As another round of national elections draws near, so too do the increasingly familiar lamentations of election observers and reform advocates: Campaigns are too negative and expensive; candidates offer no substance or dialogue; voters are apathetic and ignorant. As Keena Lipsitz notes on page 1: “Americans love to hate campaigns.” In Competitive Elections and the American Voter, she seeks to aid reformers and scholars by providing a more thorough empirical foundation to the many proposals for ways to improve elections. Increasing the competitiveness of elections, she concludes, provides the best chance of improving the campaign information environment.
Lipsitz is concerned primarily with the information environment of the campaign—the information about the candidates and parties available to citizens before the election. Consequently, she starts by asking what alternative democratic theories—competitive, egalitarian, and deliberative—ask of campaigns and voters. From here, she draws out five characteristics of campaign information that reflect a promising campaign information environment: volume, diversity, dialogue, equality between contenders, and absence of deception.
Focusing on the campaign environment as shaped by advertising, the author first considers how electoral competition affects the information environment. Using advertising data collected by Campaign Media Analysis Group and coded and shared by the Wisconsin Advertising Project, Lipsitz develops five measures of the information environment: the number of ads (volume), the number of unique ad sponsors (diversity), the ratio of incumbent-supporting ads to challenger-supporting ads (equality), issue convergence (dialogue), and the proportion of attack ads (negativity). Using the Cook Political Report method of ranking of competitiveness—safe, leans heavily toward a candidate, likely to favor a candidate, or toss-up—she models the impact of competition on these characteristics of the information environment.
Lipsitz looks at more than one type of election, however. She considers House, Senate, and state-level presidential campaign environments. Unlike much work on campaigns that emphasizes only one of these environments, the author seeks to build the most generalizable case. She finds that in all of these types of elections, competitiveness improves the information environment; but the nature of the effects differs across elections and information attributes. In some cases, it is linear (e.g., competition and volume of ads in House campaigns), in others it is nonlinear (e.g., competition and diversity of ads in Senate campaigns), and in still others, there is a threshold effect that sets in at a modest level of competition (e.g., competition and dialogue in Senate campaigns) or at a higher level of competition (e.g., competition and equality in presidential campaigns). In other words, the key result is clear, but the details are complicated.
In the empirical heart of the book, Lipsitz tests how these informational attributes impact voter knowledge and, to a lesser extent, participation across House, Senate, and state-level presidential elections. What characteristics of information, she asks, account for voter learning, especially in competitive campaigns? Various elements of voter knowledge—the ability to rate House candidates, to rate Senate candidates, to identify the ideology of House incumbents, to identify issue positions of presidential candidates—are examined and modeled as a function of the five distinct information characteristics, the interaction of information volume with each of the four remaining information characteristics, and key controls.
Among the many findings are the following: While ad volume alone increases the likelihood that voters can rate House candidates, an understanding of incumbent ideology only improves when quantity is combined with high levels of equality, diversity, dialogue, or negativity. In Senate campaigns, as well, only a high volume of ads combined with plenty of negativity or dialogue produces a clear positive effect on voter knowledge. As to identifying the issue positions of presidential candidates, equality, diversity, and negativity all boost citizen knowledge, but dialogue, when combined with a high volume of ads, undermines it. While negativity is consistently beneficial, candidate dialogue is not, an important and somewhat unexpected finding.
The ambitiousness of the book—in particular, covering House, Senate, and state-level presidential elections—proves both a strength and a weakness. Lipsitz more than adequately reinforces the conclusion that campaign effects cannot be generalized across these different electoral contexts. In doing so, she presents an almost dizzying array of results (85 models are provided in the chapters, with another 30-plus in the appendix). A reader may find it easy to get lost in the weeds, at the expense of the bigger picture. At a minimum, it will be hard for those uninitiated in quantitative political science work (i.e., undergraduates) to absorb.
Moreover, the tantalizing differences across election types raise many unanswered questions, some noted by Lipsitz herself: Are the differences real or a function of different measured outcomes across elections? Do they stem from simple differences in campaign intensity and media attention or from some of the other dissimilarities across the election types? Do informational characteristics have the same meaning across electoral contexts? For instance, does the number of advertising sponsors represent the same sort of diversity in House campaigns and presidential campaigns, given the often different array of players involved? Are the informational needs the same across electoral contexts, and do citizens themselves understand them to be?
The thought and effort to tie the work into democratic theories—and not just a vague all-purpose democratic theory—is spot-on. How each element was derived from the relevant theories, though, was not always fully elaborated. For example, deception, introduced in the first chapter, plays little or no role in the consideration of the demands of democratic theories (or in the analysis), and negativity, which plays an important role in the analysis, is not obviously tied to any desirable outcome of the democratic theories considered here. These omissions loom large, as research increasingly points to both misinformation and negativity as persistent hallmarks of American campaigns.
The book is at its strongest in the empirical chapters. The delineation and measurement of different attributes of the campaign information environment (beyond negativity) is an important contribution. The author builds on work that attempts to designate better and worse information types, and she provides evidence regarding the elements of information that are actually more and less useful. Her careful analytic approach accommodating interaction between, and potential nonlinearity of, the information characteristics makes for a much more realistic and interesting story. Lipsitz is right to suggest that future work on the effects of campaign information and advertising will need to incorporate these informational elements, or dimensions akin to them, into theory and analysis.
The work ends with a thorough consideration of the potential reforms, their likelihood of promoting greater electoral competition, and the likelihood that it is in the interests of any powerful actors to pursue them. A thought-provoking epilogue walks the reader through various metaphors of campaigns—campaigns as battles, as sporting events, and as town hall meetings—analyzing how the congruence and incongruence of the metaphors with campaigns helps explain the citizenry's lack of enthusiasm for campaigns. These metaphors have parallels to the democratic theories considered previously and could be fruitfully brought back into conversation with them.
Students of American elections will find a great deal to like in this effort. Campaign scholars will find a clear demonstration of the value in disaggregating campaign information into distinct components. Reform advocates will find an empirical foundation to guide and justify their efforts.
