndumbaro L, Siplon P. Tanzania's HIV/AIDS policy: Emerging ethical issues. Unpublished paper prepared for the 3rd AmFiTan Conference in Helsinki, August 2002; Rugemalila JB. The epidemiology of AIDS in Tanzania. In: Proceedings of the 12th Annual Joint Scientific Conference, Arusha, Tanzania, 1994; Swai RO. Epidemiology of AIDS in Tanzania. In: Killewo JZJ et al. (eds). Behavioral and Epidemiological Aspects of AIDS Research in Tanzania. Stockholm, 1992.
Commonsense ethics would defend a public health professional's responsibility to inform an HIV positive person of his or her sero-status and its consequence, so as to prevent that person from spreading the disease. What makes the policy ethically more suspect is the fact that health personnel are in practice forced to give HIV positive donors information that they know is incorrect, leading blood donors to conclude that they are HIV negative. Having to conceal the truth in this manner is a serious problem for health workers, who depend on a trusting relationship between themselves and the public. The policy remains silent on this issue, apart from the ambiguous statement that “the approved screening centers will offer pre- and posttest counseling services to all blood donors.”13
United Republic of Tanzania, National Policy on HIV/AIDS, 2001:18.
Ryder RW. Difficulties associated with providing HIV-free blood supply in tropical Africa. AIDS 1992:6.
The provisions made for HIV testing and disclosure of HIV test results, which are central to preventing the spread of the virus, appear to officially emphasize the protection of infected individuals over and above the uninfected,15
This is partly because in its early days, AIDS in Tanzania, for instance, was attached to prostitution as well as to homosexuality (the existence of which, nevertheless, is still widely disputed and/or denied; Zanzibar passed a law in 2004 that can lead to the arrest of individuals suspected of homosexual activities/same sex relations and imprisonment for up to 25 years). As still deeply religious and spiritual nations (whether this spirituality appears in forms of Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, or indigenous belief system), many East Africans tend to see HIV/AIDS as God's punishment for those who commit adultery or other evil acts. Although perhaps hypocritical, with double standards in sexual relations and fidelity, this approach still tends to lead to intolerance and prejudice against people with HIV/AIDS. The negative attitude of many religious leaders toward condom use further fuels the spread of the epidemic, despite the attempts to encourage abstinence and sexual fidelity.
In the Tanzanian constitution, for instance, there are distinct clauses for the protection of collective rights, including national interest, that can be used to violate the protection of individual rights. Hellsten S. Human rights versus the common good in the African constitutional development and democratization process: The case of Tanzania. The African Review 1999;26:3–77.
The issue of breaching confidentiality in relation to HIV/AIDS testing, however, is always a two-edged sword. If confidentiality is breached publicly, there is the likelihood that even fewer people will seek testing to determine their health status. The stigmatization involved in HIV/AIDS often prevents even those who might otherwise take social responsibility from revealing their status. In Tanzania, as in many other African countries, AIDS has been stigmatized primarily because it is thought to be transmitted mainly through certain high-risk sexual behaviors and also because persons who are infected are perceived as putting others at risk by violating the value of social responsibility. Consequently, AIDS-related stigma has led to discriminatory practices toward HIV-infected individuals, including harassment, threats of job discrimination, and removal from school. Thus, although society has a legitimate interest in protecting public health, that is, the health of uninfected citizens, and in controlling any further spread of HIV, the policies it formulates to realize these ends must also attend to the needs and rights of infected persons or others affected by the disease.17
See note 12, Ndumbaro, Siplon 2002.
The issue of cultural integrity is also central for medical ethics in relation to HIV/AIDS prevention and treatment. It combines the issues of group rights and the promotion of traditional cultures and individuals' cultural identities and willingness to abide by new, modern regulations and recommendations for different ways of life than what they are used to. The problem that arises is the fact that not only may the religious or spiritual beliefs (such as the opposition to condom use) be obstacles to preventing AIDS, but various other cultural traditions and practices may contribute to the spread of HIV/AIDS. This is also directly related to the issues of gender inequality and the violation of the rights of women that has led to a growing “feminization” of HIV/AIDS in Africa, particularly among young people aged 15–24. These discrepancies have been attributed to several factors, including the biological fact that HIV is more easily transmitted from men to women (than vice versa). Also, sexual activity tends to start earlier for females, with young women tending to have sex with much older partners. Women also have less to say in determining with whom, when, and under what circumstances they have sex. In many Tanzanian local cultures there are also socio-cultural traditions (e.g., male and female genital mutilations, polygamy, widow inheritance, conjugal bonds, and few social sanctions on premarital or extramarital sex) that contribute to the further spread of HIV/AIDS, particularly among women. Because of gender inequality, women have less influence on policies concerning HIV/AIDS, and women living with HIV/AIDS often experience greater stigma and discrimination. From the point of view of medical ethics and bioethics, this is directly related to the lack of women's reproductive rights and freedom, and it becomes an issue of professional ethics when doctors and healthcare professionals need to advise, educate, and help women despite the wishes of their communities or against cultural beliefs and practices.18
Baylies C. Perspectives on gender and AIDS in Africa. In: Baylies C, Bujira J, eds. AIDS, Sexuality and Gender in Africa. London: Routledge, 2000; see note 9, UNAIDS 2004.
This brings the debate back to the conflicts between group and individual rights, which can be a particular problem in countries where collective rights still exist in the constitution. Questions arise as to whether the state has the right (or possibly an obligation) to intercede against cultural practices that are believed to facilitate the spread of AIDS or whether this is violation of cultural tolerance and integrity. Should the state offer information to individuals that may be viewed as immoral or unethical from the point of view of particular cultural groups? Do some high-risk populations have greater moral claim to resources than others? Do some cultures merit more education and resource allocation than others depending on their lifestyles and traditions? What level of support should be extended to the surviving children and spouses of those who have died?
This article has focused on the complexity of the issues related to the international application of universal ethical standards of medical practice and research in Tanzania, as well as in poor countries generally. In discussions on the global standards of bioethics, or the lack of such, there tend to be parallel debates: one on global distributive justice and the other on clashing cultural values. However, the difficult questions about bioethics in Tanzania, for instance, are not primarily about potential cultural clashes or value conflicts—that is, the debate on the compatibility of individualist and collectivist (or Western vs. African) value systems as such. More widely, they are about the lack of resources or the unequal distribution of existing resources, whether we talk about material inequality, ethnic imbalance, or gender disparity in a global or local context. The relation between these two separate, but mutually influential, dimensions of “global bioethics” has to be clearly recognized if we want to avoid double standards that can give justification to various forms of unprofessionalism (from corruption to the use of unskilled personnel to take over the tasks of “missing” physicians) in the name of efficiency in service delivery or in the name of cultural rights. Therefore, I suggest that in a Tanzanian and in a wider African context, we should explore bioethical questions in the following distinct, but clearly overlapping, areas of debates:
Bioethics guidelines should bring together international guidelines, national laws, and local social ethics in coherent sets of norms, rather than leave them to compete with and contradict each other.