Dance Lest We All Fall Down documents the rise of a grassroots organisation in urban Brazil by portraying the author's journey from the first encounter with the local society to co-leadership in a successful NGO. A friendly invitation takes Margaret Willson on a detour to her next anthropological fieldwork site. She starts by recalling how she spent her first night in Brazil, sleeping on the roof of her friend's house, surrounded by one of the many poverty-stricken favelas, and escaping the suffocating heat and crowding below only to be ambushed by ants and mosquitoes above.
In joining Willson in her encounters with Brazilian society, we witness her growing love, fascination, respect and admiration for urban Afro-Brazilians. Her vivid field notes from years of living in Salvador both divulge how the people she comes to know struggle with severe poverty and racial discrimination and reveal important features of the local society, ranging from crack to candomblé. Finally, back in the United States, Willson confesses that she is haunted by depression and ‘demons of hopelessness that visited with the news each morning’ (p. 140). Her emotional reactions trigger the urge to start a new NGO. She recalls how a phone call to her friend Rita Conceição in Salvador results in air tickets, a cold beer at their favourite bar and the formation of the organisation's main ideas.
After consulting people living in the favelas, Willson explains, the women decide to focus on an educational programme for poor girls. Bahia Street is founded. In developing the organisation, the two women emphasise the importance of adjusting the curriculum to the participants' life-worlds. The organisation was set up to provide not just general education of high quality, but also information on health and reproduction and courses on social inequality and violence. Willson narrates that she and her colleagues painfully experience how the education of the girls depends on their general well-being, so the organisation also starts offering healthy nutrition, medical care, therapy and family counselling.
Willson recounts the formation of the organisation step by step, illustrating the tricky paths of her and Conceição's progress in organisational knowledge and the participants' thorny paths from illiteracy to university. Her chronological memoirs are complemented by her periodic electronic newsletters headed ‘Dear Donors, Friends, and Volunteers’. She reports honestly about the process, including accounts of wearisome encounters with the British aristocracy and the Brazilian bureaucracy, and unpleasant conflicts with ethnocentric US lawyers and patronising US college students. The story of Bahia Street demonstrates that it is not only possible but also necessary to embrace the energy, knowledge, competence and judgements of the local community in founding a successful NGO. By acknowledging how a ‘charity’ might end up oppressing the people it is set up to help, Willson and Conceição encourage local contribution and empowerment. They are not only able to subvert the very power structures in which they are embedded, but also learn how to use these structures to their advantage.
As Willson herself stresses, the book does not fit neatly into any genre. It is highly personal, emotional, informal and confessional, combining poetic depictions with academic reflections. Willson's raw and honest approach both enriches and gives credibility. Many of the frustrations admitted and challenges discussed – such as arrogance, racism, internal power struggles and friends turning board members – are shoved beneath the carpet far too often in accounts of successful NGOs. Scenes from field notes are consciously selected to trigger reflections on patronage systems and power relations within the world of NGOs. Being a white, middle-class North American leading an NGO for poor Afro-Brazilians, Willson situates herself in the midst of potential minority/majority world controversy. In avoiding potential pitfalls, she openly questions the motives of her own and others' idealism, while demonstrating her ability to mediate between the different socio-cultural backgrounds at play in the organisation.
In my opinion, the only drawback with Willson's narrative is the language she occasionally uses in describing unfortunate people in Salvador: ‘The street boys knew they could die any day and would easily slit your stomach if they thought you were preventing them from getting money for food or for glue’ (p. 50), for example; and ‘She could hardly have survived this long on the street without being raped, probably several times. Her eyes had the look of someone who hasn't eaten enough for a long time. She was barefoot on this filthy street. If she looked to her future, she saw prostitution, begging, and death’ (p. 52). Although perhaps true, the conclusions drawn are deterministic. These portrayals might also reveal a tension within Willson as novelist and as academic. While this kind of simplistic language may raise money for NGOs, it undermines credibility in academia.
Although they are secondary, fieldwork experiences familiar to social scientists visiting foreign cultures are also considered in the book. Willson demonstrates the importance of being ‘street-wise’ for gaining access to a field perceived as dangerous by many, for instance by befriending the ‘Other’ in the public sphere, such as prostitutes and street children. Her memoirs depict the complex discourses on race, class and nationality in contemporary Brazil, as well as revealing the frustration of constantly being betwixt and between: while she identifies with her poor Afro-Brazilian friends, doing capoeira and speaking street Portuguese, she continues to be identified as a white foreigner. This not only evokes personal identity crises, but also causes distress among those in her company. Even though she identifies herself as a modern vagabond, always being the ‘outsider’ eventually results in a feeling of ‘homelessness’.
The book is accessible to a broad range of readers but is especially suitable for academics and activists who can recognise themselves in Willson's journey, as a fieldworker, an activist or both. Although Dance Lest We All Fall Down should not be read as an ABC of starting an NGO, the book certainly provides invaluable inspiration, reflection and ideas on how to proceed.
