The method of Asad Ahmed's study of early Islamic history, which is based on his 2007 doctoral dissertation at Princeton, is to plot the marriages of five prominent companions of the Prophet (all among the ten promised Paradise) and their descendants in the Umayyad period. Saʿd b. Abi Waqqas was politically active in Iraq but had difficulty with ʿUmar and possibly ʿUthman and so retreated to the Hijaz late in life, away from politics. The record of his marriages, according to Ahmed, shows that he allied himself chiefly with southern Arabian tribes, as did his children. The family lost out as Syrians prevailed over Iraqis. Next is ʿAbd al-Rahman b. ʿAwf. He was connected by marriage with the Umayyads, and some of his descendants were sufficiently close to them to fight on their side or be massacred with them by the Abbasids. Nevertheless, one of his sons, Musʿab, was a sometime contender for the caliphate. In the event, Ibn al-Zubayr came to represent the pretentions of the old Hijazi elite in the Second Civil War but apparently only because Musʿab and another early Meccan ally died early on. Had they not died, a shūrā would have chosen one of the three to succeed Muʿawiya. At some point during or shortly after ʿAbd al-Malik's reign, the Umayyads seem to have ceased to intermarry with the old Hijazi elite, presumably having found it unprofitable to patronize a group so inclined to press its own claims to rule.
Talha b. ʿUbayd Allah perished in battle against ʿAli, but his descendants intermarried with both ʿAlids and Abbasids, evidently preparing the way for a brief return to prominence in government under the early Abbasids. The descendants of the caliph ʿUthman unsurprisingly tended to intermarry mainly with fellow Umayyads. However, some lines from his son ʿAmr were attracted to the Zubayrids, Talhads, and ʿAlids, which supported a brief return to favor under the early Abbasids. Ahmed's last investigation is of the descendants of ʿAli b. Abi Talib, and it is the longest and most complex (over twice as many pages as any other chapter). Ahmed observes a certain tendency toward endogamy in the early Abbasid period, with ʿAlids marrying fellow ʿAlids and therefore weakening their power to summon up allies when any of them revolted. The ʿAlids were sufficiently troublesome, however, that al-Maʾmun famously appointed as his successor ʿAli al-Rida, marrying a daughter to him.
Genealogy is notoriously subject to reshaping. E. E. Evans-Pritchard observed that strong clans among the Sanusi bedouin had elaborate genealogies, and weak clans had only sketchy ones. The prevailing ideology was of course that virtue in the present was the consequence of virtuous ancestors. Scholars will suppose that causality was actually working in the opposite direction, with ancestors becoming more or less virtuous through back projection. Severe hadith reports against falsifying one's ancestry show that the early Muslims were well aware of the problem. For example, “There is no man who knowingly identifies himself with other than his father but that he has committed unbelief in God. Whoever identifies himself with a people to whom he is not related, let him prepare his seat in the Fire” (Bukhari, manāqib 5, no 3508). Ahmed's evidence of the companions’ marriages is from books of the 9th century and later, raising the question of whether his evidence is vitiated by back projection.
To the contrary, Ahmed argues that falsification at this very high social level must have been much more difficult than among humbler strata; that falsification is more likely for remote ancestors (here, in the Jahili period); and that such falsification as the later sources offer is normally detectable. He himself raises the suspicion that Saʿd b. Abi Waqqas was not Qurashi at all, his descendants having manufactured a Qurashi lineage for themselves some time in late Umayyad or early Abbasid times. Ahmed deprecates a general tendency of later sources to augment ʿAli b. Abi Talib's marital connections for the sake of legitimizing later dynasties. He convinces me here. A telling contrast, I would say, is with Fuʾad Jabali, The Companions of the Prophet (Islamic History and Civilization, Studies and Texts 47 [Leiden: E. J. Brill, 2003]), which proposes statistical analyses of all reported companions. Jabali is defeated by contradictions in the sources, evidence of massive falsification, or at least reconstruction of the past by guesswork. This is because he overambitiously takes on so many more than the top families Ahmed surveys.
This is an admirably competent study. I would complain only about some technical points. In a book with very many names, transliteration is commendably accurate. By analogy with “Umayyads,” however, “Talhads” seems a better form for “the sons of Talha” than Ahmed's “Talhids.” Ahmed's “ʿAlīds” with a macron does not improve on the conventional “ʿAlids” without. “ʿAliyyids” would be more logical. Ahmed says once, “I suggest that ‘Sharāḥīl bin Janāb’ be read as ‘Sharāḥīl min Janāb’” (p. 41). The emendation is plausible, but it is not true that classical Arabic omits to write the waṣl for “the son of” between names because there the bāʾ picks up a vowel. Rather, by orthographic convention, the waṣl is not written because there the previous name supplies a vowel, mainly its case ending (e.g., Sharāḥīlu bnu Janāb). (By another orthographic convention, likewise unrelated to pronunciation, the waṣl reappears at the beginning of a line.) Bin is unexceptionable when the referent is from the KSA, for example, but inappropriate for quoting from classical sources. Annoyingly, Ahmed also sticks to minuscule a for transcribing the definite article, even at the beginning of a paragraph. This can hardly be said to respect the Arabic, which has no minuscule. It is inconsistent with the conventional treatment of European names (e.g., “d'Artagnan” in the middle of a sentence but “D'Artagnan” at the beginning). It is likewise inconsistent with Ahmed's own treatment of ibn, which he fearlessly writes as “Ibn” at the beginning of a sentence, even though the capital letter represents the same waṣl in the Arabic as the a of the definite article.
Ahmed's prosopographical method is new, at least as applied to early Islamic history. His results are fairly modest: the apparent priority given family fortune over ideology; the equal importance of relationships through women and men (cognate and agnate, respectively, in Ahmed's terminology); the unwillingness of the Umayyads after ʿAbd al-Malik to involve themselves with the old Hijazi elite, contrasted with the carefully limited patronage of the Abbasids after them. His interpretations commonly depend on the traditional narrative sources (which he does read shrewdly). He expressly warns at the end not to expect prosopography to yield the same results for Islamic history as it has yielded for (among others) republican Roman or early modern British history, given the peculiar emphases of the available sources: for example, patchy information about administrative posts, especially outside the main centers, and almost nothing on property holdings. It is much to Ahmed's credit that he does not try to force greater results from his method than it will yield. As he recognizes, we (alas) cannot expect spectacular new understanding from the application of his method to other places and periods in premodern Islamic history. That said, Ahmed will provoke historians to continually look for marital connections when investigating how coalitions were formed and dynasties founded.
